Uncategorized
How Jewish comedy found religion, from Philip Roth to ‘Broad City’
(JTA) — In the 2020 comedy “Shiva Baby,” a 20-something young woman shows up at a house of Jewish mourners and gently offers her condolences. When she finds her mother in the kitchen, they chat about the funeral and the rugelach before the daughter asks, “Mom, who died?”
While “Shiva Baby” explores themes of sexuality and gender, the comedy almost never comes at the expense of Jewish tradition, which is treated seriously by its millennial writer and director Emma Seligman (born in 1995) even as the shiva-goers collide. It’s far cry from the acerbic way an author raised during the Depression like Philip Roth lampooned a Jewish wedding or a baby boomer like Jerry Seinfeld mocked a bris.
These generational differences are explored in Jenny Caplan’s new book, “Funny, You Don’t Look Funny: Judaism and Humor from the Silent Generation to Millennials.” A religion scholar, Caplan writes about the way North American Jewish comedy has evolved since World War II, with a focus on how humorists treat Judaism as a religion. Her subjects range from writers and filmmakers who came of age shortly after the war (who viewed Judaism as “a joke at best and an actual danger at worst”) to Generation X and millennials, whose Jewish comedy often recognizes “the power of community, the value of family tradition, and the way that religion can serve as a port in an emotional storm.”
“I see great value in zeroing in on the ways in which Jewish humorists have engaged Jewish practices and their own Jewishness,” Caplan writes. “It tells us something (or perhaps it tells us many somethings) about the relationship between Jews and humor that goes deeper than the mere coincidence that a certain humorist was born into a certain family.”
Caplan is the chair in Judaic Studies at the University of Cincinnati. She has a master’s of theological studies degree from Harvard Divinity School and earned a Ph.D. in religion from Syracuse University.
In a conversation last week, we spoke about the Jewishness of Jerry Seinfeld, efforts by young women comics to reclaim the “Jewish American Princess” label, and why she no longer shows Woody Allen movies in her classrooms.
Our conversation was edited for length and clarity
[Note: For the purpose of her book and our conversation, this is how Caplan isolates the generations: the Silent Generation (b. 1925-45), the baby boom (1946-65), Generation X (1966-79) and millennials (1980–95).]
Jewish Telegraphic Agency: Let me ask how you got into this topic.
Jenny Caplan: I grew up in a family where I was just sort of surrounded by this kind of material. My dad is a comedic actor and director who went to [Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey’s] Clown College. My degrees were more broadly in American religion, not Jewish studies, but I was really interested in the combination of American religion and popular culture. When I got to Syracuse and it came time to start thinking about my larger project and what I wanted to do, I proposed a dissertation on Jewish humor.
The key to your book is how Jewish humor reflects the Jewish identity and compulsions of four sequential generations. Let’s start with the Silent Generation, which is sandwiched between the generation whose men were old enough to fight in World War II and the baby boomers who were born just after the war.
The hallmark of the Silent Generation is that they were old enough to be aware of the war, but they were mostly too young to serve. Every time I told people what I was writing about, they would say Woody Allen or Philip Roth, two people of roughly the same generation.
In “Funny, You Don’t Look Funny: Judaism and Humor from the Silent Generation to Millennials,” Jenny Caplan explores how comics treated religion from the end of World War II to the 21st century. (Courtesy)
The Roth story you focus on is “Eli, the Fanatic” from 1959, about an assimilated Jewish suburb that is embarrassed and sort of freaks out when an Orthodox yeshiva, led by a Holocaust survivor, sets up in town.
Roth spent the first 20 to 30 years of his career dodging the claim of being a self-loathing Jew and bad for the Jews. But the actual social critique of “Eli, the Fanatic” is so sharp. It is about how American Jewish comfort comes at the expense of displaced persons from World War II and at the expense of those for whom Judaism is a real thriving, living religious practice.
That’s an example you offer when you write that the Silent Generation “may have found organized religion to be a dangerous force, but they nevertheless wanted to protect and preserve the Jewish people.” I think that would surprise people in regards to Roth, and maybe to some degree Woody Allen.
Yeah, it surprised me. They really did, I think, share that postwar Jewish sense of insecurity about ongoing Jewish continuity, and that there’s still an existential threat to the ongoing existence of Jews.
