By MYRON LOVE As B’nai Brith Winnipeg reminds us every year during Holocaust Remembrance Week,”to every person there is a name.”
When we hear or read numbers – 500,000 people murdered in Syria’s decade long civil war – or an estimated 300,000 dead in Yemen’s civil war – or 25 million Sudanese at risk of starvation, they are just numbers without meaning for most of us.
The same could be said for the 1,200 Israelis massacred by Hamas and their minions on October 7, 2023.  For me, personally, the face and name that I put to that horrendous mini-Holocaust was -from the very first news reports, our community’s Vivian Silver.  We had known each other since we were seven. We went to school together. In later years, I had grown close to her parents, Meyer and Ros, through our common shul membership, and I would see Vivian at shul when she came to visit. I admired her efforts to foster harmonious relations between Jewish and Arab Israelis and Israelis and Palestinians.
I now have another name and face to picture when I think of the October 7 massacre.
On Tuesday, August 26, I was among 200 fellow Winnipeggers in attendance at the Shaarey Zedek to hear Jacqui Vital tell us about her daughter, Adi.  Adi, we were told, had fought valiantly against the terrorists despite impossible odds and died heroically.
“I want people to know that my daughter is not just a number,” Vital said.  “She was a wife,  a protective and strong mother, a sister, a daughter, a friend.  She was a born leader imbued with the spirit of volunteering.  She was always true to herself.  And she loved the land and people of Israel.”
Jacqui Vital has dedicated the last two years to keeping alive Adi’s memory by speaking about her wherever she can.     
Vital’s appearance in Winnipeg – part of a cross-Canada tour – was co-sponsored by the Shaarey Zedek, the Asper Foundation, Bridges for Peace Canada, and the Rady JCC.
Vital was introduced by Kelly Hiebert, a Westwood Collegiate teacher who is dedicated to educating his students about the Holocaust. The speaker began her presentation by reviewing her road to aliyah. 
Born and raised in  Ottawa, Vital attended the University of Toronto. Fifty years ago she immigrated to Israel.  In Israel, she met and married Yaron. The couple had three daughters – with Adi being the youngest – and one son.
Adi and her husband, Anani, had two children: sons Negev – who was three-and –a-half  at the time – and Eshel, who was just six months old.  Adi was an engineer and cyber-security expert.
As part of her presentation, Jacqui Vital played a video of Adi and another member of the kibbutz speaking about why they decided to move to Holit, a small kibbutz near the Gaza border, and became kibbutzniks.  There were also videos of the extended family in happier times –with the last photo from a family gathering on Rosh Hashanah, three weeks before her murder.
In the early hours of Saturday, October 7, 2023, Jacqui Vital said , when Adi heard the first signs of the invasion and recognized that this wasn’t the norm – and with her husband, Anani, somewhere else – she took her sons into the home’s safe room and contacted Anani.  There was a rifle in the safe room because Anani was the deputy head of security for the kibbutz.  Adi phoned Anani and asked how to load it.  When the terrorists began to shoot through the door to the safe room, Adi fired the rifle, killing one of the attackers before the other terrorists killed her.
I have long believed that everyone who survived the Holocaust was saved by a miracle – if not several miracles.  In the case of Adi and her family, several miracles followed her killing.
First, among this group of terrorists, there were at least some who retained vestiges of humanity.  Instead of murdering the children – as happened in many other cases on that infamous day – the killers spared the children. Not only that, they gave them to the care of a neighbour – Avital Alajem. 
Then – a second miracle. This is a story I remember from that time.  After taking Avital Alajem and the two boys into Gaza, they stopped before entering the tunnel they had used to enter into Israel, and one of the terrorists inexplicably indicated to Avital that she should turn back with the boys and return to Israel. She was able to return the boys to their father.
Now, Jacqui recounted, she was visiting family in Ottawa around this time. She was scheduled to return to Israel on October 8.  Adi’s father, Yaron, had gone to stay with Adi and the boys over Sukkot, while Anani was away.
More miracles:  Adi had suggested to her father that he should stay in the kibbutz guest house lest the baby’s cries wake him up at night.  At the sound of the commotion outside, he went into the guest house’s safe room and waited… The terrorists never came.
As Jacqui reported, the attackers had a detailed map of the kibbutz and who lived where.  The guest house was listed as uninhabited, so they didn’t enter that house.  Yaron waited until late in the afternoon when IDF soldiers broke in and he was able to leave. 
