Features
The British Invasion: Douglas Murray and Colonel Richard Kemp, Tel Aviv International Salon, Dec.21, 2023
By GABRIEL EMMANUEL In 1964 the Beatles were banned from performing in Israel (to the Jewish state’s everlasting shame and embarrassment). Nearly 60 years later a British invasion of a different sort took place and the crowd reaction was almost like a mini Beatlemania.
Some 600 or more twenty and thirty somethings packed themselves into a meeting room at the Carlton Hotel in Tel Aviv that was meant to accommodate only about a third of that size. The featured speakers were former Commander of the British forces in Afghanistan, Richard Kemp, and author, political commentator, Douglas Murray, whose book “War on the West”(2018) quickly became a New York Times bestseller. Both Kemp and Murray have spent the past two and a half months in Israel covering the war. “I’ve almost made Aliya” quipped Kemp as the talk was about to begin. When the charismatic Murray entered the room a little late for reasons which he would come to share, the audience broke into spontaneous applause.
While Colonel Kemp has been known for years for endorsing the IDF as the “most moral army” in the world, Douglas Murray shot to fame at the opening of the present conflict with his acerbic response to an interviewer’s question as to whether Israel’s response to the atrocities of Oct. 7 could be considered “proportionate”. In a segment on British Talk TV https://talk.tv/top-stories/31465/douglas-murray-proportionality-in-conflict-is-a-joke that went instantly viral Murray responded “There is some deep perversion in Britain whenever Israel is involved in a conflict and it’s the word you just used – proportion, proportionate, proportionality. Only Britain is really obsessed with this…Proportionality in conflict rarely exists but if we were to decide that we should have this fetish about proportionality then that would mean that in retaliation for what Hamas did in Israel on Saturday (Oct. 7, G.E.) then Israel should try and locate a music festival in Gaza for instance (and good luck with that), and rape precisely the number of women that Hamas raped, kill precisely the number of young people that Hamas killed. They should find a town of exactly the same size of Sderot… and make sure they go door to door and kill precisely the correct number of babies that Hamas killed in Sderot and shoot in the head precisely the same number of old age pensioners that Hamas shot in the head on Saturday…Proportionality in conflict is a joke,” spurned Douglas adding, “that it is only the Israelis that when attacked are expected to have precisely a proportionate response.”
Given the British gentlemens’ philo-semitic reputations the audience broke out with mixed laughter and applause when the two were introduced as the “two most beloved “Goyim” in all of Israel. Non-plussed by the off-colour moniker, Kemp stated proudly that “I am also an extremely talented “Shabbat Goy” the result of having been residing in a hotel with many displaced persons from Kiryat Shmona “who have used my services quite extensively.”
Asked by another Brit, moderator Deborah Danon, what drew each of them to supporting Israel in a topsy turvy world that was largely hostile towards the Jewish State, each had similar reasons for doing so. “I was taught when I was very young to know right from wrong,” said Kemp, “and it’s my duty to support those who are right. There is no question who is in the right in this fight,” he added.
Moreover, underscoring his 30 years spent fighting terrorists in Afghanistan and Iraq Kemp felt duty bound “to do what little I can do to help fight this fight with you because it’s not just your fight it’s a fight for Western civilization; the same ideology that’s attacking you now has attacked us in the past and will intensify its attacks in the future.”
Apologizing for his late entrance for having been held up in an interview on the Piers Morgan show (“It’s quite hard to get Piers to stop talking”) Murray offered another reason responsible for drawing him over to Israel’s side. “Aside from my love for this country and its people,” he said, “I also see something which I think any writer or journalist should see and get very annoyed by, which is lies. When it’s lies about an entire nation and people, when I hear someone like this blowhard I heard earlier (on Piers Morgan, G.E.) accusing Israel of ‘genociding’ the Palestinians, I can’t sit here and not say something. I’m not going to allow these canards, smears and lies and defamation to just go on…I don’t like lies being told and Israel has been on the receiving end of some of the biggest, longest, deepest and most wounding lies of our era,” said Murray. Demonstrating his effortless ability to deftly cross over from political commentary to artful literary imagery he caps the thought with finesse: “So I believe in the simple cause of “moral hygiene” that it’s necessary to try and clean some of that up.”