I hear that and I think of Woody Allen’s characters, atheists who are often on the lookout for antisemitism. But you don’t focus on Allen as the intellectual nebbish of the movies. You look at his satire of Jewish texts, like his very funny “Hassidic Tales, With a Guide to Their Interpretation by the Noted Scholar” from 1970, which appeared in The New Yorker. It’s a parody of Martin Buber’s “Tales of the Hasidim” and sentimental depictions of the shtetl, perhaps like “Fiddler on the Roof.” A reader might think he’s just mocking the tradition, but you think there’s something else going on.
He’s not mocking the tradition as much as he’s mocking a sort of consumerist approach to the tradition. There was this sort of very superficial attachment to Buber’s “Tales of the Hasidim.” Allen’s satire is not a critique of the traditions of Judaism, it’s a critique of the way that people latch onto things like the Kabbalah and these new English translations of Hasidic stories without any real depth of thought or intellect. Intellectual hypocrisy seems to be a common theme in his movies and in his writing. It’s really a critique of organized religion, and it’s a critique of institutions, and it’s a critique of the power of institutions. But it’s not a critique of the concept of religion.
The idea of making fun of the wise men and their gullible followers reminds me of the folk tales of Chelm, which feature rabbis and other Jewish leaders who use Jewish logic to come to illogical conclusions.
Yes.
You write that the baby boomers are sort of a transition between the Silent Generation and a later generation: They were the teenagers of the counterculture, and warned about the dangers of empty religion, but also came to consider religion and tradition as valuable. But before you get there, you have a 1977 “Saturday Night Live” skit in which a bris is performed in the back seat of a luxury car, and the rabbi who performs it is portrayed as what you call an absolute sellout.
Exactly. You know: Institutional religion is empty and it’s hollow, it’s dangerous and it’s seductive.
Jerry Seinfeld, born in 1954, is seen as an icon of Jewish humor, but to me is an example of someone who never depicts religion as a positive thing. (Not that there’s anything wrong with that.)
“Seinfeld” is more a show about New York than it is necessarily a show about anything Jewish. The New York of Seinfeld is very similar to the New York of Woody Allen, peopled almost entirely by white, middle-class, attractive folks. It’s a sort of Upper West Side myopia.
But there’s the bris episode, aired in 1993, and written by Larry Charles. Unless you are really interested in the medium, you may not know much about Larry Charles, because he stays behind the camera. But he also goes on to do things like direct Bill Maher’s anti-religion documentary “Religulous,” and there’s a real strong case for him as having very negative feelings about organized religion which feels like a holdover from the Silent Generation. And so in that episode you have Kramer as the Larry Charles stand-in, just opining about the barbaric nature of the circumcision and trying to save this poor baby from being mutilated.
The few references to actual Judaism in “Seinfeld” are squirmy. I am thinking of the 1995 episode in which a buffoon of a rabbi blurts out Elaine’s secrets on a TV show. That was written by Larry David, another boomer, whose follow-up series, “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” is similarly known for its irreverence toward Judaism. But you say David can also surprise you with a kind of empathy for religion.
For the most part, he’s classic, old school, anti-organized religion. There’s the Palestinian Chicken episode where the Jews are rabidly protesting the existence of a Palestinian-run chicken restaurant near a Jewish deli, and where his friend Funkhouser won’t play golf on Shabbos until Larry gets permission by bribing the rabbi with the Palestinian chicken. There, rabbis are ridiculous and can be bought and religion is hollow and this is all terrible.
But then there’s this bat mitzvah montage where for one moment in the entire run of this show, Larry seems happy and in a healthy relationship and fulfilled and enjoying life.
That’s where he falls in love with Loretta Black during a bat mitzvah and imagines a happy future with her.
It’s so startling: It is the most human we ever see Larry over the run of the show, and I believe that was the season finale for the 2007 season. It was much more in line with what we’ve been seeing from a lot of younger comedians at that point, which was religion as an anchor in a good way — not to pull you down but to keep you grounded.
So for Generation X, as you write, Judaism serves “real, emotional, or psychological purpose for the practitioners.”
I wouldn’t actually call it respect but religion is an idea that’s not just something to be mocked and relegated to the dustbin. I’m not saying that Generation X is necessarily more religious, but they see real power and value in tradition and in certain kinds of family experiences. So, a huge amount of the humor can still come at the expense of your Jewish mother or your Jewish grandmother, but the family can also be the thing that is keeping you grounded, and frequently through some sort of religious ritual.
