RSS
‘Moderate’ Palestinian Authority Supports Hamas Decision to Keep Israelis Hostage
The IDF announced this week that Capt. Omer Neutra, a US citizen, was confirmed to have been killed on October 7, 2023, and his body was taken hostage to Gaza.
Significantly, the Palestinian Authority (PA) fully supports Hamas’ abduction tactics of October 7.
Ever since Fatah — the PA’s ruling party — kidnapped 8 Israeli soldiers in 1982 and exchanged them for 4,700 terrorist prisoners in 1983, it has talked about hostage-taking as a legitimate tactic.
After Hamas succeeded in exchanging kidnapped Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit for 1,027 imprisoned terrorists in 2011, including then Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas praised them:
Hamas kidnapped a soldier (i.e., Shalit) and managed to keep him for five years — that’s a good thing.”
[Official PA TV, Oct. 24, 2011]
Similarly, this year on the anniversary of the kidnapping of the 8 soldiers in 1982, the PA/Fatah celebrated and presented Hamas’ kidnapping of Israelis on Oct. 7, 2023, as an opportunity to free all the terrorists in prison.
Top Fatah official Jibril Rajoub emphasized that Fatah still celebrates the same terror tactics today. Rajoub confirmed that the release of all imprisoned Palestinian terrorists is what the PA/Fatah — just like Hamas — demand in exchange for the release of the Israeli hostages, who were kidnapped by Hamas and other terror organizations on Oct. 7, 2023:
[Fatah] Central Committee Secretary [Jibril Rajoub] demanded that Japan take action on all levels and in all circles to pressure the occupation state (i.e., Israel) to reach a ceasefire agreement and the release of all the captives from both sides.
[Fatah Central Committee Secretary Jibril Rajoub, Facebook page, Sept. 3, 2024]
Rajoub invoked this Palestinian “logic” of exchanging all the hostages for all the terrorist prisoners already in June, insisting on “everyone in exchange for everyone”:
Fatah Central Committee Secretary Jibril Rajoub: “There are two goals. The first goal is to stop -”
Host: “The [Israeli] aggression.”
Jibril Rajoub: “The second is the prisoner exchange – a prisoner exchange under the logic of everyone in exchange for everyone. I tell everyone: If one [Palestinian] prisoner remains – and I’m certain that the motive for 150% of October 7 is that they [Hamas] want the prisoners (i.e., terrorists) – this is an open wound… Whoever wants to end this issue needs to go for everything in exchange for everything.”
[Fatah Central Committee Secretary Jibril Rajoub, Facebook page, June 21, 2024]
Speaking in the name of Abbas following the Shalit exchange deal, Rajoub “saluted” the Hamas kidnappers:
Rajoub: “We salute those who dug the tunnel [to kidnap Gilad Shalit]; we salute those who captured the captive (i.e., Gilad Shalit), and salute those who guarded the captive until this deal was completed.”
[Official PA TV, Oct. 30, 2011]
While most of the current Israeli hostages are civilians, Rajoub has falsely claimed they “are not hostages” but “soldiers arrested by the Palestinian fighters,” as reported by Palestinian Media Watch:
Fatah Central Committee Secretary Jibril Rajoub: “The Palestinian prisoners should be released [in exchange] for the Israeli prisoners who are in the custody of Hamas (i.e., Israeli hostages captured on Oct. 7). [We] should have a prisoner of war exchange…”
South African SABC News interviewer: “Israel is demanding an immediate release of those who have been taken hostage by Hamas.”
Jibril Rajoub: “Those are not hostages. Most of those are Israeli soldiers and they were arrested by the Palestinian fighters. The civilians who were at the beginning already have been released.”
[Fatah Central Committee Secretary Jibril Rajoub, Facebook page, Feb. 22, 2024]
The currently imprisoned Palestinian terrorists themselves believe they will be released in exchange for Israeli hostages, as is evident from the following statement by a young Fatah prisoner, who was released in the terrorist-hostage exchange deal following October 7:
Released terrorist prisoner: “From the moment the war began [i.e., 2023 Gaza war], we [i.e., imprisoned terrorists] knew that we would be released.
