RSS
The Line from Jonathan Glazer to the Columbia and National Encampments
Director Jonathan Glazer, of the United Kingdom, poses with the Oscar for Best International Feature Film for “The Zone of Interest” in the Oscars photo room at the 96th Academy Awards in Hollywood, Los Angeles, California, US, March 10, 2024. Photo: REUTERS/Carlos Barria
A week after Jonathan Glazer’s now infamous Oscar speech, a letter appeared in the Hollywood trade publication Variety that refuted his statement. That letter was signed by approximately 450 Hollywood professionals at the time of its initial publication. The number of signers would climb to more than 1,330 in the following days. I was among the 1,330 who signed the letter.
It was bad enough that Glazer drew, in the words of the letter, “a moral equivalence between a Nazi regime that sought to exterminate a race of people, and an Israeli nation that seeks to avert its own extermination.” But he also blamed the war on Israel’s occupation — “an occupation which has led to conflict,” as he put it.
An occupation of what, I wondered.
Israel hasn’t occupied Gaza since 2005, so that can’t be the cause of the current conflict. Many, even many Jews and Israelis, find Israel’s settlements on the West Bank problematic, but I’ve yet to see anyone make the case that this West Bank “occupation” was what led Hamas to attack on October 7.
That only leaves “occupation” in the sense that Israel’s enemies use the term — to describe the very existence of the state of Israel. That is precisely the meaning of “From the River to the Sea,” a geographic area that encompasses all of Israel.
So if Glazer is suggesting that Israel’s very existence is the cause of the conflict, what, I wondered, would he suggest as the solution?
Of course, an anti-Israel polemic like Glazer’s speech is hardly unusual or surprising — not before October 7, and even less so since. What upset me more than the speech itself was the applause it received from the audience that night, and the absence of any dissenting voices during the Oscar broadcast.
I can’t speak for everyone who signed the letter, but I thought it was important, essential even, that Glazer’s claims not go unchallenged in the general culture.
My father spent his working life as a professor of cultural anthropology. As such, he had a very specific lens through which he viewed various laws and policies in terms of how they impacted the culture beyond the more narrow realms to which they applied.
For example, he spoke about capital punishment not just in terms of its function in the criminal justice system, but also in terms of the message it sent throughout the larger culture regarding the value (or lack of value) our society places upon human life. And before the liberals who are reading this begin nodding too vigorously in agreement, he made the same point about abortion. Not that he opposed either abortion or capital punishment. But he saw the costs in terms of messages sent through culture and the impact those messages have upon the society at large.
And so, when Glazer stood upon one of the most prominent stages of our culture and sent his message, seeming to suggest that Israel caused the war by its very existence and is comparable to Nazi Germany, it had — and has — an impact.
I am not going to argue that Glazer’s speech directly led to the student encampments at Columbia and NYU and many other colleges. Nor will I argue that his speech resulted in the intensification of the rhetoric of those protestors, who have continued to praise Hamas, support the October 7 massacre, and oppose any Jewish state in the Middle East. I think it’s unlikely, given the demographics of the Oscars’ audience, that many of the student protestors saw the Oscars. But messages permeate culture like a cup of dye diffusing throughout a gallon of water.
The message Glazer sent has been doing just that.
Glazer’s not the only one, of course. In Hollywood, he’s in the company of Susan Sarandon, Cynthia Nixon, and Mark Ruffalo, among many others. Hundreds of Jewish professionals signed a competing letter endorsing Glazer’s views.
When President Biden erroneously states that Israel has been “indiscriminately bombing civilians,” when our UN delegation refuses to veto a resolution calling for a ceasefire without conditioning it on the release of the hostages, when various US officials call on Israel to “be more careful” not to kill civilians (as though they are not already being more careful than any other military force in history, including ours), it all sends a clear message — that Israel is the villain in the current conflict.
I’ve heard from some pro-Israel Democrats who excuse this rhetoric: so what if Biden has to criticize Israel to appease his left flank politically, they say, as long as he keeps sending arms and aid? And yes, the arms and aid are important. But so is the rhetoric. According to a recent Pew Research poll, only 36% of Americans currently favor sending military aid to Israel. Is this shockingly low number due to all the anti-Israel rhetoric? How long before the negative rhetoric drives public opinion to the point where the continuation of aid is politically untenable? The rhetoric moves the culture, and our culture is definitely moving against Israel, and against all Jews.
