Local News
High holiday services for both Etz Chayim and Shaarey Zedek congregations to mark last high holidays before both congregations move into new venues
By MYRON LOVE Rosh Hashanah, which begins on the evening of Friday, September 15 and Yom Kippur, on Sunday, September 24, finds our synagogue scene in a state of flux. While this will be the last Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur for Etz Chayim congregants in their current 70-year-old location in north Winnipeg, for Shaarey Zedek members this will be the last Yom Tov outside their building on Wellington Crescent – currently undergoing renovations and an expansion.
And, under the dynamic leadership of new executive director Dr. Rena Secter Elbaze, the Shaarey Zedek is going all out to make this a Yom Tov to remember.
This is the second year that the Shaarey Zedek will have been holding Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur services at the Asper Campus – with regular Shabbat services at the Berney Theatre and weekday services at Temple Shalom – and, Elbaze says, “in an effort to show our members that we appreciate their patience and understanding during this period of construction, we are offering all of our members free seating for Yom Tov for those who want to attend services in person as well as congregants viewing the services on-line.”
Non-members, she adds, can purchase their seats and will also be eligible for free seating if they participate in our daily minyanim or volunteer their time to help with Shabbat minyanim.
A further incentive will be the return of the popular Rabbi Alan Green to join Rabbi Anibal Mass to lead the main service. Rabbi Mass will also be leading the family service – accompanied by Grant Park High School Grade 12 student Noah Trachtenberg – in the Asper campus Multipurpose room.
Elbaze adds that the popular Quartet will be returning – along with the 20-voice Ruach Folk Choir to further uplift and engage participants in this year’s services.
Childcare will also be on offer.
Elbaze reports that thus far 350 have registered for in-person attendance (“We hope to have 500,” she says) along with106 for the family services and 92 for the online services.
“We have received over $21,000 in donations so far,” she notes.
As to regular Shabbat attendance, the numbers are still not back to where they were pre-pandemic restrictions. Elbaze reports that Shabbat services are averaging about 40 as compared to 175 three years ago.
“We are excited about our future prospects,” she adds. “We are making a concerted effort to attract younger people through organizing regular Shabbat dinners and havdalah parties in members’ homes.”
Meanwhile, Congregation Etz Chayim in north Winnipeg is celebrating its last Yom Tov at its current location at 123 Matheson. In November, our community’s second largest congregation will be leaving behind its 71-year-old building and moving to the former Shriners’ headquarters on Wilkes in south Winnipeg.
For this final Yom Tov on Matheson services will continue to be led by Rabbi Kliel Rose and Cantor Tracy Kasner – with Kelly Robinson leading the High Holy Day Choir. Jonathan Buchwald, Etz Chayim’s executive director, further reports that “this year, in addition to the regular adult choir, we will be incorporating youth voices as well.
“We are also offering a Family Service designed for young families led by Deborah Spigelman and Nina Eilberg. This will be a 45 minute service” and will include storytelling, games and songs.
In addition, there will be a Junior Congregation youth service for all ages and a special designated group for Kadima age children. And, on the first day of Rosh Hashanah and on Kol Nidre there will be a program designed specifically for teens in grades 9 to 12.
Services are available either in-person or online.
Rob Waldman, the president of the egalitarian Chevra Mishnayes congregation in Garden City, says that the board is not expecting much change from last year. “We hope that attendance will be a little higher this year,” he says.
Last year’s attendance was 90 – exceeding all expectations.
Once again, Al Benarroch will be leading the services.
Still with the North End, the venerable House of Ashkenazie, the last of our community’s older-style Orthodox congregations, is also, according to president Gary Minuk, expecting little change for Yom Tov from last year when about 50 were in attendance for the first day of Rosh Hashanah and over 40 for Kol Nidre – numbers which were the best in some years.
One new option this year for frum members of our community living in the North End may be the former Chavurat Tefila – on the corner of Hartford and McGregor – which has reopened – after being closed for three years – as the North End Orthodox Minyan. The new congregation began regular Shabbat services at the end of July and is planning to be open for all Yom Tovim throughout the year – but the situation for Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur is still to be determined.
South Winnipeg also has a new Yom Tov option this year in the form of services being offered by Rabbi Matthew Leibl at the Gates on Roblin. “Last year, I had a lots of people ask me what I was going to do for Yom Tov,” says Leibl, who has been in demand for weddings, funerals and other community events since he left the Shaarey Zedek four years ago. “I perceived that there was a need for another alternative for High Holiday services.”