When we were in prison, we weren’t worried because we knew that behind us there are men and the noble people of the Gaza Strip, great guys who can be counted on. There’s no one like the resistance members, may Allah protect them and strengthen them.” [emphasis added]
[“Fateh_Pal65,” X account, Nov. 28, 2023]
Likewise, in November 2023, a PA TV political commentator expressed the expectation that the world would pressure Israel to agree to a hostage exchange for all imprisoned Palestinian terrorists:
Official PA TV political commentator Riyad Helles: “… The pressure will lead to a comprehensive agreement that will include all the prisoners (i.e., Israeli and foreign hostages) who are with the Palestinian resistance and all the [Palestinian] prisoners (i.e., terrorists) in the hands of the Israeli occupation authorities.”
[Official PA TV, Nov. 22, 2023]
In September this year, Fatah celebrated the anniversary of the 1982 hostage-taking as “a great joy,” emphasizing the cleverness of “the plan”:
Awdah TV host: “It was a black night and a great joy when Fatah’s self-sacrificing fighters succeeded in capturing 8 [Israeli] soldiers, which was the first step towards the largest prisoner exchange deal known in Palestinian history.
On Sept. 4, 1982, and with the blessings and guidance of late [PLO Chairman and PA] President Yasser Arafat and Prince of Martyrs and Al-Asifa Forces Deputy General Commander Khalil Al-Wazir ‘Abu Jihad’ (i.e., terrorist, responsible for murder of 125), a squad of self-sacrificing fighters set out with Kalashnikovs. When the zero hour came, the commander of the squad, fighter Issa Hajo, set out towards the Israeli patrol claiming he was from the Lebanese Phalanges Party. He spoke with them in French… to divert their attention and make it easier for the rest of his comrades to complete the plan.” [emphasis added]
[Fatah Commission of Information and Culture, Facebook page, Sept. 4, 2024]
The implication of all these Fatah and Hamas statements is that previous terrorist releases were precedents, and therefore Fatah supports Hamas holding the Israeli hostages until many, if not all, Palestinian terrorists in prison are released in an exchange deal.
The authors are the founder and senior analyst at Palestinian Media Watch, where a version of this article was originally published.
The post ‘Moderate’ Palestinian Authority Supports Hamas Decision to Keep Israelis Hostage first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
RSS
Donald Carr believed The Canadian Jewish News should reflect a vibrant and diverse community
Elizabeth Wolfe is the immediate past-president of The CJN, and a currently a member of its board of directors. Donald Carr had the distinction of being the longest serving director […]
The post Donald Carr believed The Canadian Jewish News should reflect a vibrant and diverse community appeared first on The Canadian Jewish News.
RSS
Iran Is Recruiting Operatives From the Former Soviet Union to Target Israelis
Recent events in the UAE and Central Asia show that Iran is again boosting recruitment of individuals from former Soviet republics for various purposes, including terrorist attacks and intelligence-gathering activities.
Tehran plans to use these individuals directly against Israeli “targets” this time. The abduction and murder of Rabbi Zvi Kogan by three Uzbek terrorists is the most recent case. Despite the lack of public disclosure of definitive evidence linking this attack to Iran, experts point to several factors that support this conclusion.
The Modus Operandi is consistent with Iranian tactics:
- The circumstances surrounding Rabbi Kogan’s murder align with methods previously attributed to Iranian operations, such as targeting individuals abroad through criminal proxies.
- The incident occurred amid heightened tensions between Israel and Iran, with Iran historically opposing normalization efforts between Israel and Arab states, with an emphasis on the Persian Gulf emirates.
- While direct ties of the apprehended perpetrators to Iran have not been confirmed, the use of foreign nationals in such operations is known to be a trademark tactic of the IRGC. One might think to first look into the Muslim denomination these terrorist operatives are a part of, however, no concrete evidence has surfaced to link them with Shia Islam – the primary religion in Iran.
