Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Uncategorized

As Christopher Nolan revives ‘The Odyssey,’ a scholar finds links between Homer and the Hebrew Bible

(JTA) — Even before its release on Friday, buzz over Christopher Nolan’s much-anticipated film adaptation, “The Odyssey,” is introducing a new generation to Homer’s tale of shipwrecks, monsters, gods and the long road home. But what does an ancient Greek epic have to do with Jewish readers — or with the Hebrew Bible?

Quite a bit, says Jacob Howland, a philosopher and classicist who has spent much of his career exploring what has been called the conversation between Athens and Jerusalem. His 1998 book “Plato and the Talmud” was inspired in part by a Talmud study group at his synagogue in Tulsa, Oklahoma, where he was a professor of philosophy at the University of Tulsa from 1988 to 2020.

Howland is currently a distinguished visiting professor in the School of Civic Leadership at the University of Texas, founded in 2023 to put Western civilization and “the American idea” at the center of academia in the Lone Star State. Howland has written extensively on the Greeks, the Hebrew Bible and the Talmud for Mosaic, the online magazine of the conservative Jewish think tank and educational philanthropy Tikvah.

In the first of a recent series of essays on the “Odyssey” for Mosaic, Howland asks, “Should Jews Read Homer?” His answer, no surprise, is “yes”: The “Odyssey” and the Hebrew Bible, he writes, “illuminate the enduring questions of human life, including how to bring order and common purpose to the otherwise chaotic relationships between men and women, fathers and sons, familiars and strangers, clans and nations.”

To recap: The “Odyssey” follows the Greek hero Odysseus (Matt Damon in the film) on his 10-year journey home after the Trojan War. Delayed by storms, nymphs, temptations and the whims of the gods, he survives encounters with the Cyclops, the Sirens and the sorceress Circe before finally returning to Ithaca. There, disguised as a beggar, he reunites with his faithful wife, Penelope (Anne Hathaway), and son, Telemachus (Tom Holland), and (spoiler alert) reclaims his kingdom from the suitors who have overrun his household.

As Nolan’s blockbuster brings Odysseus back into the cultural conversation, we spoke with Howland about what Homer and the Bible have in common, how they differ and why both epics are at the center of the conservative discourse around “Western civilization.”

Our conversation was edited for length and clarity.

As someone who reads the “Odyssey” professionally, are you excited about a new movie production of this?

I am going to see the film. I’ve been encouraged, actually — there’s been an incredible amount of controversy, which is funny, because no one’s seen it yet. But I read that a number of people, including the historian Tom Holland — the “Rest Is History” podcast host, not the actor playing Telemachus — have seen it and given it strong reviews.

I’m fairly confident we won’t get something like “300” — that film about Thermopylae, with its computer-generated monsters, which younger audiences oddly loved but which was, historically, terrible. I think there has to be some attempt, if not at full historical accuracy, then at least a semblance of it in costuming, ships and so on — at a minimum, a gritty reality that transports you into another time and place, even if a hypercritical viewer could point out an anachronistic helmet or two.

I want to talk a little about Athens and Jerusalem, which is how the 20th-century German-Jewish philosopher and conservative icon Leo Strauss described the tension in Western civilization between the Bible and classical Greek philosophy. The “Odyssey” was written down somewhere between 725 and 675 BCE, and the Hebrew Bible was composed primarily between the eighth and second centuries BCE. How aware are these two cultures of each other?

If you’re asking about the time of Homer, it’s all speculation. But I can talk to you about the Talmudic period [roughly the first through fourth centuries CE]. According to Warren Zev Harvey at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, the rabbis seemed to have known a lot about Greek philosophy. They just didn’t make that clear in the Talmud. They didn’t want to say, “We’ve studied the Greeks.”

I think it’s safer to talk about the Homeric and the biblical as two fundamentally different approaches — different understandings of the world, of human life, of the divine — and then ask how they differ, how they interact and what overlap they have.

In other words, what are the fruitful comparisons for understanding the differences and similarities between these cultures?

Yes. Athens and Jerusalem are the two oldest, greatest roots of Western civilization. I don’t always agree with everything Leo Strauss says, but he regards those two as a coiled spring, a tension from which the West itself grows. These texts, if we look at their fundamental view of the world, pose a question we have to decide for ourselves — and in some sense the future of our civilization depends on how we decide it.

What are some of the major episodes in the “Odyssey” we can expect to see in Nolan’s film that bear these kinds of comparisons to Jewish texts, and what questions and answers can we derive from them?

