Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Features

Mud: Shtetl to Shoah

Shtetl scene

By DAVID TOPPER A Note to the reader: I will preface this story with a remark about me. I often write stories and poems using the pseudonym Dee Artea (pronounced D R T, my monogram) when writing in a female voice. But this is the first time I have put Dee into a story.

I’m trying to decide what to do with the document that you’re reading. You’ll see shortly, I’m sure, what I’m talking about – that is, if you read on.
I don’t know what to do. I’m stymied. And it’s all because of this new assistant I hired. Dee Artea, who refuses to tell me anything about her past. Not where she’s from, her family, nor even the origin of her name. Nothing. Beyond her being Jewish, I don’t know anything about her.
Well, to be precise, I didn’t hire her, and I guess calling her an assistant is not quite right either – since we’re living together. So, I can’t really fire her, can I?
Which is why – or, at least, one reason why – I’m stymied.
Plus, it just occurred to me that you may agree with her point of view – and then, so-to-speak, take her side on this matter. Well, so be it. Still, what to do?

Many readers will agree with me. My point-of-view, I’m sure. Yes. I am.
There you go. That’s my friend Dee, butting in and making her point. Forcefully, I would say. What should I do about her, short of putting a password on my computer?
In the meantime, I need to bring in some back-story.
It all started when Dee saw my heart-rending book of Roman Vishniac’s photographs of Jews living in the Pale of Settlement in the 1930s. … Wait, before that: I wanted to write something for the local Jewish paper about the pogroms of the late 19th & early 20th centuries as precursors to the Shoah. … No, that’s not it, either. … I need to go … further back. Yes, here goes.
I first met Dee, who was out of a job. I think she got fired for insubordination and th—

That’s what my boss called it. Actually, I was just correcting his mistakes. Proofreading and such.
Okay, anyway, we met one warm day this past spring when I was sitting on a bench in the English flower garden in Assiniboine Park, reading a book. As she walked by, she noticed that I was reading a book of stories by Sholem Aleichem, so she sat down beside me and started a conversation. She immediately told me that Sholem Aleichem (meaning “peace to you”) was the pseudonym of Solomon Rabinowitz, born in the Ukraine in 1859 and one of the most famous Yiddish writers of fictional stories of shtetl life; but, having witnessed a vicious pogrom in 1905, he emigrated, and eventually settled in New York City for the rest of his life – all of which I already knew (well, maybe not the exact dates).
It was quickly clear that Dee was bright, Jewish, and knew a lot about some of the same things that fascinate me in Jewish culture and history. We “hit it off” as they say. Indeed, it was uncanny how much we thought alike – well, at least, on most things. When we parted and decided to meet on this same bench the next day, I thought to myself: bashert.

That’s a very strong statement, I’d say. Don’t you think?
Yes, indeed.
Well, clearly, I liked her. But I must say that I wasn’t attracted to her. She was friendly and all, but not physically appealing. To be honest, she looks a lot like me – which isn’t a compliment, since I’m a man. We are moreover about the same height, complexion, and body weight. There’s nothing particularly feminine about her physique and manners. Nonetheless, over time (really the short time we’ve been together) I’ve moved beyond these external matters, as we’ve become closer, a lot closer, as intellectual – and I might even say, as spiritual – mates.
Despite looking alike, we have different personalities. I’m the rational, level-headed guy, calm (at least, externally so) under pressure. Whereas Dee is passionate, compulsive, and readily shows her emotions. Of course, there is nothing unusual about this classic male/female dichotomy. Cliché? Well, so be it.

You know, there’s a reason for all of this, eh?
In subsequent meetings – initially in the park, then later in my home – I showed her my writings and told her about my research and plans for an essay on the 19th & 20th century pogroms, as portending the Shoah. She was very knowledgeable on this topic, and diligently read over the draft of my essay, correcting my mistakes as she went along. Her proofreading I found very helpful and not at all intimidating. Her changes to my original draft made it a much better essay. And I’m thankful to her for it.

As you should be.
Once she moved in with me, she had access to all my books. Quickly she read all the stories I have by Sholem Aleichem, which was the catalyst of our relationship, as you know. Next came Roman Vishniac’s book, mentioned before. Specifically, it’s called A Vanished World, published in 1983, with 180 photographs of life in the shtetls in Eastern Europe between 1935 and 1938.
Either Dee found it, or I pointed it out to her – but, in either case, she read the book and devoured it. She could not stop speaking about it for days – yes, days. She was that obsessed with it.

Yes, and I’m still obsessed because these pictures are almost too painful to look at. They break my heart. They should break yours too.
Yes, I agree. And it occurs to me that this is a good time to bring in some more back-story. Here goes. Roman Vishniac (1897–1990) was born in Russia and grew up in Moscow. In 1918 the family moved to Berlin (ironically because of the rise of anti-Semitism in revolutionary Russia). Hence it was from Germany, although sponsored by – namely, paid for – by the JDC (American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee), that Vishniac made several trips into Eastern Europe to photograph Jewish life. He frequently used a hidden camera to capture everyday life in the world of the shtetl (Yiddish, for “little town”), as immortalised, as was said, in the stories of Sholem Aleichem.
Since his trips took place in the years 1935-1938, the title of his book, A Vanished World, had a doubly tragic meaning: that the world of the shtetls was gone, but so were the lives of the people in the photographs, almost all of whom most likely perished by coldblooded murder. Vishniac himself narrowly avoided being another victim of the Shoah, but luckily ended up in 1940 as a refugee in the USA – alive, yet penniless, trying to make a living by taking pictures of people in and around New York City.

You know, he once took a series of pictures of Einstein.
I know.

Ah, of course, you would know that. Oh, and did you know that there is a crater on the planet Mercury named Sholem Aleichem?
Yes.

