Uncategorized
Jewish villains out to destroy Jesus are a staple of Ukrainian Catholic church pageants in the U.S. The Vatican has remained silent.
At a pizza restaurant in Baltimore last year, a church youth group performed a Ukrainian Christmas pageant that promised patrons “carols, jokes and well wishes for a great year ahead.”
What the audience received was a character called Moshko, a Jewish merchant. Moshko was dressed in black with long sideburns — a villain disrupting the Nativity story.
“Wait, don’t be in a hurry, maybe you’ll get something from Moshko,” the character urges townspeople who are trying to celebrate the birth of Jesus.
After the admirers of infant Jesus reject his overtures, Moshko rushes off to betray the infant Jesus to King Herod.
It was a traditional scene in a vertep, the popular Ukrainian pageant performed during the Christmas season, and the actors came from St. Michael the Archangel Ukrainian Catholic Church in suburban Philadelphia.
Verteps draw on Ukraine’s rich culture, weaving together caroling, dancing, brightly embroidered shirts called vyshyvanky, and elaborate floral crowns into a show that runs for about 10 to 25 minutes. The storylines vary. Many pageants do not include the blatant antisemitic stereotype of the devious Jew who sets out to sabotage Christ. But plenty do.
Ukrainian Catholic religious leaders in the U.S. — appointed to their posts by the pope — have been photographed at verteps featuring the bad-guy Jewish character. Such pageants are also promoted in many instances by churches that they oversee.
They include the church’s highest-ranking leader in the U.S., Metropolitan Archbishop Borys Gudziak, who heads the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in the United States. Gudziak addressed and then joined the audience for a performance by the St. Michael group days after it performed in Baltimore, a moment documented in photos the church posted to Facebook.
Gudziak was deeply familiar with the problematic elements of verteps.
Fifteen years ago, when he was running the largest Catholic university in Ukraine, Gudziak and two colleagues penned an emotional call to remove the Jewish character, often referred to using the antisemitic slur “zhyd,” from performances. He described a sense of foreboding each holiday season.
“At the moment of the highest spiritual culmination of holy Christmas, the vertep ‘Zhyd’ will once again burst into our home — and the seed of evil that the vertep performance was meant to uproot will once again make a nest in our soul,” Gudziak and his colleagues wrote.
In 2019, Pope Francis appointed him to the position of Metropolitan Archbishop of Philadelphia, charged with overseeing U.S. districts for the Ukrainian Catholic church. Gudziak continued to call for friendship between Jews and Catholics. He is on a committee of Interfaith Philadelphia and released a statement following the Capital Jewish Museum shooting last year that condemned antisemitism: “As Catholics, we are called not only to reject such hatred, but to actively foster mutual understanding, respect, and solidarity with the Jewish people.”
But despite these expressions of solidarity, churches within Gudziak’s own archeparchy (the equivalent of an archdiocese) have promoted, organized or hosted pageants featuring negative depictions of Jews. So have other Ukrainian Catholic churches and institutions in the U.S.
The Forward compiled and reviewed video of 10 pageants in the U.S. since 2020 that feature a Jewish character named “zhyd,” “Moshko” or “Chaim,” and sometimes his wife, usually named Sarah. All were posted to social media, in many cases by the churches themselves.
The pageants mix and match a few motifs, all showing these two Jews in a negative light as they try to lure Christians to commit sin. Some tempt the faithful with goods, loans or liquor. Some mock believers for worshipping Christ; curse Christians; summon and collude with the devil, or betray baby Jesus to King Herod, who is seeking to kill him.
Most of the actors playing the zhyd role wore what look to be peyos, the sidelocks traditionally worn by Orthodox Jews. In one instance, the character wore an exaggerated fake nose.
The Forward located photos from an additional eight pageants for which video is not publicly available that show actors with what appear to be peyos or a fake nose.
Those U.S. pageants are part of a global phenomenon, centered in Europe. A Forward review of more than 200 videos of recent verteps internationally associated with the Ukrainian Catholic Church found that when a Jewish character was included, that character in nearly every case was portrayed in a negative light.
The verteps with offensive scenes are almost exclusively performed in the Ukrainian language and have gone largely unnoticed by Jewish organizations in the U.S.
Presented with the Forward’s findings, both the American Jewish Committee and the Anti-Defamation League raised concerns about the performances.
“The caricatures in these celebrations, depicting Jews as greedy or aligned with evil, are inherently antisemitic and are part and parcel of the same dangerous myths that have fueled violence and pogroms against Jewish communities for centuries,” Ken Jacobson, deputy national director of the ADL, said in an email.
In most instances, the video of the pageants was posted online by official church social media accounts. Gudziak was not the only church official to attend; Bishop Paul Chomnycky in Connecticut and Bishop Benedykt Aleksiychuk in Chicago have also attended pageants that featured a Jewish character.
In 2025, Chomnycky’s eparchy posted photos of the bishop speaking at a holiday event that included a vertep featuring a little boy in peyos. The Forward was unable to obtain video of that performance.
The previous year, Aleksiychuk attended and spoke at a festival where photos posted to social media show at least four verteps had Jewish characters. Video from the one performance for which video was publicly available, which was in Ukrainian, has the Jew cursing the faithful, summoning the devil, and lamenting about not being able to sell alcohol. Aleksiychuk posed for a photo with a different vertep cast, which also had an actor in peyos.