Who exemplifies that?
My favorite example is the 2009 Jonathan Tropper novel, “This Is Where I Leave You.” I’m so disappointed that the film adaptation of that sucked a lot of the Jewish identity out of the story, so let’s stick with the novel. In that book, where a family gathers for their father’s shiva, the characters are horrible people in a dysfunctional family writ large. They lie to each other. They backstab each other. But in scene where the protagonist Judd describes standing up on the bimah [in synagogue] to say Kaddish [the Mourner’s Prayer] after the death of his father, and the way he talks about this emotional catharsis that comes from saying the words and hearing the congregation say the words — it’s a startling moment of clarity in a book where these characters are otherwise just truly reprehensible.
Adam Sandler was born in 1966, the first year of Generation X, and his “Chanukah Song” seems like such a touchstone for his generation and the ones that follow. It’s not about religious Judaism, but in listing Jewish celebrities, it’s a statement of ethnic pride that Roth or Woody Allen couldn’t imagine.
It’s the reclamation of Jewish identity as something great and cool and fun and hip and wonderful and absolutely not to be ashamed of.
From left, Ilana Glazer, Abbi Jacobson and Seth Green in an episode of “Broad City” parodying Birthright Israel. (Screenshot from Comedy Central)
Which brings us to “Broad City,” which aired between 2014 and 2019. It’s about two 20-something Jewish women in New York who, in the case of Ilana Glazer’s character, anyway, are almost giddy about being Jewish and embrace it just as they embrace their sexuality: as just liberating. Ilana even upends the Jewish mother cliche by loving her mother to death.
That’s the episode with Ilana at her grandmother’s shiva, which also has the B plot where Ilana and her mother are shopping for underground illegal handbags. They spend most of the episode snarking at each other and fighting with each other and her mother’s a nag and Ilana is a bumbling idiot. But at the moment that the cops show up, and try to nab them for having all of these illegal knockoff handbags, the two of them are a team. They are an absolute unit of destructive force against these hapless police officers.
I think all of your examples of younger comics are women, who have always had fraught relationships with Jewish humor, both as practitioners and as the target of jokes. You write about “The JAP Battle” rap from “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” which both leans into the stereotype of the Jewish-American Princess — spoiled, acquisitive, “hard as nails” — and tries to reclaim it without the misogyny.
Rachel Bloom’s character Rebecca in “Girlfriend” self-identifies as a JAP, but she doesn’t actually fit the category. It’s her mother, Naomi, who truly is the Philip Roth, “Marjorie Morningstar,” Herman Wouk model of a JAP. So Bloom is kind of using the term, but you can’t repurpose the term when the original is still there.
So as an alternative, I offer up a new term: the Modern Ashkenazi American Woman. It’s very New York, it’s very East Coast, it’s very particular to a type of upbringing and community that in the 1950s and ’60s would have been almost exclusively Conservative Jews, and then may have become a bit more Reform as we’ve gotten into the ’90s and 2000s. They went to the JCC. They probably went to Jewish summer camp.
But even that doesn’t even really speak to the American sense of what Jewish is anymore, because American Jews have become increasingly racially and culturally diverse.
There is also something that’s happening historically with Generation X, and that’s the distance from the two major Jewish events of the 20th century, which is the Holocaust and the creation of Israel.
The Silent Generation and baby boomers still had a lingering sense of existential dread — the sense that we’re not so far removed from an attempted total annihilation of Jews. Gen X and millennials are so far removed from the Holocaust that they don’t feel that same fear.
But the real battleground we’re seeing in contemporary American Judaism is about the relationship to Israel. For baby boomers and even for some older members of Gen X, there’s still a sense that you can criticize Israel, but at the end of the day, it’s your duty to ultimately support Israel’s right to exist. And I think millennials and Zoomers [Gen Z] are much more comfortable with the idea of Israel being illegitimate.
Have you seen that in comedy?
I certainly think you can see the leading edge of that in some millennial stuff. The “Jews on a Plane” episode of “Broad City” is an absolute excoriation of Birthright Israel, and does not seem particularly interested in softening its punches about the whole idea of Jews going to Israel. I think we can see a trend in that direction, where younger American Jewish comedians do not see that as punching down.
