Uncategorized
An Israel analyst’s best- and worst-case scenarios for the new right-wing government
(JTA) — The recent Israeli elections, the fifth in less than four years, returned Benjamin Netanyahu to the driver’s seat for the third time.
The twice and future prime minister appears able to cobble together a coalition that has been called the most right-wing in Israeli history. It will include three far-right and two haredi Orthodox parties, and his partners include the far-right Religious Zionism party and its leader Bezalel Smotrich, who has sucessfully pushed for a heavier hand in controlling Israeli policies in the West Bank; Itamar Ben-Gvir, head of the extremist Otzma Yehudit party, who is due to head a new National Security Ministry that will be given authority over Border Police in the West Bank; and far-right Knesset member Avi Maoz, whose Noam party campaigned on a homophobic and anti-pluralistic platform.
These developments have cheered the American Jewish right, which has long called for Israel to consolidate its power in — if not outright annex — the disputed territories of the West Bank that are home to 480,000 Israeli settlers and 2.7 million Palestinians, of whom 220,000 live in East Jerusalem.
For Jews on the center and left, however, the results have prompted anxiety. If the two-state solution has long looked out of reach, many were at least hoping Israel would stay on a centrist path and maintain the status quo until Israelis and Palestinians seem ready for their long-delayed divorce. American Jewish leaders are worried — privately and in public — that Jewish support for Israel will erode further than it has if Jews become convinced Israel doesn’t share their democratic and pluralistic values.
I spoke this past week about these issues and more with Michael Koplow, the chief policy officer of the Israel Policy Forum and a senior research fellow of the Kogod Research Center at the Shalom Hartman Institute of North America. The IPF supports a viable two-state solution, and Koplow acknowledges that he agrees with “almost nothing that I’m going to see from this Israeli government.” But he remains one of the most articulate analysts I know of the high stakes on all sides.
Our conversation was presented as a Zoom event sponsored by Congregation Beth Sholom, my own synagogue in Teaneck, New Jersey. The transcript below has been edited for length and clarity
Jewish Telegraphic Agency: What are the far right’s big asks, and what might we expect to see going forward?
Michael Koplow: There are a few issues that are really coming to the fore. The first is judicial reform. There’s a longstanding complaint among the Israeli right that the Israeli Supreme Court is perceived to be left-leaning — the mirror image of what we have here in the United States. Secondly, the Supreme Court is perceived by many Israelis to be an undemocratic institution, because it is an appointed body. In Israel, you have a selection committee for the Supreme Court that is actually composed mostly of sitting Supreme Court justices and members of the Israeli Bar Association. A common complaint is that the Knesset is a democratic body selected by the people and it’s hampered by this undemocratic body that gets to dictate to the Knesset what is legal and what is not.
And so for a long time on the Israeli right there has been a call to have a bill passed that would allow the Knesset to override Supreme Court decisions. At the moment, there’s no recourse. The ultra-Orthodox parties in Israel have long sought exemptions for haredi Israelis to serve in the IDF and the Supreme Court has consistently ruled that ultra-Orthodox members of Israeli society can’t get a blanket exemption. A Supreme Court override bill would allow the Knesset to exempt the ultra-Orthodox from serving in the IDF. For the more right-wing nationalist parties, particularly Religious Zionism, the Israeli Supreme Court has ruled on multiple occasions that settlements cannot be established on private Palestinian land in the West Bank. Their main interest in a Supreme Court override is so that they can pass laws that will effectively allow settlements anywhere in [the West Bank’s Israeli-controlled] Area C, whether it’s state land or private Palestinian land.
Is Netanyahu interested for these same reasons?
Netanyahu is to a lesser extent interested in these things, but right now he’s on trial for three different counts, all for fraud and breach of trust, which is the crime that Israeli politicians get charged with in matters of corruption. He’s also in trouble for bribery. One of the things that he wants to do is to pass something called the “French law,” which would bar sitting Israeli prime ministers from being investigated and indicted. And in order to do that, he almost certainly will have to get around the Supreme Court.
The second thing that I think we can expect to see from this prospective coalition has to do with the West Bank. In late 2019 and early 2020, there was a lot of talk in the Israeli political sphere about either applying sovereignty to the West Bank or annexing the West Bank. This happened also in conjunction with the release of the Trump plan in January 2020, which envisioned upfront 30% of the West Bank being annexed to Israel.
This all got shelved in the summer of 2020, with the Abraham Accords, when the Emirati ambassador to the United States wrote an op-ed where he said to Israelis, “You can have normalization with the UAE or you can have annexation, but you can’t have both.” Israelis overwhelmingly wanted normalization versus West Bank annexation. Between 10% and 15% of Israeli Jews want annexation, so this annexation plan was dropped. In the new coalition, annexation is back, but it’s back in a different way. Bezalel Smotrich is a particularly smart and savvy politician, and understands that if you talk about annexation or application of sovereignty on day one, he’d likely run into some of the same problems — from the United States and potentially from other countries in the region. And so the way they’re going about it now is by instituting a piecemeal plan that will add up to what is effectively annexation.
