Uncategorized
Synagogues are joining the ‘effective altruism’ movement. Will the Sam Bankman-Fried scandal stop them?
(JTA) — A few years ago, Adam Azari was frustrated over how little he could do to alleviate suffering in the world with his modest income as a writer and caretaker for people with disabilities.
He kept thinking about a set of statistics and ideas he had encountered during his graduate studies in philosophy. For example, he remembered reading that for the price of training a guide dog for the blind in the United States, one could prevent hundreds of cases of blindness in the developing world.
This hyper-rational way of thinking about doing good was called effective altruism, and it was growing into a movement, known as E.A. for short. Some proponents were even opting to pursue lucrative careers in finance and tech that they otherwise might not have chosen so they would have more money to give away.
Azari, meanwhile, had become a believer who was stuck on the sidelines. Then, one day, he had what he calls a “personal eureka moment.” Azari would return to his roots as the son of a Reform rabbi in Tel Aviv and spread the word of E.A. across the Jewish denomination and among its millions of followers.
“It suddenly hit me that the Reform movement has this crazy untapped potential to save thousands and thousands of lives by simply informing Jews about effective giving,” he recalled.
He badgered his father, Rabbi Meir Azari, and, for a moment, thought of becoming a rabbi himself. But he abandoned the idea and focused on pitching E.A. to the Reform movement’s international arm, the World Union for Progressive Judaism. Azari found an ally in WUPJ’s president, Rabbi Sergio Bergman, and the organization soon decided to sponsor his efforts, paying him a salary for his work.
Over the past year, Azari’s Jewish Effective Giving Initiative has presented to about 100 rabbis and secured pledges from 37 Reform congregations to donate at least $3,000 to charities rated as the most impactful by E.A. advocates and which aid poor people in the developing world. Per E.A. calculations, it costs $3,000 to $5,000 to save a single life.
“Progressive Judaism inspires us to carry out tikkun olam, our concrete action to make the world better and repair its injustices,” Bergman said. “With this call we not only do what the heart dictates in values, but also do it effectively to be efficient and responsible for saving a life.”
This charitable philosophy appears to be gaining traction in the Jewish world just as one of the figures most associated with it, who happens to be Jewish, has become engulfed in scandal.
Sam Bankman-Fried built a cryptocurrency empire worth billions, amassing a fortune he pledged to give away to causes such as artificial intelligence, combatting biohazards and climate change, all selected on criteria developed by the proponents of effective altruism.
A few weeks ago, Bankman-Fried’s fortune evaporated amid suspicions of financial misconduct and revelations of improper oversight at his company, FTX, a cryptocurrency exchange that was worth as much as $32 billion before a run of withdrawals ultimately left it illiquid. The situation has drawn comparisons to the implosion of Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, and authorities investigating the situation have said Bankman-Fried could face criminal penalties over his role.
In the wake of FTX’s collapse, Bankman-Fried has suggested that his embrace of E.A. was insincere, a tactic to bolster his reputation.
But Azari and the organizer of another initiative, a growing reading and discussion group called Effective Altruism for Jews, are undaunted and don’t believe the scandal should taint the underlying principles of the movement.
“Whether you call it E.A. or just directly donating to global health and development, it doesn’t matter,” Azari said. “The basic idea is to support these wonderful charities, and I don’t think the FTX scandal changes any of that. Malaria nets, vitamin A supplements and vaccine distribution are still super cost-effective, evidence-based ways of helping others.”
Azari added that he has had several meetings with rabbis since the news about Bankman-Fried broke and that no one has asked him about it.
“I don’t think people are making the connection,” he said. “And to me, there is no connection between us and FTX.”
When talking to rabbis about why E.A. would make a good fit with their congregation’s charitable mission, Azari cites the Jewish value of tikkun olam, a mandate to “repair the world” often used to implore people to care for others. He explains that donating to charities with a proven track record is a concrete way to fulfill a Jewish responsibility.
That kind of thinking proved attractive to Steven Pinker, the prominent Harvard psychologist, who has endorsed Azari’s initiative. In a recorded discussion with Azari and others last year, Pinker recalled his Reform upbringing, which included Hebrew school, summer camp and synagogue services.
“The thing I remember most is how much of my so-called religious education was like a university course in moral philosophy,” Pinker said. “We chewed over moral dilemmas.”