As I suspected.
As mentioned, many of Vishniac’s pictures were taken in the Pale of Settlement in Eastern Europe. This was a clearly marked area, roughly comprising Lithuania, Ukraine, Belarus, and parts of western Russia and eastern Poland (including Warsaw). It was the creation of Imperial Russia under Catherine the Great and was controlled by the Russian army. Recall, for example, that the Jews in 16th century Venice were segregated or quarantined into what was called for the first time a “ghetto.” Well, I would call the Pale of Settlement that began around the late 18th century, a ghetto writ large. Except for Jews with specific professions, businesses, or other situations (such as Vishniac’s father, when they lived in Moscow), all Jews were forbidden to live or even to just be anywhere outside the Pale (such as in Russia proper) – a rule that was strictly enforced until 1914, around the start of the First World War.

Since Vishniac grew up in Moscow, he had a childhood that was fundamentally isolated from Jewish culture.
Yes, that’s true. Thus, those years in the Pale were his first exposure to shtetl life. Incidentally, to be accurate, the area over which Vishniac roved in those years 1935-1938 encompassed more than the Pale. It also covered other parts of Eastern Europe, such as Austrian Galicia, the Kingdom of Romania, and the Kingdom of Hungary – for they too had shtetls scattered throughout their lands.
Nonetheless, having so many Jews concentrated in such small areas between the east and the west, made them (crudely put) sitting ducks. Or, switching metaphors, the Jewish shtetls were islands in a sea of Christianity, prone to occasional violent storms or even hurricanes of hostility, often resulting in the loss of life. This was true, first with the series of pogroms out of Imperial Russia in the 19th and early 20th centuries in the Pale of Settlement; then, later, as armies criss-crossed Eastern Europe during and between the two World Wars. Whether it was the German army moving east, or the Russian army moving west – it didn’t matter. With the breakdown of the rule of law, murder became ordinary: gentile neighbours just walked in and killed Jewish neighbours, confiscating their homes, belongings, and land. The lawlessness often led not only to brutality, where Jews could be slaughtered where they lived, but also to sadistic acts of humiliation, torture, and rape – before being butchered. Then there were the mass executions where men, women, and children were marched into nearby forests or open fields or over ravines or along riverbanks by German army units, often accompanied by local militia (collaborators), and shot point blank – the bodies then dumped into mass graves or allowed to float down rivers to a grave in the sea.

Do you know what happened in Latvia under German occupation?
Sadly, I do. In German-occupied Latvia, a blue bus of commandoes (Germans and locals) traveled the countryside for six months (July – December 1941) killing the Jews of the towns and villages, murdering over 22,000 innocent children, women, and men – one-third of the population of Jews in Latvia. They went on to assist in other killings, so that the entire Jewish population of Latvia – minus a few survivors – died in the Shoah. These Nazi mobile killing units, roaming throughout Eastern Europe, slaughtered more than one-million Jews – often wiping out entire communities. Such extreme, excessive, meaningless, malicious, senseless, and unprovoked cruelty – is unique in history.

Importantly, today sites of these past atrocities are being excavated in Eastern Europe, as this mass murder is finally, painstakingly, and painfully exposing its gruesome tale.
Yes, finally. Historian Timothy Snyder has called these the European “killing fields.” Let me put it in perspective this way. Probably the common mental image of the Shoah for most of us is that of emaciated prisoners in a concentration camp, such as Auschwitz. However – and this is not commonly known – in fact, more Jews died in these killing fields than in all the camps combined. It’s what has been called “the other Holocaust.”

As you know, I too have read Snyder’s book. I agree with him when he says that “the crime of the Holocaust was unprecedented in that it was the only such attempt to remove an entire people from the planet by way of mass murder.” Indeed, he calls it “the single most murderous outburst in human history.” You know, I sometimes have trouble sleeping at night, knowing so many died in vain, while I’m living peacefully in my bubble in Winnipeg.
Yes, Dee, me too, as you know.
But back to life in the shtetls throughout Europe because there’s more I want to say, starting with another topic that deeply haunts me.

Ah yes, the other Vishniac book.
This other book is titled Children of a Vanished World, published in 1999 (after Roman died) and it is edited by Mara Vishniac Kohn (Roman Vishniac’s daughter, who chose the pictures from her father’s massive oeuvre) and Miriam Hartman Flacks (a Yiddish scholar). The text is in Yiddish (with English translations), plus some poems and music. The main motivating force of the book (for me, at least) is the imagery: 70 black & white photographs, exclusively of children, making it another “Vishniac book” that tugs deeply at the reader’s emotions. So many child Shoah victims: 1.5 million, who perished in the madness of hate – epitomized in these 70 or so innocent faces.

So difficult to look at these pictures and not imagine how, in addition to their already hard lives in the shtetls, they were destined to experience a horrific fate.
To me, the photographs reveal how the life of many shtetl dwellers was, in itself, miserable.

Yes, life in the shtetl was much worse than most of us realize. Actually, it’s there in Sholem Aleichem’s stories, if you look closely.
True, although there were also wealthy Jews here and there. Rich merchants, for example, usually living in large cities, such as Warsaw, Cracow, or Lviv. Perhaps epitomized by the Rothschilds in Paris.

Remember Shalom Aleichem’s story “If I were Rothschild?” An amusing little story where he dreams about what he would do with all that money, starting with paying for his Sabbath meal, then further helping his family, friends, others, and then all the Jews of the world. In fact, with all that money he could end all wars. But then he realizes that the source of all this trouble is money itself, and so he eliminates money altogether.
And so, he ends by asking: How will I now provide for the Sabbath? – thus coming full circle. Which brings me back to the lowly life of most Jews, especially in the Pale and other shtetls, which was economically bleak, with many living in poverty. Women worked almost exclusively in the home, of course. Men were primarily tailors, artisans, shopkeepers, carpenters, cobblers, push-cart peddlers, and tax collectors – as such they often interacted with their non-Jewish neighbours in the village and sometime at weekly fairs. Few Jews farmed because (with some exceptions) Jews were not permitted to own land. When they did own land, what was allotted was often of poor quality for growing crops. Overall, therefore, they were forced to live in the shtetls, where the buildings were shabby wooden structures, and the streets were unpaved.

