Features
Interview with Daniel Levin – author of international best seller “Proof of Life”, the sensational true story of the hunt for a young man gone missing in Syria in 2012

By BERNIE BELLAN A couple of months back I had the opportunity to read and review an advance copy of a terrific new book titled “Proof of Life”, by Daniel Levin.
In it Levin tells the true story of a task he was given to try and find out what happened to a young man who disappeared in Syria during the early stages of what turned out to be a protracted struggle between the regime of Bashar Assad and the many different groups that emerged determined to fight him.
By now we know how incredibly vicious that fighting became – with all sides committing atrocities that shocked much of the world. Yet, despite the tremendous dangers he knew he would face in accepting his assignment, Levin was able to navigate some of the murkiest corners of the Middle East in pursuit of his goal.
Levin’s book was so completely riveting – and disturbing in many aspects, that when I was offered the opportunity to interview Levin himself, I immediately accepted. It took some time, however, to find a time where Daniel Levin could sit down and talk with me over the phone – about his life and his endlessly fascinating career which has involved his working in some of the world’s most dangerous areas.
Finally, on June 4, Levin was available – for what I originally thought was only going to be about 20 minutes, but when he told me that he actually had 45 minutes to spare, I took advantage to delve as much as I could into how he came to be doing what he does. I spoke with Levin, who was in his home somewhere in New York.
Levin’s early years took him all over the world
I had thought that what might follow would be a give and take, but in reality Levin operates in such a different world that would be so unfamiliar to most of us that he spent a good deal of his time explaining just what it is that he does. I began by saying to him: “Your background was as sort of as a negotiator – you were working to develop modes of democracy in states that had authoritarian-led governments. Is that correct?”
Rather than answer that question in a brief manner, however, Levin entered into a long and fairly complex explanation of what he does and how he ended up in the world of hostage negotiation, which is a byproduct of his primary work.
He began by informing me that he had read my review of his book, which, he said, was quite good, except that I had made one mistake. I had written that Levin was a “Swiss-born Jew”.
“I was actually Israeli-born,” he clarified – “in 1963. My father was an early founder generation – served in the Palmach, ended up going into politics, was close to Ben Gurion, became a diplomat, and in the mid-60s he was posted to Kenya – where my sister was born.
“We were there during the Six-Day War and after he returned – in 1969, his views diverged from those of his colleagues in the Labor Party. He favoured a negotiation with the Palestinians immediately – despite the Khartoum Resolution (which became famous for the “three nos: no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, no negotiations with Israel”), had a big clash with most of them, and decided to leave for a few years. And because my mother was from the Italian part of Switzerland, we moved to Switzerland in 1970. That’s how the Swiss angle started.
“We lived there for most of my school years – elementary and high school. After high school I came to the US, where I went to Yeshiva, also studied martial arts. I went back to Switzerland, went to law school, moved back to Israel in 1988, both to do my military service, also because I was working on my doctorate in law and my thesis was about clashes between religious and secular legal systems.
“I came to the States in 1992 – I’m basically anchored here since.
“The reason that I’m telling you all this is that my most of my work as a lawyer involved conflicts between different legal, religious, and political systems and how they can be reconciled.
“As an example, if you have a Jewish divorce that a secular judge has to evaluate for compliance with secular constitutional norms – does he just go into his American law – or his Swiss law or his French law, or does he look at the Jewish law and see whether it might provide suitable alternate solutions that would be more compliant with his secular law principles?
“That was my initial background and when I came to the States in the early 90s I did a post doctorate at Columbia, then ended up working in a large law firm, and most of our work was in developing countries, trying to develop their new financial markets and judicial systems. I did that for a few years until I decided I wasn’t interested in doing just the transactional part and I started my own law firm with some partners with the idea of initially helping countries – in Africa, South America, in the Middle East, help them emerge from poverty and high debt levels, and try to develop new political and economic structures.
“That was in the 90s. We developed essentially a development platform – at its core a non-World Bank approach. We didn’t just fly in experts and tell them what to do, but rather we developed a kind of knowledge platform – like a library, and we would provide that platform as a tool to local talent, to young professionals on the ground, and we would work with them to develop their own solutions.