“Services on the River: A modern High Holidays” are scheduled for the second day of Rosh Hashanah, Kol Nidre and Yom Kippur morning. “Because the Shofar is not traditionally blown on Shabbat, we decided to celebrate Rosh Hashanah on the second day instead to be able to have the shofar in our service, ” Rabbi Leibl explains.
“ ‘Services on the River’ will be three services designed to offer moments of reflection and introspection, beautiful live music, and a celebration of the Jewish New Year, all against the pastoral backdrop of the Assiniboine River, which will also be our site for Tashlich on Rosh Hashanah. Rabbi Leibl adds.
He notes that he will be blending his trademark Torah commentary, relevant explanations, and some humour with a mix of traditional and contemporary liturgy, to deliver a High Holy Day experience that will feel both familiar and modern. He adds that he will be working with the husband and wife cantorial team of Justin Odwak and Sarah Sommer. All services will run 90 minutes. While families are encouraged to attend, there are no programs designed specifically for children.
Rabbi Leibl reports that the venue can accommodate up to 400 and that, thus far, he has commitments from about 150.
Both Ruth Livingston and Jack Craven, presidents respectively of Reform Congregation Temple Shalom and the Orthodox Adas Yeshurun Herzlia in south Winnipeg are reporting that it is business as usual this year. Both are hoping to see some growth in the numbers in attendance though, as fears of Covid continue to recede.
The Lubavitch Centre will also be business as usual. Capacity for the south Winnipeg institution is about 250-300. There is no charge for those wishing to attend services.
And, after a three-year absence, the Simkin Centre will again be holding Yom Tov services that are open to the general public. The services, which will begin at 10:00 A.M. on all three days of Yom Tov, will be led by Steven Hyman with the choir being led by Bonnie Antel.
Caitlin Liewicki, the manager of Resident Experience, is asking that anyone who may be planning on attending the service from the public to RSVP either by email (caitlin.liewicki@simkincentre.ca) or telephone (204- 589-9008), so that she knows how many to plan for.
Finally for those who enjoy the alternative – and, by now traditional services in their own way – at Camp Massad, there remains one more option for those seeking to attend a High Holiday service. After two years absence, Camp Massad is resuming its innovative Rosh Hashanah service. Daniel Sprintz, the camp’s executive director, is pleased to announce that Massad will again be hosting its usual Rosh Hashonah program on the second day.
“We offer a creative and interactive service that combines some traditional prayers with contemporary readings, folk music and our usual Camp massad Shtick,” Sprintz says. “Our services will be followed by a kosher lunch and Tashlich at the Lake.”
The service, this year, he notes, is being led by Rabbanit Dorit Kosmin. In pre-Covid times, Sprintz reports, Rosh Hashanah at Massad attracted as many as 150 participants. Last year, 90 attended. He is hoping to have a somewhat larger number this year.
The Registration deadline (massad.ca) is September 15.
Yom Tov this year begins on Friday, September 15, in the evening.
Wishing all readers a sweet new year.
Local News
BB Camp: A Legacy of Wilderness, Community, and Jewish Connection
Introduction: Readers of this website may have read stories some months back about the huge controversy in which BB Camp on Town Island in Lake of the Woods had found itself. You can read a number of different stories on this website simply by searching for BB Camp.
Those stories give a great deal of detail about what happened, beginning with a story posted on April 10 titled “BB Camp finds itself embroiled in controversy over camp co-director Jacob Brodovsky.”
Subsequently, we reported that the BB Camp board of directors had given a full vote of confidence to Brodovsky, only to find itself just a few days later ordered by the Jewish Federation of Winnipeg to reverse that decision and fire Brodovsky. (The Jewish Federation has consistently ignored requests from us to offer an explanation why it demanded the firing of Brodovsky.)
On April 27, however, we reported that the board of BB Camp had just appointed two new co-directors: Aliza Millo and Sarah Gould. You can read that story at “Well, that didn’t take long.” (We should note, however, as we did in that story posted on April 27, that Millo’s and Gould’s titles were “co-director,” not “co-executive director,” which were the titles held by their predecessors, Brodovsky and Lexie Yurman (who also happen to be married to each other). Although Jacob Brodovsky had been fired as camp co-executive director, Lexie Yurman happened to be on maternity leave at the time of Jacob’s firing. Whether she will be allowed to return as executive director next summer has not been announced by the board.