You’re teaching a class on Jewish humor. What do your undergraduates find funny? Now that Woody Allen is better known for having married his adoptive daughter and for the molestation allegations brought by another adoptive daughter, do they look at his classic films and ask, “Why are you teaching us this guy?”
For the first time I’m not including Woody Allen. I had shown “Crimes and Misdemeanors” for years because I think it’s his most theological film. I think it’s a great film. And then a couple years ago, I backed off, because some students were responding that it was hard to look at him with all the baggage. He’s still coming up in conversation because you can’t really talk about the people who came after him without talking about him, but for the first time I’m not having them actually watch or read any of his stuff.
They have found things funny that I didn’t expect them to, and they have not found things funny that I would have thought they would. They laughed their way through “Yidl mitn fidl,” the 1936 Yiddish musical starring Molly Picon. I also thought they’d enjoy the Marx Brothers’ “Duck Soup” and they did not laugh once. Some of that is the fact that Groucho’s delivery is just so fast.
—
The post How Jewish comedy found religion, from Philip Roth to ‘Broad City’ appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
Uncategorized
Yiddish educator Asya Schulman to receive ‘Dreaming in Yiddish’ Award
Asya Vaisman, a scholar of Yiddish pedagogy and language acquisition, has been selected as this year’s recipient of the prestigious Adrienne Cooper Dreaming in Yiddish Award. Vaisman is also a Yiddish instructor, singer-songwriter, dance leader and translator of Yiddish poetry.
The ceremony will take place at the Dreaming in Yiddish Award Concert during the Yiddish New York festival — the largest annual Yiddish culture festival in the world — to be held December 26-31 at the 14th Street Y and the adjacent Town & Village Synagogue.
Vaisman is the director of the Yiddish Language Institute and the Steiner Summer Yiddish Program at the Yiddish Book Center in Amherst, Mass., and the lead author of the widely praised book In eynem: The New Yiddish Textbook, which received the 2021 Textbook Excellence Award.
She received her PhD in Yiddish Language and Culture from Harvard University, where she wrote her dissertation on the Yiddish songs and singing practices of contemporary Hasidic women. She has participated in and taught at Klezmer and Yiddish culture festivals around the world.
Now in its eleventh year, Yiddish New York brings together a global community for in-person events in downtown New York, as well as online programming via Zoom. The festival includes concerts, workshops, lectures, films, Yiddish classes, dance parties and intergenerational community events.
The award is named for Adrienne Cooper, a popular Yiddish singer, musician and activist who was integral to the revival of klezmer music. The Dreaming in Yiddish Award supports artists who have contributed to the contemporary Yiddish cultural scene.
To register for the Dreaming in Yiddish concert in person or online, or to find out more about the festival, click here.
The post Yiddish educator Asya Schulman to receive ‘Dreaming in Yiddish’ Award appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Israel’s opposition will decide the country’s future. Here are their choices.
Israel’s opposition is approaching a choice that could determine not only who governs the country but whether it can address some of the gravest threats to its future.
Gadi Eisenkot, the former military chief seeking to replace Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, can form a government with Arab support or he can make costly concessions to the ultra-Orthodox and form a coalition with them.
Accepting the support of Arab lawmakers breaks a political promise but costs relatively little in policy concessions. Bringing the ultra-Orthodox parties into the government almost certainly sacrifices reforms essential to Israel’s economic and social survival.
Negotiations now underway suggest a possible outcome that is less straightforward than either choice: an Arab-backed government that eventually brings in the ultra-Orthodox on considerably less favorable terms.
The decision rests largely with Avigdor Lieberman — and the outcome may surprise everyone.
The latest developments
To recap, Eisenkot commands 48 seats in the 120-member Knesset. Another 19 belong to Arab parties, an unprecedented number whose support is effectively available without major policy concessions. Together, they would have 67 seats, a comfortable majority. But most of Eisenkot’s prospective coalition partners promised not to form a government dependent on Arab parties. Accepting Arab support would break that promise.
Lieberman, a 68-year-old secular nationalist who broke years ago with Netanyahu, his former boss, has over the past week been pushing hard for negotiating with the 14 lawmakers from the ultra-Orthodox, or Haredi, parties, longtime allies of Netanyahu’s Likud. Controlling seven seats himself, he could deny Eisenkot a majority. But giving in to Haredi demands would compromise another central opposition promise: ending sweeping military draft exemptions for tens of thousands of yeshiva students.