Yes, and unpaved roads turn to mud when it rains. Mud, mud, lots of mud. Allow me to quote from a landmark book on shtetl life: “In the summer the dust piles in thick layers, which the rain changes to mud so deep that wagon wheels stick fast and must be pried loose by the sweating driver, with the assistance of helpful bystanders. …When the mud gets too bad, boards are put down over the black slush so that people can cross the street.”
Yes Dee. And because of the extensive poverty, Jewish organizations within the shtetls set up a social welfare system, with free medical treatment for the poor. According to some historical statistics, no shtetl in the Pale had fewer than about 15% of Jews receiving tzedakah (charity or relief). Some sources say the number was even as high as over 30%.

There is nothing to romanticize about in such a life. Believe me. A life steeped in mud.
Agreed. Nonetheless, and against these grave odds, the Yiddish-speaking culture flourished. Valuing education and intellectual proclivity, most males were literate (unlike many of their gentile neighbours, such as the peasants).

Here’s a line from a story by Sholem Aleichem: “Earlier in the day the ice had begun to melt, and the snow had turned into waist-high mud.”
The modern Yeshiva system developed too; here students learned Hebrew under a melamed (teacher), of course Hebrew being the alphabet of Yiddish. Showing Jewish fortitude and resilience, they were able to make a life out of the bleak world of the shtetl.

“Joseph the Righteous took my hand and we leaped across the mud. Night was drawing closer and closer, and the mud became deep and deeper. I imagined I had wings, I was being wafted in the air.”
For them the “shtetl” was not the place: it was the people. And the “home” was not the house: it was the family.

“I was plodding through the mud alongside Methuselah, … who pulled his legs from the mud.”
Such dogged spirit produced Sholem Aleichem, whose most well-known creation was Tevye the Dairyman.

“Well, from all the good luck, nothing is left, but nothing, nothing but mud.”
From his stories of Tevye came the Broadway musical and film Fiddler on the Roof. One of the highlights of Fiddler is the scene showing a pogrom, which disrupts the otherwise joy of a wedding scene.

“They slogged through the clay mud and seated themselves on a log.”
As depicted in the play and film, however, this pogrom is mild as far as pogroms go; it’s more like a nasty act of vandalism.

No wonder Philip Roth called Fiddler “Shtetl Kitsch.” And Cynthia Ozick said it was an “emptied-out, prettified romantic vulgarization” of literary master Sholem Aleichem’s Yiddish tales.
One of the first series of pogroms took place in Odessa in 1821, where 14 Jews were killed.

“Around here the mud is so deep that it took the wagon all night to pull through the town.”
But in the late 19th century and into the 20th century it got worse. A series of about 200 pogroms took place from 1881-1884 in the Pale. Thousands of Jewish homes were destroyed. At least 40 Jews were killed and there are reports of 100s of rapes. The next wave was 1903-1906 and much bloodier with over 2000 Jews killed.

“For a time, it even looked as if I might spend Passover axle-deep in mud.”
Thus, from the 1880s to about 1914, over 2 million Jews emigrated out of Russia ending up primarily in the UK, USA, & Canada. I’m sure many readers are where they are today because their forefathers and foremothers came over in one of those human waves.

“She admits that she’s a tinderbox. When a bad mood hits her, she’ll throw mud at anyone.”
Sounds like you, Dee. You, the passionate one.

“We greeted and shook hands, with me knee-deep in the mud.”
But this is enough, already. Stop it. Yes, Sholem Aleichem called attention to the role of mud in shtetl life. So Dee, you’ve made your point.
Time to end this tale. … Now!
And, Dee, you know what? Despite my original misgivings about your insufferable intrusions in my story – I’ve decided to keep them where they are, for they force me to acknowledge the hardship of the Jews in the shtetls. Considering that this culminated in the Shoah, I see them as appropriate for such a terrible tale that is often difficult even to fathom.
From mud in the shtetl to mud in the mass graves – mud has become for me both a reality and a metaphor for all the pain and sorrow of our people in Europe before the rebirth of Israel.


Albert Einstein was mentioned by Dee, and so I’ve added this, to give some levity to what is otherwise grim and depressing.
As mentioned before, when Vishniac was a new immigrant in New York he earned a living by photographing people. One day he traveled to Princeton, New Jersey, where Einstein lived. Vishniac falsely told the guard at the Institute where Einstein worked that they had known each other in Germany, and thus gained access to Einstein’s office. Einstein was sympathetic to a fellow Jew, a refugee too, and thus allowed Vishniac to take pictures of him while he was working in his office that day doing mainly mathematical calculations, either on paper at a desk or on several blackboards on the walls. Among the many famous portraits of Einstein is one by Vishniac, which you will find on the Wikipedia website for “Vishniac.” I must say, however, that I question the assertion there, that it was Albert’s favourite portrait of himself.
I also wish to point out that throughout the 1930s and into the 1940s, Einstein, using his celebrity status, worked tirelessly writing letters and such, to get Jews out of Nazi Europe – and was successful in many cases.


Since Fiddler on the Roof was mentioned above, here are a few comments on it, considering the theme of this story.
First, Fiddler was preceded by the Yiddish movie Tevya by Maurice Schwartz in 1939, a symbolic year, with the start of the Second World War. Although once thought to be lost, a print of the film was discovered in 1978, and it is now in the US National film Registry by the Library of Congress. In black & white, with English subtitles, Tevya is worth watching for historical reasons, but otherwise it also romanticizes the lives of the Russian Jews. Indeed, it ends, not with a pogrom, but a mere eviction of Tevya and his family from the village they were born into. Incidentally, there were also some earlier theatre productions based on the life of “Tevya the Dairyman.”
As for Fiddler – music by ,  by , and book by Jose – it was first a stage musical in 1964. The title comes from a painting by Marc Chagall (who made a harrowing escape from the Germans by being smuggled out of Nazi-occupied France in May 1941), and as such, the set and scenery of the stage productions mostly reflected the brightly coloured palette of his paintings. The 1971 film, in colour, was probably grittier and more realistic than most of the stage productions. Nonetheless, after watching it again, I must say that it lacks the necessary mud. There’s lots of dirt, well-packed dirt, and the occasional dust – but no mud. Not until the very end, when all the villagers are leaving Russia in the winter, with a layer of snow on the ground; and, at one point, a wagon gets temporarily stuck in a (muddy?) rut, but it’s immediately pushed out – a brief moment, a fraction of a second. That’s it.


