Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Uncategorized

Wikipedia’s ‘Supreme Court’ tackles alleged conspiracy to distort articles on Holocaust

(JTA) — When a pair of professors earlier this month published a paper accusing a group of Wikipedia editors from Poland of revising articles to distort the history of the Holocaust, their research went viral.

Most academic articles are seen by dozens or hundreds of people at best. This one, published in The Journal of Holocaust Research, hit more than 27,000 pageviews within weeks.

The paper’s reach was fueled by its analysis, unprecedented in the academic literature on Wikipedia, and its finding that a dedicated group has for some 15 years manipulated a source of information used by millions in ways that lay blame for the Holocaust on Jews and absolve Poland of almost any responsibility for its record of antisemitism.

The paper caught the eye of not just scholars and journalists but of the people in charge of resolving disputes over editing on crowd-sourced Wikipedia, the seventh-most popular website on the internet and one that is seen as the last bastion of shared truth in an ever-fracturing online environment.

Typically, disputes among Wikipedia editors are resolved through community consensus mechanisms, but occasionally those mechanisms fail and allegations are brought to Wikipedia’s Arbitration Committee, a panel of elected editors known as Wikipedia’s Supreme Court. 

“Wikipedia is not exactly democratic but anarchistic in a way that actively discourages any sort of an authority coming to solve a dispute,” said Joe Roe, a veteran Wikipedia editor who served on the committee in 2019 and 2020. “The Arbitration Committee is a very limited exception.”

In this case, something especially unusual happened. The Arbitration Committee, or ArbCom, decided to look into the allegations without receiving a formal request to do so. No one could recall the committee taking such a step in its nearly two decades of existence. 

“A myopic decision here could result in untold numbers of people being fed a distorted view of Jewish/WWII history, which could have very real consequences given the recent amplification of violently antisemitic rhetoric by mainstream public figures,” wrote a user named SamX in a public post about the case. “ArbCom needs to get this right.”

The article that triggered the opening of the case was published under the title, “Wikipedia’s Intentional Distortion of the History of the Holocaust.” It accused 11 current and former editors of intentional distortions to numerous articles relating to the Holocaust in Poland. The paper referred to the editors by their usernames but also provided their real names if they had publicly identified themselves on Wikipedia message boards. 

“Due to this group’s zealous handiwork, Wikipedia’s articles on the Holocaust in Poland minimize Polish antisemitism, exaggerate the Poles’ role in saving Jews, insinuate that most Jews supported Communism and conspired with Communists to betray Poles, blame Jews for their own persecution, and inflate Jewish collaboration with the Nazis,” wrote co-authors Jan Grabowski, a historian at the University of Ottawa, and Shira Klein of the history department at Chapman University in Orange, California. 

Normally, mistakes on Wikipedia, whether intentional or not, can be quickly fixed by experienced editors who deploy a set of rules regarding sourcing and style. But in this case, the alleged distortionists know Wikipedia’s mechanisms well enough to at least appear to follow the rules and are willing to spend time arguing with other editors who step in to intervene. It becomes harder to get to the truth because they work to discredit established historians and prop up fringe voices to create the semblance of a real-world debate over historical events, according to the article. 

In one of the dozens of examples documented in the study, the alleged distortionists have tried to pass the self-published work of an antisemitic Polish writer named Ewa Kurek as a reliable source. Kurek has said that COVID-19 is a cover for an attempt by Jews to take over Europe and that Jews enjoyed life in Nazi ghettos. An editor named Volunteer Marek argued in a backstage conversation among editors that Kurek should be cited as any “mainstream scholar” would be. And another editor, working on an article about a 1941 massacre of Jews in Poland, added Kurek’s claim that minimized the number of Jewish victims and exonerated Polish perpetrators. 

Jewish school children pose for a portrait in the 1930s in Wizna, near Jedwabne, Poland. New research revealed that members of the Polish community killed their Jewish neighbors on July 10, 1941 during World War ll despite previous claims that Nazi Germans were entirely responsible. Polish President Aleksander Kwasniewski apologized for the massacre of hundreds of Jews by their neighbors during ceremonies marking the 60th anniversary of the murders. (Laski Diffusion/Getty Images)

One thing the research didn’t discuss is what motivates these editors to invest so much time and effort into distorting Wikipedia. Klein said the omission was deliberate. 

“We’ve been very careful not to make any assumptions on what drives them or what their politics are,” Klein said. “Instead, we’ve tried to focus just on what they’ve done, which is in the written record. And as we say in the article, we don’t see any evidence of them being tied to a government or being in the service of anyone else.”