The moderator then asked a pertinent question: “In a world of Tik Tok where Jesus is Palestinian, do you wonder if this is just a Myth of Sisyphus syndrome where you are just pushing that rock up the hill and do you ever ask yourself just what’s the point?”
“Never, actually,” Murray replied emphatically. “Even if it was the case what option have you got? Just to sit at the bottom of the hill and get crushed by the rock?” he asks rhetorically.
Despite the omnipresence of social media in the world, where lies are able to “rocket around the world” Murray holds fast to a different view. “if you live in a world where 99 lies are being told and one person tells the truth, the truth will win,” he asserts and gives the example of writers such as Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn whose work was effective in bringing down the entire Soviet Empire. “The validity of a truth in an era of lies cannot be underestimated,” he says.
From the topic of lies it was an easy segue to Hamas battle figures. “I don’t know what the latest exaggerated figure is from Hamas about the number of people that have been killed in Gaza” says Kemp, “I just know that it has to be defeated. If it means that a very large number of people whether military or civilian have to die in that process then unfortunately that’s the case because no sovereign, democratic state can exist under this threat so it must be eliminated, it’s as simple as that,” states Kemp in a no nonsense, tell it like it is, military analysis. Despite the unreliability of figures Kemp posits that based on the figures he’s received from Israeli sources of 8,000 or 9,000 or more have been killed from Hamas and Islamic Jihad, which would represent about 30% of the total number of terrorists. “That’s a very significant proportion,” he says, “that’s in excess of 30% of their fighting capability. The whole edifice then begins to crumble and I think we’re going to see that,” he says with conviction.
“I’ve been in Gaza on a number of occasions. I’m deeply impressed by the IDF combat effectiveness. This is going to come down at some point,” Kemp says quite bluntly.
Kamp makes regular visits to the soldiers in hospital and knows the tragedy of war from close up. “Tragically, many Israeli soldiers will die and have died already,” he concedes, “but they will undoubtedly prevail in the end.” He contrasts the irony with Hamas: “They want the I.D.F. to kill their civilians. They want as many civilians killed as possible because that then provokes the inevitable international demand for ceasefire, condemning Israel for War Crimes,” he concludes while shaking his head at the anticipated perversion of justice.
Asked about pressure from the United States, Douglas Murray elucidated his view that “You should be courteous to your allies but not subservient to them,” earning a strong round of applause. “The future of this State, of the Jewish people must be in the hands of the Jewish people,” he continued.” It cannot be in the hands of anyone else. It cannot be in the hands of people who, for instance say the day after the massacre of October 7th that this is why we need to double down on the two state solution. It just can’t be in the hands of people going at that kind of slow speed”, he says.
Had the events of Oct.7th happened in the U.S.A., Murray points out, proportionately over 120,000 Americans would have been massacred on one day. “Nobody can tell me that the Americans would have listened to anyone then, nor should they, “he adds. The one potential outcome of the war that Murray absolutely rejects is that the situation might return to the status quo ante of October 6th. “Israel must be allowed to win,” he asserts. “It cannot simply always be encouraged to fight for a stalemate.” Regarding the as of yet unresolved situation with Hezbollah, Murray poked fun at the thought that we will all have to relearn the map of the North and become experts again on the Litani River. “Since 2006 it’s just been a replay of the same thing,” he says. “It just feels like Groundhog Day,” he quips to the amused young people in the room. And then in a more somber tone: “Anything other than actual victory by the Israelis in this conflict is unacceptable because all of these efforts to make Israel fight into a stalemate will simply prepare the groundwork for the next war and this country deserves not to be forced into perpetual war,” he emphasizes.
According to Colonel Kemp’s analysis much of what has transpired in the world in terms of instability with the Ukraine and now Gaza has to do with a weak image projected by President Joe Biden. On the other hand, Kemp considers that Biden has been strongly in favour of Israel and the U.S. unlikely to pressure Israel to desist its military operations. For this dichotomous view Kemp actually earned applause from both Biden supporters and detractors.