Here’s a short, Annotated Bibliography.

  1. Sholom Aleichem, Favorite Tales of Sholom Aleichem, trans. by Julius & Frances Butwin (New York: Avenel Books, 1983). Note: most sources spell his first name as Sholem. This book contains 55 story stories. Of course, the quotes about mud are clearly Yiddish exaggerations – but, in having done so, they speak of the true misery of shtetl life.
  2. Wendy Lower, The Ravine: A Family, A Photograph, A Holocaust Massacre Revealed (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2021). This is an extraordinary work of historical research. But it’s an extremely painful book to read, for it takes the reader through the details of a specific murder of a woman and a child in the Holocaust. Now, multiply that horror by millions. This book is in the Winnipeg Library system.
  3. Timothy Snyder, Black Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning (New York: Tim Duggan Books, 2015). This too is a painful-to-read chronicle of the “other Holocaust” in Eastern Europe, which at the time was the heartland of world Jewry. Multiple copies are in the Winnipeg Library system.
  4. Roman Vishniac, A Vanished World (New York: Farrar, Straus, & Giroux, 1983). Out of print. Many of the pictures are mesmerizing. I treasure my copy.
  5. Mara Vishniac Kohn and Miriam Hartman Flacks (editors), Children of a Vanished World (Berkeley: Univ. of California, 1999). There is a copy of this book in the Winnipeg Library system. As said: it’s heartbreaking to look at these pictures of children – and to contemplate their fate.
  6. The archives of Vishniac’s estate were deposited in 2018 in the Magnes Collection of Jewish Art & Life in the Library of the University of California, at Berkeley. For the scholars – or future scholars – out there.
  7. Mark Zborowski & Elizabeth Herzog, Life is with People: The Culture of the Shtetl (New York: Schocken, 1952). 1995 reprint. This is the “landmark” book mentioned in the story. The quotation is from page 61.

Features

The Enduring Forms of Jew-Hatred

By HENRY SREBRNIK “Antisemitism” and “antizionism” are not, in their essential features, forms of racism. These ideological constructs may include depictions of Jews in disparaging ways – through looks, accents, and other forms of prejudice – but they are political projects, just as anti-Judaism in the past was found (and sometimes still can be) in Christian and Muslim theology. 

Both words are also misleading — few Jew-haters are concerned with “Semites” or actual “Zionists” (in the historical sense) as such. The word “Zionist” is for them, not about a political movement, ideology, or history. It is simply a metonym or synonym for “Jew.” Both words posit “the Jew” or “the Zionist” as a member of a malignant world-historical force, the antithesis and enemy of all that is good among human beings. 

Neither the “Zionist” nor the “Semite” in these constructions corresponds to a real, discrete group; both are caricature figures onto whom an entire set of libels, suspicions, and eliminationist fantasies are projected. Retaining the hyphen unwittingly affirms the antizionist claim that they are engaged in a normal political dispute with an actual constituency called “Zionists,” rather than waging a hostility organized around the erasure of Jewish collective existence.

Jew-haters in the past condemned Jews as deicides, and they today consider Jews responsible for both the excesses of capitalism and the economic and social evils of Communism. The consequence is that Jews are to be hated and deemed unworthy of sympathy and solidarity. Even the facts of Jewish victimhood, whether the Holocaust or the massacres of October 7, can be portrayed as a scheme for Jews seeking some kind of dominance by “exploiting” their own past historical sufferings.

It’s an old story. In his 1882 pamphlet Auto-Emancipation, Leon Pinsker, a founder and leader of   the Hibat Zion movement in tsarist Russia, observed: “To the living the Jew is a corpse, to the native a foreigner, to the homesteader a vagrant, to the proprietary a beggar, to the poor an exploiter and a millionaire, to the patriot a man without a country, for all a hated rival.”

Today’s “antizionism” has nothing to do with the “anti-Zionism” that existed within the political debates in the Jewish world earlier in the 19th and 20th centuries, mainly prior to 1948. These remained internal Jewish arguments about the future of Jewish life. Jewish anti-Zionists still understood Jews as a people with shared history, continuity, and collective identity. What they did not do was portray Jewish self-determination as inherently racist or fundamentally illegitimate, nor frame Zionism as a global conspiracy threatening humanity itself.

There is little direct link between the various actual anti-Zionist programs that existed within the Jewish world before the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948 and contemporary antizionism, like that of the Jewish Voices for Peace or Students for Justice in Palestine. They gain credibility and authenticity if people are led to believe they have inherited the mantle of those who opposed the establishment of a Jewish state seventy-five or a hundred years ago. Efforts to eliminate an actual state with millions of Jewish citizens bear no relationship, especially post-Holocaust, with earlier arguments that assimilation into European societies working classes represented a solution preferable to Jewish statehood. 

That confusion even exists among leftist pro-Palestinian Jews, some of whom now have rediscovered the Jewish Labour Bund. They relate to, and are seen by Jew-haters, the way a Jew who converted to Christianity, Islam, or Communism was treated in previous eras. 