Klein’s disclaimer obliquely points to a larger challenge around the historical record of the Holocaust in Poland. A central tenet of the country’s ruling Law and Justice party is defending the image of ethnic Poles and imposing nationalist narratives on the past, especially the period of World War II. While history shows that many Poles participated in the persecution of Jews, Poland’s nationalist right insists on portraying Poles only as victims or heroes. 

In 2018, the Polish government passed what’s known as the Polish Holocaust Law, which makes it illegal to slander the Polish nation or blame the country for Nazi crimes. In practice, the law has served to censor scholars and chill debate. 

Grabowski, Klein’s co-author on the paper, has for years sparred with the nationalist right over Poland’s historical memory. He sued a Polish group that accused him of publishing lies about Polish history in 2018, and in 2021 was ordered by a Polish court to apologize for his research before an appeals court ultimately overturned the order. 

Domestically, Poland’s ultranationalists have largely won the war over the public discourse, which has freed them to focus on the global scene, where English-language Wikipedia is regarded as a major battlefront. 

In this atmosphere, even something as basic as the background of Yiddish novelist and Nobel prize laureate Isaac Bashevis Singer can become fodder for debate. For years, Singer was at the center of a fight between two editors over whether Singer was best described in the first line of his Wikipedia article as a Jewish or Polish author. The eventual compromise — “Polish-born Jewish American” — lasted for almost two years until Feb. 23 when someone again dropped the “Jewish.”

The Wikipedia editors now being accused of distorting articles to further nationalist narratives have rejected the allegations against them. 

“I have not engaged in any ‘Holocaust distortion,’ on Wikipedia or anywhere else. I am not a ‘right-wing Polish nationalist,’” said Volunteer Marek in a public comment on a Wikipedia message board that was endorsed by at least one other alleged distortionist. “I am not part of some nefarious ‘Polish conspiracy’ on Wikipedia which seeks to manipulate content. All of these accusations are ridiculous and absurd. They are particularly disgusting and vile since they go against everything I believe in.”

In the debate about how to handle the case, dozens of arbitrators and ordinary Wikipedia editors — all volunteers — spoke of the situation on a Wikipedia message board as something close to an existential crisis for Wikipedia. Not only was the website accused of being used to spread antisemitic propaganda, but it was also alleged to be vulnerable to large-scale manipulation by a small group of bad-faith actors. 

There is little confidence in the community that a solution is within reach. By its own rules, the committee isn’t supposed to decide on disputed information. It’s more of a disciplinary body that evaluates the behavior of Wikipedia editors and can ultimately decide whether to restrict their editing privileges or ban them outright. 

But figuring out if the accused editors have indeed evaded safeguards and undermined Wikipedia’s integrity would seem to require that the arbitrators become experts on the history of the Holocaust in Poland. 

The decision to take up the case serves to acknowledge that the committee failed to solve the problem when it last considered complaints about editing related to the Holocaust in Poland about two years ago. That was during Roe’s tenure and he says the committee was distracted by another dispute at the time. 

“It can’t be escalated further than it already has in our mechanisms,” Roe said. “The best we can do is what’s currently happening now — just put it through those mechanisms again, and hope that something better will come out on the other side.”

In explaining why the committee must nevertheless take on the case, an arbitrator who goes by Wugapodes commented that the only other choice is to kick the can down the road. 

“This will not be an easy issue to resolve, but the committee was not convened to solve easy issues,” Wugapodes wrote, pointing out that the timing is right given the attention and involvement of outside experts and editors. “We can leverage these resources now or wait for this decade-long problem to get still worse.”

By a vote of nine to one on Feb. 13, the committee decided to open the case. The proceedings, which start with an evidence-gathering phase, are expected to last up to six weeks, after which they can decide to ban and restrict offending editors. 

Beyond that, an unorthodox last resort option is also available. Wikipedia’s so-called Supreme Court could ask for help from an even higher authority: the Wikimedia Foundation, a nonprofit that owns the encyclopedia. The foundation intervened in 2021 in what some see as a similar scenario of a far-right takeover on the Croatian-language Wikipedia, hiring an outside expert to disentangle the web of obfuscation and banning a set of editors. 

Roe said that his tenure on the committee in 2019 and 2020, which featured related complaints about the editing of articles on the Holocaust in Poland, helped lead him to believe that Wikipedia should embrace change, at least when it comes to controversial political topics. 