The moderator brought up the tragic issue of the three hostages who had been mistakenly killed by Israeli troops. Douglas Murray reflected on the incident and said that he was genuinely shocked by “the lack of empathy for Israel internationally”. A glaring example of such a lack of empathy he suggested could be found with the posters of the hostages in various cities around the world. What followed was another of Murray’s innovative insights: “If you put up a poster of a missing cat or dog in your neighbourhood you would not expect anyone to rip it down,” he matter of factly suggests. “And if anyone did rip it down you would think that person was subhuman. You would think what kind of a sick person are we dealing with here?” he asks. “And this wasn’t dogs or cats. These were Jewish children. And in city after city sociopaths tore down these posters…This lack of empathy has been there since the day (Oct.7th G.E.) itself. And the media treats it as more evidence of the brutality of the Israeli soldiers – they even kill their own! Imagine the lives of those soldiers who shot those three hostages, how they must have felt. And yet instead of recognizing what a tragedy that is for everybody involved they use it as a weapon against Israel!” Murray’s damning condemnation resounds through the packed but quiet room. “That really has slightly startled me in this conflict,” he continued to reflect in an afterthought.
The door was left open for a little humour when the Moderator, in her last question, asked about the Day After. Colonel Kemp was first to pick up the gauntlet: “I think we need a two state solution with the United Nations supervising it,” he said without flinching and with a stiff British upper lip to boot which held tightly in place until the audience stopped laughing. And then more seriously his sober insight: “The I.D.F. has no option, whatsoever, apart from to stay in control of Gaza from now on. It doesn’t matter what anyone else thinks; it doesn’t matter what President Biden might wish to happen…What is absolutely certain is that the I.D.F. must maintain security control of Gaza. It means either a permanent IDF presence inside the whole of Gaza or it means the creation of a one or two mile buffer zone on the inside of the Gaza border which no one is allowed to go into and which the I.D.F can police.”
Kemp had nary a kind word to say about the folks on the other side:”The reality in Gaza is that the vast majority of the population of allegedly innocent civilians support Hamas, even when they see the horrors that Hamas has brought on them, they still support Hamas . And there will be efforts to have a Hamas 2,” the Colonel warned.
Murray concurs that it is a “very bleak necessity” but that Israel will need to stay in Gaza. For how long? “Call me a pessimist,” says Kemp, “but I would say forever.” Like his colleague, Murray also spends some of his days visiting the wounded in hospitals. On a recent visit he met one of the victims, a farmer, from a border Kibbutz who had lost his wife, son and both of his legs in the Hamas attack of Oct.7th . “He said something that has really stuck with me,” Murray recalled, “He said, ‘I have been a leftist all my life. I now want to look out on nothing but potato fields from here to the Mediterranean.’ Who can risk living beside these people? Nobody else in the world would be expected to have to put up with that. I don’t think the Israelis have to be an experiment test case either. I think you should have the right to live in peace and to know that the border you have does not contain genocidal maniacs on the other side who wish to kill you all.”
In the question period which followed, Murray was asked what changes he would like to see in present day Britain. “Obviously the first thing I’d do would be to make Richard Kemp Minister of Defence,” he suggests to uproarious laughter from the crowd. “I assume you’ll be Prime Minister, will you,” Kemp shot back. Feigning humility, Murray wistfully demurred saying only, “If the nations calls…” Presumably, they may one day.
Getting more serious Murray took aim at the “appalling” pro Hamas demonstrations which took place in London and included one on Remembrance Day. “I think it’s been shameful,” he said. “I want no Hamas supporters in my country. And that’s quite easy to arrange in my view,” he added making reference to a case in point of Muhammud Sawalha, a key Hamas terrorist from the West Bank who subsequently obtained British citizenship. “To get a British passport you must, among other things sign a form that says you are a person of good character. I submit that he is not a person of good character,” said Murray, “and that he lied on his form when he said that he was. I would like to see his citizenship stripped and I would like to see him deported and to try his luck in Gaza.” On a humorous roll, Murray recalled the case of a young lady whose British passport was recalled when she returned from having joined Isis and tried to pretend – once the Caliphate fell apart – that she didn’t know that they were actually a “murderous, head-hacking group” and besides, “we all make mistakes”. She shouldn’t get her passport back argued Murray maintaining vociferously that “If you’re with an Islamist death cult you should not be allowed to be in Britain.”
Colonel Kemp fielded a question about another hot potato issue, that of missiles being fired from Yemen which no one seems to be doing anything about. “Yemen has been firing missiles into Israel since the war began including the first ever in history engagement in space when a Houthi ballistic missile was intercepted by an Israeli Aero missile outside the earth’s atmosphere. They’ve been firing numerous missiles and drones towards Israel, all of which have been shot down.” Unless a message is sent soon to Yemen and Iran by the U.S. Kemp warns that war in Lebanon will be inevitable.