In response to a request for comment from the Forward, Gudziak said in a statement on behalf of himself and the other bishops that he did not condone offensive depictions.
“Christmas pageants have included characters that are objectionable, including ones that are offensive to the Jewish community. I do not condone this as a pastor, educator and scholar,” he said. “We will heighten our vigilance and work with our clergy and parishes to make sure that such expressions will not be repeated.”
He noted that Ukrainian Catholics and Ukrainian-Americans have themselves been hurt by stereotypes, and that his church has been shut down and banned in parts of Ukraine now occupied by Russia.
“We highly value our good relations with the Jewish community in the United States and in Ukraine and are most grateful for the many expressions of Jewish solidarity as our community faces existential threats,” Gudziak said, a reference to Russia’s ongoing invasion of Ukraine.
The Catholic Church is composed of 24 distinct churches, with around 99% of the world’s estimated 1.3 billion Catholics belonging to what is officially known as the Latin Church but generally referred to as the Catholic Church. The Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church is the second-largest Catholic church, with around five million adherents.
While it has some distinct practices and liturgy, the UGCC ultimately reports to the Vatican and is bound by the Catholic Church’s teachings on Jews. Those include guidance stating any dramatic performances that “seek to shift responsibility from human sin onto this or that historical group, such as the Jews, can only be said to obscure a core gospel truth.”
Pope Leo XIV, who became pontiff last year, has come under fire from some Jewish organizations — mostly over his criticism of Israel’s war with Iran — but has called for “a world without antisemitism” and stressed that the Church “does not tolerate” it.
The Vatican did not respond to repeated requests for comment from the Forward about antisemitism in verteps organized by the UGCC. The International Jewish Committee for Interreligious Consultations, an umbrella group that describes itself as representing “world Jewry in dialogue with the Vatican,” also did not respond to requests for comment.
A play with deep roots
Verteps are theatrical performances rooted in Ukrainian folk tradition that mix an account of the Christmas story with characters from early modern Ukraine, transporting Ukrainian Christians to ancient Bethlehem as Mary gives birth to Jesus. The juxtaposition is meant to draw a parallel between the lessons from the Nativity and those that the church beginning in the early 19th century wanted to impart onto Ukrainians.
Indeed, the UGCC isn’t the only institution that stages verteps. Various Ukrainian Orthodox denominations also put on the pageants, as do town councils, schools, civic organizations, and simply groups of friends and neighbors, and many have been updated by removing the offensive elements or replacing them with contemporary characters.
In the traditional vertep script, Jesus, Mary and Joseph face off against the devil and contend with murderous intentions by King Herod. Meanwhile, Ukrainians meant to represent everyday Christians celebrate the Nativity while resisting worldly temptations — merchandise, loans and alcohol — that are often personified by a group of ethnic villains: a Jew, his wife and a Roma character often referred to using a slur.
Throughout the performance, this evil troika wreaks havoc, conspiring with the devil to hurt Jesus, while tempting Ukrainian villagers with goods or alcohol. “If the peasant doesn’t drink, how will Moshko make money?” the Jewish character asks the audience in one popular version of the play.
Verteps were suppressed during Soviet control of Ukraine, reemerging after the fall of communism as a cultural touchstone for many Ukrainians. Russia’s war against Ukraine has supercharged support for Ukrainian nationalism — including verteps.
“People brand this as cherishing Ukrainian tradition, especially nowadays when cherishing tradition is portrayed as resistance to Russian aggression,” said Marta Havryshko, a visiting professor at Clark University who studies nationalism and the Holocaust.
Some scriptwriters have come up with corrective alternatives. For instance, Ukrainian playwright Tetyana Shpaykher produces verteps substituting Vladimir Putin for King Herod and Russian propagandists for the devil — while Sarah and Moshko are entirely absent.
“The Church teaches that God is born to us every year,” Shpaykher told a Ukrainian news outlet last year, “each time within new realities.”
‘Bring everything to the zhyd’
The U.S. performances at issue lean into tradition — and negative portrayals showing Jews as greedy and derisive of Christian faith.
In a January vertep performed at Ukrainian Catholic Church of the Epiphany in Rochester, New York, characters playing the Three Kings rebuke a Jewish merchant for seeking to sell beads to the townspeople, as seen in a video posted to social media and since removed.
In Ukrainian, one king says: “We’re not trading, and we’re not buying, and we don’t need you, zhyd!”
After another announces that they plan to worship the messiah, the zhyd mocks them.
“What does a peasant need the messiah for?” he scoffs. “A peasant must plow, and sow, and learn how to thresh, and bring everything to the zhyd instead of asking God for mercy.”
The zhyd’s response draws on antisemitic stereotypes in which Jews supposedly lived off the labor of others.
The Rochester church did not respond to multiple requests for comment from the Forward about the performance, but other organizations have defended the inclusion of Jewish characters as a reflection of Ukrainian history.
“Vertep characters reflect the social realities and archetypes of the 16th- and 17th-century Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, where these folk traditions developed,” Orest Dudyak, head of the Ukrainian American Youth Association in Tampa Bay, wrote in an email in response to the Forward’s outreach. “The tavern keeper character reflects one such historical social role and was traditionally portrayed as a Jewish figure.”