“I would like to see these difficult and politically charged content problems be referred to a new body made up of external experts, and that we don’t insist on doing everything internally among the community volunteers,” Roe said.

But he acknowledged that such a scenario is unlikely to result from the Poland dispute. 

“It’s not a popular view and it kind of goes against the general idea of Wikipedia,” he said. 

—
The post Wikipedia’s ‘Supreme Court’ tackles alleged conspiracy to distort articles on Holocaust appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uncategorized

Van Gogh painting with a complex Jewish history sells for record $190.4 million at auction

(JTA) — A Vincent van Gogh painting of blooming chestnut trees sold for $190.4 million at Sotheby’s on Wednesday night, after a last-minute dispute about its sale during the Nazi era threatened to derail the auction.

While the set a new auction record for a Van Gogh painting, the lead-up to the event was fraught with questions of ownership. The heirs of Samuel Fischer, a German Jewish publisher, last week asked Sotheby’s to postpone the sale of the 1890 piece, called “Châtaigniers en fleurs,” arguing that their ancestors sold it in 1936 under financial duress caused by the Nazis.

The family’s lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, demanded that Sotheby’s prove that the 1936 transaction would have occurred “even without Nazi rule,” in an email shared with The New York Times.

A day before the auction, however, Sotheby’s announced in a statement that it had come to an agreement with “all of the legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer” and the Blaquier-Arrieta family, the collectors who were selling the painting.

Noting that Van Gogh painted “Châtaigniers en Fleurs” in May 1890 during an “extraordinary period of creative intensity” in the final two months of his life, Sotheby’s described the piece as one of the most important of such works to remain in private hands.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post Van Gogh painting with a complex Jewish history sells for record $190.4 million at auction appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

In rare, emotional interview, Bernie Sanders says his politics are rooted in growing up Jewish during WWII

Sen. Bernie Sanders, who rarely talks about his Jewish upbringing, appeared emotional in a new podcast interview as he recalled learning that his father’s family was killed in the Holocaust and discussed how that tragedy shaped his perspective, including his stance on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

“The insanity of that certainly had a big impact on my life,” the 85-year-old Vermont senator and progressive icon said when shown a photograph of a two-story house in Slopnice, Poland, where his father and relatives once lived, during an appearance on The Diary of a CEO with Steven Bartlett, recorded on Nov. 9 and published on Thursday.  “If you ask me where my political views came from,” he said, “One, I’m Jewish. And when I was a kid, I was born in 1941.”

Sanders, who was born in Brooklyn, said his parents tried to shield him and his older brother, Larry, from the horrors of the Holocaust. But as he grew older, he began reading about what had happened to his relatives. None of the Jews living in the southern Polish village survived the Holocaust, according to historical accounts. “I learned, you know, the pogroms, people living in a community, and one day in Poland some people ransack your house. Horrible, horrible.”

The Sanders brothers visited the home village in 2013. “It was quite the experience,” Sanders said, adding that the local mayor “took us to a place. There was a mound, and they killed hundreds of people and dumped them into a mound.”

On the podcast, Sanders recounted a childhood memory of an unexpected telephone call the family received from Europe in the middle of the night, in which they learned that one of his father’s cousins had survived the Holocaust and was living in a displaced persons camp.

“I can still see the emotion in your face when you recount these stories,” Bartlett, a British podcaster, remarked.

“Yeah,” Sanders responded. “Well, what do you say? They are horrible stories. Period. End of discussion.”

“Difficult to talk about,” Bartlett said.

“Yeah. That is,” Sanders replied.

Sanders has rarely spoken at length about being Jewish, even during his two presidential campaigns. One of his advisers later said that Sanders took great pride in his Jewish identity and the historic significance of his candidacy.

A voice for progressives

Sanders said the memories continue to shape his political views today, including his criticism of the war in Gaza and Israel’s treatment of Palestinians. Sanders has repeatedly called for limits on U.S. military assistance to Israel and restrictions on weapons sales. During the same interview, he again said military aid to Israel “has got to end,” and be redirected toward domestic needs.

“This is why I’m so upset about what’s happening,” Sanders said. “As somebody who is Jewish, to see what Israel has done in Gaza to the Palestinian people is horrible.”

The reflections come at a moment when Sanders’ political influence appears to be growing. The Vermont senator remains one of the most recognizable progressive figures, and his calls for economic equality and a political revolution have found a new generation of supporters and leaders. The election of Zohran Mamdani as New York City’s mayor, along with recent congressional victories by democratic socialists and outspoken critics of Israel, has energized a movement that Sanders helped bring into the political mainstream through his presidential campaigns and endorsements.