He went with IDF soldiers to his daughter’s house, Jacqui continued.  Inside, they found the body of the terrorist that Adi killed lying on the floor – but no signs of Adi and the kids. They weren’t able to open the door to the safe room wide enough to get in.  On the following Tuesday, a different group of IDF soldiers found a back way in and saw Adi’s body – rigged with explosives. If the soldiers had entered through the safe room door, there would have been a massive explosion.
The final miracle, as told by Jacqui:  Although Yaron’s car was riddled with bullet holes, it was drivable.  The soldiers recommended that he take Road 232 back to Jerusalem.  On a hunch, he chose a different route.  It turned out that terrorists were firing at cars traveling on 232.
Jacqui reported that there have been several acts of kindness helping to keep the memory of Adi alive.  About 1,500 people attended her funeral. Some of Yaron’s students planted a tree in her memory in the yard of the school where Yaron teaches. A couple in Ottawa, who didn’t know Adi,- designed a logo as a tribute to her featuring the head of a lioness – for the boys’ trust fund – the Adi Kaploun-Vital Memorial Fund – which is intended to help support Eshel and Negev.
Any readers who might be interested in donating can go online to the Adi Kaploun-Vital  Memorial Fund on Jgive.

By MYRON LOVE Over the years, I have written about Klara Belkin several times in this newspaper – most recently this past spring when I learned about a documentary that had been filmed highlighting quite likely one of the most significant moments in her life – in the spring of 1945 – when the Hungarian-born cellist and her family were rescued by American forces from a train that was heading for Theresienstadt concentration camp.
After the war, she studied the cello at the Franz Liszt Academy in her native Budapest. Following the Hungarian Revolution in October 1956, she was able to leave Budapest – with the encouragement of her mother – for Vienna. In Vienna, though, the symphony was not hiring any female musicians. So, she came to Canada and found a position with the Winnipeg Symphony Orchestra. That was also where she met her husband, Emile, a violin player, who was also a member of the WSO.
 She was the principal cellist for the Winnipeg Symphony Orchestra for 20 years.  As well, for many years, in the winters, she and Emile were also members of the Tampa Symphony Orchestra in Tampa Bay. As a teacher, she served as a member of the faculty of the University of Manitoba’s School of Music for almost 20 years.  
Now, I have always thought of  Klara Belkin as a classical musician.  So, you can imagine my surprise when my family and I were at Rainbow Stage in August enjoying the recent production of “Frozen” and I noticed in the program that Klara had been inducted on to Rainbow Stage’s Wall of Fame a few weeks earlier.
“It was a different direction for her,” notes her daughter, Lisa Belkin.
According to Lisa, her mother was a member of the Rainbow Stage Orchestra throughout the 1960s and 70s.  “My sister, Brenda, and I were little kids when she began performing at Rainbow Stage,” Lisa recalls.  “Our family spent our summers at our cottage at Sandy Hook. Our mother would play as part of the Rainbow Stage orchestra in the evenings and generally get back at midnight.”  
She reports that Klara left Rainbow Stage in 1979 when she began teaching at the University of Manitoba School of Music.
She was back at the summer theatre briefly in 1990 when she was part of the orchestra backing up the premiere of local playwright/composer Danny Schur’s production of “Strike”, his tribute to the 1919 General Strike in Winnipeg.
One memory Klara has of her time at Rainbow Stage was theatre founder Jack Shapira’s Rolls Royce which, she believes, was the first in Winnipeg.
While Klara appreciated the honour, Lisa notes, her mother was unable to attend the induction ceremony in person.  The famed cellist – now 95 – moved to Saskatoon four years ago – shortly after Emile passed away – to be closer to Lisa.  Family friends represented her at the induction.
In her acceptance speech, Klara Belkin expressed her thanks to the Rainbow Stage organization.  “I am grateful to my dear friends who are with you this evening to accept this honour on my behalf,” she wrote.  “Participating in Rainbow Stage over the years has been very meaningful to me.  As a newcomer to Canada from Europe in 1957, I was not at all familiar with North American musical theatre.  Playing Rainbow Stage over many years gave me the familiarity and joy of Broadway musicals.  
 
“In the early days of Rainbow Stage,” she recalled, “for me – that was in the 1960s… there was a roof over the stage, but not over the orchestra pit or the audience.  When it rained – that was the end of the show and everyone went home.  It happened a lot.  
“Also – playing the shows over many weeks each season, my orchestra colleagues and I were very sure we could play the various roles on stage as substitute actors in a pinch.”