Yes, many Orthodox Jews traditionally opposed Zionism on theological grounds, but that belief lost its persuasive power with the Holocaust and the establishment of Israel. There remain remnants of Jewish groups opposed to Israel’s existence, notably the Haredi Satmar Jews, who believe only the Messiah can found a Jewish state, but they are not Jews who hate or wish to harm other Jews. Even in Israel, there are genuine, religious ultra-Orthodox rabbis opposed. Rabbi Dov Lando, an influential figure in the United Torah Judaism party, recently contended that Zionism “made Arabs hate us” and Arab rule would have been preferable to the establishment of the state. This is genuine, Jewish anti-Zionism, not “antizionism.”

Modern antizionism did not emerge organically from moral reflection. It is the inheritance of an ideological campaign that replaced the word Jew with Zionist while leaving every underlying accusation intact. The language of conspiracy, domination, blood guilt, and moral corruption was simply updated.

Antizionist ideology treats Jewish peoplehood and sovereignty as an intrinsic injustice. It is today’s evolved form of anti-Jewish hate, less crude than classical antisemitism, but no less potent. Defined by its practice rather than by any claims it makes about “Zionism,” antizionism involves a now-familiar behavioural repertoire: encampments and other occupations of university spaces, boycotts of Israeli scholars and artists, masked harassment of Jewish students, defacement and destruction of Jewish property, disruption of performances by Jewish musicians, and so forth. Like other movements, antizionism at the extreme finds expression in political violence.

In universities, workplaces, and public culture, many Jews now find that their relationship to Israel has become a moral lens through which their broader ethical character is interpreted. Statements are no longer heard merely as judgments about a distant conflict, but as disclosures of one’s deeper moral orientation. 

“These are behaviours,” contends Shaul Kelner, a professor of Jewish studies and sociology at Vanderbilt University, in his article on “American Antizionism” published in the Fall/Winter 2025 issue of Sources: A Journal of Jewish Ideas, “by which antizionists construct themselves as a moral community in contradistinction to a polluting Other. (A polluting Other that, we need not add, just happens to be Jewish.)”

Because antizionist politics have taken root mainly among the intelligentsia, such as professors, university students, journalists, and artists, many people assume that antizionism is a reasoned intellectual position, more rational than emotional. This certainly serves the interests of antizionism’s proponents, but “antizionism” is actually a conspiracy theory about Jewish world power corrupting and subduing the nations and peoples of the world. Political “Jew-hatred,” to use the more correct term, is a political project, one needed to defeat a “world Jewry” in power in, among other places, the United States. It is not simple “racism,” as it ascribes to Jews almost demonic powers virtually across the globe, and not just confined to the actions of an Israel that is uniquely evil, precisely because it is Jewish. 

Soviet “Zionology” as early as the 1960s was expressed in this way, and if one simply substituted “Zionist” for “Jew,” it was an almost exact replica of similar Nazi terminology. Remember what Israeli historian Saul Friedlander wrote in his 2007 book The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939–1945: The Nazis regarded Jews “as an active threat, for all of Aryan humanity in the long run, and in the immediate future for a Reich embroiled in a world war. Thus the Jews had to be exterminated before they could harm ‘Fortress Europe’ from within or join forces with the enemy coalition they had themselves set against the Reich.”

Thus, as Naya Lekht, who teaches the history of anti-Jewish movements, explains in “Where the Soviets Won,” Fathom, Sept. 13, 2026, the Jew-hater does not hate Jews in a racist way. “The antisemite is not so much contemptuous of the inferior Jews as he is afraid and resentful of them. In the antisemitic imagination, the Jew is not subhuman but superhuman, possessed of an almost supernatural capacity to infiltrate, manipulate, transform, and corrupt.” Antizionism is a lot more than ideological opposition to a Jewish state. It is the continuation of an ancient project centred on producing Jewish villains. The threat is that the Jew will get inside your institutions, your culture, your bloodline, and make you into something you are not. 

When the USSR was rabidly “anti-Zionist” and an enemy of the Jewish state, few people in western countries denied it was antisemitism. In 1975 the Soviet bloc and Arab states passed the notorious “Zionism is Racism” motion in the United Nations General Assembly. It too had little traction in North American political circles. The U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, in a stirring speech eloquently defended Israel. What would he make of the direction the Democratic Party is taking now? Today, when university professors and politicians, including a newly elected Michigan senator and a New York mayor, use the same language, it is suddenly “kosher,” and Jew-haters get a pass when they scream about Israeli “apartheid” and “genocide.”  

 “The anti-Zionist is not genuinely concerned with Zionism or Israel as they exist,” continues Lekht. “Rather, the Jewish state is distorted and mythologized into a 21st-century bogeyman, a repository for society’s fears, grievances, and moral anxieties.”

At its core, asserts filmmaker and podcaster Lucy Tabrizi, in “The Return of the ‘Good Jew,’” Notes from the Ruins, January 24, 2026, “Jewish anti-Zionism demands something extraordinary — that Jews uniquely surrender not merely a state, but their historical memory, their collective identity, and their right to self-defence, all in exchange for the promise of moral approval from cultures that have never protected them.”

Dave Rich, an Associate Research Fellow at the Pears Institute for the Study of Anti-Semitism, who writes extensively about the intersection of anti-Israel activism, far-left politics, and modern antisemitism, puts it plainly, in “From Be’eri to Bondi: Global Antisemitism After October 7,” Fathom, October 2026:

“But what is anti-Zionism for, exactly? If we strip away the political sloganeering and academic ambiguities, it is a plot to kill a nation. That’s it. Anti-Zionism is a campaign, across decades and continents, to kill the nation of Israel, erase its name and its national identity from history, and replace it with something non-Jewish. Whether this campaign is pursued through ballistic missiles and suicide bombers, seminars and journals, or street protests and placards, that is its goal.” In 1939 the Anglo-Jewish writer Simon Blemfeld published the novel They Won’t Let You Live. Are we there again?

Eliyahu Stern, professor of Modern Jewish Intellectual and Cultural History at Yale University, in a September 15, 2026 article in the online journal ARC:Religion, Politics, Et Cetera, reviewed two recently published “antizionist” books. The title of his critique? “Destroy Israel, Repair the World.” That sums their contents up perfectly.