A visiting American Major with a pronounced Midwestern drawl asked Colonel Kemp if he could explain the concept known as “the fog of war”. “It’s an extraordinary thing that doesn’t apply anywhere else in life,” said Kemp, “you have very often young, inexperienced soldiers in the reserves with a limited amount of recent training and then suddenly they are thrown into Gaza which I would say is one of the most treacherous and demanding battlefields that anyone has fought on in the history of warfare. And they’re expected to always make the right decision. That simply cannot happen. We all make mistakes. And that’s when nobody is shooting at us. Nobody is trying to kill us. We haven’t suffered lack of sleep for days on end, we’re not cold, hungry, we’re not terrified and yet we still make mistakes. So how can these guys not make mistakes? And the enemy is trying to fool you all the time, trying to make you think that the reality in front of your eyes is not the reality in front of your eyes. And the difference is when a soldier makes a mistake very often people die as a consequence.” The reference that was embedded on most peoples’ minds was the recent tragic killing of the three Israeli hostages by friendly fire.
Murray was asked about the effect of “hasbara” (P.R. G.E) in the current war. “I believe they should be given some credit for they have done a better job that any time previously that I have been covering since 2006”, he said. Taking the Al-Shifa hospital as an example, Murray pointed out that Israel “got on top of it very fast” like releasing the closed circuit TV footage of the hostages being led in to the hospital and showing the weapons cache that was discovered there. But at the same time, he underscores why not even the best P.R. may succeed in certain circumstances. “The minute they show that the hospital has an arms dump inside it and has a load of kalashnikovs and grenades , Jeremy Bowen of the BBC goes on and is asked about it and says, ‘well, it is not inconceivable that the kalshnikovs belonged to the hospital’s security department’. On the television the next day I said, ‘yes, and it’s possible the grenades were for the cardiology department’.” Murray’s point is well taken. No matter how strong the evidence is, it is not necessarily strong enough to overcome bias.
Kemp concurs, “This extraordinary propaganda campaign against Israel – everything that Israel does is wrong. For the past 10 years the BBC has not allowed me to speak on any program about Israel. Any other security issue, any other country I’m on all the time on the BBC just not about Israel. I got a call a few weeks back asking if I would do an interview about Israel. I almost fell off my chair,” recalls Kemp. “Then I realized what was going on. They had been heavily criticized and were under a lot of pressure for their lies about Al-Alhi hospital attack (where Israel was wrongly blamed for the bombing, G.E.) They felt we need to show how broadminded we are, so we’ll even get this extremist Kemp on to speak. So that’s how I became a human shield for the BBC”, Kemp concluded with a wry smile.
In a final story, also about the BBC, Kemp relates that he was once invited to the BBC studio in Jerusalem to do a number of interviews. In the interview which was live from London he was asked why the IDF were so keen to send in ground forces to Gaza. I explained “they don’t want to go in on the ground, they know the problems with that. So I was asked then why do the politicians want to go in on the ground. I said they don’t. I’ve spoken to them, the Prime Minister, the Defence Minister they will only go in if they have to. The interviewer was completely stumped at this and all he could say was, ‘yes, but you’re a Jew’. Now how do you answer that,” Kemp asked incredulously. Do I say in a belligerent tone, “how dare you accuse me of being a Jew!?” But instead I said simply, “I don’t have that honour.”
“If I can just say something” interjected Murray, “about the youth of this country. So young! So brilliant! So vivacious. I met a young woman the other day of 21 who was an expert on Yemen! Why her contemporary in America is being educated to become stupid and wicked!” his observation met by peals of laughter. Then more seriously, “I have been so moved by these young people. They will be an example not just to Israel but to the people of the world. And if I may leave you with one last thought,” he continued. “I know this period is incredibly troubling, disturbing, upsetting and much more for the people of this country. I think the country is still going through a trauma, trying to work out what was done to you in October. You asked at the beginning why we do this. I would just say whether I can answer it or not, it is the honour of my life to be standing in alliance with you.”
The evening done, the young people rushed the small stage to take selfies with both fine gentlemen. Douglas Murray and Colonel Richard Kemp. Two of Israel’s most beloved friends, indeed.
Gabriel Emanuel is a former Winnipegger.