Contacted by the Prince of Liechtenstein to help start a foundation
“That was the origin of our work and, around 2006 I was contacted by a head of state – a monarch in Europe, the Prince of Liechtenstein, who said ‘I really like your approach to development. What I’d like to do is start a not-for-profit foundation and you’ll use your methodology as a way to work in failed states, conflict zones, war torn areas, to help rebuild them by helping with the next generation of leaders to develop solutions that might work – so that, for example, if you go to a country like Yemen, which has been shattered by civil war and by tribalism – 187 tribes, can we figure out different political systems, different constitutional systems – rotation governments for example – not what you have in Israel right now, but rotations among tribes, and can those solutions work?’ ”
Levin continued: “We develop platform tools for training of next-generation leaders. We work with partners in the different regions. For Yemen, for example, we’re working with a partnership in Abu Dhabi. In Libya we’re working with a very high quality individual to develop a think tank outside of Libya, where we’re training young Libyans to take future leadership positions in the country.
“It’s not as if we’re coming into countries and telling people what their countries should look like. Our goal is to use our knowledge platform and our tools to help teams on the ground to develop their country based on their own preferences and traditions, but with the benefit of best practices from other countries and regions.”
Levin went on to describe the often painfully slow steps required in trying to develop democratic institutions within countries that have not had any sort of tradition of democracy. He said that his foundation tries to find young, uncorrupted individuals – not the sons and daughters of ruling elites, he emphasized – and teach them about such things as constitutions and a judicial system that will remain uncorrupted.
I wondered whether it was even possible to find – and train, young individuals, inside the countries themselves where Levin’s foundation might be attempting to develop basic democratic norms.
He admitted that, in many cases, it involves having to take individuals outside of their countries for training. “But,” he cautioned, “there is no way to replace the presence in the country itself. There is no way, for example, to avoid having to go to Syria in those early years and interact with people there.”
Levin added though, that the goal, “at some point, is to take the core team that you’re working with out of the country – and take them for further training, in the Syrian case – to Lebanon, because it’s just not safe for your own staff and for the individuals who you’re wanting to train to leave them there.”

As much as one may harbour notions of glamorous international diplomacy – jetting into world hot spots – such as how American diplomat Richard Holbrooke was famous for doing, Levin said, he wanted to make sure to dispel any idea that what he and his small team do is anything except very hard work – often leading to total disappointment.
With that in mind, Levin launched into a more detailed explanation how he became involved in what was, at the time, a civil war in Syria between the Assad regime and a large number of factions opposed to that regime.
“That became the beginning of my work and, since the Arab Spring (which began in 2011), we’ve been so heavily involved in war zones – in Syria, for example, which is the basis of the book, that we were involved not just in developing these solutions, but in mediating between the war sides. This was early in the war – when it wasn’t clear how the war was going to end or that the regime would end up with the upper hand following the Russian intervention in 2015.
How Levin became a hostage negotiator in Syria
“It was in that context that I was approached by various families (including of the young man who went missing in Syria), who said: ‘You’re active in Syria, you’re active in Libya, can you help us find our missing son, our missing husband? That was the entry into the world of hostage negotiations.”
At that point I said to Levin that I was glad he provided context for how he ended up involved in trying to find out what happened to one young man in particular in Syria. I said to him that anyone who would read “Proof of Life” would find themselves plunged right into the harrowing tale of Levin being immersed in a very dangerous pursuit of information – without knowing all that much about Levin himself. In fact, I said to him, if he hadn’t made clear at the outset of the book that what the reader was about to read was all true, I’m sure that a great many readers would think that it’s a work of fiction.
I said to Levin that “the next question that would probably come to mind to any Jewish reader, for sure, and probably almost anyone for that matter, is how does a Jew – and you didn’t pretend to be anything other, gain entrée into all these countries where one would think a Jew – never mind an Israeli, would not exactly be received with open arms. Was it a problem at all?”
Never hid the fact he was a Jews – although he didn’t advertise his being Israeli-born
Levin responded: “There are a number of elements to that. First of all I never have hidden the fact that I’m Jewish; I did not advertise the fact that I’m Israeli. I have multiple citizenships, but I am Israeli-born. Israeli was my first one (citizenship) and the one I’m most attached to. I view myself as Israeli; I served in the army there, my father served in the army there; I was in combat multiple times. I didn’t advertise that and that is why I am very careful how I describe myself in the book.
“I do show how I recorded and documented everything in the book, but I didn’t want the book to be too much about myself. I am the protagonist in this, but I really wanted to tell the story of this war economy (in Syria) and some of its victims (some girls who were forced into prostitution in Dubai became subjects of Levin’s interest during the course of his investigation).