Jewish tavernkeepers were ubiquitous in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, which covers much of modern Poland and Ukraine, because the nobility granted a monopoly on liquor sales to the Jewish community in exchange for a series of fees.
Glenn Dynner, author of Yankel’s Tavern: Jews, Liquor, & Life in the Kingdom of Poland, said that the system incentivized tavernkeepers to exploit peasants in order to cover the exorbitant fees owed to the local nobleman. But he emphasized the stereotype of Jews pressuring Ukrainian peasants to drink themselves into debt was greatly exaggerated.
“The system was based to a large degree on trust,” Dynner said in an interview. His research found many cases of warm relations between Jewish tavernkeepers and villagers.
Yet in the 19th century the regional Catholic church began to blame widespread drunkenness on Jews, rather than the nobility who converted their surplus grain into vodka for the local peasants. The church propaganda helped solidify the notion that Jews were undermining society.
Dynner, a history professor at the University of Virginia, said in an interview that the Jew became a proxy for anger that otherwise would have been directed at the local nobility in a feudal society. “That’s the way it almost always works,” he said. “There’s a Jewish figure you prop up to siphon off any resentment.”
The resentment has endured through the centuries. In 2016, the director of Lviv’s regional library told a journalist that 17th century Cossack leader Bohdan Khmelnytskyi murdered Jews because they “owned the taverns, and they sold vodka on credit — when people couldn’t pay, they confiscated their property.” Khmelnytskyi’s men killed hundreds of thousands of Jews.
The nuance Dynner described — that Jewish tavernkeepers had complex and sometimes positive relationships with their Christian customers — is almost always missing from the depictions of Jews in verteps.
When Dudyak’s Ukrainian youth group performed in January at Epiphany of Our Lord Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church in St. Petersburg, Florida, two Jewish characters were shown wearing what appeared to be peyos. One was referred to as “Moshko,” and together they sought to tempt Christians with goods and loans.
“Get out of here, Moshko, because we’re not going to trade,” a boy playing an angel replies to the Jew. A photo shows the two Jewish characters counting money off stage; it’s common for verteps to have the Jews collect money from the playgoers at the end of the performance.
The Rev. Bohdan Barytskyy, pastor of the St. Petersburg church, apologized for the performance, which he said his church had not organized. “If any individual was hurt or offended by aspects of the performance, I sincerely regret that pain, and I believe such concerns deserve to be heard seriously and respectfully,” Barytskyy wrote in an email.
“I also want to emphasize that I have personally expressed concerns for many years regarding certain traditional portrayals that occasionally appear in some vertep performances, including in previous parishes where I served,” he added. “I have consistently encouraged that depictions which may be perceived as offensive, hurtful, or rooted in outdated stereotypes should not be included, because they do not reflect authentic Christian values or the spirit of respect toward other peoples and faith communities.”
Dudyak, leader of the youth group that performed the play, said in response to an inquiry from the Forward that his troupe had “made a conscious effort to avoid exaggerated or mocking” depictions in the performance.
Other organizers say exaggeration is sometimes the point.
The zhyd in a January vertep organized by the Protection of the Blessed Virgin Mary Ukrainian Catholic Church in Bridgeport, Connecticut, wore a prosthetic nose and danced around with a Gucci bag.
“Like any play, people put the make-up, people put the costumes — and there was a beard, there was glasses, there was a nose, yes there was,” the Rev. Ivan Mazuryk, who runs the church, said in an interview. “But just to make it clear who the character was.”
‘Zhyd’ sparks controversy
Gudziak, the UGCC archbishop based in Philadelphia, was born in Syracuse, New York, but spent years working in Ukraine before being appointed to serve as the church’s senior leader in the U.S.
While he was head of the Ukrainian Catholic University in Lviv, a city in western Ukraine, Gudziak sparked a nationwide discussion over how Jews were depicted in verteps. In a 2011 article in Ukrainian that Guzdiak wrote along with two other university leaders, he argued that the zhyd character was contrary to Catholic values.
Gudziak acknowledged that the zhyd had a long history as part of verteps, and wrote that Jewish and non-Jewish Ukrainians lived side-by-side and sometimes found each other’s customs humorous. But he added that theatrical festivities would spill into the street with serious consequences. “In Ukrainian villages and towns, flocks of boys would chase a Jewish peer down the street, chanting: ‘Zhyd! Zhyd!’”
He discouraged use of the zhyd as part of university verteps and exhorted other Ukrainian Catholics to follow suit.
The appeal set off a national debate that lost steam following Russia’s annexation of Crimea and occupation of eastern areas of the country in 2014, which preceded its full-scale invasion eight years later. Russian propaganda claimed its conflict with Ukraine entailed fighting Nazis, and weaponized claims of antisemitism as a justification for invading the country.
That made it difficult for Ukrainian Jews and others concerned about genuine instances of antisemitism — still widespread in a country that has failed to seriously grapple with its collaboration with Nazi forces during the Holocaust.
“Usually, when we hear someone shouting that ‘Ukrainians are antisemites,’ the Kremlin is involved,” Volodymyr Butkevych, a Ukrainian legal scholar and human rights lawyer, told Radio Free Europe during a 2021 interview about antisemitic expressions in verteps.