As an adult, Pinker returned to Jewish teachings on charity and, in particular, those of the medieval philosopher Maimonides, examining these ideas through the lens of E.A. He began to wonder about the implications of Maimonides’ focus on evaluating charity based on the motives of the donor. That focus, he concluded, doesn’t always lead to the best outcomes for the beneficiary.
“What ultimately ought to count in tzedakah, in charity, is, are you making people better off?” he said.
Also on the panel with Azari and Pinker was the man credited with authoring the foundational texts upon which E.A. is built. Peter Singer, who is also Jewish and whose grandfather died in the Holocaust, teaches bioethics at Princeton. Starting in the 1970s, Singer wrote a series of books in which he argues for a utilitarian approach to ethics, namely, that we should forgo luxuries and spend our money to save lives. The extremes to which he has taken his thinking include suggesting that parents of newborn babies with severe disabilities be permitted to kill them.
From Bankman-Fried to Singer, the list of Jews who have either promoted E.A. or lead its institutions is long. With their estimated fortune of $11.3 billion, Facebook co-founder Dustin Moskovitz and his wife Cari Tuna have eclipsed Bankman-Fried as the wealthiest Jews in the field. There’s also popular philosopher Sam Harris and New York Times columnist Ezra Klein, who have each dedicated episodes of their podcast to the topic.
The website LessWrong, which defines itself as “a community blog devoted to refining the art of rationality,” is seen as an important early influence; it was founded by Eliezer Yudkowsky, an artificial intelligence researcher who grew up in a Modern Orthodox household but does not identify religiously as a Jew anymore. Two other Jews, Holden Karnofsky and Elie Hassenfeld, left the hedge fund world to establish GiveWell, a group whose research is considered the premier authority on which charities are deserving of E.A. donations.
The prevalence of Jews in the movement caught the attention of E.A. enthusiast Ben Schifman, an environmental lawyer for the federal government in Washington, D.C. About two years ago, Schifman proposed creating a group for like-minded individuals in hope of helping grow the movement. In an online post, he laid out the history of Jewish involvement and wrote a brief introduction to the topic of Judaism and charity.
Today, Schifmam runs a group called Effective Altruism for Jews, whose main program is an eight-week fellowship involving a reading and discussion group with designated facilitators. Schifman said about 70 people spread across 10 cohorts are currently participating. There’s also a Shabbat dinner program to bring people together for informal meetings with funding available for hosts.
Participants discuss how ideas that are popular in E.A. might relate to Jewish traditions and concepts, and also brainstorm ways to popularize the movement in the wider Jewish community, according to Schifman.
“There’s a lot of low-hanging fruit with regards to the Jewish community and sharing some of the ideas of Effective Altruism, like through giving circles at synagogues or, during the holidays, offering charities that are effective,” Schifman said in an interview that took place before the Bankman-Fried scandal broke.
Asked to discuss the mood in the community following the collapse of Bankman-Fried’s company and an affiliated charity, FTX Future Fund, Schifman provided a brief statement expressing continued confidence in his project.
He said, “While we’re shocked by the news and our hearts go out to all those affected, as an organization EA for Jews isn’t funded by FTX Future Fund or otherwise connected to FTX. We don’t expect our work will be impacted.”
Even if Schifman and Azari are right that their movement is robust enough to withstand the downfall of a leading evangelist, a debate remains about what impact E.A. can or should have on philanthropy itself.
Andres Spokoiny, president and CEO of the Jewish Funders Network, wrote about the question with skepticism in an article published more than two years ago. He argued against “uncritically importing the values and assumptions” of effective altruists, whose emphasis on the “cold light of reason” struck him as detached from human nature.
In a recent interview, Spokoiny echoed similar concerns, noting that applying pure rationality to all charitable giving would mean the end of cherished programs such as PJ Library, which supplies children’s books for free to Jewish families, that may not directly save lives but do contribute to a community’s culture and sense of identity.
He also worries that too strong a focus on evidence of impact would steer money away from new ideas.
“Risky, creative ideas don’t tend to emerge from rational needs assessments,” he said. “It requires a transformative vision that goes beyond that.”
But Spokoiny also sounded more open to E.A. and said that as long as it does not try to replace traditional modes of philanthropy, it could be a useful tool of analysis for donors.
“If donors want to apply some of E.A. principles to their work, I’d say that is a good idea,” he said. “I am still waiting to see if this will be a fad or buzzword or something that will be incorporated into the practice of philanthropy.”