“As to my own background and my ‘Israeliness’, it shines through – and some of the things that I did in the army were tools that I needed to navigate these 20 days (Levin spent in pursuit of his goal) and some other scenarios.
Levin answered: “I never hide my Israeliness; I just don’t advertise it. If someone asked me I wouldn’t lie about it. Anything I’m telling you now – unless I say something is off the record, you can go ahead and write about.”
As for how Levin recorded actual conversations (which are often quoted verbatim in the book – and some of them are extremely frightening as he is able to get certain characters to open up about some terrifying incidents in which they have been involved, including murder) – “The way I recorded (conversations),” Levin explained, “was primarily with my phone. I created a short cut to my home screen. I didn’t have to open my phone; I just had to tap a button and start recording, and I had a separate recording device.
“Whenever I was able to record a conversation, I did that. There were several situations in which I was unable to do that – especially the night in Beirut where I had to surrender all my electronic devices. In those cases, I would take notes whenever I could and I’m careful in the book to indicate when I’m writing down from memory, also when the memory of others was different from the way I remembered moments, so that I try to be as honest as I can.
Levin said he “wanted to add (in response to my question how Levin was able to navigate some of the murkiest areas of the world in the Middle East) that I had lived in Africa as a kid, and one of the languages I learned was Swahili – and Swahili has a very strong Arabic base. It later helped me when I learned Arabic, much, much later in my professional career. So, part of the answer to your question is I was able to blend in, rather than stand out as Jewish or Israeli.”
I wanted to switch tacks from talking about “Proof of Life” to Levin’s experience as a negotiator in other venues. “Have you been asked by various governments to get involved in behind the scenes negotiations at other times?” I wondered.
“Yes – there are two angles to this. Usually – in the case of hostages, I get approached by families and then I coordinate with governments if it’s relevant – with the intelligence community or diplomats, but generally I get approached by families because they’re not getting anywhere with their home governments.
“With respect to mediation between the sides in the Middle East (and it’s usually the Middle East where Levin gets involved, he noted) it’s on our foundation’s platform either to mediate a conflict or to provide what I call a ‘Track 3 diplomacy’ channel, which is a very informal – with full plausible deniability, communication channel, so that the sides that might not otherwise be talking – and there are several of those in the Middle East, as you can imagine, have a way to communicate – not so much to sign some sort of peace agreement – that’s an illusion, but just, for example, to prevent unintended escalations.
“Very often Israel is one side of this equation – and an action gets misinterpreted as an intended act of aggression, and there’s a real need to have indirect conversation and make sure that it doesn’t trigger consequences. It’s something that I get very involved in as part of my daily work.”
I asked: “Given that, is there anything you’d like to say about the recent war between Israel and Hamas? If you had been involved, was there some sort of expertise that you might have been able to offer that could have prevented that war?”
“The short answer to your question,” Levin offered, “is no.
“I’ve been involved in escalations both between Israel and Palestinians and countries surrounding Israel. The issue in all the clashes between Israel and Hamas – as well as Israel in Lebanon, is: ‘Are you trying to mediate this for the sake of finding a solution or are you trying simply to mitigate the suffering or are you merely going through the motions based on your own particular identity – even if you look at the recent clash and, even if you try to avoid the particular tribal or political affiliation – Jewish, not Jewish, conservative, progressive – those types of discussions tend to be tedious and unproductive, because once people have identified who they are, their positions tend to flow from there without much flexibility or room for negotiation.
“My job is different because, in the case of Israel and Hamas, these types of escalations have clear political benefits for very specific individuals or parties. If you take the recent one, it’s very clear that Netanyahu’s political fortunes had reached an end…and obviously with this most recent case, it started with a very clear provocation by right wing Israeli groups in Sheikh Jarrah. If you want to start into a discussion about who’s been in the Middle East longer – 3,000 years, 5,000 years – I’m not interested in that.
“What I’m interested in is that people are suffering in the region and you have to make a decision whether you’re working toward a political solution or not. This particular escalation benefited Netanyahu – at least very temporarily, and it benefited Hamas. Hamas itself was starting to lose control over the street in Gaza. I’ve been to Gaza many times and Gaza today is not Gaza of 20 years ago – before Israel pulled out – in 2005. It’s also not Gaza of ten years ago.
