Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Uncategorized

Harvard extends fellowship offer to leading Israel critic Ken Roth after weeks of controversy

(JTA) – Harvard University will extend a fellowship offer to former Human Rights Watch Director Ken Roth after previously rejecting him over his past comments on Israel, capping weeks of controversy that ensnared the Ivy League school in a global debate about academic freedom and criticism of Israel.

In an open letter Thursday, Harvard Kennedy School dean Douglas Elmendorf said his previous decision not to offer the fellowship to Roth had been an “error,” and that “the broader faculty input I have now sought and received has persuaded me that my decision was not the best one for the School.” 

The school’s Carr Center for Human Rights had been in talks with Roth to take a fellowship shortly after he resigned from his position as Human Rights Watch’s director last year. Roth had held the role since 1993. Elmendorf initially vetoed the Carr Center’s decision to offer Roth the fellowship, and an affiliated professor told The Nation, the progressive magazine, that she had been told Roth’s “anti-Israel bias” was the reason.

Human Rights Watch tracks human rights abuses around the world. Roth’s critics — including Human Rights Watch’s Jewish co-founder, Robert Bernstein — alleged that the group was spending a disproportionate amount of its time and resources on Israel’s treatment of Palestinians under his leadership. A year before Roth left, the organization released a landmark report condemning Israel as an “apartheid” state for the first time. 

Roth, whose father was a Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany, also frequently tweets criticism of Israel that his critics say sometimes veers into antisemitism.

The report in The Nation, and Roth’s own account of the incident in The Guardian, set off a firestorm as the Harvard community, alongside pro-Palestinian groups and academic free-speech organizations, strongly opposed the school’s decision and called on it to reverse course. 

“Withholding Roth’s participation in a human rights program due to his own staunch critiques of human rights abuses by governments worldwide raises serious questions about the credibility of the Harvard program itself,” PEN America said in a statement. The group’s CEO was an executive at HRW under Roth.

More than 1,000 Harvard students, faculty and alumni signed an open letter calling for Elmendorf’s resignation. 

Meanwhile, some pro-Israel figures, including an executive at Combined Jewish Philanthropies of Greater Boston and a student activist at Harvard, had defended the dean’s decision to turn down Roth. 

In one notable comment, Lawrence Summers, the Jewish former Harvard president and former U.S. treasury secretary with strongly pro-Israel views, also criticized the school’s decision. 

“I loathe Ken Roth’s views on Israel and think some of his statements border on antisemitic,” Summers wrote in a series of tweets. But, he added, “preventing a human rights center from having the fmr head of a leading human rights center as a visiting fellow on grounds of the person’s views/modes of expression is not consistent w/profound commitment to intellectual diversity that should be a bedrock value in universities.” 

Meanwhile, Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, objected to another element of The Nation’s report. The story, Greenblatt said, “concocts a conspiracy theory” that the dean’s decision had been swayed by a number of Israeli donors to the Kennedy School. 

“It’s a textbook case of classic antisemitism: It’s not the leadership of the Kennedy School that made this decision, oh no,” Greenblatt wrote in an op-ed. “It’s the powerful and monied Jewish elite that really influences things behind the scenes.”

Through a spokesperson, Elmendorf declined an interview with the Jewish Telegraphic Agency this week. In his letter to the school Thursday, he said his decision on Roth “was based on my evaluation of his potential contributions to the School.”

In a statement Thursday responding to the decision, Roth seemed to indicate he would accept the fellowship offer. “I have long felt that the Carr Center, and the Kennedy School, would be a congenial place for me to work on the book that I am writing. I look forward to spending time there with colleagues and students,” he wrote.

But Roth continued to criticize Elmendorf and said “I remain worried about academic freedom… The problem of people penalized for criticizing Israel is not limited to me, and most scholars and students have no comparable capacity to mobilize public attention.”

NGO Monitor, an Israeli nonprofit that acts as a watchdog of Israel criticism among NGOs, condemned Harvard’s reversal.

“In 30 years as head of Human Rights Watch, Roth has consistently singled-out Israel uniquely for demonization and delegitimization, using numerous false and distorted claims. These campaigns contributed significantly to antisemitism, and added to the targeting of Jewish students on university campuses,” the group wrote in a statement on Thursday.