When Hitler came to power in 1933, he did not immediately begin sending Jews to concentration camps. It would be seven years until Auschwitz would open in 1940. A lot would happen in those seven years to lay the groundwork for Auschwitz, to prepare the culture with policies that demonized and dehumanized. In 1933, Jews were barred from the Civil Service and university positions. In 1935, the Nuremberg Laws denied Jews German citizenship. In 1936, Jewish doctors were barred from practicing medicine. 1938 brought Kristallnacht, the expulsion of all Jewish pupils from German schools, and the forced transfer of all Jewish retail businesses to Aryans. And through all of this, there were mass anti-Jewish protests at German universities that might feel eerily familiar in light of recent news. This is a well known story to those who have studied the history of the period.
I don’t mean to suggest that governmental laws of discrimination and persecution in Nazi Germany are the equivalent of antisemitic chants and harassment on American campuses, but our culture is moving in a very disturbing direction. The rabid vitriol of the “mostly peaceful” campus protests certainly seems like an escalation — as we hear of students calling for “a final solution,” the destruction of Tel Aviv, 10,000 more October 7ths, and so on. This escalation has not come about because the death and destruction in Gaza has recently escalated. Quite the contrary, the fighting has largely paused. I would guess that the warming weather and approaching end of the school year partly explains the students’ timing. But so do the cumulative effects of the messages permeating the culture.
So are we now seven years away from our own Auschwitz? I’m not nearly pessimistic enough to believe that’s where we are headed. But groundwork is being laid and the culture is being changed. The preconditions for the Holocaust included the German national humiliation of World War I and an economic collapse the likes of which none of us have ever known. What would happen in this country if we suffered a humiliating defeat to, say, China, coupled with a Weimar-level economic catastrophe? Would it be possible for a demagogue to rise in need of scapegoats? Would the groundwork that is being laid now in our culture, demonizing the Jews, come into play?
So what do we do? We push back against the negative messages going out in the culture. We refute Jonathan Glazer’s Oscar speech. We let President Biden know, as the Muslims in Michigan have done, that no, he cannot just count on our votes regardless of what he and his underlings say. We let our alma maters know, as Robert Kraft has done, that they no longer have our support or our money if they can’t protect their Jewish students. And we make sure that Israel thrives and remains secure, so that, just in case the worst should happen some day, we have a place to go this time.
The post The Line from Jonathan Glazer to the Columbia and National Encampments first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
RSS
US States Order Flags at Half-Staff to Mark Oct. 7 Anniversary
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul delivering remarks on major legislation requiring colleges and universities in the state to strengthen hate crime policies. Photo: Darren McGee/Office of Governor Kathy Hochul
Multiple US states will lower their flags to half-mast during the day on Monday to mark the one-year anniversary of Hamas’s Oct. 7 terror attack in southern Israel.
“The hearts of Iowans go out to the innocent Israeli families and American citizens killed by Hamas,” stated Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds, a Republican, who ordered flags lowered at the state Capitol building and on all public grounds and sites in the state. (She encouraged individuals, businesses, schools and others to do the same.)
“Iran and its terrorist proxies continue to attack, as Israeli forces fight to protect their people against the forces of evil,” Reynolds added. “Iowa stands, as it always has, with Israel.”
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, ordered flags at state buildings at half-mast and that more than 12 landmarks—including several bridges, Empire State Plaza, Niagara Falls, Moynihan Train Hall and 1 World Trade Center—be lit up in yellow “in solidarity with Israel and the hostages still in captivity.”
“One year after the horrific atrocities committed against the people of Israel, my heart goes out to the victims and their families,” Hochul stated. “New York stands with Israel—today and every day.”
“As the home of the largest Jewish population outside of Israel, we will do everything in our power to defend against the forces of hatred and stand firmly against those who perpetuate it,” Hochul added.
Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, a Republican, ordered that the state flag be flown at half-mast throughout Arkansas on Monday.
“Israel is right, and the terrorists are wrong,” she stated. “Arkansas stands with Israel, prays for Israel and supports Israel as they fight to defeat the terrorists and bring the hostages home.”