How would that work?
For starters, there is a plan to legalize illegal Israeli settlements, and when I say illegal, I mean illegal under Israeli law. There are 127 settlements in the West Bank that are legal under Israeli law, because they had been built on what is called state land inside of the West Bank, and because they’ve gone through the planning and permitting process. In addition, there are about 205 illegal Israeli outposts and illegal Israeli farms, containing somewhere between 25,000 and 30,000 Israelis. And what makes them illegal under Israeli law is that they were all built without any type of Israeli government approval. In many of these cases, they’re also built on private Palestinian land.
The first part of this plan is to legalize retroactively these illegal outposts. The coalition agreement that has already been signed between Likud and Religious Zionism, Smotrich’s party, calls for, within 60 days of the formation of the government, the state paying for water and electricity to these illegal outposts. I should note there already is water and electricity to these illegal outposts, but it’s paid for by the regional settlement councils. This would have water and electricity paid for by the Israeli government, and then within a year to retroactively legalize all of them. That’s step number one.
Step number two has to do with the legal settlements inside the West Bank. There is a body called the Civil Administration, which is the body that is in charge of all construction for both Israelis and Palestinians in Area C, the 60% of the West Bank that is controlled entirely by Israel. As part of the agreement between Likud and Religious Zionism, Smotrich is going to be finance minister, but also appointed as a junior minister in the Defense Ministry, and he will control the Civil Administration and will be in charge of all settlement construction in the West Bank. He will also have the power to decide whether Palestinians can build in Area C and whether Palestinian structures in Area C that were built without a permit can be demolished. And so this will almost certainly be increasing at a very rapid rate. The Supreme Planning Committee that plans West Bank settlement construction normally would meet about four times a year, and under the [current] Bennett/Lapid government it only met twice, but Smotrich said in the past that he would like to convene it every single month. So the pace of settlement construction is almost certainly going to grow at a pretty rapid pace.
What will Itamar Ben-Gvir, an acolyte of Meir Kahane, the American rabbi barred from Israel’s parliament in the 1980s because of his racism, gain in the government?
Itamar Ben-Gvir is the head of Otzma Yehudit, the Jewish supremacist party that now has six seats in the Knesset. As part of his negotiations with Netanyahu, he is going to be appointed to a new position known as the “national security minister,” which is currently called the public security minister, but they’ve increased its powers and renamed it. They’ve also given this new ministry control over the West Bank border police, who operate in the West Bank. And they’re also giving this minister power over the police that normally belongs to the police commissioner. And so Ben-Gvir, who I should note has seven criminal convictions on his record, including one for support of a terrorist organization and incitement to racism, is going to be the minister who’s in charge of the police — not only inside of Israel, but he’ll be in charge of the police who operate in the West Bank and who operate on the Temple Mount.
Michael Koplow is the chief policy officer of the Israel Policy Forum and a senior research fellow of the Kogod Research Center at the Shalom Hartman Institute of North America. (Courtesy IPF)
And this is important because Ben-Gvir is one of the figures in Israel who has talked a lot about changing the status quo on the Temple Mount, probably the most sensitive spot in the entire world, and certainly the most sensitive spot anywhere between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Which is why Israeli governments, including very right-wing governments, have not changed the status quo [allowing Jews to enter the Muslim-administered mount, but pray there], certainly not formally. He’s also talked about increasing his own visits to the Temple Mount.
And he’s also talked about changing the rules of engagement for Israeli police, whereby they would be allowed to shoot anybody on sight, for instance, who’s holding a stone or holding a Molotov cocktail. Right now the current rules of engagement are that people like that can only be shot if they present an imminent and serious threat to a soldier or police. Changing that is certainly going to have an effect on relations between Israelis and Palestinians and likely lead to the types of clashes we’ve seen in Jerusalem over the past few years.
This is all very good news for folks who want to solidify Israeli control in the West Bank. It’s not such good news for people who support more autonomy for the Palestinians and certainly support the two-state solution — and I think I can include the Israel Policy Forum in the latter camp. I want to hear your thoughts on what you’ve called the best-case scenarios and the worst-case scenarios, and on where Netanyahu fits in.
When I say best-case scenario, I mean in terms of preserving the status quo, because a best-case scenario where you’d actually have an agreement between Israelis and Palestinians is nowhere. It’s not in any conceivable future.
I think the best-case scenario would be that Netanyahu understands Israel’s place in the international system and he understands how issues inside the West Bank impact Israel’s foreign relations. This is somebody who has served as Israeli prime minister longer than anybody else. He was prime minister when the Abraham Accords came into being, and that accomplishment is rightfully his. Netanyahu understands these factors and has a long history of being very cautious as prime minister. He’s not a prime minister that uses force. He’s not a prime minister under whom Israel has undertaken any major military operations outside of Gaza. I think that it’s not unreasonable to think that his history of relative caution isn’t just going to go away. And that means doing things to make sure that the fundamental situation in the West Bank doesn’t get overturned.