This has led to a dynamic in which even Ukrainian Catholic leaders who maintain close ties to American Jews nevertheless engage with verteps that mock Jews.
The Rev. Bohdan Hedz, the leader of St. John the Baptist Ukrainian Catholic Church in Riverhead on Long Island, joined a 2022 Holocaust memorial service at a local synagogue to condemn antisemitism and raise awareness about the war in Ukraine.
“Evil will not prevail,” he said during the event. “My heart goes out to the Jewish community.”
Hedz even said that as a child he had tended to the abandoned Jewish graveyard in his Ukrainian town.
But this December Hedz appeared in the front row of a vertep at his church that featured the familiar Moshko character with peyos and a fake Yiddish accent who tempts the Three Kings and betrays Christ to Herod. He did not respond to calls or emails from the Forward to the church.
Some leaders of the Ukrainian church in the U.S. have bristled at questions over whether they host verteps that present Jews in offensive ways — and say that they have made efforts to improve depictions.
The Rev. Daniel Schaicoski, the leader of Immaculate Conception Ukrainian Catholic Church outside Detroit, explained to the Forward that a long-haired character wearing a hat in a vertep produced by a church-affiliated school was not meant to represent a Jew but rather played a Willy Wonka-style role and handed out candy to the audience at the end of the show.
Schaicoski said that when he arrived at Immaculate Conception more than two decades ago the vertep included a Moshko character, which he insisted be removed from future productions.
“I said this is not right and people could see it — on video or whatever — and misunderstand,” Schaicoski said in a phone interview. He added that bishops from the Ukrainian church had circulated a letter to priests several years ago asking them to make sure that their verteps did not include offensive characters.
But when asked about photo albums from verteps at his church in 2017 and 2019 that both featured a character wearing a skullcap with artificial sidelocks attached — similar in appearance to how zhyd characters are often portrayed in verteps — Schaicoski refused to answer additional questions in a text exchange.
“We don’t do that. I am here for 30 years, we never did that. But I see you will not stop this shameless persecution!” Schaicoski wrote in a text message afterward. “You hunt people and then make yourselves victims, shame on you.”
Other church leaders also stopped responding when asked about vertep photographs.
The Rev. Hugo Soutus, who leads Dormition of the Mother of God Ukrainian Catholic Church in Phoenix, initially responded to an inquiry about a vertep hosted by his church where photos show a character wearing a black hat and what appeared to be artificial sidelocks by requesting more information. He signed off: “Shalom!”
But when sent a link to photos of the vertep, including a post shared by his church, Soutos stopped responding. The Facebook post has since been deleted.
Others were even more curt.
Photos of performances in 2023 and 2024 at St. Joseph the Betrothed Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church in Chicago show included a character with a black hat and sidelocks. One of the images posted by the church to social media shows the character holding beads, which are often hawked by Jewish vertep characters.
Church leaders did not respond to emails asking about the character and a woman who answered the phone at the church said: “Yes, I remember that email — that email was forwarded to our lawyer, OK? Thank you,” before hanging up.
Another Chicagoland church, the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin Mary Ukrainian Catholic Church in Palos Park, also did not respond to emails asking about a photo of a character wearing a similar outfit in its vertep last year.
“There’s no one here to help you,” a receptionist at the church said before hanging up on a Forward reporter.
A long Catholic struggle
The Catholic Church has a long history of theatrical productions that demonize and scapegoat Jews. Unlike verteps that portray the birth story of Jesus, passion plays, which originated in 12th century Europe, collectively blamed Jews for the death of Jesus and often presented Jews as evil — sometimes wearing horns.
Nostra Aetate, a declaration on Catholic-Jewish relations released as part of Vatican II in 1965, declared that Jews could no longer be held responsible as a group for killing Jesus and led to the withdrawal of official church blessings for passion plays that promoted that narrative.
But it still took decades of concerted lobbying by Jewish organizations, led by the American Jewish Committee, to root out antisemitic portrayals in the Oberammergau Passion Play, which is performed once every ten years in Germany and is considered the most prominent production of its kind in the world.
Producers of the Oberammergau began to make reforms in 1990 — 25 years after Nostra Aetate — and it would take another 30 years for the AJC to declare a kind of victory in 2022, when the play began to embrace Jewish rituals in a positive light.
Official Vatican guidelines, detailed by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in a 1988 policy paper focused on passion plays but expounding on “general principles” of church teaching, strongly discourage negative portrayals of Jewish characters. The document states that theatrical productions — “extraliturgical depictions of the sacred mysteries” — should “conform to the highest possible standards of biblical interpretation and theological sensitivity.” The paper also quoted Pope John Paul II’s declaration that Catholic teaching should present Jews “in an honest and objective manner, free from prejudices and without any offenses.”
But it can be difficult to enforce this guidance at the parish level. While the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church is technically controlled by the Vatican, its relationship with Rome is often uneven. For decades, Rome has refused to elevate the UGCC to a “patriarchate,” a status that would grant it more autonomy from the Vatican. Analysts suggest Vatican officials have rejected these repeated requests in part over concerns that the move would provoke the Russian Orthodox Church, which claims Ukraine as its religious territory.
Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk, head of the Kyiv-based UGCC — and who himself hosted a vertep with a character in peyos in 2024 — has in turn criticized the Vatican over its response to Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, telling local media in 2023 that “the pope does not fully understand the pain of Ukraine” and that “all the pope tried to do for Ukraine after the full-scale invasion failed.” In office for a year, Pope Leo has not significantly shifted the church’s approach in Ukraine.
Language is also a barrier. Like the religious services, most verteps take place in Ukranian, making it difficult for officials outside the church to understand what’s being performed.
Verteps themselves are often organized by individual church members. In other cases, local Ukrainian theater troupes perform versions that were created without input from church leaders. St. Sophia Ukrainian Catholic Church in suburban Raleigh, North Carolina, said that was the case with the vertep they hosted in January that featured Moshko betraying Jesus to King Herod.
“We will not use this version of the vertep again,” the church wrote in a statement to the Forward, adding that it would ensure future performances “align with the values of our Church and with the teachings of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, which firmly rejects antisemitism.”
But, to date, none of the Catholic institutions that could exert formal pressure on the UGCC to stamp out antisemitic verteps have been willing to comment publicly on the performances.
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which has taken a firm stand against far-right Catholic pundits who have trafficked in antisemitism, declined to weigh in on the Forward’s findings.
The Catholic Church’s inaction on verteps is at odds with the new pope’s message on Jews and the church.
Pope Leo met last month with representatives from New York City’s Jewish federation and emphasized the church’s “firm stand against antisemitism.”
Citing Nostra Aetate’s call to reject discrimination and harassment — and “shared spiritual ancestry in Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph” — Pope Leo said: “In a world still wounded by division and conflict, it called us to move beyond past misunderstandings toward collaboration for the common good.
The post Jewish villains out to destroy Jesus are a staple of Ukrainian Catholic church pageants in the U.S. The Vatican has remained silent. appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Mamdani faces growing pressure over Jewish NYPD Commissioner Tisch and over Israel from left flank
(JTA) — New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing increasing pressure from some on the leftmost flank of his voting coalition, and an ICE shooting Thursday led democratic socialist allies to add their voices to a major demand: dump police commissioner Jessica Tisch.
“The NYPD’s Strategic Response Group must be disbanded as quickly as possible, and Commissioner Tisch must step down,” said Darializa Avila Chevalier, who won her Democratic primary with Mamdani’s endorsement. The democratic socialist, who is expected to join Congress next year representing Upper Manhattan and parts of the Bronx, was referring to the heavily armed police department unit that often responds to protests.
The calls for Tisch’s removal follow strident criticism of the mayor from pro-Palestinian activists on Wednesday night who called him names, including “traitor” and “Ziohran,” when he showed up at an Oct. 7 Israeli peace vigil mourning the loss of both Jewish and Palestinian lives. The demonstrators assailed him for not doing more to advance the pro-Palestinian agenda that has long been central to his political beliefs, raising questions over whether he could lose parts of his base as he pledges to be a mayor for all New Yorkers.
The demand for Tisch’s removal came after an ICE agent shot and wounded a Dominican man in his car on Thursday afternoon while his 5-year-old son was in the back seat. Avila Chevalier, who joined protests against ICE on Thursday, wrote on X that the NYPD “spent more time protecting a militia that just shot someone than protecting New Yorkers.”
Mamdani’s decision last year to retain Tisch — a self-described “proud Zionist” who comes from a prominent Jewish family — was seen as a reassuring move by moderates and establishment Jewish organizations including UJA-Federation of New York and the Jewish Community Relations Council. (70 Faces Media, the parent company of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency and New York Jewish Week, receives UJA funding.)
A number of progressives were skeptical of the decision at the time, citing her background as an appointee of Mamdani’s predecessor, Eric Adams, and her past criticism of campus pro-Palestinian protests. Some viewed her as an impediment to criminal justice reform.
Meanwhile, some on the left have dinged him for not yet following through on campaign promises 10 months into his term, including dissolving the Strategic Response Group, or backing down from his vow to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, a plan which he later said he did not have the power to execute.
Anti-Zionist groups including Pal-Awda, Within Our Lifetime and a number of student organizations who rallied against Mamdani at the Oct. 7 vigil accused him of succumbing “to Zionist pressure.” Protesters called him a “traitor” and a number of chants rang out including, “Mayor Mamdani you can’t hide, we charge you with genocide,” drowning out speakers at the vigil and forcing the organizers to move it behind police barricades to keep the protesters from overrunning the event.
Among those protesters’ many gripes with the mayor was his decision to retain Tisch. One sign at the demonstration depicted Mamdani with the text, “Chief Executive of the NYPD SRG” with a Star of David in the middle, and a name tag on the mayor’s chest reading, “Ziohran.”
Criticism was also directed at Mamdani for not stopping Israeli real estate events at synagogues, and for his strategy to combat antisemitism, released last week, which allocates funds to a number of community-based organizations aimed at preventing hate crimes. Some critics have charged that some of the funding will aid Zionist organizations.
“The Jewish community is a large part of New York and it should be cherished. But you cannot fund these Anti-Defamation Leagues that prioritize Zionism over Judaism,” a John Jay College student protester, who declined to be named, told JTA during the demonstration.
On Thursday, the Democratic Socialists of America’s New York City chapter — which Mamdani has called his “political home” — wrote that Tisch “must end NYPD complicity with ICE” and that if she “cannot put a stop to these injustices, she must be fired.”