An edited version of this article first appeared in the Jerusalem Post, December 29, 2023 .
Features
What Happens in Poker When You Tie? Split Pots Explained
Learn what happens when poker players tie, how split pots work, and which rules determine the winner when hands have the same value.
Ties have gone by the wayside in team sports. The NFL and NHL have done their best to make sure they never happen, too. The same cannot be said for poker. On occasion, people with the same hands tie. So, what happens in poker when you tie?
How Does a Split Pot Work in Poker?
Poker tie rules result in players with equal ranked winning hands leading to the pot being split. It can also see three players with the same hand and the result is each player gets a third of the pot. It is that simple. Two people tie and the pot is 50-50. Three and it is a third to each
How Kickers and Hand Rankings Break a Tie
When thinking about a split pot in poker, kickers play a part of each player’s best five-card hand. That means building the best five-card hand you can. So say both players have a pair of 8s. What happens? It isn’t so a poker straight tie breaker because you can then check what the other three cards that comprise the players’ hands are. The player who has the stronger hand of the remaining three cards would win the pot.
An example of how a kicker would not play into a decision is when players have a straight. If they both have the same straight, that would end the hand in a tie. You don’t go any deeper than the top five.
Make sure to check out BetUS poker variants before starting to play for serious cash when you’re going to play online poker for real money.
How Does a Poker Game End When Players Tie?
A tie at the end of a hand differs from what happens should a tournament end in what could or would be considered a deadlock. Should tournaments end in a tie, the players would split the combined pot for the position. So, if players wind up tied for seventh (and eighth), they would share the combined pot for those positions. If two or more players are tied or agree to stop playing at the end of a tournament, they can decide together to split the prize pool. There can be an even split or if the players agree to the terms, it can go to whatever percentage of chips each has left.
There are poker rules, and some consider it standard that if two or more players are eliminated in the same hand, the one that started it with more chips would finish higher. This would be contrary to the splitting of the two positions but it can happen. Another level of ties in tournaments that can be factored in are seat position.
One has to understand all the rules and ramifications before sitting down to play at a poker table whether a game or tournament.
Can the River Card Turn a Winning Hand Into a Tie?
The turn and river in poker can be key cards in the way a hand plays out. The question is: Can the river wind up leading a hand into becoming a tie? The answer is yes. The river is the last community card and it can often be decisive. It can change a winning hand for someone into a losing hand or a tie. The same can be said on the flip side as the river can deliver the winning card for someone who appeared to be in a losing position.
Which Cards Matter When Both Players Have the Same Pair?
When both players have the same pair, the next three cards in their hands would make the difference in who wins the hand. So if someone has a pair of Kings and 7-8-9 and the opponent has kings and 8-9-Jack, the latter’s hand would be considered stronger because the Jack is a higher card than the nine the former has as their top card outside the Kings.
Can this get sticky and thicket-like, sometimes? Yes, but the reality is that the stronger overall five-card hand is the one that is considered the winning hand; unless they are absolutely equal, like having the same cards in a straight or, in a rarer occurrence, a flush, they will not be considered a tie.
FAQs
Can a poker game end in a tie?
Yes, a poker game can end in a tie. If that happens, then the players would either decide how to split the overall pot, or there would be rules that were set before the game or tournament starts.
Who wins a two pair tie?
A two-pair tie would go to the player whose fifth card is higher. If the fifth cards are equal, the hand would be a tie and then the pot split.
How is a split pot divided in poker?
A split pot is divided equally among the players involved in the tie, whether two-way, three-way, etc.
Features
The Enduring Forms of Jew-Hatred
By HENRY SREBRNIK “Antisemitism” and “antizionism” are not, in their essential features, forms of racism. These ideological constructs may include depictions of Jews in disparaging ways – through looks, accents, and other forms of prejudice – but they are political projects, just as anti-Judaism in the past was found (and sometimes still can be) in Christian and Muslim theology.
Both words are also misleading — few Jew-haters are concerned with “Semites” or actual “Zionists” (in the historical sense) as such. The word “Zionist” is for them, not about a political movement, ideology, or history. It is simply a metonym or synonym for “Jew.” Both words posit “the Jew” or “the Zionist” as a member of a malignant world-historical force, the antithesis and enemy of all that is good among human beings.