Lieberman, who has been appointed by the Knesset to head its Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, conceded that under his proposals “not everyone will be drafted.” This is a dramatic break with his central election promise.
And the costs of the different broken promises are profoundly different.
The consequences of each choice
The Arab parties are asking for relatively little, principally a crackdown on organized crime and violence in Arab communities. The Haredim want to preserve not only draft exemptions but also government funding for schools that refuse to teach core subjects, subsidies encouraging prolonged religious study, and institutional arrangements that impede economic integration.
These demands threaten Israel’s future.
Only about half of working-age Haredi men are employed, and many Haredi boys receive little instruction in mathematics, English and other subjects essential to participation in a modern economy. The community already constitutes roughly one-sixth of Israel’s population and has exceptionally high birthrates.
Research published by the Bank of Israel found that public expenditure attributable to an average Haredi household approaches 13,000 shekels monthly, including benefits, subsidies and government services.
As the Haredi share of the population grows, preserving this system becomes increasingly unsustainable. The consequences could include higher taxes, declining productivity and an exodus of economically productive Israelis who see no prospect of change.
For years, the hope was that a centrist government freed from Netanyahu’s dependence on the Haredim could finally implement essential reforms. Now a government formed to replace him risks perpetuating precisely the same system.
This would be devastating to those reservist Israelis who have just spent three years of war constantly shuttled from one front to another, being promised that eventually, should the opposition come to power, the burdens will be distributed more evenly. The idea was that Netanyahu – whose right wing has rarely had a Knesset majority with the Haredim – depends on the existing arrangement whereas the opposition does not.
Lieberman’s sudden willingness to abandon his opposition to ultra-Orthodox privileges – one TV anchor described it as “hating the Arabs more than the Haredim” – complicates matters and raises another interesting scenario.
What to watch for
If it turns out that the Haredi price is too high for the opposition to pay, these talks may fall apart. That could happen if, for example, the Haredi parties insist on an “override clause” enabling the Knesset to overturn the expected Supreme Court veto of any deal legalizing the now-informal sweeping draft exemptions for seminary students.
That would mean that unless a deal with the Arabs were revived – or the even less likely option of joining Netanyahu was seriously considered – Israel would be headed toward another round of elections. And in those elections, Lieberman would face the very real prospect of being wiped out – or failing to make the threshold of 3.25 percent of the vote; he won 6 percent on Oct. 27, largely on the strength of his anti-Haredi position.
The prospect of political extinction may focus his mind and make him more amenable to the Arab option.
Eisenkot himself appears prepared to pursue it, possibly forming a 48-member coalition supported from outside by Arab lawmakers.
Such a government would not necessarily be as unstable as Netanyahu claims. Israel’s constructive vote of no confidence requires 61 lawmakers to agree on an alternative government. Netanyahu’s bloc has only 53 seats. Removing Eisenkot through that mechanism would effectively require Arab lawmakers to help reinstall Netanyahu, an exceedingly unlikely prospect.
At least one Arab party, Ra’am, has indicated willingness to meet Eisenkot’s conditions, including recognition of Hamas as a terrorist organization.
And there is a further possibility that could change the entire calculation.
Once Eisenkot demonstrates that he can form a government with Arab support, the Haredim would no longer be indispensable. Their bargaining power would diminish, and they might eventually choose to join the government on much less favorable terms. Shas’s participation in the Rabin government formed in 1992 offers a historical parallel.
That would turn the current negotiations on their head. The opposition could establish a government without agreeing to the Haredim’s most damaging demands, while leaving open the possibility of their eventual participation.
Watch for the moment the Haredi demands become unacceptable to Lieberman. That may be the point at which Israel’s next government finally begins to take shape.
The post Israel’s opposition will decide the country’s future. Here are their choices. appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Before he died, an Orthodox leader worked quietly on a guide to LGBTQ+ inclusion. Few will ever read what he wrote.
After Rabbi Moshe Hauer died suddenly at 60 in October 2025, the tributes that poured in from his peers lauded his drive to expand the tent of Orthodox Judaism.
As executive vice president of the Orthodox Union, the largest umbrella organization for Orthodox synagogues in the U.S., Hauer had designed programs to foster greater inclusion of community members who were often marginalized, like unmarried adults and people with disabilities.