Netanyahu is operating in a political context in which his voters and voters for the other parties in his coalition do expect some real radical changes. Interestingly, however, part of this agreement with Religious Zionism is that everything has to be approved by [Netanyahu], and so there will be a mechanism for Netanyahu to slow some things down. I think that there is a situation in which he lets things proceed at an increased pace, but doesn’t do anything to really fundamentally alter the status of the West Bank.
I also think that voters voted for Religious Zionism and Otzma Yehudit not because they’re looking for big, massive changes in the West Bank or an explosion in settlement construction, but because they were voting on law and order issues. Many Israelis are still very shell-shocked, literally and figuratively, by the events of May 2021, particularly the riots that broke out in mixed Israeli cities. And despite the fact that Itamar Ben-Gvir was blamed by the police commissioner at the time for instigating some of the violence in mixed cities, he ran a very effective campaign where he said, “Vote for me and effectively I will restore order.”
That leads to the reasonable best-case scenario of plenty of things happening that will cause friction with the United States and plenty of things that will cause friction with the Palestinians, but nothing that can necessarily be undone by a different government down the road.
And the worst-case scenario, from your perspective?
The worst-case scenario is all of these things that Smotrich, in particular, wants to carry out leads to the collapse of the Palestinian Authority. Based on my own experience in the West Bank in recent months, the Palestinian Authority has fundamentally lost control of much of the northern West Bank. In many places they have chosen not to engage in many ways. They effectively operate in and around Ramallah, and have a token presence in other spots, but don’t really have the power to enforce law and order. They’re under enormous political strain.
As a very quick refresher, the West Bank is divided into three areas, A, B and C. In theory, Area A is supposed to be entirely under the PA control and where you have between 1.3 and 1.5 million Palestinians. If the Palestinian Authority collapses, that means that Israel must go in and literally be the day to day governor and mayor of Area A and all its cities, providing services to 1.3 million Palestinians. It means acting as traffic cops, dealing with all sorts of housing and construction and literally everything that municipal governments do that Israel has not done in Area A in almost 30 years.
Does Israel even have that capability?
The standard is that 55% of all active-duty IDF soldiers are currently stationed in the West Bank. If the Palestinian Authority collapses it’s not hyperbole to say that every single active-duty IDF soldier will have to be stationed in the West Bank just to run things, just to maintain basic law and order. That means not having IDF soldiers on the border with Egypt, on the borders with Syria and Lebanon. It will effectively have turned into nothing but a full-time occupation force. And that’s Option A.
Option B is that Israel elects not to do that. And then Hamas or Islamic Jihad steps into the vacuum, and they become the new government in the West Bank. And at that point, everything that you have in Gaza, you have in the West Bank, except for the fact that the West Bank is a much larger territory. It cannot be sealed off completely. This is literally the nightmare scenario not only for Israeli security officials, but for Israeli civilians. And that’s even before we talk about the impact that will have on terrorism and violence inside of Israeli cities inside the green line, let alone what happens in the West Bank.
The United States and the European Union, and the U.N., presumably, won’t stand idly by through a lot of these changes. What leverage do they have and can they use to maintain the status quo?
The U.S. and E.U. are going to have some pretty clear, very well-defined red lines. I think it’s reasonable to expect that the Biden administration and many members of Congress will put the formal declaration of annexation as a red line. The same goes for European countries. But certainly the Biden administration doesn’t want to be in a position where they are getting into constant fights with the Israeli government. The administration rightly views Israel as an ally and an important partner and wants to maintain military and security and intelligence cooperation with Israel in the region. All those things benefit U.S. foreign policy. This is not an administration and certainly there isn’t support in Congress for things like conditioning security assistance to Israel or placing new usage restrictions on the type of weapons that we sell to Israel. And so there isn’t a huge amount of leverage in that department.
But I do think we’re going to see more diplomatic and political-type measures. People remember the controversy that ensued in December 2016 at the United Nations when the Obama administration abstained from a Security Council resolution on Israeli settlements. I think that if some of these measures go ahead, on the Israeli side, there’s a good chance that we will see the United States once again abstain from some measures in the Security Council. At the moment, the Israeli government has been working very hard to get the United States to help with [thwarting] investigations into Israeli activity in the West Bank in the International Criminal Court and the International Court of Justice. I think that those sorts of things become a lot harder if Israel has fundamentally changed the status of the situation in the West Bank.
There are probably all sorts of trade relationships with the European Union that may be at risk. One big factor here is the other states in the region, the Abraham Accords states. There’s reason to think that they may act as a check on the Israeli government, given the popularity of normalization among Israelis, and given the fact that the UAE was the party that really stepped in and prevented annexation from taking place in the summer of 2020. In a country like Saudi Arabia, where you have a population of between 25 and 30 million, or Iraq or Kuwait, [the far right’s agenda] makes normalizing relations with those countries very, very difficult, if not impossible, and it’s possible that Netanyahu will use that also as a way to try and appeal to some of his coalition partners.
Another outside partner is Diaspora Jewry. A vocal minority of American Jewry supports the right-wing government, but a majority would support a two-state solution. They connect to Israel with what they see as a shared sense of democracy and liberal values. Does Netanyahu and his coalition partners think at all about them and their concerns? Do those Diaspora Jews have any leverage at all in terms of moderating any of these trends?