—
The post Synagogues are joining the ‘effective altruism’ movement. Will the Sam Bankman-Fried scandal stop them? appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
Uncategorized
Can Palestinian Christians undermine Christian Zionism?
Americans tend to associate Palestinians with Islam. And studies show that most Americans view Islam in a negative light; a Pew study found that this has actually gotten worse since 9/11 — more than 50% of Americans surveyed in 2026 agreed with the statement that Islam encouraged violence, double the 25% who agreed with that statement in 2002.
Since Oct. 7, some Christian groups and influencers in the U.S. have been trying to change this association, drawing the attention of their fellow American Christians to the plight of — and the existence of — Palestinian Christians in the hopes of activating their empathy toward Palestinians.
American Christians have historically advocated strongly for their fellow Christians abroad. In 1998, Congress passed the International Religious Freedom Act in response to the civil war in Sudan that saw an Islamist government oppressing Christian citizens. Earlier this year, Congress passed a resolution expressing concern for Coptic Christians in Egypt. And another Pew study found that the vast majority of groups advocating for religious freedoms abroad are Christian.
In short, the U.S. is a Christian country, and many of its citizens feel connected to Christians in trouble abroad.
But this has been somewhat less true when it comes to Israel where American Christian views over the past several decades have been shaped by Christian Zionism. Evangelicals hold immense political sway through lobbying groups and voting power, and most adhere to a theology that demands support for Israel, and for Jews to return to the biblical land, in order to bring about the End Times and the return of Jesus. There is such a strong moral alignment between Israel and God — their Christian God — that some American evangelicals seem to be shocked when they learn that Israel did not distinguish between Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims in Gaza. Instead, they associated Palestinians with the violence they connect to Islam — a narrative that gels easily with Israel’s justifications for its crackdown in Gaza to eliminate Hamas.
Church collapse shifts the church
However, in 2025, Israel struck the only Catholic church in Gaza, killing three people and injuring nine others, in addition to destroying an ancient Christian historical site. The IDF claimed it was accidental, but the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, harshly criticized the destruction, and claimed that Israel had been “targeting innocent civilians.”
With this strike, American evangelicals began to take note of the plight of Palestinian Christians. Mike Huckabee, the U.S. ambassador, wrote a harsh letter to Israel’s minister of the interior about its hostility to Christians, threatening visa restrictions. Trump called Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to complain. Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, a staunch Republican but also a devout Christian, voted with Democrats to deny funding to Israel.
“Israel bombed the Catholic Church in Gaza, and that entire population is being wiped out as they continue their aggressive war in Gaza,” Greene said, to explain why she crossed party lines.
Since then, Christian influencers have drawn attention to Palestinian Christians’ treatment in Israel. Sometimes, these efforts are humanitarian and informational, such as those of the Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace, an organization that grew out of the progressive mainline Protestant United Methodist Church’s movement to divest from Israel.
Other influencers, like Tucker Carlson, have taken more of a shockjock approach. Carlson has regularly interviewed Palestinian clergy, including Bethlehem-based Lutheran priest Munther Isaac; Mother Agapia, an American Greek Orthodox nun who immigrated to the Holy Land; and Hosan Naoum, an Anglican archbishop in Jerusalem. All of them emphasize a direct throughline from Jesus to Palestinian Christians, depicting them as upholding the most original form of Christianity.
When Carlson speaks on the subject, he often omits that the people in question are Palestinian, referring to them simply as Christians in astonished tones, playing the audience he imagines, then trying to walk his viewers step by step away from their prior assumptions
“So Christian churches in the United States send more money to Jewish settlements in the West Bank than they do to Christians in Jesus’ own town of Nazareth?” Carlson asked Naoum, in tones of total befuddlement. “When people in the American media say Palestinian, it means someone who is an Islamist, basically — but you’re saying a lot of those Palestinian refugees were Christians!”
Palestinians, both Christian and Muslim, are being attacked and oppressed by Israeli settlers and soldiers; this much has been established, including by many Jewish groups. But many of these Christian influencers, including Carlson, who are now advocating for Palestinians, have a history of antisemitism, which frames their exposés on Israeli violence — Jews, they believe, killed Jesus. Now, they highlight Jews destroying the Christian-owned olive groves in Taybeh or Bethlehem, bombing a church in Gaza, or spitting on a priest. The implication is clear.