—
The post Harvard extends fellowship offer to leading Israel critic Ken Roth after weeks of controversy appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uncategorized

The Jewish hotel on the Lower East Side that was too good to last

The Ritz with a Shvitz: The Rise and Fall of the Lower East Side’s Libby’s Hotel in Tammany Era New York
By Shulamith Z. Berger and Jai Zion
State University of New York Press, 240 pages, $27.95

When the Lower East Side was the capital of the Jewish world, the 12-story Libby’s Hotel, a glorious edifice climbing out of the surrounding tenements, was one of its brightest achievements. Until hostile forces brought it down. Literally.

As explained in a new book, The Ritz with a Shvitz: The Rise and Fall of the Lower East Side’s Libby’s Hotel in Tammany Era New York, Libby’s was the brainchild of Max Bernstein, who came to the U.S. from Slutsk, a city in the Russian Empire (Belarus today), in 1900, at age 11. He had been here just eight months when his beloved mother Libby died suddenly in childbirth.

An energetic and ambitious boy, Max seems to have channeled his grief into entrepreneurship. He hustled Yiddish newspapers on the street until, by the age of 14, he saved $75 (close to $3,000 in today’s money) and built a candy stand next to his father’s small restaurant. He moved on to a bigger business: buying, refurbishing, and selling restaurants. He was 15 years old. (As novelist L.P. Hartley put it, “The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there.”)

At 27, he took over his father’s conventional restaurant and changed it to “self-service.” It became so successful that within a year, he opened a second one a few blocks away. Then a third restaurant a year after that. And so on. He became a rich man. But he wanted more than just money; he wanted to build something to memorialize his mother.

At first he thought it would be a shvitz, a bathhouse: the shvitz was for Jews what the bar was for other ethnic groups. But ultimately he decided Libby’s would be a sumptuous, modern Jewish hotel. Such a hotel was needed at the time because many of the older hotels in New York were “restricted” — i.e., no “Hebrews” were permitted to register.

Though he was quite wealthy, Max needed to drum up outside capital, so he began advertising in the Yiddish press. His goal was to attract investment both from the moneyed classes and from ordinary working people; he wanted everyone to have a stake in the project. A single share of Libby’s stock cost $10 ($190 today), and they were bought by pushcart peddlers, grocers, janitors, and factory workers.

The hotel opened five years later, and it was worth the wait. Libby’s was spectacular, and it had everything. Live music was pumped throughout the building via a state-of-the-art PA system. It had a gymnasium, an in-house newspaper, a concert hall, a barber shop, elegant lounges, a gilded swimming pool, two kosher restaurants (one dairy and one meat), grand ballrooms, a radio studio — which broadcast the first successful ongoing Yiddish radio program — and of course the shvitz, which had an orchestra playing in its lounge.

The hotel had accommodations for people of every income level, from upper-floor luxury suites to lower-floor dormitories, and all of its amenities were available to every guest, no matter how humble. People from the neighborhood came for concerts, weddings, organizational meetings, and grand seders.

It was too good to last.

What brought down Libby’s was an evident collusion between an unscrupulous mortgage agency — villains out of an old melodrama, but real — and the city’s corrupt administration. The mortgage agency had so arranged their contract as to make it almost impossible for their loan to be repaid, and then they would foreclose.

Simultaneously, the city planned to condemn Libby’s as part of an eminent domain proceeding. The lenders would foreclose and take the hotel, then get a huge monetary award for it after it was condemned; the book describes the process in appalling detail. The administration of Mayor Jimmy Walker, controlled by the notorious Tammany Hall Democratic machine, did everything they could to help the lenders, and though there is no real evidence to prove it, it’s hard to believe it wasn’t deliberate.

It’s an incredibly dramatic story, and impeccably researched (there’s an excellent essay describing the process in the pre-internet era) — but I do have a few taynes (complaints). For one thing, there is too much detail about the long legal battle for the property; after a while we get the point. Also, the book depicts Mayor Walker, who clearly was putting his thumb on the scale, as if he masterminded the scam. But the evidence for this is thin, and it seems unlikely given Walker’s personality. It seems far more likely that Walker was just obeying his Tammany overlords, who gave him his whole political career.