“This week, Iran launched a missile attack against Israel, emphasizing that this conflict is far from over,” Huckabee Sanders added. “Alongside the ongoing attacks against Israel, there has been a shocking rise in antisemitism and pro-Hamas protests in the United States. These activists deny Israel’s fundamental right to defend itself in this war between good and evil.”
New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy, a Democrat, and Montana Gov. Greg Gianforte, a Republican, also ordered flags at half-staff on Oct. 7.
“One year after the tragedies of Oct. 7, 2023, we continue to mourn the devastating losses and urge all parties to reach an agreement that immediately returns every hostage and puts an end to the continued suffering of civilians in Israel, Gaza and throughout the region,” Murphy stated.
“Our hearts go out to the families that have been shattered by the terrorist attacks on Oct. 7 and the humanitarian suffering that followed, and we continue to pray for a swift end to the war and restoration of peace across the region,” he added.
“In remembrance of the one-year anniversary of the horrific Oct. 7 terrorist attacks, I invite all Montanans to join me in remembering the innocent victims who were brutally murdered or injured during acts of war committed by Hamas and for the seven Americans still held hostage,” Gianforte stated.
“The State of Montana continues to stand with Israel and the Jewish people as they continue to face unspeakable persecution, hatred and terrorism,” he added.
The post US States Order Flags at Half-Staff to Mark Oct. 7 Anniversary first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
RSS
IDF’s Ground Op in Lebanon Aims to Prevent Oct. 7-Style Atrocity
Mourners carry a coffin during the funeral of Wissam Tawil, a commander of Hezbollah’s elite Radwan forces who according to Lebanese security sources was killed during an Israeli strike on south Lebanon, in Khirbet Selm, Lebanon, Jan. 9, 2024. Photo: REUTERS/Aziz Taher
JNS.org – The Israel Defense Forces’ ground maneuver in southern Lebanon, launched last week, is focused on dismantling Hezbollah’s infrastructure within a few kilometers from the Israeli border. Put differently, the goal is removing the Iranian-backed terror army’s ability to conduct an Oct. 7-style mass murder attack in northern Israel.
The operation is specifically targeting Hezbollah’s Radwan Force, which has been responsible for ongoing threats to Israeli civilian communities in northern Israel. The Radwan Force’s Galilee invasion plan served as the blueprint for the Hamas Nukhba death squads which led the Oct. 7 attack on the western Negev.
The IDF confirmed on Tuesday that IDF special forces had been acting against Hezbollah compounds in southern Lebanon “since the beginning of the war” in dozens of targeted border operations.
The covert operations targeted the staging areas of three Radwan battalions, including underground and weapons storage facilities. They uncovered tunnels that were 20 to 25 meters deep, some of which entered a mountain and reached nearby villages such as Ayta Al-Shab, Lafr Kila and Miss Al-Jabael.
According to a report by Army Radio, the IDF has, during those earlier raids, destroyed some 30 tons of explosives and anti-tank warheads, a staggering 450 RPGs, hundreds of personal firearms, hundreds of thousands of bullets, dozens of Kornet and other anti-tank missiles, many made in Iran, and 120 different types of missiles.
Over 1,000 intelligence documents were recovered, in addition to aerial photographs, maps and night-vision equipment.
IDF officials confirmed in recent days that the current operation, carried out under the auspices of its Northern Command, involves localized raids. Participating units include the Golani Brigade, the 188th Armored Brigade and the 6th Infantry Brigade, among other forces. On Wednesday, the 36th Division, including soldiers of the Golani Brigade, 188th Armored Brigade, 6th Infantry Brigade and additional forces joined the operation, signifying an expansion of the maneuver.
Since the conflict began, Hezbollah has fired over 10,000 rockets and missiles into Israel, in an effort to force Israel into a two-front conflict and ease the pressure on Hamas in Gaza, an Iranian ally.
The IDF’s current operations, which come after a series of massive airstrikes took much of Hezbollah’s arsenal offline, are aimed at neutralizing Hezbollah’s cross-border threat, and the massive quantities of advanced weaponry and underground facilities so far uncovered are testament to the terror group’s genocidal intent. These capabilities were amassed in blatant violation of U.N. Security Council Resolution 1701, under the nose of the hapless United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon.