An increasing number of viral videos featuring Israelis opposing Christianity in some way are now being shared virally: Orthodox Jews in Jerusalem’s Old City spitting on Christians, an IDF soldier taking an axe to a statue of Jesus in southern Lebanon. Even the Christian Broadcasting Network, an evangelical channel that has historically been extremely Zionist, aired a number of clips about Jewish attacks on Christians and Christian holy sites.
But the sympathy only holds among the Christian influencers if the victims are Christian; though they may criticize violence against Palestinians at large, the argument is clearly weaker. As Candace Owens, a devout Catholic and outspoken antisemite put it, “The biggest issue that I have, by the way, with Israel, and talking about them being above reproach, is the fact that they are supplying the arms to murder Christians.”
Yet many of these videos rely on separating Palestinian Christians from Palestinians more generally for greater emotional impact in the U.S. And the reality is that Palestinian Christians are still Palestinians, first and foremost, a tougher sell to the American Christian populace, which is still largely rooted in Zionism.
To address this, two Christian conferences —Not In Christ’s Name last week in D.C. and the Crossroads Conference in Atlanta earlier this month — invited Palestinian priests Issa Thaljieh and Munther Isaac, both from Bethlehem, to speak. Their testimony was meant to describe the experience of Palestinian Christians, to address Christian Zionism and to be “an invitation to American evangelicals to meet Palestinian Christians, and to reckon with the ways their theology harms Palestinians on the ground.”
But because of Trump’s blanket ban on Palestinian Authority passport holders, neither of them could get a visa — even though they’re priests.
The post Can Palestinian Christians undermine Christian Zionism? appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
For Jewish democrats walking a fine line on Israel, Hannah Arendt charts a path forward
As I periodically lifted my jaw back into place while watching the returns roll in from the midterm elections, I could not help but wonder what Hannah Arendt might have made of this event. In particular, what would this firmly secularist, proudly Jewish, and merciless theorist, one whose worldview was shaped by the experience of the horrors of the 20th century, have thought about the sudden and shocking eruption of religion in the ranks of the Democratic Party.
Riding the crest of the blue tsunami that swept across our country two weeks ago were women and men of faith. “After decades of a religious right,” the Wall Street Journal announced, “Democrats find a religious left.” Not just any religion, mind you, but specifically the Christian religion. “The religious left has a Jesus-speak secret sauce that works,” theologian Anthony Bradley declared.
Statistics seem to support this claim: Among the 257 Democrats who, at last count, will take their places in the 120th Congress, nine either studied or graduated from seminary or divinity school. Hardly a stunning number in terms of percentage, but very stunning in terms of recent history. After the Jimmy Carter parenthesis, the Democratic Party was long seen as, at best, the friend of secular values and, at worst, the enemy of religious values. (It was not even 20 years ago that then-presidential candidate Barack Obama described working class voters as those who bitterly “cling to their guns or religion.”)
This attitude towards religion-clinging, especially within the suddenly bigger tent of a resurrected Democratic Party, seems to be over, then. Rather than clinging, the time for bringing back religion seems to have arrived. Right?
Not quite. In May, a Politico poll revealed that, for Democratic voters, being Jewish was more of a handicap for a politician running for office than being Christian. (Interestingly, atheists are as mistrusted as Jews; tragically, Muslims are even more mistrusted than both atheists and Jews.) Though the poll did not explore the sources of this mistrust, one element may well be antisemitic sentiment found mostly on the party’s leftwing fringe.
But most of this mistrust no doubt results from Israel’s military response to the Hamas massacre of Oct. 7, 2023 which the International Criminal Court labeled war crimes and crimes against humanity in 2024, and has since been described by other critics, including the Israeli-American Holocaust scholar Omer Bartov, as genocidal.
One of the many consequences of the catastrophic state of affairs in Gaza is that support for Israel among Democratic voters has cratered. Whereas about one-half of Democrats and Independents had favorable views of Israel in 2022, an August poll by the Pew Research Foundation found that the percentage had dropped to nearly 20%. Fairly or not, this has placed Democratic Jewish politicians, especially those with presidential ambitions, in a fiendishly fraught position.