Most significantly, the book has a protagonist‚ Max Bernstein‚ and at two key moments we’re not there with him. What happened on May 18th, 1926, Libby’s opening day, when Max would have watched his first guests walk in under the ten-story-tall sign with his mother’s name in colored lights? It would have been the climactic moment of his life; what did he feel?

And what went through his mind four years later, when the bad guys won? Did Max stand across the street watching as the beds, the restaurant’s plates with his name on them, the gym equipment, and the radio studio were all torn from the building and driven off? What about when the wrecking ball smashed through the building itself? Was he even there?

Of course, tracing what was in one person’s mind on a given day a hundred years ago is impossible, and if researchers as thorough as Berger and Zion can’t turn something up, it probably didn’t survive. Nevertheless, some writerly exploration of the moment is pretty much demanded, and we don’t get one.

Still, it’s a compelling, if sad, story. There are many illustrations. There’s a lot of material about life on the Jewish Lower East Side at its absolute pinnacle, before the effects of the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924, which restricted European immigration, were felt. (Another essay, maybe the book’s high point, describes how Max treated two poor neighborhood boys to a stay in the hotel.) The Ritz With A Shvitz is written in easy, clear prose — unusual for an academic press — and even shows the occasional flash of wit, as in the phrase “beware the eyes of Marx” — a reference to the picture of Karl Marx that graces the front of the old Forward building on the Lower East Side until today.

And Max himself? He picked himself up, brushed himself off, and started all over again, finding new success in the restaurant business, among other things.

He was a brave man.

The post The Jewish hotel on the Lower East Side that was too good to last appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Why this Maryland synagogue says a gun control law violates their religious freedom

Menashe Shapiro, a 29-year-old ordained rabbi and law student at Georgetown University, brings his gun with him whenever he goes to synagogue.

His shul, the Silver Spring Jewish Center, can’t afford to have its hired security guard on duty whenever people are in the building, from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m. Instead, the Orthodox synagogue relies on a volunteer security force — trained congregants like Shapiro with permits to carry firearms.

Menashe Shapiro. Courtesy of Menashe Shapiro

But a quirk in a judge’s September ruling on a local gun control law has created a peculiar legal arrangement: While Shapiro can legally carry his firearm inside synagogue walls, if he carries his gun while walking to shul on Shabbat, he could face a civil fine of up to $500 for a first offense — or $750 for subsequent offenses.

“It seems a little bit purposeless to uphold the right to carry within the synagogue if you can’t get to the synagogue,” Eric Baxter, senior counsel at the religious liberty nonprofit Becket, which is representing the Silver Spring Jewish Center, told the Forward.

The legal oddity stems from a 2022 Montgomery County, Maryland law that bars licensed gun owners from carrying firearms in parks, schools and houses of worship, as well as within 100 yards of those locations. The law does not apply to hired security guards.

But in April of this year, the Maryland Supreme Court said the county could not apply the gun-free zone to drivers passing through the area because of conflicts with state law. In response, Montgomery County amended the law to clarify that the 100-yard buffer zone does not apply to cars.

Then in July, the Silver Spring Jewish Center and Shapiro sued the county, arguing that the law violates congregants’ First and Second Amendment rights. Baxter argues that the congregants believe Jewish law requires them to be prepared to defend themselves and their community, and Montgomery County is preventing them from fulfilling this belief. A federal judge partially agreed, ruling in September to temporarily block enforcement of the law inside houses of worship, while leaving the 100-yard buffer zone intact.

That means licensed gun owners can now legally drive to synagogue with their firearms, but not walk — a necessity on Shabbat, when driving is religiously prohibited. (Shapiro’s route falls within an eruv, the enclosure where observant Jews are permitted to carry certain objects on Shabbat.)

“You can’t claim that you’re enforcing some safety interest by barring guns in this location,” Baxter told the Forward. “Allow everyone else to do it as long as they drive through, but deny Jews because they have to walk on the Sabbath.”