One thing that will probably show up is the recognition of Odysseus by his nurse Eurycleia when he returns to Ithaca in disguise — that’s where Homer tells the story of how Odysseus got his scar. As a youth — mid-teens, or thereabouts — Odysseus goes out to hunt a boar. The ordinary way the ancient Greeks hunted a boar: You get about five guys with javelins and a bunch of dogs and a net. The dogs locate the boar, drive it into its lair, and keep it at bay, barking. You set up the net, unleash the dogs, and they harass the boar until it runs out and gets caught in the net. Then a group of men comes in and stabs it.

Instead, Odysseus jumps out in front and rushes the boar himself, to stab it on his own, and that’s when the boar gashes him and gives him his scar.

In my view, this charging, wounding boar is a Homeric image of reality, at least from Odysseus’ perspective. Reality will wound you, and how do you confront it? You go out, and you fight. That’s a premise that explains Odysseus’s behavior through much of the “Odyssey.”

What’s the Hebrew counterpart? 

Fundamentally, trust in God — trust that there is an Almighty Creator who has fashioned a world habitable and suitable for human beings, and who will support them if they trust in Him. It’s not that the Hebrews didn’t know reality is wounding — it’s that there’s something above that wounding reality. The boar is an animal; the highest thing for Homer is essentially nature. There are the gods, but what exactly are they?

It’s not that the Jewish tradition doesn’t understand realpolitik. Abraham is a great warrior as well as a man of God. They understand it. But the starting point is trust. Odysseus does not trust. Odysseus is a man of disguises, cunning, cleverness — leveraging every trick.

Along with the charging-boar business, there’s a famous essay by a scholar named George Dimock called “The Name of Odysseus.” Dimock’s essential point: There’s a Greek verb, odusasthai, that means to cause pain to oneself and others, and to be willing to do so. Dimock points out that Odysseus does this in many ways — the Cyclops, whose eye he takes; the suitors, whom he kills; all of it.

By the end of the story, hasn’t he basically sacrificed his entire entourage?

This is incredible, if you look at it. Odysseus leaves Troy with 12 ships, which means around a thousand men. One way or another, they all die. So he takes a generation of young men to Troy and comes back with zero.

Twenty years later, you have the next generation — the noble cream of the crop, 108 suitors from Ithaca and the outlying islands. He kills all of them. So: Another generation of young people gone. Then the fathers of those suitors want revenge, so they make war against him. He would have killed them all too, except that Zeus had Athena intervene, essentially averting a civil war, with a pact of peace afterward.

Now, this begins to get at the real difference between the “Odyssey” and the Bible. After the universal history of Genesis 1 through 11, we get to the patriarchs. God is, in effect, saying: All right, I’m going with this guy Abraham — and remarkably, astonishingly, He says, “Come with me, leave your ways and customs behind, leave your gods, leave your family — we’re just going to go.” At that point, you’re dealing with God’s desire to form community, starting with a family, and it builds from there. Odysseus, by contrast, wants to get back home, but he’s a loner, a man of pain who must endure the world’s harsh reality to find fulfillment.

Let’s talk about the Cyclops, an episode that reveals a lot about the character of Odysseus. A one-eyed giant imprisons Odysseus’s men in a cave and rolls a stone against the entrance so they can’t get out — even if they kill him, they’d still be trapped inside.

Odysseus comes away from the war with Troy into a postwar world, a political crisis, He’s now a grizzled veteran of a bloody, horrible 10-year war. And the first thing he does is sack the city of the Cicones — an actual historical people — killing all the men and enslaving the women. He’s in a nasty mood. Very shortly after, they spot the Cyclops’s island — smoke rising — and decide to go see. They realize a monster must live there: Everything is enormous, racks of cheese stacked way up high. Odysseus says, “Let’s wait and meet this guy.” His men say, “No — let’s just take the stuff and go.” He insists on sitting inside the cave, waiting. It’s insane — he wants to measure himself.

The Cyclops episode is really the antithesis of what’s happening with Abraham and the patriarchs, who are building a family, a tribe, a nation, looking forward. Odysseus just wants to test himself. When the Cyclops returns, Odysseus uses his cleverness, blinds him, and they sneak out under the rams. Then he shouts his own name — which is what gets all his men killed, because the Cyclops is Poseidon’s son, and Poseidon is furious. He identifies himself completely: “I’m Odysseus, I live in Ithaca, here’s my address.” That episode is clearly one in which Odysseus is giving birth to himself — an act of absolute hubris.

So Odysseus has two competing desires. One is to make his name — to achieve glory and fame through his exploits. The other becomes: I have to get home.

Is there a biblical character who’s a useful compare-and-contrast for this notion of what it means to be a man, or a hero?