The newly re-elected senator from Georgia, Jon Ossoff, who has long emphasized the vital role of Jewish values in his life, has become increasingly critical of Israel’s actions in Gaza. Not only has he lambasted the Netanyahu government’s actions in Gaza, but he was also among the first senators to vote in 2024 (and again in 2025 and 2026) for a measure that would block sales of offensive weapons to Israel. And while he refuses to address the question — a purity test for the party’s leftwing — of whether Israel’s government has committed genocide, Ossoff does not hesitate to affirm that the government has violated international laws of war.
Ossoff’s words and votes contrast, at times sharply, with those of Josh Shapiro, the governor of Pennsylvania. More so than Ossoff, Shapiro emphasizes — at some length in his recent book Where We Keep the Light: Stories from a Life of Service — his deep attachment not just to Judaism but also to Israel. He tends to speak about Israel and Gaza in a way which supporters might find even-handed while critics will find evasive. Thus, in an interview earlier this year on the podcast Pod Save America, he criticized the “lawlessness” of West Bank settlers against Palestinians, but rejected the term “apartheid” to describe the government’s policies towards those same Palestinians. Similarly, while he condemned Israeli policies last year that wrought widespread hunger in Gaza, he is reluctant to use American military support as leverage to use against this same government.
Just as these are not the only potential Jewish presidential candidates — Senator Elissa Slotkin of Michigan and Governor J.B. Pritzker of Illinois come to mind — their positions are not the only positions to be taken. Is there one position, though, that might be not just strategically best, but also ethically best?
This leads us to Arendt. In his graceful and thoughtful book, A World We Share: Hannah Arendt and the Power of Friendship in a Broken World, Roger Berkowitz explores Arendt’s understanding of friendship, the very stuff with which we build a shared world. Inspired by Aristotle’s claim that a healthy polis, or nation, is constituted by “a multitude of persons…differing in kind,” one that cultivates a diversity of ideas and beliefs. This alone, Arendt argued, gives us the “ability to truly see topics from various sides — that is, politically.”
Rather disturbingly, at least at first, Arendt insisted that the enemy of a shared world is truth. Arendt bristled at the notion that truth should be the north star of right-thinking friends or citizens. The primacy we reflexively give to truth, Arendt warned, entails the sacrifice of “human worth [and] friendship,” transforming our shared world into an inhuman world, one where conversation and dialogue are canceled by conformity and monologue. For Arendt, Berkowitz writes, “politics begins not in correctness but instead in dialogue — and in the fragile, human act of sharing the world with those who see it differently.”
This conviction on Arendt’s part was challenged time and again during her lifetime, whether by her youthful affair with Martin Heidegger or the much later affair that raged over her book Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. And, of course, it challenges our own convictions — namely, the unbudging certitude that I possess the truth — when confronted by events as tragic as Gaza transformed into rubble. (Or, for that matter, events as parodic as the Oval Office transformed into a Cheesecake Factory.) The awfully, perhaps fatally entangled nature of the Arab-Israeli conflict is presented by both sides, as Berkowitz writes, “within a framework of moral and political simplicity and reductive righteousness.”
Rather than each side taking a knife to this impossibly knotty affair, which opposing camps in the Democratic Party at times seem determined to so, might it not be better to sit down, to assess and discuss it? Just as Arendt believed that sincere dialogue was vital to a nation, so too must it be for a political party. To his credit, Berkowitz acknowledges the contradictions and inconsistencies in Arendt’s own position on Israel and Palestine, as well as his own. It would equally be to the credit of Jewish Democrats to do the very same. To both their supporters and opponents, they must insist on the necessity of dialogue on a subject where the only truth is that tens of thousands of innocent lives have been taken since Oct. 7.
The post For Jewish democrats walking a fine line on Israel, Hannah Arendt charts a path forward appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Is it a tornado or bomb warning? No, it’s the Shabbat siren!
One Friday, shortly after I moved to New York City, I was walking through Bedford-Stuyvesant when an air raid siren went off. As it wailed, a group of older Black men playing chess in the park stood up, shook hands and clapped each other on the back. “Shabbat Shalom!” they said to each other. “Gut shabbes!”
I have no idea if any of these men were Jewish. But they knew what the siren was for. After all, they go off every week in the very Jewish neighborhoods of Crown Heights, Borough Park, Midwood and Williamsburg, to mark the arrival of Shabbat. Twice, actually: Once 18 minutes before Shabbat, as a warning, and then moments before Shabbat begins. They also blare before holidays such as Passover, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
Not everyone feels so positively about the Shabbat sirens, however — or, as one Redditor called them, “shalarms.” They’ve startled and panicked plenty of newer, unfamiliar residents. On Reddit, transplants near the Jewish neighborhoods often ask their fellow residents if there is some sort of bomb or tornado warning. A friend of mine told me she had to Google it when she first moved to the area, confused by the weekly wailing.