“Abolish ICE. Disband the SRG. Fire Tisch,” wrote Illapa Sairitupac, a fellow democratic socialist who won the Democratic nomination for a Lower Manhattan State Assembly district. Mamdani endorsed both Sairitupac and Avila Chevalier this past year.
While some protesters at the vigil said they were Mamdani voters — and one speaker even identified herself as a former intern for the now-mayor — some of the mayor’s allies have stressed that the crowd protesting him was not representative of his base.
“If I had to gamble, I would gamble that the vast majority of them were people who never supported him,” activist Abby Stein told JTA on Thursday night, during the Mazals gala held by left-wing group Jews for Racial & Economic Justice. Mamdani was due to attend the JFREJ event, but because of the ICE shooting was instead in the Bronx, where he denounced the federal agency and demanded that it cease its operations in New York City.
Many of the signs excoriating Mamdani at Wednesday’s protest outside of City Hall were signed with the name of the Maoist Communist Union, an organization that opposed Mamdani before he took office. Some protesters were handing out copies of Spartacist, the Trotskyist International Communist League’s journal.
“We certainly didn’t support Mamdani or vote for him,” said Erica Jones, among the Trotskyist protesters. “We knew he was running as a Democrat and he would be as big of a sellout as AOC and Bernie Sanders and all the rest of those who claim to have, at one time, stood for socialism but in reality, stand for the capitalist masters who are oppressing us all.”
Stein, a member of the DSA in addition to JFREJ, called out some of the protesters’ rhetoric and the choice to crash the Israelis for Peace Oct. 7 vigil. But she also acknowledged that there was overlap between their demands and her views, including over the police commissioner.
“There are things that people are upset over that I think are legit — like keeping Jessica Tisch on, for example,” Stein said. “A lot of us were not very happy about it.”
Ultimately, Stein said there is “always going to be something to protest” with any politician, and pointed to a quote from New York’s mayor in the 1970s and ‘80s, Ed Koch: “If you agree with me on 9 out of 12 issues, vote for me. If you agree with me on 12 out of 12 issues, see a psychiatrist.”
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post Mamdani faces growing pressure over Jewish NYPD Commissioner Tisch and over Israel from left flank appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
A planned non-Zionist Jewish school in Boston hopes to ride the momentum of the left
(JTA) — BOSTON — In the middle of a conversation about her future children, it dawned on Leah Robbins that the school she imagined for them did not exist.
Robbins envisioned a Jewish school where children studied Jewish texts, history and observance, as she did at the school run out of her Conservative synagogue in northern Florida. But having long ago rejected the allegiance to Israel that was entwined with her education, she could not fathom sending her children to a school that promoted Zionism — which ruled out all the Jewish day schools she knew.
“I was just overwhelmed with a sense of grief that my kids could be less Jewishly educated than I was,” Robbins, who has lived in Boston for 10 years, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. “I would never ever consider sending my kids to any of the local day schools because of total values misalignment.”
Four years after that conversation, Robbins is building her own institution for the children she hopes to have. She plans to open Achvat Olam, a “diasporist” day school whose name translates to “global solidarity” in Hebrew, in the Boston area in fall 2029. The school aims to launch with eight to 10 families, starting with a kindergarten and adding grade levels until ultimately becoming a K-8 school.
Achvat Olam is fiscally sponsored by Beloved Builders, a Massachusetts-based nonprofit that supports progressive Jewish projects. Robbins, who has a background in fundraising for Jewish nonprofits, hopes to raise $625,000 for the launch. She said she has met about 20 local families who expressed interest, and will start formal recruitment efforts, including focus groups and open houses, next year.
Achvat Olam will teach about Jewish history, cultures and languages outside of Israel, while engaging with Hebrew and Israel’s history from a non-Zionist perspective. The school’s website includes a page on “Israel/Palestine,” saying its community will share a belief that “the pursuit of justice, dignity, and thriving for all people is a Jewish moral imperative.”
“This includes an age-appropriate, honest confrontation with Zionism and the ongoing Nakba against the Palestinian people,” the website says, using the Arabic word for the displacement of over 700,000 Palestinians at the time of the State of Israel’s founding. The school also says that students will consider “the complicity and support of the US government and Diaspora Jews.”
Micah-Shalom Kesselman is the parent of a 4-year-old in Medford, Massachusetts, and participates in local left-wing Jewish groups such as the Boston Workers Circle. He’s disappointed that his son Oren will age out of Achvat Olam by the time it is scheduled to open as a kindergarten. “I would super want Oren to attend something like what Achvat Olam is shaping up to be,” he said.
Kesselman, who studies Yiddish with his son, explained that he would like Oren to be steeped in Jewish traditions and culture. But as a parent who is “not a supporter of Zionism,” he said he has found few Jewish educational opportunities that match his beliefs.
Diverse day school histories
Jewish day schools have historically encompassed a range of orientations toward Israel, according to Jonathan Krasner, a historian of American Jewish education at Brandeis University. The modern day school movement was born in the 1920s and initially dominated by orthodox schools, some of which did not emphasize Zionism. In the 1950s, secular Yiddishist schools taught varied attitudes toward Israel. Some yeshivas in the orthodox Haredi movement still today oppose Zionism on religious grounds, believing that Jewish sovereignty should only be established through the coming of the Messiah.