In a statement provided to the Forward, Montgomery County Councilmember Dawn Luedtke said that the law treats driving and walking differently to avoid confusion with Maryland state law, given that some roads in Montgomery County are policed by the state.

Luedtke added that nothing in the county law “prohibits private security guards or law enforcement from providing security services to houses of worship.”

Shapiro told the Forward that he looked into becoming a security guard officially certified with the state, but he found the requirements impractical. Maryland mandates security guards to take a 12-hour training, undergo a criminal background check, and be employed by a licensed security agency, which must carry at least $500,000 in liability insurance.

Advocates say those regulations are in place for a reason — to prevent civilians from acting as armed security without adequate training or oversight.

“What you want to avoid is someone feeling threatened or intimidated by someone who is concealed carrying a weapon and may expose that during a service or where someone is not trained and not authorized under state law to be a security guard,” Luedtke told ABC 7 News earlier this month.

Shapiro noted that the volunteers at Silver Spring Jewish Center do have training; many are former members of the military, and all have received firearm safety instruction and regularly meet up to train.

Baxter said he doesn’t object to a training requirement for armed volunteers. The constitutional issue, he said, is that the law doesn’t apply consistently to religious and secular people.

“Anybody who wants to carry for self-defense to get to another location — to get to their house of worship, to the Apple Store — they can carry guns through those spaces if they’re in a car,” Baxter told the Forward. “But if you’re Jewish and you need to walk to a synagogue because it’s the Sabbath? Then you’re prohibited from carrying a gun.”

The post Why this Maryland synagogue says a gun control law violates their religious freedom appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Out of Berlin — two collections of new Yiddish poetry

אין אָנהייב 20ער יאָרן פֿונעם פֿאָריקן יאָרהונדערט איז בערלין געוואָרן אויף אַ קורצער צײַט אַ וויכטיקער צענטער פֿון דער ייִדישער און העברעיִשער ליטעראַטור.

דאָרט האָבן דאַן געוווינט און געשאַפֿן אַ סך באַקאַנטע שרײַבער ווי חיים־נחמן ביאַליק, שאול טשערניכאָווסקי, דוד פֿרישמאַן און דוד בערגעלסאָן. אין בערלין האָט אורי־צבֿי גרינבערג אַרויסגעגעבן דעם לעצטן נומער פֿון זײַן „אַלבאַטראָס“ מיט דער באַרימטער פּאָעמע „אין מלכות פֿון צלם“. (אין בערלין האָבן דאַן ניט געפֿעלט ייִדישע פֿאַרלאַגן). ס׳איז געווען נאָר אַ קורצער, הגם ביז גאָר בולטער קאַפּיטל אין דער געשיכטע פֿון אונדזער ליטעראַטור. געווען און פֿאַרבײַ. ווי עס האָט זיך געדאַכט, פֿאַרבײַ אויף אייביק.

און פֿאָרט, במשך פֿון די לעצטע יאָרן, ממש מיט אַ הונדערט יאָר נאָך יענעם קורצן אויפֿבלי, איז בערלין ווידער געוואָרן אַ באַדײַטנדיקער צענטער פֿון דער ייִדישער ליטעראַטור. איך נעם זיך ניט פֿאַרגלײַכן די איצטיקע בערלינער ייִדישע מחברים מיט די אויבן דערמאָנטע ליטעראַרישע גדולים. ס׳איז נאָך צו פֿרי צו וויסן.

דאָך מיט הונדערט יאָר שפּעטער לעבט די ייִדישע ליטעראַטור איבער גאָר אַנדערע צײַטן. עפּעס אַ צענטער איז נאָך פֿאַראַן בײַ אונדז אין ישׂראל, עפּעס איז פֿאַראַן אין אַמעריקע, נאָר אַז מע רעדט וועגן נײַע (און ייִנגערע) שעפֿערישע כּוחות, דאַרף מען אַנערקענען, אַז זיי געפֿינען זיך הײַנט איבערהויפּט דווקא אין מערבֿ־אייראָפּע.