In the podcast interview, Sanders invoked Rosa Luxemburg, the Polish-born Jewish socialist revolutionary who was murdered in Germany in 1919, and her warning about the choice between socialism and barbarism.

“That was before Hitler. Got it?” Sanders said. “And the struggle that we have is to bring out the better angels of people rather than the worst parts of humanity, the ugliest parts.”

The post In rare, emotional interview, Bernie Sanders says his politics are rooted in growing up Jewish during WWII appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Sarah Lawrence changes rules after J Street student group was blocked on campus

(JTA) — Sarah Lawrence College has changed policies to more easily overrule decisions made by its student senate, after the senate rejected a J Street chapter last year, likening the liberal Zionist group to white supremacists.

The private college instituted its rule change after the JTA reported in May that administrators had declined to intervene when its student senate blocked Jewish students from forming a J Street U chapter. At the time, student senators had proclaimed that J Street was akin to “a white supremacist organization.”

Now, Sarah Lawrence’s leadership says, the student senate will no longer hold that level of power.

“New organizations that meet the published requirements for membership, leadership, bylaws, nondiscrimination, and organizational purpose will be recognized by the College,” reads a September letter to select campus faculty sent by dean of students Dave Stanfield. “Recognition no longer requires a Student Senate vote.”

Yet months into the new semester, there is still no J Street U chapter at Sarah Lawrence. The leading advocate for the chapter on campus last year graduated in May. A co-organizer who remains on campus says he doesn’t have the bandwidth to restart efforts to form the chapter on his own.

“It’s quite convenient that right after our leader has to graduate and move on, they change the rules to make it easier to apply,” Asher Modell, the Sarah Lawrence student, told JTA.

The J Street controversy at the progressive college reflected how campus Israel politics have shifted in the three years since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas-led attacks in Israel and war in Gaza that followed. J Street itself has called for phasing out direct U.S. military subsidies to Israel, months before President Donald Trump publicly announced a similar goal.

The group has also received pushback from institutional Jewish groups to its right: This fall, the University of Michigan Hillel ended its affiliation with the campus J Street U chapter, citing a broader policy against affiliation with Israel advocacy organizations. J Street U disputed that explanation, saying the decision effectively targeted its chapter.

Yet the student senate at Sarah Lawrence, a school where liberal Jewish pundit Ezra Klein had been protested last year as a “Nazi normalizer,” viewed J Street’s Zionism as beyond the pale. Under Sarah Lawrence’s administrative guidelines, student government had enjoyed a large degree of autonomy in campus affairs.

Stanfield’s letter announcing the change did not mention J Street by name, and the dean did not immediately respond to questions from JTA. But he referenced “our conversations last year regarding the student organization recognition process,” and sent the letter to a select group of faculty and staff who he said had “engaged with us on the issue last year.”

Members of that group celebrated the rule change to JTA. Many of them had lobbied Sarah Lawrence to override the student senate after the college became the first school ever to stop a chapter of J Street U, the lobbyist’s campus arm, from forming.

“It’s about time,” Matthew Ellis, an endowed chair of Middle East studies at the college, told JTA. “After the J Street chapter was denied, many of us on the faculty felt that something was gravely wrong with the adjudication process. I’m glad that the process has now been streamlined to undercut any possibility of political discrimination.”

Joel Swanson, a Jewish Studies professor at the college, told JTA that the rule change had been in the works since before the J Street incident. The broader issue, he wrote in an email, was “student and faculty concerns about viewpoint discrimination.”

“I see it as a positive step toward ensuring that a diversity of perspectives and organizations are represented on campus,” he said.

Modell, though, is convinced the J Street controversy was central to the college’s decision to make the rule change. “They wouldn’t have done it otherwise,” he told JTA.

For Modell, the environment at Sarah Lawrence was a big part of his motivation for becoming involved in J Street. Prior to college he had called himself an anti-Zionist, he told JTA. But that changed after coming to the college and witnessing his fellow students’ responses to the Oct. 7 attacks.

“The environment itself moved me close to the center,” he said, describing hostile environments at the encampment protests and on signs posted around campus.

Modell has remained involved in J Street. He attended the organization’s recent campus conference in Washington, , the only college student unaffiliated with a campus chapter to do so. The group made an exception for him, he said. He told JTA he would still be concerned about promoting J Street U activities on campus today.

“I feel like anything of that sort would get protested,” he said.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post Sarah Lawrence changes rules after J Street student group was blocked on campus appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News