She remembered that the orchestra pit was nearly always cramped – especially for the string players.  There would only be enough room to play her cello using the center one-third part of her bow; that was so she didn’t poke the two guys on either side of her.   
 “I looked forward to every season at Rainbow Stage,” she wrote.  “It was always wonderful seeing how much the audience enjoyed the show … while the mosquitoes always enjoyed them.  Thank you so much for this wonderful honor.”
Lisa is happy to report that her mother’s health is still relatively good and that she keeps busy drawing  and practising her beloved cello.

By MYRON LOVE Many readers will no doubt remember the uproar caused 15 months ago (on May 16, 2024) when the valedictorian for the University of Manitoba Max Rady College of Medicine used his podium to slam Israel, rather than focus on the traditional themes of looking back on the graduating students’ life journey while looking ahead to the future.
As this website in a story posted at the time reported at the time, Gem Newman dedicated half of his 25 minute presentation to the Israel-Hamas conflict, demanded an immediate ceasefire in the conflict with Hamas, and decried the widespread destruction in Gaza. Newman also claimed that 35,000 Palestinians had been killed by the IDF – a figure that even the United Nations had discredited at the time.  Newman further charged Israel with deliberately targeting healthcare workers.  Finally, he specifically challenged Doctors Manitoba and the Canadian Medical Association to add their voices to the call for a ceasefire. 
“What should have been a joyful occasion was turned into a negative experience for my family,” says Dr. Sheldon Glow, whose daughter was one of the graduates.  “What made it even worse were the Muslim families behind us clapping, screaming, dancing and cheering.  My family was emotionally devastated.”
 Glow was one of several members of our Jewish community – individually, or as a group – who filed complaints with the Medical College, the University of Manitoba, the College of Physicians and Surgeons and the provincial Health Minister.
“I had heard that there were 24 major complaints and dozens of other written complaints that were not accepted by the investigating committee,” Glow says.
One of the complainants was Judy Werier.  Although she didn’t have any family members among the graduates, Newman’s remarks struck a negative note for her.
“October 7 changed everything,” she observes.  “I was always an advocate for different causes.  But, after October 7, several of my left wing friends turned on Israel.  These were people I had been long connected to. Their accusations that Israel is an apartheid state and is committing genocide I found deeply distressing.”
She felt the same way on hearing about Newman’s slanders.  “I remembered our joy when our daughter graduated from Medical College in 2014,” she notes.  “Newman stole that joy from our Jewish students.
”Newman’s speech was inflammatory,” Werier says.  “It was in violation of the medical code of ethics.  I checked his social media posts. They are despicable.”
Wanting to take action, Werier went online and filed a complaint with the College of Physicians and Surgeons.  That got a response, she reports, with nice words – but no action was taken. 
Sheldon Glow also reached out to the Minister of Health and the Human Rights Commission as well as the university and the College of Physicians and Surgeons – with the same lacklustre response.  
The controversy was re-ignited this past April when the Canadian Palestinian Association of Manitoba shared the following post: “A Big Win for Mb Health Care Workers: All 24 complaints filed against Dr. Gem Newman following his valedictory speech at the U of M were resolved informally.  The College of Physicians & Surgeons of Mb found no evidence of wrongdoing in relation to Dr Newman’s advocacy for Palestine.”
In response, an ad hoc group of Jewish Winnipeggers, led by internationally known human rights advocate David Matas, have created an online petition challenging the College’s conclusions, demanding that the College reconsider its findings, based on several points.     
The basis for the request, the petition points out, is that: the original refusal to act on the complaints did not comply with the Regulated Health Professions Act; did not follow the procedure for the disposition of complaints set out by the College, leading to an unjustifiable denial to the complainants of an appeal from the dismissal of their complaints; treated freedom of expression as an absolute; did not have due regard for the counter-balancing values of freedom from incitement to discrimination and hatred; is not consistent with the College policy “Advice to the Profession: Maintaining Professional Obligations when Engaging on Public Platforms”; excluded unjustifiably consideration of some complaints; lacked transparency and had an overly limited focus on the potential harm at issue.
“The call for reconsideration,” Matas points out, “comes amid a rising wave of antisemitic incidents across Canada. Most recently, attendees at the Israeli pavilion during Winnipeg’s Folklorama festival reported being subjected to vulgarities and threats, a reflection of growing intolerance.”
 
Matas notes that over 200 community members  had signed on in support of the complaint and the request for reconsideration as of  the end of August.  Readers who may want to add their names to the petition can click here: petition
“I have two young granddaughters,” says Judy Werier.  “I worry about their future here.”