The short answer is not really. The parties in a prospective coalition are not ones that historically have cared very much about the relationship with the Diaspora. Haredi parties are not concerned about the erosion of liberal values inside of Israel or the situation in the West Bank for the most part. And parties like Religious Zionism and Otzma Yehudit really don’t care what American Jewry thinks about much of anything. We’ve already seen demands in some of these coalition agreements to amend the Law of Return, where right now, anybody who has one Jewish grandparent is eligible to be an Israeli citizen. These parties have been requesting that it be amended so that you are only eligible if you are halachically Jewish, meaning you have a Jewish mother [or have converted formally].
North American Jewry is a real asset to the State of Israel given its role traditionally in supporting the state economically and politically. And yet over the past decade and a half there have been repeated comments [among Israeli politicians, including Netanyahu’s ambassador to the United States, Ron Dermer] that it’s more important to be making inroads with evangelical Christians than with North American Jews, given the politics of evangelical Christians and given their size.
Many American Jews, particularly from the Reform and Conservative denominations, have already been angry that Israel doesn’t fully recognize the authenticity of non-Orthodox Judaism, and that an agreement to create a permanent egalitarian prayer space at the Western Wall has been repeatedly shelved under pressure from Israel’s religious right.
We are in for a tough time in terms of Diaspora-Israel relations. You know, it’s not just about the issues that have been on the table over the past few years that have been disappointing to Diaspora Jewry, whether it be the Western Wall arrangement, whether it be recognition of Conservative and Reform Judaism inside of Israel, whether it be things like the Law of Return, which now seems to be under threat. In general, this question of values, which has been a big deal, is going to be even more front and center. Many American Jews have looked at Israel and thought of it as a place that shares liberal values with the United States. To some extent, that’s been historically accurate. But that picture, whether it’s accurate or not, is going to be under incredible strain.
What about within Israel? Are there any countervailing powers that might moderate the far right — professional military leadership, major business leaders, other opinion-makers outside the political process?
Thankfully, there is no history of IDF leadership interfering in the political decisions of elected civilian leaders in Israel. I hope that will continue. The way the security establishment has generally dealt with these sorts of things is by presenting a united front when they speak to the political leadership and give their opinions and advice and warnings about what might happen. They tend to be very savvy at leaking those opinions to the media. I’m certain that that sort of thing will continue. We already saw some discord over the past week between IDF leadership and some of the members of the prospective new coalition over disciplinary measures that were taken against soldiers who were serving in Hebron, one of whom punched a [Palestinian] protester, another who verbally assaulted a protester. And that can be a moderating influence, but I actually do not expect to see the military leadership stepping in any way in preventing something that the government may want to do.
The biggest check will be Israelis themselves. There was something else interesting that happened [last] week: Avi Maoz, who was the single member of Knesset from Noam, which is one of these three very, very radical right-wing parties, was appointed as a deputy minister in the prime minister’s office, and he was given control over effectively everything in education that is not part of the core curriculum and Israeli schools — like culture and Jewish identity issues. And that led to a revolt from Israeli mayors. You’ve had over 100 mayors of over 100 municipalities signing a letter saying that they are not going to be bound by Maoz’s dictates on curriculum. And this includes right-wing cities. I think that the most effective check is going to be government overreach, which leads to a backlash like this among Israeli citizens and among Israeli politicians who are not members of Knesset.
We’ve covered a lot of ground. Is there something we haven’t touched upon?
It’s really important that people don’t look at what’s taking place in Israel, throw up their hands and say, “You know, there’s nothing we can do to change this and Israelis are increasingly uninterested in what we think and so we’re going to disengage.” To my mind, the relationship that American Jews have to Israel is too important to just throw up our hands and say it doesn’t matter.
If we take American Jewish identity seriously, and we take the American Jewish project seriously, we have to think about two things. First, how we build an American Jewish identity that’s uniquely American. But second, how we preserve some sort of relationship with Israel, even when we see things coming from Israel that don’t speak to our Jewish values. We’re living in a time where we have an independent Jewish state with Jewish sovereignty in the Jewish homeland. This is a historical anomaly. If we turn our backs on that, despite all of the difficulties, it really would be a tragedy and catastrophic for American Jewish identity.
If you don’t like what you see going on in Israel, try to figure out what your relationship with Israel will look like and how to have a productive one. And that doesn’t have to mean supporting everything the Israeli government does. I consider myself you know, somebody who is a strong Zionist, strongly pro-Israel. It’s a place that I love. I agree with almost nothing that I’m going to see from this Israeli government. But I’m still able to have a strong, meaningful relationship with the State of Israel, and I hope that people are able to do the same, irrespective of the day-to-day of Israeli politics.
—
The post An Israel analyst’s best- and worst-case scenarios for the new right-wing government appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
Uncategorized
Hunter College student government cancels cultural event, and Jewish students say Hillel was the reason
Hunter College’s Undergraduate Student Government canceled a cultural arts festival that had been set for Monday — and some Jewish groups are saying it was because of Hillel’s involvement. A Hunter alumna says it was a long time coming. The cancellation also follows a similar decision on another campus, with Hillels increasingly under attack.