There’s Jacob, but let me start with David. The David and Goliath scene is fantastic, because Goliath is a Philistine, and the Philistines came from the Aegean — probably Greek speakers, though some think Crete. So Goliath, in effect, is a Greek. He’s described as enormous, fantastic — and he’s bested by David. David killing Goliath is a version of what scholars of myth call the “wily lad” story — another version is Odysseus with the Cyclops, another big, bad opponent. Interestingly, David hits Goliath right in the middle of the forehead, which is where, on Greek vases, the Cyclops’ eye is depicted.

So Goliath is big and bad, and then there’s Saul, a doofus who says, “You have to wear my armor.” David says, no, I’m not going to do that. David trusts in the Lord. When Odysseus defeats the Cyclops, he says, in effect, “I did this — I am Odysseus.” David says, “No — I trust in the Lord; the Lord protects me.”

And Jacob?

Odysseus is a wrestler, and Jacob is very Odyssean — fighting with Esau, leveraging Esau’s hunger to steal his birthright, scheming with his mother Rebecca, who is also an Odyssean figure, telling him to dress in skins to deceive Isaac. Then Esau wants to kill him, and we get the scene where Jacob wrestles at the Jabbok [River], the night before he has to confront Esau. He’s worried, he’s wounded, he fights this “ish” — this figure, angel, whatever it is — and he’s vulnerable. He’s feeling fear, feeling guilt. He’s holding on and fighting because only if Esau blesses him — which happens the next day — can Jacob let go. In other words: “I have to make it right with my brother.” Then he’s told his name will be Israel — because he strives with God.

So to sum this up: The Jewish hero is vulnerable and trusts in God; the Greek hero can show no vulnerability and can only trust in himself. And yes, there’s Athena and the other gods, but the Greek gods are fickle.

Are there similar comparisons between a female heroine in the “Odyssey” and a biblical character — perhaps Penelope and what she represents versus one of the matriarchs?

Penelope and Rebecca are two strong but very different women. Both are capable, like Odysseus, of enduring deep and lasting pain. Penelope seems more passive, but she has a kind of Odyssean cunning and steely determination. She holds the suitors at bay for three years by delaying marriage until she’s finished weaving the funeral shroud for Odysseus’s father Laertes. Besides her trick of weaving by day and unraveling by night, the shroud is not just for Laertes. It is for the suitors, and it signifies the burial of an entire epoch — a past slain by the violent passions of the younger generation, no longer constrained by ancestral ways.

While Penelope patiently awaits Odysseus’s return and prepares to bury a dying epoch, Rebecca looks forward, toward the great nation that God had promised to make of Abraham’s offspring. Isaac, doubtless traumatized by his near sacrifice, is the passive partner in their marriage; he stays put when Abraham sends his servant to find a wife for him, while Rebecca jumps at the chance to leave her home. She is physically vigorous (she endures a breach birth of twins, and carries water for all the servant’s camels) and strong in will, and it is she who is endowed with Odyssean cunning. She perceives that it is Jacob, not Esau, who has the toughness and ambition needed to be the bearer of the covenant. It is she who instructs Jacob how to disguise himself as Esau so that Isaac’s blessing will go to him; who takes on herself whatever curse Isaac may put on Jacob; and who instructs Jacob to flee to Beersheba, knowing that she will probably never see him again.

Those are really useful comparisons. But it raises a question, which maybe a rabbi would answer differently than a scholar: Is there a temptation, reading the “Odyssey” and the Bible, to conclude that one worldview, not the quality of the literature but the worldview, is simply better than the other? Does Homer have something to teach Jews about how to be a hero, or a lover, or how to be clever?

I was just teaching Exodus, and we got to the scene where Moses punishes the Israelites for the sin of the Golden Calf — a very Homeric episode, morally messy. Were any of the Levites who did the killing themselves involved in making the calf? Are they only killing people who deserve it, or will innocent people die too? My students find it extreme — 3,000 men killed. My response is: Read Machiavelli, where he says armed prophets succeed and unarmed prophets fail — and that 3,000 is about half a percent of the roughly two million Israelites there. If Moses doesn’t get this under control, they’re all going to die. That’s Greek — that’s realpolitik. But it’s already there in the Jewish tradition too, going back to Abraham.

So — is the Jewish tradition superior? I think so, and especially for today, because of our circumstances. The United States was at its height after World War II, and now our institutions are collapsing. What do we need? Trust. We need to rebuild. So if you ask which tradition is better, here’s one criterion: What’s the advantage of trust? It’s a kind of youthfulness, a kind of fertility, a kind of generativity — the capacity of the Jews to rebuild what’s been broken, to regrow, to reestablish themselves at every civilizational crisis, is unparalleled in history. The Greeks have a parallel of sorts — there’s a capacity to find a new way forward there too. But it seems to me what we need today is trust — because people are withdrawing their energy from the task of mending the world, because they don’t want to invest their time, energy and hope in something they believe might fail.