But why air raid sirens? Who runs them? Why aren’t there similar alarms in most Jewish neighborhoods, or other cities with many Jews? (A siren briefly made an appearance in London, and was quickly removed.) And how on earth did this custom develop in the first place? The mystery is surprisingly difficult to solve.
Of sirens and shofars
According to the Talmud, in the tractate Shabbat, Jews are supposed to announce the approach of the Sabbath with six blasts of a shofar, each of which corresponds to an act of preparation for the evening:
“The first blast is in order to stop the people from work in the fields. The second blast is to stop those who are working in the city, and to inform the proprietors to close the stores. The third is to inform them to light the Shabbat light.”
The Talmud instructs there be a pause after the third blast that lasts “the length of time it takes to fry a small fish or to stick bread to the sides of the oven” so that anyone who forgot to cook “and needs those foods for Shabbat may do so then.”
As Jews were ousted from Jerusalem in the early second century, this practice fell out of favor — it drew too much attention to an already-persecuted group. But some version of the practice was kept alive in many Jewish communities around the world. Some places, including Krakow in Poland, had a town crier who would go through the Jewish neighborhoods to remind people of the incoming Sabbath. In Jerusalem in the 1930s, someone would walk through Mahane Yehuda market to warn shopkeepers that it was time to shutter their stores. And in Djerba, Tunisia, someone still blows a shofar on a roof in the Jewish neighborhood.
Perhaps this is what inspired the sirens — though the air raid sirens heard in Brooklyn do not give blasts in the sound of a shofar, nor are there six of them. They do seem to operate by a similar logic, however; a gap of 15 minutes between the two sirens allows people to rush home, take a quick shower or finish frying a small fish, apparently. In today’s New York City, no one needs time to trudge back from a field, but a warning call is still relevant.
And sirens announce Shabbat in religious cities across Israel, including in Jerusalem, differentiated from the sirens that warn of missile fire only by cadence — a steady tone for Shabbat, an oscillating pitch for rockets. (During times of war, to reduce confusion and blood pressure, Jerusalem has sometimes broadcast religious melodies instead of a siren.)
Battles over noise
The Brooklyn sirens are independently operated and they don’t come from one central authority in any given neighborhood; there are multiple in the Orthodox area of Midwood in Brooklyn, on top of various yeshivas, and several throughout the Satmar areas of Williamsburg and the edges of Bed-Stuy. Crown Heights seems to have only a single horn, on top of the synagogue Chevra Shas — but it’s powerful enough to reach my apartment, more than half a mile away.
They are not universally beloved; neighbors have complained about the noise level and disruption, filing complaints with the city for sirens that have reached as high as 106 decibels — about the same as a jackhammer — sometimes resulting in tickets from the city’s Environmental Protection Agency issued to the yeshivas or synagogues housing each alarm. There have been Change.org petitions to ban them, and people have regularly called the police on their local sirens.
But the synagogues operating the alarms have resisted, pointing out that noise limits have exemptions for religious institutions, and citing nearby churches bells and mosque calls to prayer that reach similar decibel levels.
A similar interfaith alliance has been forged in Israel. In 2016, Orthodox political parties in Israel, which usually stand in opposition to Arab parties, blocked a bill requiring mosques to lower their volume for the call to prayer. Their fear was that any ruling about religious noise ordinances would limit the Shabbos siren too.
Some cities, often more religious ones like Jerusalem or Bnei Barak, run Shabbat sirens municipally, but in others, they are installed and distributed by an organization called Noam Kedushat — which specializes in speakers that play melodies instead of a loud tone — or are even operated by individuals off of their own roofs. There have been feuds over the sirens, particularly in religiously divided cities; progressive party Meretz tried to block the sirens in Tel Aviv, categorizing them as noise disturbances, and there have been lawsuits in Beer Sheva over a Shabbat speaker one woman installed on her house.
As religion increasingly splits Israeli politics, the sirens have become increasingly contentious; secular residents regard them as an annoyance or impediment akin to the fact that Israel’s public transit does not run on Shabbat. This year, a group of activists claimed the sirens amounted to “religious coercion.”