Recently, writer Jon van der Veen went out to BB Camp to see for himself how the camp had done this summer and to talk to both Millo and Gould.
Here is Jon’s report:
Nestled on Town Island in Lake of the Woods, BB Camp has been a cherished summer haven for generations of campers, counselors, and families. This year, BB welcomed back two dedicated staff members, Sarah Gould and Aliza Millo, to run the camp; their deep ties to the camp highlight its enduring magic and evolving traditions. In a heartfelt conversation, they shared their reasons for returning, the camp’s unique wilderness focus, and its vibrant Jewish programming that continues to foster community and growth.
A Homecoming Rooted in History:
Sarah’s connection to BB Camp spans decades. Starting as an eight-year-old camper, she progressed through the ranks to become a counselor, then to teaching canoeing and leading the camp’s renowned four-week AC (Advanced Camp) canoe trip. After years away—working at another camp, earning a graduate degree in anthropology, and raising a daughter—she returned this summer. “I’ve always been part of BB Camp,” Sarah said. “It held a special place in my heart, and when we heard there was an opportunity to come back, it just seemed like the right thing to do.”
Aliza, too, has deep roots at BB Camp. A former camper who completed the AC canoe trip, she later served as a counselor before moving to Toronto. Even during her time away, she stayed engaged through volunteer work and the camp’s alumni committee. “It feels like home,” Aliza shared. “It’s like a place where all Jewish people can come and feel completely safe and secure, like they belong.” Her personal milestone of meeting her husband at camp and marrying on the island underscores the lifelong bonds formed here.
The Wilderness Heart of BB Camp:
At the core of BB Camp’s identity is its wilderness program, a tradition that remains as strong today as it was decades ago. The pinnacle is the AC program, a four-week canoe trip where campers, aged 15, venture into the wilderness, covering up to 20 miles a day with multiple portages.
This year, five AC trips took approximately 50 campers into the remote reaches of Lake of the Woods, equipped with spot devices and satellite phones for safety—an update from Sarah’s era as a tripper when groups were entirely cut off from civilization.
The wilderness program starts young, with even the youngest campers, aged 11 to 12, embarking on overnight trips around the island’s conservation-protected campsites. As they grow, their adventures extend farther, culminating in the intensive AC trip. “The more skills they have, the more confident they feel,” Sarah noted, highlighting activities like knot-tying, fire-building, and canoeing that empower campers to embrace the outdoors. This skill-based learning is being revitalized this summer, with plans to bring back canoeing awards and wooden beads for achievements like sleeping under the stars—a tradition that resonates deeply with alumni.
A Vibrant Jewish Identity:
BB Camp’s commitment to Jewish culture is equally robust, thanks to the efforts of the “J-Crew,” a group of staff who have spearheaded a revival of Judaic programming. Aliza explained their grassroots initiative is inteded to amplify Jewish identity- something she says, was in already in motion before she and Sarah returned as camp directors.
A standout event is Israel Day, a camp-wide celebration that transforms the island into a vibrant tribute to Israeli culture. This year, campers “climbed Masada” at the ropes course, relaxed at a “Dead Sea spa” with oatmeal and cucumber slices, and enjoyed a “Tel Aviv beach party” with kayaking and canoe races. Falafel and Bissli snacks added authentic flavor, while decorations like Israeli flags and red thread bracelets created an immersive experience. “One kid said, ‘Israel Day is heaven,’” Aliza said – a testament to the program’s success. Aliza noted that the staff set up Israel Day at night, so that when the campers woke up it was a big surprise to see the camp transformed!
Beyond Israel Day, the camp weaves Jewish values into daily life, using Hebrew words like “chadar” for the dining hall. Shabbat programming offers flexibility, with counselors designing activities like book clubs or arts and crafts, ensuring every camper finds their place. “It’s about being intentional,” Aliza said, noting the camp’s efforts to foster a shared Jewish language and sense of belonging.
Aliza also informed me that BB camp had two Israeli staff members this year. Although not a new phenomenon, their continued incorporation into camp life provides a valuable cross-cultural exchange and helps enhance the Jewish identity.