But Krasner could not name another day school that has Achvat Olam’s goal: education for Jewish families who disavow the current-day political realities of Israel and Zionism. In the aftermath of the Hamas attacks on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, many day schools went the opposite direction, adding curricula to strengthen solidarity between Diaspora Jews and Israel.
“The initial response of the organized Jewish community was, understandably, to circle the wagons and to reinforce their connections to Israel and to the Israeli people,” Krasner said.
Jack Wertheimer, a professor of American Jewish history at the Conservative movement’s Jewish Theological Seminary, isn’t convinced that Achvat Olam will change that trend. He said he was “highly skeptical” that Robbins could attract enough families to sustain a school. According to historical data, he said, Jews who lean more politically left tend to be less engaged in Jewish life.
“From what I know, the overwhelming majority of parents who are interested in sending their children to Jewish day schools are pro-Israel,” said Wertheimer.
Nonetheless, Robbins believes that the market for her school is growing. Survey after survey has captured a drop in Americans’ support for Israel since the Gaza war, and Jews are not an exception to the trend. After decades of being treated as fringe in many of their communities, left-wing Jews who are anti-Zionist — or simply do not see Israel as part of their identity — say that instead of adapting to their congregations and Jewish schools, the institutions should adapt to them.
There are signs that this group makes up a substantial portion of Jews in the United States. About 30% of Jewish adults believe that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, according to a June poll of 1,022 Jews from the Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, which had a 5% error margin. Less than 40% said that “supporting Israel” was crucial to their Jewish identity.
Younger Jews emphasize traditions
At the same time, among adults who identified as religiously Jewish, younger people said they emphasized Jewish traditions more than their older counterparts. Younger Jews were more likely than older ones to say that “celebrating Jewish holidays” and “celebrating or marking Shabbat” were important to them, while Jews over 45 placed more emphasis on “remembering the Holocaust” and “supporting Israel” than younger ones.
This finding could reflect the growing share of younger Jews who are Orthodox. It also comes amid a boom in Jewish leftist organizations that explicitly ground their activism in religious tradition. IfNotNow, an anti-occupation group that has grown from 1,000 dues-paying members in 2023 to 7,000 this year, says it is “growing a community rooted in Jewish values and ritual.” The anti-Zionist Jewish Voice for Peace, which has amassed 32,000 dues-paying members, often frames its protests through Jewish holidays, texts and prayer.
Robbins is betting that a significant pool of younger Jews, many of them now parents to young children, are seeking avenues to both protect their Jewish traditions and reset their community’s relationship with Israel for the next generation. Instead of supporting Israel, Achvat Olam says that its students will learn a curriculum of “collective liberation at home, globally, and in Israel/Palestine.”
“This is a very experimental moment in Jewish history. The Jewish left is growing by leaps and bounds,” said Robbins, referencing estimates of dozens of anti-Zionist congregations and prayer groups sprouting across the country. “There is hunger for this.”
Boston is a hub for such new organizations. Since 2024, the city has hosted the Conference on the Jewish Left at Boston University, a gathering of left-wing Jewish scholars, students, activists and faith leaders. The first annual meeting drew 300 people, the second 700, and the third in February saw more than 900 participants. A poll of Greater Boston by Combined Jewish Philanthropies, the central fundraising arm of Boston’s Jewish community, found earlier this year that 38% of Jews aged 18 to 29 identified as “anti-Zionist,” and another 30% said they were “uncommitted” to Zionism or anti-Zionism.
Rabbi Greg Hersh left his congregation at Temple Emmanuel in Wakefield, north of Boston, in 2024. He said he became increasingly alienated from his congregants after Oct. 7. Hersh felt that the congregation, focused on supporting Israel and fighting antisemitism locally, did not share his anguish about the deaths of Palestinians.
Last year, Hersh founded V’ahavtah, a mostly Cambridge-based congregation devoted to “practicing Judaism beyond Zionism.” V’ahavtah joined Jews, like him, who felt uncomfortable with the norm of Israeli flags flying inside synagogues. Their Shabbat services regularly draw 30 to 40 people, numbers he said he never saw in Wakefield. He believes that is proof of growing demand for non-Zionist Jewish institutions.
“You take Israel out of the equation and the Jews will show up, and that’s what happened with V’ahavtah,” said Hersh. “My expectation is Achvat Olam is going to be very well poised to fill that void.”
On the ground, Robbins faces formidable obstacles to funding Achvat Olam. Jewish day schools struggle across the country to attract enrollment in the face of tuition that many families can’t afford, along with budgets strained by economic uncertainty and heightened spending to ward off security threats. Earlier this year, MetroWest Jewish Day School in Framingham, a suburb of Boston, shuttered and said that its “model of highly individualized Jewish day school education is no longer sustainable.”
Heavy investments from local philanthropies have helped day schools offset high costs. Prizmah, a national network of 305 day schools, recently reported that it saw enrollment rise across denominations for the first time last year, thanks in large part to philanthropy.
But many groups that fund Jewish education hold values that are antithetical to Robbins’ — including CJP, which calls itself a “pro-Israel, Zionist organization.” Prizmah and CJP declined requests for comment from JTA.