In Brooklyn, however, even after Oct. 7 when antisemitism has risen, public feeling toward the sirens is generally warm. Every few months, a Reddit post pops up asking about the siren. And every time, commenters reliably identify the noise as “our Jewish friends,” “your Jewish neighbors” or something similarly friendly; some celebrate it as an announcement of the weekend.
At most, they find it slightly annoying, but not particularly bothersome. A woman at a bus stop on the same block as one of the sirens told me that it shocked her at first — “It was like a tsunami of sound,” she said. “But you get used to it. It’s annoying but it’s only on Fridays.”
As my friend Phil put it, they are part of the “delightful (noisy) fabric of the city.” He likes to imagine “it’s two old siren nerds going up on the roof to crank the war surplus siren they lovingly maintain.”
But is that what’s happening?
A loud mystery
It’s not clear how long the sirens have been marking Shabbat in New York City; a 1991 New York Times article on the Crown Heights riots noted the sirens. In a 2014 article on a Chabad news site, a rabbi named Mendel Goldstein claimed to have invented the Crown Heights siren and said at the time of publication that he’d been running it for 30 years, placing that siren’s birth in the mid-1980s.
There is shockingly little information about the sirens publicly available — not who owns them, or how they run, or whether they’ve been updated over the decades. A 2014 article in Gothamist, ostensibly about the sirens, is in fact largely about the city’s history with actual air raid sirens, during World War II. No synagogue or yeshiva has ever commented to a mainstream news outlet about the noise complaints, and no one has gone on record explaining how they run in NYC. Somehow, the Shabbos versions remain elusive, even though they’re a hard-to-miss part of life in Brooklyn.
And despite the warm feelings many Brooklynites seem to hold toward the sirens, people are oddly close-lipped and even hostile about their origin story or their owners.

I went to find the source of the sound nearest me one Friday afternoon, and was standing there, staring up at it and waiting when it went off, as dozens of Chabad families streamed by me. One man, perhaps seeing an opportunity to bring me into the Chabad fold, stopped and smiled and asked me if I knew what the tall pole with flared air horn speakers on top was, I said I knew what it was, but nothing else about it, and that I was a journalist trying to discover its history; he speed-walked away.
I got a bit more of information from an elderly white-bearded man, who stopped to ask me if I was looking for a synagogue. He told me that the siren goes off automatically, programmed once a year — disappointing information for Phil’s romantic vision of old nerds maintaining their analog siren. But my most knowledgeable source yet peeled off to greet a friend when I tried to learn more.
After reaching out to a Chabad-run neighborhood news site for Crown Heights, I got a number for Mendel Goldstein. When he didn’t answer numerous calls or messages, I asked around and got the number for his nephew Levi. He answered, but while he was jovial, he was also openly suspicious of my intentions. He wanted to know who gave out his phone number, and asked what the piece was about.
“I want to make sure, you know, you’re depicting the siren in a positive light!” he told me. I related my story about the chess players, and he seemed pacified; he said he’d get back to me with his uncle on the phone. He did not.
I had a similar exchange with another Chabad representative, Motti Seligson; he was excited about the idea, and told me he loved the siren and grew up with it. When I told him about my experience trying to reach Goldstein, he opined that that the inventor, whoever it might truly be — he notably did not confirm Goldstein’s claim to invention — didn’t want to talk about it and just wanted to humbly serve his community without any fanfare, or no more fanfare than an air raid siren that can be heard for blocks already provided.
Still, Seligson promised me he’d find somebody who would chat about the siren. He also promised to find me the perfect Shabbos dinner that would connect me to the perfect Chabad shul. He never got back to me either, even after I followed up about dinner. I tried a Chabad-run library; no answer.
I may never know the true history of my Friday sirens. But for me, they symbolize everything I love about New York — its diversity, its quirks, the way Judaism is woven into the city in a way everyone, Jewish or not, knows about and appreciates. Judaism is part of being a New Yorker, whether it’s the people graciously explaining to concerned Redditors that the sirens announce the weekend instead of an incoming hurricane, or it’s the men playing chess in the park and pausing to wish each other a gut shabbes.
I think of it every Friday as the siren sings faintly through my own Crown Heights apartment windows. Though these days the Shabbat siren also serves as a disheartening reminder of how early the sun sets.
The post Is it a tornado or bomb warning? No, it’s the Shabbat siren! appeared first on The Forward.