Neither the “Zionist” nor the “Semite” in these constructions corresponds to a real, discrete group; both are caricature figures onto whom an entire set of libels, suspicions, and eliminationist fantasies are projected. Retaining the hyphen unwittingly affirms the antizionist claim that they are engaged in a normal political dispute with an actual constituency called “Zionists,” rather than waging a hostility organized around the erasure of Jewish collective existence.
Jew-haters in the past condemned Jews as deicides, and they today consider Jews responsible for both the excesses of capitalism and the economic and social evils of Communism. The consequence is that Jews are to be hated and deemed unworthy of sympathy and solidarity. Even the facts of Jewish victimhood, whether the Holocaust or the massacres of October 7, can be portrayed as a scheme for Jews seeking some kind of dominance by “exploiting” their own past historical sufferings.
It’s an old story. In his 1882 pamphlet Auto-Emancipation, Leon Pinsker, a founder and leader of the Hibat Zion movement in tsarist Russia, observed: “To the living the Jew is a corpse, to the native a foreigner, to the homesteader a vagrant, to the proprietary a beggar, to the poor an exploiter and a millionaire, to the patriot a man without a country, for all a hated rival.”
Today’s “antizionism” has nothing to do with the “anti-Zionism” that existed within the political debates in the Jewish world earlier in the 19th and 20th centuries, mainly prior to 1948. These remained internal Jewish arguments about the future of Jewish life. Jewish anti-Zionists still understood Jews as a people with shared history, continuity, and collective identity. What they did not do was portray Jewish self-determination as inherently racist or fundamentally illegitimate, nor frame Zionism as a global conspiracy threatening humanity itself.
There is little direct link between the various actual anti-Zionist programs that existed within the Jewish world before the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948 and contemporary antizionism, like that of the Jewish Voices for Peace or Students for Justice in Palestine. They gain credibility and authenticity if people are led to believe they have inherited the mantle of those who opposed the establishment of a Jewish state seventy-five or a hundred years ago. Efforts to eliminate an actual state with millions of Jewish citizens bear no relationship, especially post-Holocaust, with earlier arguments that assimilation into European societies working classes represented a solution preferable to Jewish statehood.
That confusion even exists among leftist pro-Palestinian Jews, some of whom now have rediscovered the Jewish Labour Bund. They relate to, and are seen by Jew-haters, the way a Jew who converted to Christianity, Islam, or Communism was treated in previous eras.
Yes, many Orthodox Jews traditionally opposed Zionism on theological grounds, but that belief lost its persuasive power with the Holocaust and the establishment of Israel. There remain remnants of Jewish groups opposed to Israel’s existence, notably the Haredi Satmar Jews, who believe only the Messiah can found a Jewish state, but they are not Jews who hate or wish to harm other Jews. Even in Israel, there are genuine, religious ultra-Orthodox rabbis opposed. Rabbi Dov Lando, an influential figure in the United Torah Judaism party, recently contended that Zionism “made Arabs hate us” and Arab rule would have been preferable to the establishment of the state. This is genuine, Jewish anti-Zionism, not “antizionism.”
Modern antizionism did not emerge organically from moral reflection. It is the inheritance of an ideological campaign that replaced the word Jew with Zionist while leaving every underlying accusation intact. The language of conspiracy, domination, blood guilt, and moral corruption was simply updated.
Antizionist ideology treats Jewish peoplehood and sovereignty as an intrinsic injustice. It is today’s evolved form of anti-Jewish hate, less crude than classical antisemitism, but no less potent. Defined by its practice rather than by any claims it makes about “Zionism,” antizionism involves a now-familiar behavioural repertoire: encampments and other occupations of university spaces, boycotts of Israeli scholars and artists, masked harassment of Jewish students, defacement and destruction of Jewish property, disruption of performances by Jewish musicians, and so forth. Like other movements, antizionism at the extreme finds expression in political violence.
In universities, workplaces, and public culture, many Jews now find that their relationship to Israel has become a moral lens through which their broader ethical character is interpreted. Statements are no longer heard merely as judgments about a distant conflict, but as disclosures of one’s deeper moral orientation.
“These are behaviours,” contends Shaul Kelner, a professor of Jewish studies and sociology at Vanderbilt University, in his article on “American Antizionism” published in the Fall/Winter 2025 issue of Sources: A Journal of Jewish Ideas, “by which antizionists construct themselves as a moral community in contradistinction to a polluting Other. (A polluting Other that, we need not add, just happens to be Jewish.)”