The individual donors who fund Jewish schools also tend to be older, more conservative than Robbins and more motivated by support for Israel, according to Krasner.
“The people who are most likely to be in a financial position to support day schools with generous philanthropic gifts are demographically very different from the population that Leah is trying to attract,” he said.
Robbins admitted that funding challenges meant the success of Achvat Olam was not “any sort of inevitability.” But she believes there is inevitability to the political momentum that could drive families toward such a school. “Something I want to convey to people is that the train has already left the station,” she said. “There is no stemming the tide of the growth of the Jewish left.”
Robbins has turned to funding from left-wing organizations, which already siphon much of their resources to grassroots activism, legal defense and awareness campaigns.
“It can be hard to get in the face of people to make the case for something that requires long-game thinking,” she said. “I’m trying to make the case, when the last fire has been put out, what’s going to be left if we’re not building it right now?”
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post A planned non-Zionist Jewish school in Boston hopes to ride the momentum of the left appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Protesters in Toronto: ‘We will honor all our martyrs’ after 3 years of Gaza war
(JTA) — TORONTO – Hundreds of protesters marched through Toronto’s downtown core via Yonge Street Saturday afternoon, chanting more loudly as additional people joined the demonstration. “We will honor all our martyrs, all our children, sons and daughters!” and “In my lifetime I will see Palestinians living free!” the crowd yelled in unison.
Separated by metal barricades and police officers, a much smaller group of counterprotesters waving Israeli and Iranian flags stood at the southern end of Sankofa Square, where the demonstrators gathered before the march to mark the third anniversary of the war in Gaza.
Trailing behind a white Ford F-150 equipped with speakers, protesters at one point shouted, “Overthrow the Epstein class,” a slogan referring to disgraced Jewish financier Jeffrey Epstein to decry the global elite and call for the ultra-wealthy to be stripped of power. Tensions briefly flared when a man wearing a Turning Point Canada sweatshirt confronted a group of pro-Palestinian demonstrators.
Otherwise, the protest was largely peaceful. Toronto police said that one individual was arrested at the demonstration after being recognized by officers as someone wanted in connection with an unrelated incident.
The protest was part of a broader international wave of demonstrations, with the Israeli Ministry for Diaspora Affairs counting 17 protests in Canada planned for Saturday through Wednesday, including in Montreal and Ottawa.
The demonstrators included Jews and Israelis who are highly critical of the prosecution of the war in Gaza and Zionism as a whole. “I went to school in Haifa, and I saw how Palestinians are treated,” said pro-Palestinian protester Shlomit, 65, who didn’t provide a last name due to concerns for her safety. “I grew up in a very Zionist family, but being in Israel actually changed my mind about things.”
Shlomit said she had mutual friends with Vivian Silver, a Canadian-Israeli peace activist who was murdered on Oct. 7, 2023, when Hamas attacked Israel, launching the Gaza war. She said she was emotionally impacted by Silver’s death, and believes the kind of work like Silver’s was critical to building peace between Israelis and Palestinians.
“I knew all these people who were connected to [Vivian]. She was a peace activist, and what happened to her was distressing to me,” said Shlomit, who wore a pin labeled “Jews Against Occupation.”
Prime Minister Mark Carney mentioned Silver in a statement on Wednesday, the three-year anniversary of Oct. 7 itself. “Canada unequivocally condemns Hamas, which must play no role in the future governance of a demilitarised Palestinian state,” read Carney’s statement. “We stand steadfastly with the Israeli people in their pursuit of a safe and secure Israel as part of a two-state solution.”
The statement continued by commemorating the Canadian lives lost to the Hamas attack, mentioning Silver and eight others. “We remember them for the lives they lived and the people they loved – and we honour the families and friends who continue to mourn their loss. May their memory be a blessing,” he said.
Other demonstrators expressed solidarity with issues beyond the Middle East. Caelen Leizer-Romalis, 24, was attending the protest as part of the Revolutionary Communist Party. “We have an obligation as Canadians to stand up to imperialism,” said Leizer-Romalis, who is Jewish. “In order to liberate the people of Palestine, we need to liberate the workers here as well.”
Despite being outnumbered, pro-Israel demonstrators — all of whom carried either an Iranian flag or a picture of the last shah of Iran before his ouster in the Iranian Revolution of 1979 — waved their flags as “Tel Aviv” by Omer Adam blasted from a boombox.
Mahya Tayabi, 38, decided to come to the protest to demonstrate unity between Israel and Iran. “I’m Persian, but I love Israel. I love Jewish people. Bibi and the IDF helped my country,” said Tayabi, referring to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu by his nickname. As Tayabi spoke, the boombox switched to playing an EDM beat featuring the lyrics “Ayatollah Khamenei is dead!” Israel and the United States killed the ayatollah at the beginning of the war on Iran that they launched in late February.
The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs expressed concern regarding the weekend’s protests.
“Canada’s Integrated Threat Assessment Centre has warned about the consequences of turning a blind eye: when targeting of the Jewish community becomes frequent and normalized, it can push susceptible individuals toward violence. Events praising the ‘resistance’ responsible for the October 7 atrocities as communities gather to mourn the murdered demands moral clarity from civic leaders about what is acceptable in our society.”
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post Protesters in Toronto: ‘We will honor all our martyrs’ after 3 years of Gaza war appeared first on The Forward.