But another Hauer initiative in that vein, carefully developed under the radar, only became known a year after his death: A policy for how Orthodox communities might better include members who are gay and transgender.
The existence of the project was largely unknown until this fall, when the OU’s in-house magazine, Jewish Action, produced a tribute to Hauer on the occasion of his first yahrzeit. An article revealed that Hauer had been working on “a framework of communal guidelines” for LGBTQ+ inclusion — and briefly quoted it — before stating that it was unlikely to ever be published.
“For such communal guidelines to be accepted within the Orthodox community, the author would need to be widely respected, with unimpeachable credentials,” Rabbi Yisrael Motzen, the head of OU’s inclusion initiative, wrote in the article. “It is hard to imagine someone other than Rabbi Hauer taking on this much-needed project.”
Any official guide to including LGBTQ+ members would have been a first for the Orthodox Union, and had the potential to be a watershed. Orthodox tradition regards same-sex relationships as being in violation of halacha, or Jewish law, and in 2022 the OU reiterated its halachic opposition to same-sex marriage, even as it affirmed legislation protecting it. The OU has offered even less indication of its stance on trans issues.
The revelation of Hauer’s lost project comes during a period of uncertainty for LGBTQ+ issues in Orthodox Judaism. The question of how gay identity can coexist with halacha, seen for much of the 21st century as an existential concern for Modern Orthodox Judaism, has in recent years moved to the backburner, as Israel advocacy and antisemitism have moved to the forefront. LGBTQ+ advocates, after years of making inroads toward queer acceptance in Orthodox communities, say a decade’s worth of progress is now unraveling.
What impact the publication of OU guidelines would have, whether during Hauer’s lifetime or now, is up for debate. Some believed any plausible OU guidance would have been self-defeating — that hardliners would have dismissed it while more liberal groups would inevitably have said it fell short. But everyone interviewed for this article agreed that the OU, because of its stature in the Orthodox world, was in a unique position to help.

“Having such a prominent organization have any kind of recognition, or even use words that are respectful and not demeaning, would be a big deal,” said Rachael Fried, chief executive of JQY, an organization that supports LGBTQ+ Orthodox teens and young adults.
It was admittedly difficult for those who had not seen the document to speculate on its impact. It remains unclear how much Hauer wrote or how many other people knew about it, as well as whether he was still working on it when he died or whether he had shelved it. Reached by email, Motzen said he did not want to elaborate on its contents because Hauer was “very careful about how he discussed his position.” A spokesperson for the OU sent a statement in response to a detailed list of questions about the document.
“Leaders at the OU engage in scholarship and discussion on a number of important issues facing our community,” the spokesperson wrote. “The work that was mentioned in the Jewish Action article is an unfinished example of such scholarship and just one of many works left unfinished by Rabbi Hauer, zt”l at the time of his tragic passing.”
The document would have almost certainly restated the OU’s opposition to same-sex relationships as a matter of halacha. The question is what else it might have said. Hauer’s earlier writing on LGBTQ+ Orthodox Jews, recollections from people who knew him, and an account from one person who read the document offer clues.
‘Private spiritual heroism’
The appointment of Hauer in 2020 as the top religious authority at the OU defied a trend at the organization. A longtime pulpit leader in Baltimore, he had been ordained not by Yeshiva University, but by Ner Israel Rabbinical College, a Haredi yeshiva.
As executive vice president, Hauer cultivated relationships between the OU and Haredi world, which both fit into his broader vision of building bridges across the spectrum of observance and accompanied a rightward shift of Orthodoxy both religiously and politically.
The yeshiva system from which Hauer emerged tends to be less receptive toward LGBTQ+ inclusion than Modern Orthodox spaces. And in recent years, rising Haredi membership at some Orthodox synagogues has made them less hospitable to queer congregants, according to Saundra Sterling Epstein, who runs the Welcoming Shuls Project, a registry of LGBTQ+-friendly synagogues and clergy.
“I can’t tell you how many communities in this country,” Epstein said, “where people went to shul X, and cannot go there anymore because it has been taken over by a very ‘black hat’ population.”
But Hauer’s views on LGBTQ+ issues did not fall neatly into right-wing ideology. In 2006 — around the time others in the Orthodox world were promoting conversion therapy — Hauer conveyed in writing his sympathy toward gay Orthodox Jews.