Continuity and Change
Despite the passage of time, much of BB Camp feels unchanged. The swim docks, the energy of kids running down camp trails, and the closing tradition of the “burning B’s”—a raft with the camp’s initials set alight on the final night—evoke nostalgia for Sarah and Aliza. “The energy hasn’t changed,” Aliza said, reflecting on the familiar giggles and excitement that define camp life. Yet, modern touches like printed emails from parents and safety devices for wilderness trips reflect thoughtful evolution. However, BB Camp isn’t in a rush to adopt all the trappings of modern life, wary of ruining the wilderness experience. “We want them to experience the wilderness without distractions,” Sarah explained, emphasizing that the camp’s no-phone policy offers kids a rare chance to disconnect from a technology dominated world.
The camp’s generational continuity is striking. Sarah noted, saying that she would see the children of former counselors and campers, with families from Toronto, Vancouver, and beyond sending their kids to experience BB Camp’s magic. Kids like to find the names of their parents and other relatives on the canoe trip paddles – dating back to 1968, that line the dining hall walls. “There’s a real generational continuity here,” she said. “It’s a place that’s special in people’s hearts.”
This generational continuity is something Sarah experienced first-hand this summer, as she brought along her young daughter when she took the job at camp. “ She loves it,” Sarah remarked. “We live in Toronto now, but I wanted her to be part of the BB camp family.”
A Place of Growth and Connection:
With 117 campers and 28 leaders-in-training this session, BB Camp buzzes with activity. From the competitive Maccabi Games to canoe trips, the schedule is packed yet purposeful, with a balance between the arts and the outdoors.
The camp’s small cabins, ranging from seven to twelve campers, ensure personalized attention, with counselors, while staff-in-training fosters a supportive environment.
For Sarah and Aliza, BB Camp is more than a summer getaway—it’s a transformative space where kids grow through challenges, whether conquering a ropes course, paddling a canoe, or simply sleeping away from home. “Kids find their thing here,” Sarah said. “From that challenge comes growth.” The camp’s pristine wilderness – free from the distractions of modern life, amplifies this impact, offering a rare opportunity for decompression and self-discovery.
As Sarah and Aliza walked through the camp, pointing out the tripper track—a relic from the island’s days as a 1950s army base—and sharing stories of their own camp days, their passion was palpable. “There’s nowhere else like Lake of the Woods,” Sarah said, reflecting on the solitude and beauty of the AC trips. “It’s a true wilderness experience.”
After a successful grassroots campaign to save Towne Island from development in 2021, BB Camp now partners with the Nature Conservancy of Canada as stewards of Towne Island. Protecting and caring for the environment, its pristine forests and wildlife, is a key value instilled in camp life.
A Community United:
This year, BB Camp has seen an outpouring of support from the broader camp community, including partnerships with other Jewish camps like Camp Massad. “There’s no need for rivalry,” Aliza said, noting the collaborative spirit that strengthens Winnipeg’s Jewish camping scene. With only about 14,000 Jews in the city, the existence of two such nearby camps is a remarkable asset.
As each summer comes and goes, BB Camp remains a beacon of tradition, growth, and community. For Sarah, Aliza, and countless others, it’s a place where memories are made, skills are honed, and Jewish identity is celebrated—a true home away from home on the picturesque shores of Town Island.
Local News
Arthur V. Mauro Institute for Peace & Justice at St. Paul’s College to offer series of lectures
The Mauro Institute is very pleased to be offering the first two events in a new series – The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution.
Dialogue #1 – Wednesday, September 17 | 7:00 pm to 8:30 pm | Hanley Hall (Room 220) St. Paul’s College (reception to follow)
The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution
Resisting the Perceived Limits of Dialogue
Middle powers such as Canada depend on the power of dialogue to create institutions and agreements with dispute settlement mechanisms designed to level the playing field with big powers. The post-war architecture of multilateralism that depended on American leadership and involvement and the willingness to underwrite the global operating system is fractured with President Donald Trump’s premise to “make America great again”. This presentation by former Canadian diplomat, Colin Robertson and roundtable discussion will consider if it can be put back together or how it should change, and what forms of dialogue that would entail.
Panelists will include Dr. Ursula Lehmkuhl and Dr. Manuel Fröhlich of Trier University, and Dr. James Fergusson and Dr. Stephan Jaeger of the University of Manitoba. The roundtable discussion will be moderated by Dr. Andrea Charron, Director, Centre for Defence and Security Studies, and Professor, International Relations University of Manitoba
Reserve your free tickets to the lecture 7:00 pm, in-person at St. Paul’s College
Livestream on the Mauro Institute YouTube channel.