Youth in Gaza feel oppressed by Hamas
“In Gaza today you have a youth fighting battles that were born after those conflicts of 20-25 years ago and they don’t feel the same allegiance to Hamas; they feel oppressed by Hamas. Hamas is starting to lose some of its authority and needs to resort to more and more oppression to stay in power. They had an interest in this escalation because they can present themselves as the protector of Al Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem and responding to the provocation of Israeli policemen and soldiers with boots in the mosque. Those kinds of games and provocations have been going on for decades. There’s really nothing for me to do because no one is really trying to find a solution, through mediation or by other means – yes, there’s mediation for a cease-fire, but you’re never getting at the root of the conflict. I want to get involved when there’s a genuine desire to go beyond just repeating the same mistakes.”
I wanted to return to Levin’s experience in Syria, which, after all, led him to write “Proof of Life”. I asked him whether his involvement in mediating between various sides – both pro-regime and anti-regime, would also have led him to get involved with “Islamist groups” as well?
He answered: “No, not at the time. If you look at the timeline of the war in Syria, you have the uprising starting in 2011 – and it’s really starting over an increase in bread and food prices. And, instead of responding intelligently, they (the Assad regime) responded brutally – like many countries in the Arab Spring they started to slaughter children – 15-year-old boys spraying on a wall ‘We want cheaper food’ would be beaten to death in a police van, and that triggered huge uprisings and an insurgency started in September 2011.
“My involvement was primarily in 2012-13 in a mediating capacity. It was when the UN was trying to negotiate a cease-fire. It was before the rise of the Islamists in 2014, which also led to those gruesome executions of American and other Western hostages. It was also before the Russian intervention in September 2015, which completely tipped the war in favour of the regime.”
Levin also reminded me that there were no Islamist insurgents in 2011 in Syria, although Assad did release thousands of Islamists from prison at the very beginning of the insurgency – exactly the same way Saddam Hussein did during the American invasion of Iraq – and those released prisoners became the core of ISIS.
“At the point that we were involved, it was to see if we could deescalate the violence; the regime was not gaining the upper hand, the opposition was organized under the Free Syrian Army, and there were – within each camp, really genuine requests to see if there was a way that we could end this slaughter.
“When the whole thing collapsed – in 2014 and 15, we aborted our project there and stopped any form of mediation because the regime was no longer interested in a peaceful, negotiated solution. But I still remained involved in several matters in Syria, including the searches for missing persons and hostages.”
Levin’s current focus is on Libya and Yemen
I asked: “You say you’ve been involved in countries in Africa and the Middle East that could be described either as failed states or states attempting to emerge from authoritarian rule. Are there any other countries in which you’ve been involved?”
Levin said: “Yes, certainly in a development capacity, in Central America, Southeast Asia – Malaysia, Indonesia, but in terms of real conflict negotiation in the sense that I’ve been describing (during this conversation), it’s been primarily in north Africa, the Middle East, and the Gulf – from Yemen to Libya, even some aspects of the Iran conflict.”
“Libya and Yemen?” I said. “Those can best be described as failed states run by gangs and warlords. Is there anything you can offer as a ray of hope for the futures of those two countries?”
“Yes, I think so,” Levin replied. “Our foundation is actively involved in both those countries. In Libya, there is some hope – not so much because of the current temporary prime minister – (whose name is Dbeibeh), but rather because there is a weakening of the warlords, particularly the warlord in the east of the country, whose name is Khalifa Haftar, who is supported primarily by Egypt and the United Arab Emirates, and Russia. There is some form of reconciliation there, also encouraged and supported by European countries which finally recognized that the only way to stem the flow of African refugees coming to Europe through Libya was to have some form of stability in Libya.
“Yemen,” Levin observed, “is a very tribal society – some 187 different tribes – very fragmented, fragmented religiously between Sunni and Shia – fragmented between south and north. Yemen has been in a tenuous state since the 50s and every outside party that has tried to get involved in Yemen has failed. It’s sort of the Arab Vietnam. It’s a very complicated place to try to turn into a functioning state.
“There are very legitimate questions – and we’re working with groups, trying to figure out whether Yemen should be one nation or should it be a confederation of states or even tribes? Yemen was also a terrible mistake by the Saudi Crown Prince who thought he could prove his manhood with a quick win in Yemen and didn’t realize he would face the same fate as Nasser did 65-70 years ago (when Egypt’s then President Nasser also intervened in Yemen).
“So, Yemen is in far worse shape than Libya, I would say in answer to your question.”
As much as reading “Proof of Life” led me to want to find out quite a bit more about Daniel Levin, talking to him about the book and his career led me to ask him whether there might be more books in the works.