In a post on the Orthodoxy blog Cross-Currents, Hauer said that having worked with several gay Orthodox Jews, he understood that the difficulty of being “forced to face life with their most basic drive unmet” — that is, to remain celibate rather than violate the prohibition against gay sex — was impossible for him to comprehend, and he praised their self-sacrifice.
To a reader 20 years later, aspects of the post might come across as outdated even in the Orthodox world. Hauer wrote that homosexuality was “sometimes apparently genetic, and many, many other times caused by trauma, most typically child sexual abuse.” (Major scientific and medical organizations, including the American Psychological Association and the National Institutes of Health, say there is no evidence that sexual orientation is determined by trauma or abuse.)
Other remarks in the post, like referring to a Pride parade as a moral outrage celebrating “sexual deviance,” reflected Orthodox mores around modesty, not just sexuality. Still, the blog post showed that Hauer wanted to help. “I am concerned for the pain and alienation that they inevitably feel in these tumultuous days,” he said, offering that their “quiet and private spiritual heroism” in remaining celibate might be “what is keeping our world going.”
A similar tone comes through in the excerpt printed in Jewish Action.
The article provided just one sentence from the unpublished document: “[I] humbly recognize the unimaginable challenges confronting Orthodox Jews with exclusively same-sex attraction or gender dysphoria as they struggle with both halachic observance and their place within the Orthodox community,” Hauer wrote, according to the article.
The spirit of compassion comported with the experience of Ron Citro, a gay former member of Bnei Jacob Shaarei Zion, the Orthodox congregation Hauer led in Baltimore. Citro, who attended the synagogue from 1997 to 2001, was not out with his partner in the congregation. He said Hauer had the two over for Shabbat meals “many, many times.”
“We don’t know if he knew, so we don’t know what he thought about us,” Citro said. “All we know is that he didn’t try to set us up with women, and we were always invited together.”
“I think he just cared about treating people with respect,” he added, “and not defining them or uncovering their secrets.”
Not everyone was impressed by Hauer’s public statements — whether published in 2006 or 2026. And some found little to distinguish between them, which they said encapsulated how far Orthodox institutions were lagging behind the rest of society, including segments of their own membership.
Rabbi Shua Brick, an Orthodox educator who publicly came out as gay in 2023, said that describing LGBTQ+ people as having “exclusively same-sex attraction,” as Hauer had in the unpublished document, was a “very destructive and insidious way to talk about it.”
“Because of the amount of pressure communally that there is to try to marry a woman,” Brick said, “I would super over-index on any fleeting moment that I kind of thought women were interesting, because I thought my life depended on it.”

Fried, the JQY director, contrasted the language Hauer used with other statements made by Orthodox leaders, especially around trans issues. She cited comments made by prominent rabbis in the last two years who referred to gender affirming surgery as “castration.”
“The thing that’s so noteworthy to me is the kindness in it,“ Fried said of the Jewish Action excerpt. “It starts ‘I humbly recognize the challenges.’ That to me is a really big deal.”
The lines Orthodox leaders drew
While the Orthodox Union has not publicly disseminated a position on LGBTQ+ inclusion, the two other umbrella institutions in the Orthodox mainstream did publicly announce policies, albeit in different ways.
Yeshiva University’s position was stated in and out of court, where a lawsuit brought in 2021 by gay students led to the establishment — and shortly thereafter, the dissolution — of an LGBTQ+ undergraduate affinity group. The school said in March 2025 that a Pride club was “antithetical to the undergraduate program in which the traditional view of marriage and genders being determined at birth are transmitted.”
Less well-known is the policy of the Rabbinical Council of America, a professional organization for the Orthodox rabbinate. In 2016, the RCA passed a resolution that prohibited rabbis from acknowledging gay relationships or weddings and urged celibacy for gay Orthodox Jews. It did not consider trans issues. But it also said that gay congregants should not be excluded from synagogue functions any more than those who do not observe the laws of Shabbat.
Rabbi Mark Dratch, who led the RCA when the resolution was passed, described the difficulty of reaching consensus on the resolution, which took pains to emphasize the need for empathy and sensitivity toward gay community members — and even noted that the Torah frowns upon celibacy.
“We recognize that these strictures provide no permitted outlet for those with homosexual desire, thereby creating the extraordinary demand of lifelong abstinence as well as the absence of companionate love,” the resolution read. “Although some overcome these and other challenges, we deeply empathize with those who face them.”