ISIS might have carried out the attack, but it is well known that this organization consistently takes responsibility for the sake of clout, while Iran consistently refutes any involvement in such actions. Besides, the MO of the attack is different from those preferred by ISIS, which focus less on individual clandestine assassinations and more on mass casualty attacks.
Tajiks are known to be the IRGC’s primary recruiting pool; however, what about the Uzbeks?
Let’s examine previous cases in more detail. From December 2023 till January 2024, there were a series of failed attempts to attack Jewish Agency offices and the Ohr Avner Jewish Center in Almaty (Kazakhstan), an arson attempt on a farm belonging to the Israeli Saxovat Broyler Co. in Tashkent (Uzbekistan), and smaller events following the same pattern.
In August 2024, it became known that the organization behind these attempts was the IRGC-controlled Iraqi militia, Kata’ib Hezbollah (Hezbollah Brigades). The main coordinator, according to several sources, was Tajik operative Muhammad Ali Burhanov, also known as Sayed Hamid al-Tajiki.
According to the GFATF (Global Fight Against Terrorism Funding), Burhanov was recruited while studying at Al-Mustafa University in Iran — a known recruitment center for Tehran-backed militant groups, which is operating under the Islamic Propaganda Bureau of the Qom Seminary. The IRGC Qods Force’s Department 400 coordinates Burhanov’s activities. His handlers are Hossein Rahmani and Hossein Rahban, who are behind other attempts to murder Israelis abroad. For example, a November 2022 case in Georgia, where agents of the IRGC tried to kill a prominent Israeli businessman.
According to The Washington Institute, Quds Force’s Department 400 sometimes collaborates with ISIS and the Taliban despite deep-seated sectarian differences and opposing objectives.
It is crucial to remember that such sectarian differences as Sunni vs Shia Islam have not stopped the IRGC and Quds force from supporting Sunni terrorist groups before, as is the case with Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad.
This brings us back to the recent murder of Rabbi Kogan in the UAE, where three Uzbek nationals were involved. Previously there were no cases of IRGC recruiting Uzbeks — Iranians prefer Tajik Shias. Tajikistan’s population shares linguistic and cultural ties with Iran, as both are Persian-speaking nations. Since 2013, the IRGC has enlisted Tajiks to fight in Syria alongside pro-Assad forces. They were instrumental in key battles, including the recapture of Aleppo, under the command of Iranian military advisors.
By recruiting Tajiks, Iran aims to extend its influence into Central Asia, countering the presence of other regional powers and promoting its ideological and political interests. Furthermore, the emergence of ISIS-Khorasan (ISIS-K), also known as the Islamic State Khorasan Province (ISKP), in Afghanistan and its recruitment of Central Asians, including Tajiks and Balochis, presents a significant threat to Iran. By recruiting Tajik Shia fighters, Iran seeks to counterbalance Sunni groups.
Interestingly enough, ISIS-Khorasan is actively recruiting Uzbeks to fight in Afghanistan. Reports indicate that ISKP has deliberately expanded its social media efforts in the Uzbek language.
As previously mentioned, the relationship between ISKP and Iran is hostile. In January 2024, ISKP claimed responsibility for twin bombings in the Iranian city of Kerman, Iran, during a ceremony commemorating Qassem Soleimani, resulting in nearly 100 fatalities. In August 2024, Iran’s Intelligence Ministry announced the detention of 14 ISKP members, alleging their involvement in planning attacks within the country.
It is difficult to imagine that the IRGC and ISKP have found common ground. However, taking into account the above-mentioned Qods Force’s Department 400 ties to ISIS and desperate need for any retaliatory action against Israel (considering the failed attacks in Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan), there is the probability of a joint operation aimed to murder a prominent Israeli citizen. ISIS may have “loaned” its operatives or provided a “blessing” for the use of Uzbeks.
Another possibility exists, one that carries even greater risk. There is a chance that IRGC emissaries have found a way to recruit representatives of a tiny (between 200,000 and 300,000) Uzbek Shia minority living in Bukhara and Samarkand. Their existence is hardly common knowledge in the Arab world and in the West, as they are primarily comprised of descendants of ethnic Iranians, who live there for 2-3 hundred years. Uzbek extremists, being associated with Sunni groups such as Al Qaeda and ISIS, are much less visible and identifiable as IRGC agents and thus constitute a larger threat.