USG put out two disparate statements on the cancellation. The first, signed by USG President Sumaiya Ahmed and Vice President Ahmad Waraich, said the student government had miscommunicated about the event and that not all members were aware it was even happening.
“We hear what the student body has said, and we have made the decision to cancel the event as it doesn’t align with our values or the values of the students we represent as the Hunter community,” the statement, released on Saturday, read.
Yonathan Eilon, Hillel student president, read dozens of comments on the post before they were all deleted.
“Almost the entire comment section was full of people just saying that it was canceled because of Hillel in one way or another,” he told the Forward. “Either because USG doesn’t want to work with Hillel, or because other student groups don’t want to work with Hillel.”
Elion added that some groups don’t actually have an issue with Hillel, but are afraid of backlash so they’ll refuse to collaborate. This is disappointing, he said, because Hillel is actively seeking intercultural dialogue.
The other groups involved in the festival included the Taiwanese Student Association, the Peruvian Student Association, the Chinese Student and Scholar Association and Students for Justice in Palestine.
But less than 24 hours after the first statement, USG put out another. This time it did not include signatures and specifically cited safety concerns.
“If we, as a Student Government, are not able to provide a safe and secure space for all our students, then we cannot continue to move forward with an event,” read the statement. “As planning progressed, several participating student organizations withdrew, creating additional difficulties in moving forward with the event as originally envisioned.”
This alarmed Eilon, who told the Forward he is concerned about keeping himself and other Jewish students safe. He has attended Hunter since 2023, and said there has been an “abundance” of what he calls “ambient antisemitism.” This includes social isolation students experience for sharing their Jewish background, to banners at pro-Palestinian protests that say “Bring the war home,” Eilon said.
Hunter professor Leah Garett, who directs the Jewish Studies Center, is suing City University of New York, which oversees Hunter, alleging antisemitic discrimination. Her lawsuit accuses the university of allowing protesters to intimidate and harass Jewish campus members under the guise of free speech.
Hunter Hillel put out its own statement about the cancellation of the event, writing: “Jewish students should never be singled out, scapegoated, or made to feel unwelcome because of who they are and the antisemitic response online to the cancellation notice has been egregious and inappropriate.”
Hunter College, USG, SJP, the Taiwanese Student Association, the Peruvian Student Association, and the Chinese Student and Scholar Association did not respond to the Forward’s requests for comment.
New York City Council members Eric Dinowitz and Virginia Maloney urged the university to launch a Title VI investigation to determine if the incident amounted to discrimination based on race, color and national origin.
CUNY’s website makes clear that its students cannot be denied access to a program or activity based on their perceived or actual origin. Groups that protest Hillel are quick to say they are against the club’s connection to Israel, rather than against its Judaism.
Moshe Spern, activist and president of United Jewish Teachers — a network of Jewish teachers from across New York City public schools — is not convinced.
“When Jewish students participating is the dealbreaker, the spin doesn’t change the outcome,” he wrote in response to USG’s second statement.
Hillels increasingly scrutinized
The controversy at Hunter comes as Hillels across the country are increasingly protested by pro-Palestinian student organizations that take issue primarily with the Jewish student club sponsoring Birthright and Perspectives trips to Israel. This year, New York City’s New School student government voted to cut ties with Hillel and strip its funding, though they lack the authority to take these steps.
At the University of Oregon, protesters burned an American-Israeli flag outside of a Hillel House, and flyers naming and attacking its director were distributed around campus. At Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois, a festival similar to Hunter’s was canceled due to the inclusion of Wildcats for Israel, a club housed within Hillel that describes itself as focused on Israeli culture and society.
The instances are part of an ongoing debate about Zionist bans. While bans against people for political beliefs are sometimes legal, bans may be illegal if Zionist is simply a substitute for Jew.
For Gabi Schiller, an American Israeli Hunter alumna who graduated in spring 2023, the festival controversy is not a surprise. If anything, she said it’s been a long time coming.
Schiller, who engages in pro-Israel activism, told the Forward that she and other Zionist-leaning students had wanted to bring in speakers to facilitate discussion on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with other groups. This was before Oct. 7, and she said that the sentiment at Hillel was not to “rock the boat.”
“The tension builds and builds until either it eventually explodes or it leads to a complete boycott of Jewish life altogether,” Schiller said. “Because no one was brave from either side, brave enough to be willing to sit down and talk — not just have an interfaith event, but talk about the elephant in the room, which is the conflict.”
At Hunter, Hillel’s office is right next to the Muslim Student Association. Despite their close proximity, Schiller said there was hardly interaction between the two groups during her time as a student.
“It’s so sad to me,” Schiller reflected.
For now, students are waiting to hear what, if anything, the university has to say. USG has gone quiet on the matter since releasing its second statement, even disabling comments on its most recent statement with the caption:
“Comments have been turned off due to safety concerns and hateful rhetoric. Hunter College seeks to promote inclusivity and safety for all students.”