“It doesn’t go as far as some would have liked,” Dratch said in an interview. “It goes too far, probably, for what other people would have liked. Looking at it now, there are things that people who supported it then may now be uncomfortable with. But it’s a challenge.”
Hauer’s role at the OU, of course, carried very different demands from running a synagogue. And running the OU had higher stakes than the RCA. As executive vice president, Hauer was charged with setting the religious policy for an organization that serves hundreds of synagogues and schools, runs youth education programs and summer camps and certifies kosher food.
As the face of the organization, Hauer had a lot riding on any statement, much less one on a topic as fraught as LGBTQ+ inclusion. One step too far to the left, and those on the right might cast aspersions on OU’s other work, including kosher certification, a multimillion-dollar business. Moreover, he risked a setback in his central mission as head of the OU: uniting the Orthodox fabric.
Imagining impact
While Motzen, the author of the Jewish Action article, wrote in it that an OU-led LGBTQ+ inclusion effort was “much-needed,” some Orthodox advocates doubted whether it would change minds.
Epstein, the Welcoming Shuls Project director, was complimentary of Hauer, saying that he was known to deal compassionately with LGBTQ+ synagogue members at his Baltimore synagogue.
But she named respected Orthodox leaders who had offered more progressive guidance than Hauer’s excerpt suggests. Among them were Rabbi Benny Lau, a prominent Israeli rabbi who in 2020 urged gay Orthodox Jews to live openly and seek long-term partners, and Rabbi Eliezer Waldenberg, a renowned expert on Jewish law who proposed a halachic framework for gender affirmation surgery.
Despite those rabbis’ prestige, she said, they had not managed to move the needle in the Orthodox mainstream. And there were signs that years of progress are now being eroded. Several shuls Epstein once considered welcoming to queer Jews have recently begun shunning them as their membership became more predominantly Haredi.
“I think there’s this mentality — and I think it’s gotten worse — that, ‘My mind is made up. Don’t confuse me with the facts,’” Epstein said.
With the Orthodox Union standing behind Hauer’s call, though, it’s possible the impact would have been more widely felt.
Misha Holleb, who is trans and launched a now-defunct LGBTQ+-inclusive Orthodox prayer group, said merely acknowledging that gay and trans alienation was a problem in the Orthodox world would count as a “baby step” for the OU.
“They think that they’re moving the needle, and they are, which is the sad thing,” said Holleb.
Holleb said he had recently left Orthodoxy in part because of how he was treated in those spaces. “The best you can hope for is the kind of homophobia and transphobia that’s reflected in that statement,” he said.
Dratch, the former RCA head, agreed with Epstein that Hauer would have been wading into controversy no matter what the document said. But that did not mean there was no point in publishing it.
Passing a resolution, as his former organization had, served a long-term purpose even if people disagreed with it.
“This is the challenge of leadership,” Dratch said. “It would have been easier for nobody to say anything, and behind the scenes try to resolve each case as it comes. But that’s not responsible when you’re leading a community. You need to change attitudes because you need to change people’s opinions.”
For the OU, he said, publishing anything could help kickstart an exchange of ideas among rabbinic leadership or between leadership and community members.
That was just the impact Fried, the JQY director, said she hoped the Jewish Action piece would have.
One challenge her organization has is reaching people who would benefit most from its support. The stigma against LGBTQ+ identity is so great in the Orthodox world that many community publications won’t run ads for JQY.
Hauer’s attempt at tackling the issue, even if it didn’t land, left her feeling optimistic the Orthodox world would trend toward normalization.
“Even Jewish Action publishing this is a positive sign,” she said.
Citro, Hauer’s old congregant in Baltimore, now lives with his husband on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, where they attend a synagogue that uses Orthodox liturgy but allows both women and men to lead prayer services, a model known as a partnership minyan. There are lots of gay couples at the synagogue, he said, and no limits placed on them.
The one-sentence excerpt in Jewish Action struck Citro as generic and safe. Nevertheless, he was curious about the rest.
“I would like to see it,” he said, “and I would like to draw my own conclusions from it.”
The post Before he died, an Orthodox leader worked quietly on a guide to LGBTQ+ inclusion. Few will ever read what he wrote. appeared first on The Forward.