He said that in September a book called “Milena’s Promises” will be released in German (“Milenas Versprechen”). “It’s a crime story, a dialogue between an Israeli woman and a young man in the U.S. in the form of an email exchange. It’s all about the question of God’s existence and omnipotence, the suffering of innocent people, and the meaning of being a “chosen” people.”
“Proof of Life”, which was released on May 18th, has garnered a myriad of sensational reviews – including my own. As a result, I can hardly wait to read “Milena’s Promises” once it comes out in English.
Features
The Enduring Forms of Jew-Hatred
By HENRY SREBRNIK “Antisemitism” and “antizionism” are not, in their essential features, forms of racism. These ideological constructs may include depictions of Jews in disparaging ways – through looks, accents, and other forms of prejudice – but they are political projects, just as anti-Judaism in the past was found (and sometimes still can be) in Christian and Muslim theology.
Both words are also misleading — few Jew-haters are concerned with “Semites” or actual “Zionists” (in the historical sense) as such. The word “Zionist” is for them, not about a political movement, ideology, or history. It is simply a metonym or synonym for “Jew.” Both words posit “the Jew” or “the Zionist” as a member of a malignant world-historical force, the antithesis and enemy of all that is good among human beings.
Neither the “Zionist” nor the “Semite” in these constructions corresponds to a real, discrete group; both are caricature figures onto whom an entire set of libels, suspicions, and eliminationist fantasies are projected. Retaining the hyphen unwittingly affirms the antizionist claim that they are engaged in a normal political dispute with an actual constituency called “Zionists,” rather than waging a hostility organized around the erasure of Jewish collective existence.
Jew-haters in the past condemned Jews as deicides, and they today consider Jews responsible for both the excesses of capitalism and the economic and social evils of Communism. The consequence is that Jews are to be hated and deemed unworthy of sympathy and solidarity. Even the facts of Jewish victimhood, whether the Holocaust or the massacres of October 7, can be portrayed as a scheme for Jews seeking some kind of dominance by “exploiting” their own past historical sufferings.
It’s an old story. In his 1882 pamphlet Auto-Emancipation, Leon Pinsker, a founder and leader of the Hibat Zion movement in tsarist Russia, observed: “To the living the Jew is a corpse, to the native a foreigner, to the homesteader a vagrant, to the proprietary a beggar, to the poor an exploiter and a millionaire, to the patriot a man without a country, for all a hated rival.”
Today’s “antizionism” has nothing to do with the “anti-Zionism” that existed within the political debates in the Jewish world earlier in the 19th and 20th centuries, mainly prior to 1948. These remained internal Jewish arguments about the future of Jewish life. Jewish anti-Zionists still understood Jews as a people with shared history, continuity, and collective identity. What they did not do was portray Jewish self-determination as inherently racist or fundamentally illegitimate, nor frame Zionism as a global conspiracy threatening humanity itself.
There is little direct link between the various actual anti-Zionist programs that existed within the Jewish world before the establishment of the state of Israel in 1948 and contemporary antizionism, like that of the Jewish Voices for Peace or Students for Justice in Palestine. They gain credibility and authenticity if people are led to believe they have inherited the mantle of those who opposed the establishment of a Jewish state seventy-five or a hundred years ago. Efforts to eliminate an actual state with millions of Jewish citizens bear no relationship, especially post-Holocaust, with earlier arguments that assimilation into European societies working classes represented a solution preferable to Jewish statehood.
That confusion even exists among leftist pro-Palestinian Jews, some of whom now have rediscovered the Jewish Labour Bund. They relate to, and are seen by Jew-haters, the way a Jew who converted to Christianity, Islam, or Communism was treated in previous eras.
Yes, many Orthodox Jews traditionally opposed Zionism on theological grounds, but that belief lost its persuasive power with the Holocaust and the establishment of Israel. There remain remnants of Jewish groups opposed to Israel’s existence, notably the Haredi Satmar Jews, who believe only the Messiah can found a Jewish state, but they are not Jews who hate or wish to harm other Jews. Even in Israel, there are genuine, religious ultra-Orthodox rabbis opposed. Rabbi Dov Lando, an influential figure in the United Torah Judaism party, recently contended that Zionism “made Arabs hate us” and Arab rule would have been preferable to the establishment of the state. This is genuine, Jewish anti-Zionism, not “antizionism.”