The post Hunter College student government cancels cultural event, and Jewish students say Hillel was the reason appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
‘Zio Doctors got butthurt’: Sydney doctor leaves prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism
(JTA) — A physician at one of the busiest hospitals in Sydney, Australia, left a prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism and bullying of Jewish colleagues.
Jennifer Martinez, head of sexual assault services at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital since February 2025, reportedly departed from her role earlier this month even though she was less than halfway through a five-year minimum term.
New South Wales Health began investigating Martinez in August of 2025, after a complaint was filed with NSW Health Minister Ryan Park that June alleging “antisemitic bias” and “bullying behavior” on social media, as first reported by Sky News Australia, now rebranded as News24 Australia.
The complaint, lodged by the Australian Zionist Healthcare Alliance, expressed concern about at least 16 separate incidents, primarily on Instagram but also on other social media networks.
The writers accused her of “targeted online harassment of Jewish and pro-Israel healthcare workers,” as well as of mocking Jewish trauma and using antisemitic slurs, such as “Zio doctors” or “Zio doc flops.”
One post included in the complaint celebrates “when Zio Doctors got butthurt for [tears of joy emoji] emojiing their hysterical accusations & defamatory comments” and features the hashtags “#demons #gronk #gronkisnotajewishsluryougronk,” using an Australian derogatory slang word for a brutish moron. She also appeared to mock 600 Australian Jewish creatives whose private WhatsApp conversations about antisemitism and anti-Zionism had been leaked and whose names were published, leading to harassment.
Martinez also publicly identified herself as the individual behind her social media handle, thereby posing “a serious risk to public trust in the medical profession,” according to the complaint, shared with JTA on Monday.
About 15 months after the NSW Health investigation began, News24 reported last week that the process had concluded and that Martinez had “quietly left her position” at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. The News24 report said Martinez did not reply to requests for comment.
Sharon Stoliar, who co-founded the Australian Zionist Healthcare Alliance and filed the complaint, told JTA on Monday that she viewed Martinez’s reported departure as “too little too late, but also a victory in combating antisemitism.”
“She should not have even been given this position in the first place as she had already been quite openly posting some horrific antisemitic content online well before this appointment,” Stoliar said.
“There was either a significant failure of processes by not screening her adequately before appointment, or they did screen her and did not seem to care about her online bullying, discrimination and antisemitism,” she added.
The Sydney Local Health District, which oversees the hospital, did not reply to JTA’s request for comment. However, a district spokesperson told News24 that the department “supports a safe and healthy workplace to enable our staff to provide the highest quality of care” but would not confirm whether Martinez had been terminated.
Stoliar shared with JTA a letter she received from Rebecca Tyson, general manager of the hospital, on Nov. 3. The letter informed her “that the formal investigation has been completed” and “that the conclusions reached were reasonable.”
“As you will appreciate, the outcome of the matter is confidential,” Tyson wrote, adding that “the appropriate action has been taken.”
An email sent by JTA to Martinez’s official NSW Health address bounced back, saying that she is “unavailable and will not be monitoring this inbox.”
Martinez is listed as medical director for an Australian corporate medical and health services firm called TOTIUM, but she only appears on an older “team backup” page rather than on the current staff page. TOTIUM executives did not respond to JTA’s request for confirmation that Martinez works there.
Her Instagram account still exists but lacks any posts or followers. Her most recent social media post that is still viewable is a video on X from November 2023, in which Australian doctors call for a ceasefire in Gaza and “unimpeded humanitarian aid.”
But Stoliar’s complaint, as well as additional information she supplied to investigators at a later date, included numerous screenshots of former posts, many of which have also been shared on local broadcast networks.
Stoliar said she submitted the complaint fairly soon after Martinez’s appointment, but she felt that “it took far too long to see an outcome.” In the aftermath of the Hamas Oct. 7, 2023, attacks on Israel, Stoliar said she has witnessed the emergence of an environment in which regulators “have let antisemitism fester with no consequences.”
“This has emboldened healthcare professionals into thinking they can continue to openly share antisemitic content and discriminate Jewish colleagues,” she added.
The New South Wales Jewish Board of Deputies, the official elected body and umbrella organization for the New South Wales Jewish community, did not reply to JTA’s request for comment.
A few months after Stoliar lodged the initial complaint, Martinez spoke at an October 2025 rally in Sydney, where she characterized herself as the victim.
“Doctors and healthcare workers here in Australia are being doxxed, stalked and are having our jobs threatened. I am one of them,” Martinez said at the rally.
She made these comments after speaking on behalf of Australians who had joined a Gaza-bound flotilla that was intercepted by the Israel Defense Forces.
“They want us to be silent, to be afraid, to disappear. But we will not,” Martinez said. “Our duty is to care for life and defend human rights.”
Stoliar expressed hope on Monday that Martinez’s dismissal from her position “taught her a valuable lesson,” noting that “healthcare professionals are supposed to leave their biases at the door.