If we’re going to save Western civilization, which I do think is in crisis, we need to renew ourselves by looking to the Jewish tradition in particular.

Many people today, especially on the political right, argue that Western civilization is under siege, and the key to its revival is reclaiming its roots in the Ancient Greeks and Christian traditions. I think some Jewish thinkers and think tanks — including Tikvah, where some of your work has appeared — have a lot invested in including Judaism and Jewish ideas among the cornerstones of Western civilization. Is that a natural fit, or was Judaism more of a counterculture that was constantly challenging classical and Christian ideas?

I was a senior fellow at Tikvah, and they brought me on to design Greek and Jewish courses. When I got to the University of Austin [the pro-free inquiry, “anti-woke” liberal arts college whose founders include the Jewish journalist Bari Weiss] I designed their intellectual foundations program — their liberal-education core — and set it up with Genesis, Exodus and so on. I think what Tikvah is trying to do — and what UT Austin is doing too, in the School of Civic Leadership, where I’ll be teaching Genesis and Exodus this fall — and what other universities are trying to do, is give the Jewish tradition its rightful place.

From the founding fathers onward, there’s this notion that America is a chosen land — that we are, in some sense, a chosen people, engaged in a moral, spiritual, political mission. Lincoln, I think, brings this to a kind of perfection — he turns it into a civil religion, speaking to a people who’ve read the Bible, without pushing any particular sectarian version of it. We don’t know which side God is on, but the project isn’t going to work unless we understand ourselves to be on a kind of collective mission, knowing we’ll make mistakes and need to be forgiven.

You’ve written that the Hebrew Bible, like Homer, is one of the “taproots of the great branching oak of Western civilization.” Do you worry about the Christian nationalists who insist Western civilization is intrinsically tied to the Christian faith, and denotes a specifically Christian civilization?

For sure, I think it’s a huge problem. As with anything involving the Jews, I’m horrified by the antisemitism I’ve seen building on the left, now mirrored on the right. Young people in particular are being memed into antisemitism.

It does seem to me that the only way forward is to keep having these conversations — to say, here’s what we’ve inherited, here’s how these texts have shaped who we are as Americans, how we understand things, even if you’re a staunch atheist, the Bible has shaped your thinking about all of this. Only then can we get to a point where more people than just the Jews might say, “Your Christian nationalism, which imagines Christianity came out of nowhere with no real relationship to the Jews except rejection, is fundamentally ill-informed and destructive.”

To return to Nolan’s version of the “Odyssey”: What do you hope it gets right — or, if you’d rather answer the other way, what do you dread it might do to a story of such antiquity and power?

Odysseus, as I’ve indicated, has some questionable qualities as a leader, but he’s a much more complicated, flexible person, better suited to a new reality. I think that’s part of why Homer centered him. He’s a character who can hold two things together at once — maybe more than two: “I want to be an outstanding individual, but my duty is to the community; I want to protect my family and make a name for myself, but I’m willing to do what’s necessary.”

That’s true of the Hebraic heroes too — Abraham surely didn’t think it was a great idea to say his wife Sarah was his sister [when threatened by Pharaoh and King Abimelech] not once but twice, but he had to; otherwise they weren’t getting out of there. You have to hold the necessary and the good together. That requires a complicated person who can juggle both.

And I think it’s such a primal story, from the point of view of the human soul and human history. On the individual level, it’s the shape of a life — leaving home and coming back. And it’s the shape of a community too. Biblically, we’re all exiles, all trying to get back to Eden, if you like. The story of human life is trying to make, or recover, or return to a home — on both the individual and the communal level — and it’s a never-ending task. I think Homer knew what he was doing: Read the last page of the “Odyssey”, and you sense there’s a lot of work still to be done. Because it doesn’t end. This is what life is about — and then going forward too, having children, being concerned with their home, helping them make one.

I hope the film shows that.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post As Christopher Nolan revives ‘The Odyssey,’ a scholar finds links between Homer and the Hebrew Bible appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uncategorized

Eisenkot outlines 3 paths to Israeli government, signaling urgency and openness to Arab-party backing

(JTA) — Gadi Eisenkot outlined three tracks he is pursuing to build a coalition, including a minority government that would need the outside support of Arab-led parties, saying that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was putting Israel “in a very dangerous place” with his anti-Arab rhetoric.

Each option Eisenkot presented Friday in a lengthy post on X could involve breaking a promise that at least one of the parties in the “change” bloc Eisenkot leads had made: not to rely on the Arab parties; not to join with Netanyahu; or not to work with the haredi Orthodox parties as long as they refuse to compromise on military service.

One of his partners, Avigdor Liberman, who leads the Yisrael Beytenu party, said the option of joining with the haredim was the likeliest.