Modern antizionism did not emerge organically from moral reflection. It is the inheritance of an ideological campaign that replaced the word Jew with Zionist while leaving every underlying accusation intact. The language of conspiracy, domination, blood guilt, and moral corruption was simply updated.
Antizionist ideology treats Jewish peoplehood and sovereignty as an intrinsic injustice. It is today’s evolved form of anti-Jewish hate, less crude than classical antisemitism, but no less potent. Defined by its practice rather than by any claims it makes about “Zionism,” antizionism involves a now-familiar behavioural repertoire: encampments and other occupations of university spaces, boycotts of Israeli scholars and artists, masked harassment of Jewish students, defacement and destruction of Jewish property, disruption of performances by Jewish musicians, and so forth. Like other movements, antizionism at the extreme finds expression in political violence.
In universities, workplaces, and public culture, many Jews now find that their relationship to Israel has become a moral lens through which their broader ethical character is interpreted. Statements are no longer heard merely as judgments about a distant conflict, but as disclosures of one’s deeper moral orientation.
“These are behaviours,” contends Shaul Kelner, a professor of Jewish studies and sociology at Vanderbilt University, in his article on “American Antizionism” published in the Fall/Winter 2025 issue of Sources: A Journal of Jewish Ideas, “by which antizionists construct themselves as a moral community in contradistinction to a polluting Other. (A polluting Other that, we need not add, just happens to be Jewish.)”
Because antizionist politics have taken root mainly among the intelligentsia, such as professors, university students, journalists, and artists, many people assume that antizionism is a reasoned intellectual position, more rational than emotional. This certainly serves the interests of antizionism’s proponents, but “antizionism” is actually a conspiracy theory about Jewish world power corrupting and subduing the nations and peoples of the world. Political “Jew-hatred,” to use the more correct term, is a political project, one needed to defeat a “world Jewry” in power in, among other places, the United States. It is not simple “racism,” as it ascribes to Jews almost demonic powers virtually across the globe, and not just confined to the actions of an Israel that is uniquely evil, precisely because it is Jewish.
Soviet “Zionology” as early as the 1960s was expressed in this way, and if one simply substituted “Zionist” for “Jew,” it was an almost exact replica of similar Nazi terminology. Remember what Israeli historian Saul Friedlander wrote in his 2007 book The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939–1945: The Nazis regarded Jews “as an active threat, for all of Aryan humanity in the long run, and in the immediate future for a Reich embroiled in a world war. Thus the Jews had to be exterminated before they could harm ‘Fortress Europe’ from within or join forces with the enemy coalition they had themselves set against the Reich.”
Thus, as Naya Lekht, who teaches the history of anti-Jewish movements, explains in “Where the Soviets Won,” Fathom, Sept. 13, 2026, the Jew-hater does not hate Jews in a racist way. “The antisemite is not so much contemptuous of the inferior Jews as he is afraid and resentful of them. In the antisemitic imagination, the Jew is not subhuman but superhuman, possessed of an almost supernatural capacity to infiltrate, manipulate, transform, and corrupt.” Antizionism is a lot more than ideological opposition to a Jewish state. It is the continuation of an ancient project centred on producing Jewish villains. The threat is that the Jew will get inside your institutions, your culture, your bloodline, and make you into something you are not.
When the USSR was rabidly “anti-Zionist” and an enemy of the Jewish state, few people in western countries denied it was antisemitism. In 1975 the Soviet bloc and Arab states passed the notorious “Zionism is Racism” motion in the United Nations General Assembly. It too had little traction in North American political circles. The U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, in a stirring speech eloquently defended Israel. What would he make of the direction the Democratic Party is taking now? Today, when university professors and politicians, including a newly elected Michigan senator and a New York mayor, use the same language, it is suddenly “kosher,” and Jew-haters get a pass when they scream about Israeli “apartheid” and “genocide.”
“The anti-Zionist is not genuinely concerned with Zionism or Israel as they exist,” continues Lekht. “Rather, the Jewish state is distorted and mythologized into a 21st-century bogeyman, a repository for society’s fears, grievances, and moral anxieties.”
At its core, asserts filmmaker and podcaster Lucy Tabrizi, in “The Return of the ‘Good Jew,’” Notes from the Ruins, January 24, 2026, “Jewish anti-Zionism demands something extraordinary — that Jews uniquely surrender not merely a state, but their historical memory, their collective identity, and their right to self-defence, all in exchange for the promise of moral approval from cultures that have never protected them.”