אין דער שוועדישער שטאָט מאַלמע געפֿינט זיך דער וויכטיקסטער ייִדישער פֿאַרלאַג „אָלניאַנסקי טעקסט“. אין אַמסטערדאַם וווינט דער ייִנגסטער רעדקאָלעגיע־מיטגליד פֿונעם ליטעראַרישן קוואַרטאַלניק „ייִדישלאַנד“ (ירושלים – מאַלמע) — דער פֿאָרשער און פּאָעט דוד־עומר כּהן, וועלכער רעדאַקטירט איינצײַטיק דעם אַמסטערדאַמער צוויישפּראַכיקן (נידערלענדיש און ייִדיש) אַלמאַנאַך „די גאָלדענע פּאַווע“.

פֿאָרט איז דער צענטער, לויט מײַן מיינונג, אין בערלין, וווּ די ייִדישע פּאָעטן קאַטערינאַ קוזנעצאָוואַ (וועלכע האָט שוין באַוויזן אַרויסצוגעבן איר ערשטע לידער־זאַמלונג), יעל מערליני, י.־ל. שניי און דזשייק שנײַדער האָבן אָרגאַניזירט אַ טעטיקע ליטעראַרישע ייִדישיסטישע גרופּע, וועלכע פֿאַרווירקלעכט רעגולערע עפֿנטלעכע פֿאָרלייענונגען, וואָס ציִען צו אַ גאַנץ גרויסן, יונגן עולם. אויף איינער אַן אונטערנעמונג פֿון די בערלינער ייִדישיסטן האָב איך זיך אַרײַנגעכאַפּט, קאָן איך זאָגן עדות.

פֿאַראַיאָרן איז אין בערלין דערשינען אַ קאָלעקטיווע זאַמלונג „לאָקשן און לעבן“, אין וועלכער עס האָבן גענומען אַן אָנטייל 16 פּאָעטן ניט בלויז פֿון בערלין, נאָר פֿון פֿאַרשיידענע אייראָפּעיִשע שטעט, ווי אויך פֿון די פֿאַראייניקטע שטאַטן. דאָס זײַנען געווען פֿון לאַנג באַקאַנטע אין אונדזער ליטעראַטור, ווי אויך פֿיר מחברים, וועמענס פּובליקאַציס איך פּערזענלעך האָב צום ערשטן מאָל דערזען.

דער טיטל פֿון דער זאַמלונג, „לאָקסשן און לעבן“, איז מרמז אויפֿן אָנגעזעענעם ליטעראַרישן זשורנאַל אין לאָנדאָן, „לשון און לעבן“ וואָס האָט זיך געדרוקט מער ווי 30 יאָר לאַנג, פֿון 1946 ביז 1981. דער רעדאַקטאָר פֿון דעם זשורנאַל איז געווען דער ייִדישער פּאָעט און אַקטיוויסט אַבֿרהם נחום שטענצל.

אין דער ראָלע פֿונעם צונויפֿשטעלער און רעדאַקטאָר פֿון „לאָקשן און לעבן“ איז אַרויסגעטראָטן דזשייק שנײַדער, אַ צוויי־שפּראַכיקער (ענגליש און ייִדיש) דיכטער און עסעיִסט, וועלכער איז געבוירן געוואָרן אין 1988 אין ניו־דזשערזי, האָט זיך געלערנט אין שׂרה לאָרענס קאָלעדזש אין ניו־יאָרק און אין 2012 זיך איבערגעצויגן קיין דײַטשלאַנד. זײַן וועג צו דער ייִדישער ליטעראַטור האָט דזשייק אָנגעהויבן פֿון איבערזעצונגען פֿון דער ייִדישער ליטעראַטור אויף ענגליש, און אין 2022 האָט ער דעביוטירט מיט אָריגינעלע ייִדישע לידער. זינט דעמאָלט האָט ער זיך געדרוקט אין „ייִדיש בראַנזשע“, „פֿאָרווערטס“ און „ייִדישלאַנד“.