Eisenkot, who leads the Yashar party, described an urgency to form a coalition spurred in part by Netanyahu’s relentless rhetoric targeting the Arab parties, which Eisenkot said was placing the Arab Israeli population at risk of attack. Forming a coalition under the conditions Eisenkot lays out would remove Netanyahu from his role as prime minister, depriving him of a powerful pulpit.

 

 

“We are in a very dangerous place. A place where the outgoing prime minister is acting in ways we have never seen before,” he said.

“Israeli society, our democracy, and our standing and position on the international stage are all approaching a point of no return,” he said. “The path from a violent campaign of delegitimization against 21% of the population and labeling them ‘supporters of terrorism’ to actual violence could also be short. The writing is on the wall.”

President Isaac Herzog last week gave Eisenkot the mandate to form a government within 28 days, after 67 members of the parliament, or Knesset – including the “change” bloc and the 19 Knesset members belonging to Arab-led parties – gave their nod to the former Israel Defense Forces. Netanyahu got the approval of 46 lawmakers, and seven abstained. If Eisenkot does not get a government together by Dec. 6, he can ask Herzog for a 14-day extension.

The first option Eisenkot raised was forming a government with the support of the ultra-Orthodox, or haredi, parties. Such a move would have been almost unthinkable until recently, given the longstanding and close alliance between Netanyahu and the haredi parties, as well as the central campaign promises of the anti-Netanyahu bloc to bring about fundamental changes to the state’s relationship with the ultra-Orthodox community, including mandatory military service – a position the haredi parties strongly oppose.

“Serious discussions are underway with the ultra-Orthodox parties, aimed at finding solutions and formulas that will strengthen the IDF, address security needs and preserve the status of those who study Torah, as we promised during the election campaign,” Eisenkot wrote in his post.

He stressed that the negotiations did not amount to “backing down on the issue of military service,” but rather involved formulating an arrangement based on the principles of his party’s “Service for All” framework, which would codify non-military service as an option for some sectors. All four parties in the change bloc ran on a platform of ending the vast exemptions from military service haredi Jews have enjoyed for decades.

The negotiations appear to have led one of the two ultra-Orthodox parties, United Torah Judaism, to refrain from recommending Netanyahu to the president as the candidate to form the next government. The other haredi party, Shas, which is considered more right-wing and closer to Netanyahu, has so far given no indication that it intends to cross political lines and join the anti-Netanyahu bloc. Without Shas, the bloc would have to settle for a minority government.

Liberman  said in an interview with Channel 12 News on Friday evening, hours after Eisenkot’s post, that forming a government with the support of the ultra-Orthodox parties was “the only practical option.” He said he was convinced that a government supported by both haredi parties could be formed. According to Liberman, the bloc should be willing to “sacrifice” its pledge not to cooperate with the ultra-Orthodox and to fundamentally change the state’s relationship with their community in pursuit of its primary goal: “an end to Bibi’s rule.”

The second path outlined by Eisenkot was a unity government with Likud. Negotiating teams from the two parties met earlier this week. “As for the contacts with Likud, we are making sincere and genuine efforts on our part. Unfortunately, however, there is a wide gap between the Likud’s rhetoric and their action and actual willingness to move forward,” Eisenkot said. He nevertheless made clear that “I intend to give this track another chance.”

Eisenkot did not name the “gap,” but reports have said talks have foundered on Netanyahu’s role in a unity government. Netanyahu reportedly is insisting on serving as prime minister in the first part of a “rotation” agreement that would see the premiership rotated among bloc leaders.

Liberman ruled out sitting in a government with Netanyahu under any circumstances, including a rotation agreement in which Netanyahu would serve as prime minister second after Eisenkot. Another leader of the opposition bloc, Naftali Bennett of the B’Yachad party, held lengthy talks with Netanyahu in the Knesset this week, triggering a wave of speculation that he was advancing the possibility of a unity government. But Bennett would still need to convince the other parties in his bloc to join him in doing so, as his party isn’t large enough to secure a parliamentary majority with Netanyahu on his own.

The third option Eisenkot raised at the end of his post was the formation of a “national emergency government.” He clarified that he would pursue this track only if “the necessary conditions for the formation of a broad government through the channels I am leading do not materialize.”

Although he did not explicitly say so in his post, Eisenkot appears to be referring to the possibility of a minority government that would rely on the votes of the Arab-led parties to secure the parliamentary majority needed to form a government without actually including Arab ministers in the government itself.

But the proposal faces significant opposition within Eisenkot’s own bloc, potentially jeopardizing the entire initiative. Liberman stressed that he would “categorically” vote against a narrow government relying on the support of the Arab-led parties. Channel 12 News also reported that Bennett had told leaders of the opposition bloc that he opposed forming a government dependent on Arab-led parties.