Dave Rich, an Associate Research Fellow at the Pears Institute for the Study of Anti-Semitism, who writes extensively about the intersection of anti-Israel activism, far-left politics, and modern antisemitism, puts it plainly, in “From Be’eri to Bondi: Global Antisemitism After October 7,” Fathom, October 2026:
“But what is anti-Zionism for, exactly? If we strip away the political sloganeering and academic ambiguities, it is a plot to kill a nation. That’s it. Anti-Zionism is a campaign, across decades and continents, to kill the nation of Israel, erase its name and its national identity from history, and replace it with something non-Jewish. Whether this campaign is pursued through ballistic missiles and suicide bombers, seminars and journals, or street protests and placards, that is its goal.” In 1939 the Anglo-Jewish writer Simon Blemfeld published the novel They Won’t Let You Live. Are we there again?
Eliyahu Stern, professor of Modern Jewish Intellectual and Cultural History at Yale University, in a September 15, 2026 article in the online journal ARC:Religion, Politics, Et Cetera, reviewed two recently published “antizionist” books. The title of his critique? “Destroy Israel, Repair the World.” That sums their contents up perfectly.
Think about it: Since October 7, 2023 Israel has done what every other country viciously attacked by implacable enemies throughout history has done: It has lashed back in a defensive war. Yet it’s become what some call the “omnicause.” That’s why antisemitism and antizionism are two sides of the same coin: hatred of Jews. Jews aren’t being attacked because of Israel. Israel is being condemned because it is Jewish.
Henry Srebrnik is a professor emeritus of political science at the University of Prince Edward Island.
Features
Israel has a lot riding on Nvidia, whose CEO resigned today
This story was originally published in the Forward. Click here to get the Forward’s free email newsletters delivered to your inbox.
Jensen Huang, who co-founded Nvidia and has run it for 33 years, resigned as chief executive on Thursday, ending a tenure that turned a maker of video-game chips into the engine of the artificial intelligence boom. The decision followed revelations of an affair with a businesswoman whom U.S. intelligence officials suspect of being a Chinese spy, and allegations of a second relationship, with an executive who reports to him.
Colette Kress, Nvidia’s chief financial officer, will serve as interim chief executive while the board searches for a permanent successor.
The turmoil is a Silicon Valley story with a significant Israeli subplot. Nvidia employs roughly 6,000 people in Israel, including on 18 floors of office space in a Tel Aviv skyscraper. Israel is home to the company’s largest R&D hub outside of the U.S. As well, Huang has been the driving force behind a plan to build a giant new campus in the country’s north. Huang has courted Israel for years, and the open question now is what happens to that commitment without him.
Nvidia’s Israeli business traces back to 2019, when it agreed to buy Mellanox, an Israeli chip company, for $6.9 billion. Mellanox made the technology that lets thousands of chips in a data center work together as one machine. That technology is now central to how AI data centers are built.
Huang kept Mellanox in Israel, along with its patents and its sales. The Israeli teams’ work is now woven into Nvidia’s newest products, and includes building a chip meant to rein in AI tools that act on their own.
In the second quarter of 2026 alone, Nvidia’s Israeli operation booked $17.5 billion in sales, nearly a fifth of the company’s worldwide revenue and more than four times the sales of Teva Pharmaceuticals, the multinational Israeli drugmaker. Analysts credit Nvidia with largely driving a 13% jump in Israeli tax revenue, and its workforce there has roughly doubled since Oct. 7, 2023.
A personal stake
Huang’s attachment to Israel is not purely commercial. On Oct. 7, Avinatan Or, a chip engineer at Nvidia’s Israeli operation, was captured at the Nova music festival along with his then-girlfriend, Noa Argamani, in a video seen around the world. She was rescued eight months later. Or remained a hostage for 738 days.
Nvidia colleagues held vigils with his mother, Ditza, and Huang stayed in touch with the family throughout. When Or was freed in Oct. 2025, Huang wrote to employees that “Avinatan has come home.” Huang later hosted Or and Argamani at the company’s headquarters in California. This March, as the war with Iran broke out, Huang told Israeli employees that he was “very worried” about them.
Huang has called Israel a “second home” for Nvidia.
That attachment is intended to last. In December, Nvidia announced plans for a campus in Kiryat Tivon, near Haifa, reportedly second in size only to its Silicon Valley headquarters. Construction is set to begin next year, and the offices are expected to open by 2031, with room for up to 10,000 employees.