Dialogue #2 – Thursday, September 25 | 7:00 pm to 8:30 pm | Fr. Jensen SJ Theatre (Room 100) St. Paul’s College
The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution
Leading With Compassion Amid Conflict and Violence
Deep human connection and providing service from a place of compassion is increasingly difficult in our complex and polarizing world. In our quest for peace and justice, is compassion simply a pollyannish illusion? Come, hear, and have a conversation with our panelists who have strived to bring compassion into their work in different ways. Hear their challenges and triumphs as they dared to lead with compassion in times of conflict and violence.
Panelists will include Dr. Bob Chrismas, Team Lead, Winnipeg Community Safety Team, Dr. Shauna Labman, Executive Director, Global College and Associate Professor, University of Winnipeg, and Devon Clunis, Former Chief of Police, Winnipeg Police Service, Author, and International Consultant. The roundtable discussion will be moderated by Dr. Melanie Soderstrom, Professor, Department of Psychology, University of Manitoba
The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution are free and open to all. The dialogues are both in-person and available to be streamed on the Mauro Institute’s YouTube channel.
Reserve your free tickets to the lecture 7:00 pm, in-person at St. Paul’s College (free pre-lecture reception from 6:30 pm)
Livestream on the Mauro Institute YouTube channel.
[ALSO: Save the Date – the 2025 Sol Kanee Lecture on Peace and Justice is Monday, November 3, 7:00 pm at the Canadian Museum for Human Rights]
The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution are generously supported by a gift from Dr. Hersh [BSc(Hons)/70] and Arna Shefrin [DipDHyg/70; BA/71]. The Shefrin Dialogues were established to invite two (or more) leading thinkers / speakers with different views of a specific conflict to present and exchange perspectives on topical issues related to peace, justice, and conflict resolution.
The Hersh and Arna Shefrin Dialogues on Peace and Conflict Resolution are free and open to all. The dialogues are both in-person and available to be streamed on the Mauro Institute’s YouTube channel.
Local News
Winnipeg Friends of Israel to present 2 interesting talks
Winnipeg Friends of Israel are thrilled to welcome Dr. Ted Rosenberg on Sunday, September 14 at 7:00 PM for a presentation that promises to be powerful, timely, and deeply moving.
Dr. Rosenberg will share insights from his new book, Ayekha (Where Are You?), and speak about his experiences at the University of British Columbia — where he made national headlines after resigning from the medical school in protest of its failure to address antisemitism. His story is both courageous and inspiring, and it calls on each of us to consider: Where are we when our community is under attack?
The evening will be moderated by Dr. Bryan Shwartz, and will include time for Q&A with Dr. Rosenberg.
📖 About the Book
Ayekha draws from Torah, the October 7 Hamas massacre, and today’s alarming rise in antisemitism. It challenges Jews and allies to confront hate with clarity, action, and moral responsibility. All book sales support the first Jewish day school in Victoria, BC, founded on October 7, 2024.
Copies are available on Amazon, and thanks to Dr. Cathy Moser, you can also pre-order directly (email: cathy.g.moser@gmail.com). Dr. Rosenberg will gladly autograph your copy after the event.
📅 Date: Sunday, September 14
🕖 Time: 7:00 PM
📍 Location: Shared upon registration
👉 Register here: https://tinyurl.com/mv8tvwhv
📰 Dr. Rosenberg was recently featured in the Canadian Jewish News. You can read more here: CJN article
Don’t miss this inspiring and thought-provoking evening — one that speaks to our moment in history and to the responsibility each of us carries.
We are also invited to attend another timely and exciting event and hope you could join us.
The Druze of Syria and Israel: A New Chapter
Join us for a rare and intimate fireside chat with Carlos Matni and Adham Tayfour — both members of the Syrian Druze community now living in Manitoba.
🌿 Discover the untold struggles, resilience, and hopes of the Druze community in Sweida, Syria.
🤝 Learn how Israel is stepping in during a time of crisis.
🌍 Explore the possibilities for collaboration between the Druze and Jewish communities — a conversation of unity, survival, and shared future.
📅 Thursday, September 18
🕢 7:30 PM
📍 Location provided upon registration
Don’t miss this opportunity to gain insight, ask questions, and be part of an important dialogue that bridges cultures and communities.
👉 Register now to reserve your spot:
https://shorturl.fm/SoWuv