One of the two parties, Ra’am, led by Mansour Abbas, served in a coalition under Bennett from 2021-2022. Bennett has praised Abbas as a worthy partner but has also argued that including Arab-led parties in the government after the deadly Hamas-led attacks of Oct. 7, 2023 is untenable. Netanyahu has seized on the radical statements of some members of the other Arab-led party, the Joint List, to depict both parties as supporting terrorism.

Liberman and Bennett both argued that relying on the Arab-led parties would give Netanyahu a massive boost ahead of future elections.

Eisenkot, however, signaled that he was prepared to put that opposition to the test. In his post, he stressed that “all members of Knesset will have to follow their conscience and decide whether a new government will be formed, or whether they are willing to drag the State of Israel into another election while Netanyahu remains prime minister of a transitional government.

“It would be foolish to think that we have the luxury of delaying and losing the window of opportunity that has opened up, a window that may never open again. What is at stake is Israel’s future,” Eisenkot said.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post Eisenkot outlines 3 paths to Israeli government, signaling urgency and openness to Arab-party backing appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

After devastating midterms, Jewish right-wingers lick wounds – and plan for 2028

(JTA) — NEW YORK – Anti-Israel rhetoric, “radical Islam” and the voting habits of young Jews were among the many concerns voiced this week at two of the first major events for Jewish conservatives held since Democrats’ sweeping victories in the midterm elections.

Speakers and attendees at both the Tikvah Fund’s Jewish Leadership Conference and the Zionist Organization of America’s annual gala, each held on Sunday in Manhattan, railed against the growing contingent of Democratic Socialists of America members entering Congress.

As they reeled from that “difficult Tuesday night,” as ZOA emcee Shabbos Kestenbaum referred to it, some advocated for a boost in Jewish education in hopes that young Jews would prioritize pro-Israel candidates. Others said the pendulum could swing back to a GOP victory in 2028 — but also expressed antipathy toward Vice President JD Vance, seen as the favorite to lead the party’s ticket.

ZOA president Mort Klein urged attendees at the Ziegfeld Ballroom in midtown Manhattan to fight against the “dangerous policies” of the DSA, the group that has endorsed a contingent of left-wing, Israel-critical candidates in Congress, bringing their number in the Democratic caucus to eight when the next session starts in January. He denounced growing accusations of Israeli apartheid and genocide, likening them to antisemitic propaganda used in Nazi Germany and other historical periods.

In an interview after the event, Klein said the ZOA is urging President Donald Trump “to make a major address on antisemitism — an address purely on Jew hatred and Israel hatred, not general hatred.” The ZOA, he said, is also “urging, even demanding” members of Congress to make similar speeches, noting that he could only recall Florida Rep. Randy Fine and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz as having done so to his satisfaction. He added that he is pushing for Jewish leaders and rabbis to do the same and to speak about “the dangers of radical Islam.”

It is not a new strategy for the ZOA, but Klein said the group is doubling down because “whatever strategy is in place, it’s not being fulfilled in any way, shape or form.”

A number of speakers at the ZOA event denounced young Jewish voters and the efforts of the liberal Jewish Middle East advocacy group J Street. J Street bills itself as pro-Israel and pro-peace; speakers at the ZOA gala accused it of turning young Jews against Israel.

Alan Dershowitz, the prominent pro-Israel attorney whose clients have included Trump, O.J. Simpson and Jeffrey Epstein, called J Street “the most dangerous organization to Zionism, to Israel and I believe to the Jewish future in the United States.”

“It has fraudulently convinced many young people that they are pro-Israel and has given cover, has given a hechsher [kosher certification], to anti-Israel, anti-Zionist and, in more and more respects, anti-Jewish attitudes than any other organization,” Dershowitz said.

The problem, Dershowitz continued, is exemplified by the number of Jews who “tragically voted for [New York City Mayor Zohran] Mamdani, how many Jews voted for [Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul] El-Sayed.”

J Street did not endorse either candidate. The group did not return a request for comment.

Josh Katzen, publisher of the Jerusalem News Syndicate, blasted the “new generation” as he received an award from the ZOA for Middle East journalism.

“Not only do they not have an emotional attachment to Israel, they don’t have an emotional attachment to the United States. They don’t have any idea who are the good guys, and who are the bad guys,” Katzen said. “They don’t understand that Israel is America’s front-line defense in supporting Western civilization against the attack of Islam.”

Attendees at the ZOA event had misgivings about Jews who voted for left-wing Democratic candidates, and about Muslim candidates.

Hy Drusin, a board member of the West Side Republican Club, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency that he’d coined the term “JINOs” — “Jews in Name Only” — for Jews who voted for “these Muslim socialists.”