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post ‘Zio Doctors got butthurt’: Sydney doctor leaves prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
How one Reform synagogue became a test of religious pluralism in Jerusalem
(JTA) — Forty years ago on Simchat Torah, Eliahu Abergil, the Sephardic rabbi of Jerusalem’s Baka neighborhood, arrived at a service held by the fledgling Kol HaNeshama Reform congregation with a group of followers after learning that women were dancing with Torah scrolls alongside men. The confrontation turned physical, with some of Abergil’s followers trying to wrest the scrolls away from worshippers before police intervened.
New York-born Levi Weiman-Kelman, who was ordained at the Conservative Jewish Theological Seminary, had founded Kol HaNeshama in 1984 in his living room, with many of its early members young English-speaking immigrants settling in the neighborhood.
Four decades later, Kol HaNeshama again faced hostility, with five incidents targeting the Reform congregation over a matter of weeks, including break-ins, vandalism and harassment. Its leaders say intolerance has hardened in Israeli society and have accused political leaders of helping create the climate around the attacks, whether through inflammatory rhetoric or by failing to condemn the attacks.
But at a solidarity gathering in Kol HaNeshama’s sukkah after the latest attacks, Weiman-Kelman, also a former president of Rabbis for Human Rights, pointed to a countervailing change: the circle of people willing to stand with Kol HaNeshama had grown considerably. While in 1986 the communities that rallied around the synagogue were overwhelmingly Reform, this time, Orthodox rabbis and congregations were among those who signed letters of support and came to stand alongside a community whose theology and practices they do not necessarily share.

Oded Mazor, Kol HaNeshama’s current rabbi and a former rabbinical assistant to Weiman-Kelman, said some of the Orthodox communities were explicit: “We’re not Reform, we don’t think like you. But we value you, and we will defend your right to be who you are.”
“It’s no longer only our issue, as Reform Jews, to confront this violence. There’s an understanding that responsibility for a shared, pluralistic and tolerant public space belongs to all of us together,” he said.
Anti-Defamation League CEO Jonathan Greenblatt attended the first Friday services after Sukkot in a show of solidarity with the congregation. “No Jew should feel unsafe because of the way they practice Judaism,” he wrote on X.
Police arrested three minors suspected of involvement in the incidents, which included eggs thrown at worshippers on Rosh Hashanah and objects hurled through a window ahead of Yom Kippur. Nearly two months later, Mazor said the congregation had received no further update on the investigation, and police had not responded to several inquiries from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
The youths involved appeared religious but not haredi, according to congregants who interacted with them and the synagogue’s security-camera footage. Congregants also reported harassment and homophobic comments.
A large Pride flag hung on one wall of the sukkah at the solidarity event. The repeated targeting of Pride symbols has convinced Mazor that the attacks were aimed not only at the congregation’s Reform identity but also at its embrace of LGBTQ inclusion.
“They didn’t vandalize Reform prayer books, they didn’t graffiti the walls. They came to tear down a Pride flag and commit a hate crime against a Reform community and the LGBTQ community,” he said.
The crowd in the sukkah, some 200 strong at its peak, reflected a wide cross-section of Jerusalem Jewish life: men with and without kippot, and women with and without head coverings – from kippot to headscarves.
Among them were David Goodman and his wife, Amirit Rosen, the co-rabbis of Moreshet Avraham in Jerusalem’s Armon Hanatziv neighborhood, a congregation affiliated with Israel’s Masorti movement, the Israeli branch of Conservative Judaism.
“An attack on a Jew because of their Jewish identity is an attack on me,” Goodman said. “That’s true when it happens abroad, and all the more so when it happens to my neighbors in Jerusalem.”
The gathering was organized with the support of Reshut Harabim, an umbrella network bringing together more than 65 Jewish organizations and congregations working to promote pluralistic Jewish life in Jerusalem, and as part of a nationwide sukkah initiative run by Shomrim al HaBayit HaMeshutaf bringing Israelis from different religious and political backgrounds together.
Goodman said those networks help explain why the response to the attacks on Kol HaNeshama looks so different from the 1980s.
“What were once disparate communities have become a network that knows how to stand together,” he said. “There is immense power when we cooperate.”
Several Jerusalem organizations later chose Kol HaNeshama to host a memorial marking the anniversary of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s assassination, as a show of solidarity following the attacks, Mazor said.
Today Kol HaNeshama has about 280 member families and serves a much larger circle of worshippers, including native Israelis and immigrants who grew up Reform, Conservative and Orthodox or with no affiliation.
After the 1986 confrontation, Jerusalem Mayor Teddy Kollek helped the congregation secure a permanent home in Baka. The city leased Kol HaNeshama an abandoned stone building, which it renovated before eventually expanding into the larger complex it occupies today.
While it has deep roots in Jerusalem’s English-speaking immigrant community – and counts New York Times senior correspondent Isabel Kershner, former Israeli ambassador to Germany Jeremy Issacharoff and solar-energy entrepreneur Yossi Abramowitz among its current worshippers – Kol HaNeshama never became simply an expatriate Reform transplant.