Because antizionist politics have taken root mainly among the intelligentsia, such as professors, university students, journalists, and artists, many people assume that antizionism is a reasoned intellectual position, more rational than emotional. This certainly serves the interests of antizionism’s proponents, but “antizionism” is actually a conspiracy theory about Jewish world power corrupting and subduing the nations and peoples of the world. Political “Jew-hatred,” to use the more correct term, is a political project, one needed to defeat a “world Jewry” in power in, among other places, the United States. It is not simple “racism,” as it ascribes to Jews almost demonic powers virtually across the globe, and not just confined to the actions of an Israel that is uniquely evil, precisely because it is Jewish.
Soviet “Zionology” as early as the 1960s was expressed in this way, and if one simply substituted “Zionist” for “Jew,” it was an almost exact replica of similar Nazi terminology. Remember what Israeli historian Saul Friedlander wrote in his 2007 book The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939–1945: The Nazis regarded Jews “as an active threat, for all of Aryan humanity in the long run, and in the immediate future for a Reich embroiled in a world war. Thus the Jews had to be exterminated before they could harm ‘Fortress Europe’ from within or join forces with the enemy coalition they had themselves set against the Reich.”
Thus, as Naya Lekht, who teaches the history of anti-Jewish movements, explains in “Where the Soviets Won,” Fathom, Sept. 13, 2026, the Jew-hater does not hate Jews in a racist way. “The antisemite is not so much contemptuous of the inferior Jews as he is afraid and resentful of them. In the antisemitic imagination, the Jew is not subhuman but superhuman, possessed of an almost supernatural capacity to infiltrate, manipulate, transform, and corrupt.” Antizionism is a lot more than ideological opposition to a Jewish state. It is the continuation of an ancient project centred on producing Jewish villains. The threat is that the Jew will get inside your institutions, your culture, your bloodline, and make you into something you are not.
When the USSR was rabidly “anti-Zionist” and an enemy of the Jewish state, few people in western countries denied it was antisemitism. In 1975 the Soviet bloc and Arab states passed the notorious “Zionism is Racism” motion in the United Nations General Assembly. It too had little traction in North American political circles. The U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, in a stirring speech eloquently defended Israel. What would he make of the direction the Democratic Party is taking now? Today, when university professors and politicians, including a newly elected Michigan senator and a New York mayor, use the same language, it is suddenly “kosher,” and Jew-haters get a pass when they scream about Israeli “apartheid” and “genocide.”
“The anti-Zionist is not genuinely concerned with Zionism or Israel as they exist,” continues Lekht. “Rather, the Jewish state is distorted and mythologized into a 21st-century bogeyman, a repository for society’s fears, grievances, and moral anxieties.”
At its core, asserts filmmaker and podcaster Lucy Tabrizi, in “The Return of the ‘Good Jew,’” Notes from the Ruins, January 24, 2026, “Jewish anti-Zionism demands something extraordinary — that Jews uniquely surrender not merely a state, but their historical memory, their collective identity, and their right to self-defence, all in exchange for the promise of moral approval from cultures that have never protected them.”
Dave Rich, an Associate Research Fellow at the Pears Institute for the Study of Anti-Semitism, who writes extensively about the intersection of anti-Israel activism, far-left politics, and modern antisemitism, puts it plainly, in “From Be’eri to Bondi: Global Antisemitism After October 7,” Fathom, October 2026:
“But what is anti-Zionism for, exactly? If we strip away the political sloganeering and academic ambiguities, it is a plot to kill a nation. That’s it. Anti-Zionism is a campaign, across decades and continents, to kill the nation of Israel, erase its name and its national identity from history, and replace it with something non-Jewish. Whether this campaign is pursued through ballistic missiles and suicide bombers, seminars and journals, or street protests and placards, that is its goal.” In 1939 the Anglo-Jewish writer Simon Blemfeld published the novel They Won’t Let You Live. Are we there again?
Eliyahu Stern, professor of Modern Jewish Intellectual and Cultural History at Yale University, in a September 15, 2026 article in the online journal ARC:Religion, Politics, Et Cetera, reviewed two recently published “antizionist” books. The title of his critique? “Destroy Israel, Repair the World.” That sums their contents up perfectly.