Think about it: Since October 7, 2023 Israel has done what every other country viciously attacked by implacable enemies throughout history has done: It has lashed back in a defensive war. Yet it’s become what some call the “omnicause.” That’s why antisemitism and antizionism are two sides of the same coin: hatred of Jews. Jews aren’t being attacked because of Israel. Israel is being condemned because it is Jewish.

Henry Srebrnik is a professor emeritus of political science at the University of Prince Edward Island.

Continue Reading

Features

Israel has a lot riding on Nvidia, whose CEO resigned today

The Nvidia logo on facade of a skyscraper in Tel Aviv. Photo by Artur Widak/NurPhoto via Getty Images

This story was originally published in the Forward. Click here to get the Forward’s free email newsletters delivered to your inbox.

Jensen Huang, who co-founded Nvidia and has run it for 33 years, resigned as chief executive on Thursday, ending a tenure that turned a maker of video-game chips into the engine of the artificial intelligence boom. The decision followed revelations of an affair with a businesswoman whom U.S. intelligence officials suspect of being a Chinese spy, and allegations of a second relationship, with an executive who reports to him.

Colette Kress, Nvidia’s chief financial officer, will serve as interim chief executive while the board searches for a permanent successor.

The turmoil is a Silicon Valley story with a significant Israeli subplot. Nvidia employs roughly 6,000 people in Israel, including on 18 floors of office space in a Tel Aviv skyscraper. Israel is home to the company’s largest R&D hub outside of the U.S. As well, Huang has been the driving force behind a plan to build a giant new campus in the country’s north. Huang has courted Israel for years, and the open question now is what happens to that commitment without him.

Nvidia’s Israeli business traces back to 2019, when it agreed to buy Mellanox, an Israeli chip company, for $6.9 billion. Mellanox made the technology that lets thousands of chips in a data center work together as one machine. That technology is now central to how AI data centers are built.

Huang kept Mellanox in Israel, along with its patents and its sales. The Israeli teams’ work is now woven into Nvidia’s newest products, and includes building a chip meant to rein in AI tools that act on their own.

In the second quarter of 2026 alone, Nvidia’s Israeli operation booked $17.5 billion in sales, nearly a fifth of the company’s worldwide revenue and more than four times the sales of Teva Pharmaceuticals, the multinational Israeli drugmaker. Analysts credit Nvidia with largely driving a 13% jump in Israeli tax revenue, and its workforce there has roughly doubled since Oct. 7, 2023.

A personal stake

Huang’s attachment to Israel is not purely commercial. On Oct. 7, Avinatan Or, a chip engineer at Nvidia’s Israeli operation, was captured at the Nova music festival along with his then-girlfriend, Noa Argamani, in a video seen around the world. She was rescued eight months later. Or remained a hostage for 738 days.

Nvidia colleagues held vigils with his mother, Ditza, and Huang stayed in touch with the family throughout. When Or was freed in Oct. 2025, Huang wrote to employees that “Avinatan has come home.” Huang later hosted Or and Argamani at the company’s headquarters in California. This March, as the war with Iran broke out, Huang told Israeli employees that he was “very worried” about them.

Huang has called Israel a “second home” for Nvidia.

That attachment is intended to last. In December, Nvidia announced plans for a campus in Kiryat Tivon, near Haifa, reportedly second in size only to its Silicon Valley headquarters. Construction is set to begin next year, and the offices are expected to open by 2031, with room for up to 10,000 employees.

What lies ahead

The next CEO has become a question in Israel, too. Kress, 59, has been Nvidia’s finance chief since 2013. The board says it will look both inside and outside the company for a permanent chief executive.

Haaretz speculated Thursday that two Israeli executives could be potential candidates. Both men studied at the Technion in Haifa. Michael Kagan, who was born in St. Petersburg, Russia and moved to Israel with his family after high school, co-founded Mellanox in 1999 and has been Nvidia’s chief technology officer for six years. Johny Srouji, born in Haifa to an Arab Christian family, joined Apple in 2008 and now leads its hardware work, including the chips inside its products.

Nothing so far suggests Nvidia’s plans in Israel will change. The Israeli teams work on products the company depends on, and the new campus has long been in the works.

Nvidia’s stock has fallen by about a third since early October, a loss of more than $1.5 trillion in market value, and the company is due to report earnings on Nov. 17. The numbers will matter in Israel. So will something they can’t show: whether Nvidia’s affection for the country outlasts its last CEO.

This story was originally published on the Forward.

Continue Reading

Features

Always There

The old Winnipet Arena

By MARTIN ZEILIG My first memory of attending a sporting event with my father is not of a goal, a touchdown, or a home run.

It is of a hot chocolate.

I could not have been more than six or seven years old. More than seventy years have passed, and most of the details are gone. I do not remember who the Winnipeg Warriors were playing. I do not remember the score. I do not remember who won.

What I remember is standing on the upper level of the old Winnipeg Arena holding a hot chocolate my father had bought for me at the refreshment stand.

The ice glowed beneath the lights. The crowd buzzed with anticipation. Across the arena I spotted the organist playing during a break in the action.

Why do I remember that?

I have no idea.

Of all the games my father and I would attend together, of all the famous athletes and exciting moments, it is that simple scene that survives. A little boy. A cup of hot chocolate. An organist. A father nearby.

Memory is a strange thing.

My father, Morrey Zeilig (1912-1998), was not famous.

He was a veteran of the Canadian Army who served in Europe during the Second World War with the First Line of Communication. Before entering real estate, he worked with his father at a produce stand in Winnipeg’s old North End Market. Later, he spent many years as a real estate salesman with Black & Armstrong.

He was emotional, but not excessively so. He wore his heart on his sleeve when something truly moved him. He loved people. He loved sports. And when circumstances warranted it, he could swear with the best of them.

Looking back now, I realize that many of the things I learned about life came from him.

Sports simply happened to be one of the classrooms.