According to Upper East Side resident Nathaniel Gravonsky, “The problem in New York City is too many Jews read The New York Times as their Torah.”

Rabbi Yehuda Kaploun, Trump’s special envoy to monitor and combat antisemitism, said in a speech that expanded Jewish education and stronger encouragement of young Jews to embrace their Jewish identity would set them on the right path, as opposed to voting for candidates like El-Sayed.

“For years, the Jewish community has followed the same playbook: more conferences, more photo ops and more nongovernmental organizations. It is a proven recipe, now, for failure,” Kaploun said.

Drusin opined to JTA that Jewish education would indeed “better the chances that [students] will remain Jewish or Jewish identified.” But, he added, “What Rabbi Kaploun urged has been urged for decades, centuries. Is it happening? Is it working? Spreading? Or is it declining? There are arguments and statistical evidence on both sides.”

Drusin said it was “disturbing” to see exit polls that had half of Jewish Michigan voters voting for El-Sayed, and that it would be tough to buck Jews’ “long tradition of knee-jerk affiliation with the Democrat Party.”

Earlier on Sunday, at the Jewish Leadership Conference, Cruz offered hope that the pendulum could very well swing back to the Republicans in 2028. He pointed to the election of then-Vice President George H.W. Bush in 1988, which came two years after Democrats — similar to this year’s results — won the midterms in commanding fashion and took control of the House and Senate.

But hopes of a 2028 Republican victory were accompanied by doubts about the current vice president, who is seen as Trump’s likeliest successor to lead the GOP. Vance has drawn the ire of Jewish conservatives over his reprimanding of Israeli officials, indulgence of anti-Israel conspiracy theories and his silence on his friend Tucker Carlson, a prominent media personality who promotes such narratives.

Most recently, Vance outraged a number of pro-Israel Republicans when he blamed the party’s midterm losses in part on the current U.S.-Israel relationship, and listed “change our relationship to Israel” among four strategies to bring back voters.

“I’m disgusted with it,” Drusin said about Vance’s post. “That’s why I support [Secretary of State Marco] Rubio.”

Gravonsky, too, said he is “always going to pick Marco Rubio over JD Vance” in a hypothetical primary battle between the two, echoing a number of Jewish Republican voters and donors who say Rubio is their preferred 2028 candidate.

Cruz, speaking at the Tikvah Fund’s event, said he disagreed with Vance’s assessment that Israel was a major factor in the recent GOP losses.

Mike Huckabee, Trump’s ambassador to Israel, spoke at both events about the need for a strong U.S.-Israel relationship, though he did not address Vance’s comments head on. He did so in a subsequent interview with The Press Service of Israel, however, saying that “Israel was not the reason the midterm elections yielded disappointing results for the Republicans.”

Neil Cooper, a Republican Jewish Coalition member who attended the Jewish Leadership Conference on Sunday, called the vice president’s post a “political suicide note” that would alienate voters.

Should Vance emerge as the nominee, however, Cooper said he believes Jewish conservatives would “likely hold our noses and vote for Vance on the theory that, despite his flaws, he would nevertheless be preferable to a Democrat from a policy standpoint.”

But Cooper also predicted that any rightward realignment of American Jews — a demographic whose typical allegiance to the Democratic Party has been under a microscope amid shifting sentiment on Israel — would be dampened by Vance becoming the nominee.

If Jewish voters find Vance “repugnant,” Cooper said, it becomes “that much easier to revert to their default position and vote for the Democratic candidate.”

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post After devastating midterms, Jewish right-wingers lick wounds – and plan for 2028 appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Can Palestinian Christians undermine Christian Zionism?

Americans tend to associate Palestinians with Islam. And studies show that most Americans view Islam in a negative light; a Pew study found that this has actually gotten worse since 9/11 — more than 50% of Americans surveyed in 2026 agreed with the statement that Islam encouraged violence, double the 25% who agreed with that statement in 2002.

Since Oct. 7, some Christian groups and influencers in the U.S. have been trying to change this association, drawing the attention of their fellow American Christians to the plight of — and the existence of — Palestinian Christians in the hopes of activating their empathy toward Palestinians.

American Christians have historically advocated strongly for their fellow Christians abroad. In 1998, Congress passed the International Religious Freedom Act in response to the civil war in Sudan that saw an Islamist government oppressing Christian citizens. Earlier this year, Congress passed a resolution expressing concern for Coptic Christians in Egypt. And another Pew study found that the vast majority of groups advocating for religious freedoms abroad are Christian.

In short, the U.S. is a Christian country, and many of its citizens feel connected to Christians in trouble abroad.