דערנאָך האָט זיך אַרויסגעוויזן, אַז, חוץ איבערזעצן די ייִדישע ליטעראַטור אויף ענגליש און שאַפֿן אייגענע ייִדישע ווערק, האָט דזשייק שנײַדער נאָך אַ זעלטענערע ליטעראַרישע מעלה – די יכולת צו זײַן אַ פּראַקטישער אָרגאַניזאַטאָר פֿונעם ליטעראַטור־פּראָצעס. זומער 2026 איז דערשינען אַ צווייטן נומער פּאָעזיע, מיטן נאָמען „לאָקשן און לעבן 2“.

אַ טייל פֿון די נײַ־געקומענע אין דער ייִדישער פּאָעזיע האָבן צו ערשט אויסגעפּרוּווט זייערע כּוחות אין פּאָעטישער שאַפֿונג אויף אַנדערע שפּראַכן — אַזוי ווי לאה רײַכלין פֿון זאַרבריקען, דײַטשלאַנד, וועלכע האָט פֿריִער געשאַפֿן איבערהויפּט אויף דײַטש. איר ליד „באָבע־לשון“, וואָס איז פֿאַרעפֿנטלעכט געוואָרן אין „לשון און לעבן 2“, האָט מיך באַזונדערס גערירט. כ׳וועל ברענגען דאָ די ערשטע סטראָפֿע דערפֿון:

אין אָנהייב? איז גאָרנישט נישט געווען

אַ וואָרט, אַ ליד, אפֿשר אַ זאַץ, ווערטערשפּילן

בלינד געפֿאַלן דורך נעפּלדיקע טאָלן

אַרויף צו באַוואַלדיקטע הימלען

האָב איך געקראָגן אַ ווינט

און אין די קרוינען

מיט זייערע רוישנדיקע בלעטער

געהערט האַמערן פּיקהאָלץ

אַ פּיקהאָלץ וואָס צירט אויס

אַן אַלטן פּניאָק מיט לעכער

צו דער זאַמלונג איז געווען צוגעלייגט אַן אַקוראַט אָפּגעדרוקטער בלאַט מיט איבערזעצונגען פֿון די פֿאַרעפֿנטלעכטע ווערק אין דער זאַמלונג. ס׳איז ניט צופֿעליק, נאָר אַ באַזיניקטער טראָט, וועלכער דערמעגלעכט דעם עולם, וועלכער קומט אויף די עפֿנטלעכע פֿאָרלייענונגען צו פֿאַרשטיין דעם טעקסט. ניט אַלע פֿון די, וואָס קומען אויף זיי באַהערשן ייִדיש אויף אַ געהעריקן ניוואָ, הגם דאָס קענען דײַטש העלפֿט זיי אַוודאי ביז אַ געוויסער מאָס צו.

אין צוזאַמענהאַנג מיטן אַרויסגעבן „לאָקשן און לעבן 2“ האָב איך אינטערוויוּיִרט דזשייק שנײַדערן פֿאַר דער פּראָגראַם „כּאן ייִדיש“ פֿון דער ישׂראלדיקער ראַדיאָ. צווישן אַנדערס האָב איך אים געפֿרעגט, צי פֿאַרוואַנדלט זיך ניט „לאָקשן און לעבן“ פֿון אַן איינמאָליקער קאָלעקטיווער זאַמלונג אין אַ פּאָעטישן אַלמאַנאַך. האָט ער מיר געענטפֿערט ניט זייער זיכער, נאָר פּאָזיטיוו. איך האָף, אַז ער וועט מצליח זײַן און אַז עס וועט מיט דער צײַט טאַקע פֿאַרוואַנדלט ווערן אין אַ נײַעם אַלמאַנאַך פֿאַר ייִדישער פּאָעזיע. אַזאַ זאַך איז ניט געווען זינט 2008 — 2010, ווען די פּאַריזער מעדעם־ביבליאָטעק האָט אַרויסגעגעבן אונטער דער רעדאַקציע פֿון זשיל ראָזיע אַ וואַזשנע פּאָעטיש יאָרבוך „גלגולים. נײַע שאַפֿונגען“.

צו באַשטעלן אַן עקזעמפּלאַר פֿון „לאָקשן און לעבן 2“ גיט אַ קוועטש דאָ.

The post Out of Berlin — two collections of new Yiddish poetry appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News