That evening at the Arena was only the beginning.

For decades afterward, sports became one of the ways my father and I spent time together. The games gave us somewhere to go. The teams gave us something to talk about. The events marked the passage of time in our lives.

One season blended into another.

One team replaced another.

One memory led to the next.

One of our regular destinations was the old Winnipeg Arena, where we watched the Winnipeg Maroons.

For many younger readers, the Maroons will be little more than a forgotten name. Yet in the 1950s and early 1960s they were one of the premier senior hockey teams in Canada and an important part of Winnipeg’s sporting life.

My father and I attended countless Maroons games.

The old Arena had a character all its own. The seats were hard. The building was intimate. Fans sat close to the action. Cigarette and cigar smoke often drifted through the stands. The sounds of skates carving the ice and pucks striking the boards echoed sharply through the building.

And then there were the Arena’s legendary urinals.

Anyone who attended games there knows exactly what I mean.

Let’s simply say they belonged to another era.

The Maroons regularly played touring teams from around the world. In those days, international hockey was still something of a novelty.

Television coverage was limited and travel was expensive. Seeing foreign teams in person felt like a special event.

My father and I watched teams from Sweden, Czechoslovakia, the Soviet Union and even Japan.

For a young boy growing up in Winnipeg, the experience was eye-opening. Those countries existed mainly in atlases, newspapers and school textbooks. Suddenly their hockey players were skating before me in our city.

I did not appreciate it fully at the time, but those games gave me my first glimpse of a much larger world.

The Maroons helped spark a lifelong interest not only in sports, but in places beyond Manitoba.

International hockey eventually became an even greater attraction.

One of the most memorable events my father and I attended was the Centennial hockey tournament at the old Arena. The tournament featured Canada, the Soviet Union, Sweden, Czechoslovakia and the United States. Winnipeg was home to Canada’s national team at the time, making the event feel especially significant.

The calibre of hockey was outstanding.

What I remember most was the final game. Memory no longer serves me well enough to say with certainty whether it happened late in regulation or in overtime. What remains vivid is Canadian defenceman Carl Brewer unleashing a slapshot from the blue line that secured victory for Canada.

Nearly 10,000 fans rose as one.

The building shook.

The old Arena erupted in a deafening roar.

Even all these years later, I can still hear it.

Ironically, one of the most famous hockey games ever played in Winnipeg was one I missed. When Canada faced the Soviet Union in the 1972 Summit Series at the old Winnipeg Arena, I was travelling in Europe.

My mother, Lillian Zeilig (1913-1994), and my father attended the game, however, and later described the atmosphere inside the building. Even though I was absent, the game remains part of my family’s sporting history and part of the city’s history as well.

Then came the World Hockey Association.

To younger generations, it may be difficult to appreciate just how revolutionary the WHA seemed at the time. Suddenly the National Hockey League no longer had a monopoly on elite players. Hockey’s established order was being challenged.

And nowhere was that challenge more visible than in Winnipeg.

Bobby Hull

I was standing at Portage and Main in June 1972 when Bobby Hull signed his famous one-million-dollar contract to join the Winnipeg Jets.

Standing beside him on a makeshift stage was Jets owner Benny Hatskin, who presented Hull with the giant cheque that quickly became a symbol of the World Hockey Association’s challenge to the NHL.

Thousands gathered that day to witness what proved to be a historic moment.

In one stroke, Hull’s signing gave the WHA credibility and transformed the Jets into something more than simply another expansion franchise.

Soon enough, we were watching Hull play.

Hull’s arrival helped create the Jets’ legendary “Hot Line” with Swedish stars Anders Hedberg and Ulf Nilsson. Many hockey observers regarded the trio as one of the greatest forward lines ever assembled, whether in the WHA or the NHL.

The arrival of the Jets transformed Winnipeg sports.

My father and I attended many games during the glory years of the WHA. Every game seemed important. Every season felt like an adventure.

One evening we watched the Jets play the Houston Aeros, who featured none other than Gordie Howe and his sons, Mark and Marty.

One goal from that game remains frozen in memory.

Howe crossed the blue line and unleashed one of those powerful wrist shots for which he was famous.

The puck exploded off his stick and flew past Jets goaltender Joe Daley before he could react.

Daley never moved.

One instant the puck was on Howe’s stick. The next it was resting in the back of the net.

I can still see it today.

Another unforgettable evening came when the Jets faced the mighty Soviet national hockey team.

During the Cold War, games against Soviet teams carried significance beyond hockey. The Soviets were regarded as perhaps the finest hockey machine in the world.

On the night of January 5, 1978, the Jets prevailed at the Winnipeg Arena by a score of 5–3. The win is remembered as the first time a club team defeated the Soviet national team.

Bobby Hull scored a hat trick.

The crowd was ecstatic.

Walking out of the Arena afterward with my father felt like walking out of history.

Football provided another collection of memories.

Many afternoons and evenings were spent at Winnipeg Stadium cheering for the Blue Bombers.

My late brother, Ken Zeilig (1939-1990), often joined us.

Ken Ploen

Together we watched great Bomber players such as Kenny Ploen, Leo Lewis, Dave Ramey and Billy Cooper, while legendary coach Bud Grant patrolled the sidelines wearing a Blue Bombers cap, a headset and often carrying a clipboard.

The Bombers of that era inspired fierce loyalty, especially when they made the playoffs.

Some of my strongest football memories involve late-season games played in late October and early November when winter had already begun tightening its grip on Winnipeg.

Those games could be brutally cold.

Fans arrived wearing sweaters beneath parkas, wool socks, gloves and toques. Some brought sleeping bags and wrapped themselves in them while sitting in the stands. Others arrived armed with flasks or bottles hidden in coats, convinced that alcohol would keep them warm.

Whether it actually worked was another question.

People stamped their feet continuously in an effort to restore circulation.

Breath hung in the air.

Hands grew numb.

Nobody cared.

We were watching the Blue Bombers.