One of the key objectives of this operation is to ensure that the Radwan Force, a specialized formation trained for cross-border incursions into Israel, cannot carry out a mass murder attack—a key condition for the safe return home of the 60,000 Israelis displaced from northern Israel.
An Israeli security official stated on Tuesday that the latest operations were conducted in order to dismantle the military capabilities of the Radwan Force and prevent it from carrying out its plan to invade northern Israel.
He also detailed the projectile threat posed by Hezbollah, which has stored weapons, such as surface-to-surface missiles, cruise missiles and missiles with 1,000 kilogram (2,200 pound) warheads throughout Lebanon.
IDF troops have already encountered and destroyed extensive underground networks in the targeted areas, including tunnels, weapons caches and command centers. The IDF confirmed that “soldiers identified and breached underground access points near the border area, exposed extensive weapon caches, assembly areas for terrorist operative operations, and more.”
The displacement of tens of thousands of Israelis from their homes “is a reality we cannot accept, and we will not accept, and no other country in the world would accept it,” the military official emphasized. “For many years, Hezbollah has built up a military stronghold in southern Lebanon […] just meters away from civilian communities in northern Israel,” he added.
“We are essentially focusing on three elements. One is removing immediate threats […] The second thing is, we are targeting those senior terrorists planning terror attacks against Israelis […] The third thing we’re doing is making sure that we create a reality where residents can return to northern Israel.”
In an effort to minimize collateral damage, the IDF has issued warnings to Lebanese civilians in areas where Hezbollah is operating, urging them to evacuate.
Such warnings have been issued with regard to “areas where Hezbollah is operating, is firing at Israel or storing munitions,” he added.
While the IDF has emphasized that these are targeted operations, the situation remains fluid and could change.
Senior defense officials have reiterated that the aim is to neutralize the immediate threat posed by Hezbollah’s military presence near the border, but that if the fire on Israel continues the IDF may need to expand its operations.
For now, however, the IDF is limiting the scope of the operation. “This is a limited, localized target raid on areas near the border to remove threats and to deal with Hezbollah strongholds,” Maj. David Baruch, an IDF spokesperson, stated on Tuesday.
The IDF’s actions are being closely coordinated with Israel’s political leadership, and future operations will depend on ongoing assessments of Hezbollah’s activities.
The IDF Northern Command continues to maintain a high state of readiness as the situation develops.
The post IDF’s Ground Op in Lebanon Aims to Prevent Oct. 7-Style Atrocity first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
RSS
Anti-Israel Protester Sets Himself on Fire Outside White House
White House south side and gardens. Photo: Zach Rudisin/Wikimedia.
JNS.org – A man attempted to self-immolate, lighting his left arm on fire outside the White House on Saturday during an anti-Israel protest.
The man, who identified himself as a journalist, was seen in video taken at the scene holding his arm in the air, engulfed in flames. Several members of the crowd tossed water on his arm and tried to put the flames out with towels, as the man screamed.
The sleeve of his shirt appeared to be burned off, with burn marks visible on his left arm in the video.
Washington D.C. Metropolitan Police Department officers restrained the man, and rescue services transported him to a local hospital with non-life threatening injuries, according to police.
The man reportedly screamed at one point that “we spread the misinformation,” and later that “I’m a journalist, and I said it was OK.”
The man’s identity has not yet been confirmed publicly. An Arizona man with a similar photo has social media pages loaded with content on the Israel-Hamas war and posted that he would be at the White House protest on Saturday to give a speech. That individual also identifies as a journalist.
The incident took place at about 5:45 p.m. along the 800 block of 16th Street, close to the White House, where activists—some supporting Hamas’s Oct. 7 massacre—gathered in protest ahead of the one-year anniversary of the attack.
The man on Saturday became the third known to have lit himself on fire, purportedly in protest of Israel’s military operations in Gaza.
Aaron Bushnell, a 25-year-old U.S. Air Force serviceman, died of his wounds following his actions outside the Israeli embassy in Washington in late February.
Last month, a man identified in news reports as 45-year-old Matt Nelson died four days after lighting himself on fire across the street from the Israeli consulate in Boston.
The post Anti-Israel Protester Sets Himself on Fire Outside White House first appeared on Algemeiner.com.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login