But this has been somewhat less true when it comes to Israel where American Christian views over the past several decades have been shaped by Christian Zionism. Evangelicals hold immense political sway through lobbying groups and voting power, and most adhere to a theology that demands support for Israel, and for Jews to return to the biblical land, in order to bring about the End Times and the return of Jesus. There is such a strong moral alignment between Israel and God — their Christian God — that some American evangelicals seem to be shocked when they learn that Israel did not distinguish between Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims in Gaza. Instead, they associated Palestinians with the violence they connect to Islam — a narrative that gels easily with Israel’s justifications for its crackdown in Gaza to eliminate Hamas.

Church collapse shifts the church

However, in 2025, Israel struck the only Catholic church in Gaza, killing three people and injuring nine others, in addition to destroying an ancient Christian historical site. The IDF claimed it was accidental, but the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, harshly criticized the destruction, and claimed that Israel had been “targeting innocent civilians.”

With this strike, American evangelicals began to take note of the plight of Palestinian Christians. Mike Huckabee, the U.S. ambassador, wrote a harsh letter to Israel’s minister of the interior about its hostility to Christians, threatening visa restrictions. Trump called Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to complain. Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, a staunch Republican but also a devout Christian, voted with Democrats to deny funding to Israel.

“Israel bombed the Catholic Church in Gaza, and that entire population is being wiped out as they continue their aggressive war in Gaza,” Greene said, to explain why she crossed party lines.

Since then, Christian influencers have drawn attention to Palestinian Christians’ treatment in Israel. Sometimes, these efforts are humanitarian and informational, such as those of the Palestinian Christian Alliance for Peace, an organization that grew out of the progressive mainline Protestant United Methodist Church’s movement to divest from Israel.

Other influencers, like Tucker Carlson, have taken more of a shockjock approach. Carlson has regularly interviewed Palestinian clergy, including Bethlehem-based Lutheran priest Munther Isaac; Mother Agapia, an American Greek Orthodox nun who immigrated to the Holy Land; and Hosan Naoum, an Anglican archbishop in Jerusalem. All of them emphasize a direct throughline from Jesus to Palestinian Christians, depicting them as upholding the most original form of Christianity.

When Carlson speaks on the subject, he often omits that the people in question are Palestinian, referring to them simply as Christians in astonished tones, playing the audience he imagines, then trying to walk his viewers step by step away from their prior assumptions

“So Christian churches in the United States send more money to Jewish settlements in the West Bank than they do to Christians in Jesus’ own town of Nazareth?” Carlson asked Naoum, in tones of total befuddlement. “When people in the American media say Palestinian, it means someone who is an Islamist, basically — but you’re saying a lot of those Palestinian refugees were Christians!”

Palestinians, both Christian and Muslim, are being attacked and oppressed by Israeli settlers and soldiers; this much has been established, including by many Jewish groups. But many of these Christian influencers, including Carlson, who are now advocating for Palestinians, have a history of antisemitism, which frames their exposés on Israeli violence — Jews, they believe, killed Jesus. Now, they highlight Jews destroying the Christian-owned olive groves in Taybeh or Bethlehem, bombing a church in Gaza, or spitting on a priest. The implication is clear.

An increasing number of viral videos featuring Israelis opposing Christianity in some way are now being shared virally: Orthodox Jews in Jerusalem’s Old City spitting on Christians, an IDF soldier taking an axe to a statue of Jesus in southern Lebanon. Even the Christian Broadcasting Network, an evangelical channel that has historically been extremely Zionist, aired a number of clips about Jewish attacks on Christians and Christian holy sites.

But the sympathy only holds among the Christian influencers if the victims are Christian; though they may criticize violence against Palestinians at large, the argument is clearly weaker. As Candace Owens, a devout Catholic and outspoken antisemite put it, “The biggest issue that I have, by the way, with Israel, and talking about them being above reproach, is the fact that they are supplying the arms to murder Christians.”

Yet many of these videos rely on separating Palestinian Christians from Palestinians more generally for greater emotional impact in the U.S. And the reality is that Palestinian Christians are still Palestinians, first and foremost, a tougher sell to the American Christian populace, which is still largely rooted in Zionism.

To address this, two Christian conferences —Not In Christ’s Name last week in D.C. and the Crossroads Conference in Atlanta earlier this month — invited Palestinian priests Issa Thaljieh and Munther Isaac, both from Bethlehem, to speak. Their testimony was meant to describe the experience of Palestinian Christians, to address Christian Zionism and to be “an invitation to American evangelicals to meet Palestinian Christians, and to reckon with the ways their theology harms Palestinians on the ground.”

But because of Trump’s blanket ban on Palestinian Authority passport holders, neither of them could get a visa — even though they’re priests.

The post Can Palestinian Christians undermine Christian Zionism? appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News