One football memory stands above all the others.

We were sitting in the end zone when Billy Cooper scored a touchdown.

As the crowd rose to its feet, Cooper looked toward our section and tossed the football into the stands.

It landed in my father’s arms.

Suddenly we owned an authentic CFL football.

Dad said, “Wait here,” and hurried to our car to retrieve a blanket. He wrapped the football immediately, worried that an official might reclaim it.

Back home I proudly carried that football around the neighbourhood. I showed it to every kid on our street.

We threw it.

We kicked it.

We dropped it repeatedly on concrete.

The football gradually became scuffed and worn.

None of that mattered.

To me, it was treasure.

My father’s love of sports extended beyond hockey, football and baseball.

He was also an avid boxing fan.

Many Friday nights were spent watching boxing from Madison Square Garden on television. Then Muhammad Ali came along and, like millions of others, we became devoted fans. Ali was more than a boxer. He was a phenomenon. Watching his fights became another shared experience between father and son.

Baseball brought its own pleasures.

My father and I attended games involving the original Winnipeg Goldeyes and later the Winnipeg Whips at the makeshift baseball field inside Winnipeg Stadium, a field better known as a practice area for the Blue Bombers.

Baseball moved at a gentler pace than hockey or football. There was time to study the players, chat between innings and simply enjoy an evening or weekend afternoon together.

One of my favourite memories occurred during an exhibition game between the Northern League All-Stars and the National League’s St. Louis Cardinals.

The Cardinals were major leaguers.

The Northern League, by contrast, was classified as Class D baseball, as low on the professional ladder as one could go.

Yet somehow the All-Stars were giving the Cardinals all they could handle.

Caught up in the excitement and possessing all the subtlety of a ten-year-old boy, I jumped from my seat and shouted toward the Cardinal dugout: “Major League or Little League?”

Whether any Cardinal player actually heard me remains doubtful.

The people sitting around us certainly did.

My father may have been a little embarrassed.

I thought I was hilarious.

Another baseball memory stands apart from all the rest.

My father and I saw Satchel Paige.

Even today, writing those words feels remarkable.

Millions of baseball fans know Paige only through photographs, statistics and stories.

We watched him pitch with a touring team at the Provencher baseball diamond in St. Boniface.

At the time I could not have appreciated the significance of what I was witnessing.

Today I do.

Baseball also connected two important moments in Winnipeg history for me.

My father and I attended baseball events during the 1967 Pan American Games. More than three decades later, I returned with friends to watch baseball during the 1999 Pan American Games, this time in the beautiful new stadium at The Forks that became home to the modern Winnipeg Goldeyes.

The venues were different.

The city had changed.

The years had certainly changed me.

Yet sitting at a ballgame still felt comfortingly familiar.

Soccer entered our sporting travels as well.

One memorable occasion took us to Alexander Park to watch Scotland’s famous Hibernian Football Club play a Winnipeg senior all-star team. I can still hear the distinct Scottish brogue of the Hibernian players shouting to each other on the pitch.

Like the Maroons games years earlier, it was another reminder that sports could connect Winnipeg to the wider world.

Then there was the summer of 1988 when my father and I joined thousands of others at the Maginot Arena in St. Boniface to watch Mike Tyson fight Michael Spinks on a giant closed-circuit screen.

By then, more than two decades had passed since we had first become captivated by Muhammad Ali. Ali had been the dominant figure of our boxing years together, the fighter who transformed Friday-night television into must-see events in our home.

Now a new generation had its own phenomenon.

Tyson was very different from Ali. Ali dazzled with speed, charisma and poetry. Tyson overwhelmed opponents with intimidation and power. Yet both men possessed that rare ability to draw people together and make even casual sports fans feel they were witnessing something extraordinary.

Today such events seem commonplace.

At the time it felt extraordinary.

Thousands gathered to share a collective sporting experience.

For a few hours strangers became neighbours.

As I looked around the Maginot Arena that night, it struck me that boxing had carried my father and me across another chapter of our lives. We had gone from watching Ali on television together to sitting among thousands of others watching Tyson. The fighters had changed. The years had passed. But the pleasure of sharing those moments with my father remained very much the same.

There were other teams too.

Other games.

Other tournaments.

Events I have forgotten entirely.

What remains is not a catalogue of scores and statistics but rather a collection of snapshots.

A walk toward a stadium.

A ticket in my hand.

The smell of cigars and popcorn.

A crowd moving through a gate.

My father pointing out a player.

A conversation during an intermission.

A drive home afterward discussing the game and listening to the inimitable Jack Wells on CJOB break down another Blue Bombers game. With his trademark belly laugh, “Cactus” Jack would invite motorists to sound their horns during one of his famous “Happy Honkers” moments.

As the years passed, many of the places we visited disappeared.

The old Arena.

Winnipeg Stadium.

Alexander Park.

Facilities that once seemed permanent now survive only in photographs and memory.

Teams folded.

Leagues vanished.

Athletes retired.

The city changed.

So did I.

Yet whenever I think about those sporting events, my father is always there.

He is catching Billy Cooper’s football.

He is cheering the Jets against the Red Army team.

He is watching Gordie Howe score another unforgettable goal.

He is cheering for Bobby Hull, Anders Hedberg and Ulf Nilsson during the glory years of the WHA.

He is buying a hot chocolate for a little boy at the Arena.

Looking back, I realize that my lifelong love of sports owes a great deal to my father. He introduced me to the games, the teams and the athletes, but more importantly he taught me how much enjoyment could be found in sharing those experiences with others.

What I understand now is something that never occurred to me as a child.

The games were important.

The famous athletes were exciting.

The victories were memorable.

But they were never the real story.

The real story was the time we spent together.

Sports simply provided the setting.

The crowds have long since gone home.

The final whistles have long since blown.

The scoreboards are dark.

But the memories remain.

A father.

A son.

A brother.

And a city seen through the games they attended together.

That is the story I remember.

And it is a story worth telling.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News