Services are more participatory and retain more of the traditional prayer sequence than the formal, cantor-centered style historically associated with classical Reform Judaism, while also incorporating meditation, chanting and elements Mazor said might once have been considered “New Age.” The congregation has also long experimented with liturgy, including gender-diverse language for God, innovations Mazor said later spread to other congregations.
For longtime congregant Laura Zeitlin, Kol HaNeshama became a family home as much as a place of worship. Her son attended the synagogue’s preschool and later celebrated his bar mitzvah there. Zeitlin, who said she did not identify with a particular Jewish denomination while growing up in Argentina, said she was drawn to Kol HaNeshama because she could sit beside her husband and participate fully in services.
Her frustration over the recent attacks was directed not at religious difference itself but at what she saw as a lack of mutual respect. “We have respect for them, but they don’t have respect for us,” she said.
Ezra Ende, rabbi of the Reform congregation HaDror in Jerusalem’s Kiryat HaYovel neighborhood and also involved with Mevakshei Derech in Katamon, said other congregations in Jerusalem, including his own, had also faced threats.
“The reality is that there is more violence in Israel today and all liberal communities are feeling it,” he said.
Jerusalem Mayor Moshe Lion’s response to the attacks was a recurring point of contention among congregants and supporters. Lion spoke privately with Mazor before Yom Kippur and expressed support for the community, but did not publicly name Kol HaNeshama in condemning the attacks, despite calls from Union for Reform Judaism President Rick Jacobs and Gilad Kariv, a Knesset member from the Democrats party, to speak out.
“The fact that Lion didn’t come out and say anything” naming the synagogue “says everything,” Ende said.
Lion later issued a general statement condemning attacks on others’ religious practices, customs and ways of life. His office rejected suggestions that political considerations, including sensitivity to Jerusalem’s large haredi electorate, explained his reluctance to speak publicly about Kol HaNeshama by name.
A spokesperson told JTA that the city had chosen not to draw further attention to the attacks “so as not to escalate things.”
Mazor invited Lion to the Sukkot solidarity gathering, but the mayor declined, citing prior commitments.
Naama Kelman, Weiman-Kelman’s sister and a former dean of Hebrew Union College’s Jerusalem campus – where in 1992 she became the first woman ordained as a rabbi in Israel – noted that Lion had addressed students at HUC about a year earlier. But she suggested Lion may have been more comfortable appearing at HUC because it serves as an event venue as well and is not publicly identified primarily as a Reform institution.
“Lion doesn’t get it,” Kelman said. “This neighborhood is what’s going to keep the city pluralistic.”
Mazor, who was also ordained at HUC, as were his father and sister, said Kol HaNeshama was once the only egalitarian synagogue in that part of Jerusalem; today it sits among Masorti, egalitarian and partnership Orthodox congregations. Even in some mainstream Orthodox synagogues, expanded roles for women have become common, including women dancing with Torah scrolls on Simchat Torah, the practice Abergil railed against in 1986.
Mazor sees that evolution as evidence that attitudes once thought fixed can change with familiarity and exposure.
Kol HaNeshama hosts dozens of school and pre-army academy groups each year, many arriving with little knowledge of Reform Judaism and asking why a Pride flag hangs in the synagogue. “If schools create that encounter, then the conversation happens,” Mazor said. “Without those touchpoints, students will only know what extremists want to tell them about Reform Jews or LGBTQ people.”
Both Kelman and Mazor saw the attacks as part of Israel’s wider political climate, but stressed that antagonism toward Reform Judaism was nothing new. After the 1986 confrontation, then-Sephardic chief rabbi Mordechai Eliahu declared that “there is no freedom of worship in Israel” if that meant equal recognition for different Jewish denominations, while then-Religious Affairs Minister Zevulun Hammer said he supported protection for private worship but opposed “importing problems,” an apparent reference to American-style Jewish pluralism.
Still, Kelman said, “it’s gotten worse.”
The attacks on Kol HaNeshama are “a direct result of the kind of incitement that Ben-Gvir spews, hate and messianic extremist Judaism,” she said, referring to National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.
Kelman also pointed to comments by other officials mocking Reform Judaism, saying she was “terrified” by what she saw as their contribution to a growing gulf between liberal American Jews and Jewish Israelis. In May, minister May Golan attacked Kariv, a Reform rabbi, in the Knesset, accusing him of “marrying dogs in your bizarre synagogues.” Last year, Likud lawmaker Galit Distel Atbaryan told Kariv, “If you hold a bar mitzvah for a dog, I’ll come and celebrate,” before ordering “the enlightened Reform Jew” removed from a committee meeting she was chairing. The same rhetoric surfaced during one of the Yom Kippur incidents at Kol HaNeshama, when two youths who had been harassing worshippers arrived with a large dog and asked to arrange a bar mitzvah for it.
Mazor called the Oct. 27 parliamentary elections, which produced no clear governing majority and left coalition talks unresolved, critical for the “future of Israel as both a Jewish and democratic state, in which the Jewish character of the state is expressed through its democracy.”
“This is our national home, and we have to make it work,” he said.
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post How one Reform synagogue became a test of religious pluralism in Jerusalem appeared first on The Forward.