Think about it: Since October 7, 2023 Israel has done what every other country viciously attacked by implacable enemies throughout history has done: It has lashed back in a defensive war. Yet it’s become what some call the “omnicause.” That’s why antisemitism and antizionism are two sides of the same coin: hatred of Jews. Jews aren’t being attacked because of Israel. Israel is being condemned because it is Jewish.
Henry Srebrnik is a professor emeritus of political science at the University of Prince Edward Island.
Features
Israel has a lot riding on Nvidia, whose CEO resigned today
This story was originally published in the Forward. Click here to get the Forward’s free email newsletters delivered to your inbox.
Jensen Huang, who co-founded Nvidia and has run it for 33 years, resigned as chief executive on Thursday, ending a tenure that turned a maker of video-game chips into the engine of the artificial intelligence boom. The decision followed revelations of an affair with a businesswoman whom U.S. intelligence officials suspect of being a Chinese spy, and allegations of a second relationship, with an executive who reports to him.
Colette Kress, Nvidia’s chief financial officer, will serve as interim chief executive while the board searches for a permanent successor.
The turmoil is a Silicon Valley story with a significant Israeli subplot. Nvidia employs roughly 6,000 people in Israel, including on 18 floors of office space in a Tel Aviv skyscraper. Israel is home to the company’s largest R&D hub outside of the U.S. As well, Huang has been the driving force behind a plan to build a giant new campus in the country’s north. Huang has courted Israel for years, and the open question now is what happens to that commitment without him.
Nvidia’s Israeli business traces back to 2019, when it agreed to buy Mellanox, an Israeli chip company, for $6.9 billion. Mellanox made the technology that lets thousands of chips in a data center work together as one machine. That technology is now central to how AI data centers are built.
Huang kept Mellanox in Israel, along with its patents and its sales. The Israeli teams’ work is now woven into Nvidia’s newest products, and includes building a chip meant to rein in AI tools that act on their own.
In the second quarter of 2026 alone, Nvidia’s Israeli operation booked $17.5 billion in sales, nearly a fifth of the company’s worldwide revenue and more than four times the sales of Teva Pharmaceuticals, the multinational Israeli drugmaker. Analysts credit Nvidia with largely driving a 13% jump in Israeli tax revenue, and its workforce there has roughly doubled since Oct. 7, 2023.
A personal stake
Huang’s attachment to Israel is not purely commercial. On Oct. 7, Avinatan Or, a chip engineer at Nvidia’s Israeli operation, was captured at the Nova music festival along with his then-girlfriend, Noa Argamani, in a video seen around the world. She was rescued eight months later. Or remained a hostage for 738 days.
Nvidia colleagues held vigils with his mother, Ditza, and Huang stayed in touch with the family throughout. When Or was freed in Oct. 2025, Huang wrote to employees that “Avinatan has come home.” Huang later hosted Or and Argamani at the company’s headquarters in California. This March, as the war with Iran broke out, Huang told Israeli employees that he was “very worried” about them.
Huang has called Israel a “second home” for Nvidia.
That attachment is intended to last. In December, Nvidia announced plans for a campus in Kiryat Tivon, near Haifa, reportedly second in size only to its Silicon Valley headquarters. Construction is set to begin next year, and the offices are expected to open by 2031, with room for up to 10,000 employees.
What lies ahead
The next CEO has become a question in Israel, too. Kress, 59, has been Nvidia’s finance chief since 2013. The board says it will look both inside and outside the company for a permanent chief executive.
Haaretz speculated Thursday that two Israeli executives could be potential candidates. Both men studied at the Technion in Haifa. Michael Kagan, who was born in St. Petersburg, Russia and moved to Israel with his family after high school, co-founded Mellanox in 1999 and has been Nvidia’s chief technology officer for six years. Johny Srouji, born in Haifa to an Arab Christian family, joined Apple in 2008 and now leads its hardware work, including the chips inside its products.
Nothing so far suggests Nvidia’s plans in Israel will change. The Israeli teams work on products the company depends on, and the new campus has long been in the works.
Nvidia’s stock has fallen by about a third since early October, a loss of more than $1.5 trillion in market value, and the company is due to report earnings on Nov. 17. The numbers will matter in Israel. So will something they can’t show: whether Nvidia’s affection for the country outlasts its last CEO.
This story was originally published on the Forward.