The history of the IRGC’s recruiting of the citizens of the FSU countries
The IRGC has reportedly engaged criminal gangs from former Soviet regions for operations abroad, including espionage and violent acts. This strategy leverages existing criminal networks to conduct activities that further Iran’s strategic interests while maintaining plausible deniability. As was mentioned above, Tajikistan and ethnic Tajiks are the major recruiting pools for Iranian proxy militias. Yet they are not the only source of operatives that share cultural and ideological affinity with Iranians.
Conversely, Azerbaijan is one of the most frequent locations where the IRGC attempts to carry out terrorist attacks against Jewish and Israeli targets. The highly-experienced local national security service DTX foils the vast majority of such plots.
In 2004, 2007, 2012, 2017, and 2022, DTX neutralized and apprehended several mixed groups of terrorists, comprising both local and foreign citizens (Lebanese and Afghans, for example). Iran trained most of them to gather intelligence and carry out attacks on Israeli and, occasionally, other Western embassies.
It should be mentioned that the IRGC has its own proxy organization for spreading Khomeinist ideology inside Azerbaijan, Hussainiyoun. This organization aims to destabilize the government of Azerbaijan per the mission given to it by Tehran. If and when the opportunity presents itself, Husayniyun operatives emphasize their opposition to Azerbaijani ties with Israel through incitement of local unrest. It is no mere coincidence that the leader of Husayniyun, Tawhid Ibrahim Begli, started his organization in Qom, a known recruitment center for these types of groups, as previously presented. The organization was even named by Qassem Soleimani himself.
In March 2023, an Iranian agent tried to murder Azerbaijani MP Fazil Mustafa, known for his staunch support for strengthening relations with Israel.
An Afghan citizen received a 10-year sentence in October 2024 for his attempt to attack the Israeli embassy in Baku in July 2023. He had several local accomplices, recruited by the IRGC, who were also apprehended.
In October 2021, Cypriot authorities arrested a dual Russian-Azerbaijani national suspected of planning attacks on Israeli businessmen in Cyprus. He was using a Russian passport to operate from Turkish-controlled Northern Cyprus as an operational and transit area.
In November 2022, Georgian security services thwarted an IRGC plot to assassinate an Israeli businessman in Tbilisi. A hitman of Pakistani origin had a support team of several persons with dual Iranian-Georgian citizenship, who provided him with weapons and transportation.
The IRGC primarily seeks to enlist kindred Shia Muslims to act out its bidding across the globe, yet occasionally even cooperates with Sunni groups, as long as their geopolitical goals surpass the cultural and religious differences. However, there have been cases where non-Muslims and non-Islamic entities have served other purposes. For instance, money laundering, sanction evasion, and the supply of dual-use materials have involved several Armenian businessmen and companies, including banks.
All this demonstrates how much influence and free reign the tentacles of Tehran have throughout the southern hemisphere of the post-Soviet world, especially now, when there is no longer the same level of Russian influence to stave off the propagation of extremist, fundamentalist, and Islamic ideas.
Ariel Kogan is an Israeli member of international fora of independent researchers on contemporary post-Soviet politics and society. He is affiliated with the Institute of Applied Ethnopolitical Research (Kazakhstan) and MPIC Center (Georgia). He is also a columnist for I24news and Ynet in Israel. A version of this article was originally published by The BESA Center.
The post Iran Is Recruiting Operatives From the Former Soviet Union to Target Israelis first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
RSS
Obituary: Donald Carr, 96, guided nearly every Jewish institution in Toronto—including The Canadian Jewish News
He served on the board of nearly every major Jewish institution in Canada, headed one of Toronto’s most prestigious law firms, mentored hundreds of lawyers during a 75-year legal career—and […]
The post Obituary: Donald Carr, 96, guided nearly every Jewish institution in Toronto—including The Canadian Jewish News appeared first on The Canadian Jewish News.