What lies ahead
The next CEO has become a question in Israel, too. Kress, 59, has been Nvidia’s finance chief since 2013. The board says it will look both inside and outside the company for a permanent chief executive.
Haaretz speculated Thursday that two Israeli executives could be potential candidates. Both men studied at the Technion in Haifa. Michael Kagan, who was born in St. Petersburg, Russia and moved to Israel with his family after high school, co-founded Mellanox in 1999 and has been Nvidia’s chief technology officer for six years. Johny Srouji, born in Haifa to an Arab Christian family, joined Apple in 2008 and now leads its hardware work, including the chips inside its products.
Nothing so far suggests Nvidia’s plans in Israel will change. The Israeli teams work on products the company depends on, and the new campus has long been in the works.
Nvidia’s stock has fallen by about a third since early October, a loss of more than $1.5 trillion in market value, and the company is due to report earnings on Nov. 17. The numbers will matter in Israel. So will something they can’t show: whether Nvidia’s affection for the country outlasts its last CEO.
This story was originally published on the Forward.
Features
Always There
By MARTIN ZEILIG My first memory of attending a sporting event with my father is not of a goal, a touchdown, or a home run.
It is of a hot chocolate.
I could not have been more than six or seven years old. More than seventy years have passed, and most of the details are gone. I do not remember who the Winnipeg Warriors were playing. I do not remember the score. I do not remember who won.
What I remember is standing on the upper level of the old Winnipeg Arena holding a hot chocolate my father had bought for me at the refreshment stand.
The ice glowed beneath the lights. The crowd buzzed with anticipation. Across the arena I spotted the organist playing during a break in the action.
Why do I remember that?
I have no idea.
Of all the games my father and I would attend together, of all the famous athletes and exciting moments, it is that simple scene that survives. A little boy. A cup of hot chocolate. An organist. A father nearby.
Memory is a strange thing.
My father, Morrey Zeilig (1912-1998), was not famous.
He was a veteran of the Canadian Army who served in Europe during the Second World War with the First Line of Communication. Before entering real estate, he worked with his father at a produce stand in Winnipeg’s old North End Market. Later, he spent many years as a real estate salesman with Black & Armstrong.
He was emotional, but not excessively so. He wore his heart on his sleeve when something truly moved him. He loved people. He loved sports. And when circumstances warranted it, he could swear with the best of them.
Looking back now, I realize that many of the things I learned about life came from him.
Sports simply happened to be one of the classrooms.
That evening at the Arena was only the beginning.
For decades afterward, sports became one of the ways my father and I spent time together. The games gave us somewhere to go. The teams gave us something to talk about. The events marked the passage of time in our lives.
One season blended into another.
One team replaced another.
One memory led to the next.
One of our regular destinations was the old Winnipeg Arena, where we watched the Winnipeg Maroons.
For many younger readers, the Maroons will be little more than a forgotten name. Yet in the 1950s and early 1960s they were one of the premier senior hockey teams in Canada and an important part of Winnipeg’s sporting life.
My father and I attended countless Maroons games.
The old Arena had a character all its own. The seats were hard. The building was intimate. Fans sat close to the action. Cigarette and cigar smoke often drifted through the stands. The sounds of skates carving the ice and pucks striking the boards echoed sharply through the building.
And then there were the Arena’s legendary urinals.
Anyone who attended games there knows exactly what I mean.
Let’s simply say they belonged to another era.
The Maroons regularly played touring teams from around the world. In those days, international hockey was still something of a novelty.
Television coverage was limited and travel was expensive. Seeing foreign teams in person felt like a special event.
My father and I watched teams from Sweden, Czechoslovakia, the Soviet Union and even Japan.
For a young boy growing up in Winnipeg, the experience was eye-opening. Those countries existed mainly in atlases, newspapers and school textbooks. Suddenly their hockey players were skating before me in our city.
I did not appreciate it fully at the time, but those games gave me my first glimpse of a much larger world.
The Maroons helped spark a lifelong interest not only in sports, but in places beyond Manitoba.
International hockey eventually became an even greater attraction.
One of the most memorable events my father and I attended was the Centennial hockey tournament at the old Arena. The tournament featured Canada, the Soviet Union, Sweden, Czechoslovakia and the United States. Winnipeg was home to Canada’s national team at the time, making the event feel especially significant.
The calibre of hockey was outstanding.
What I remember most was the final game. Memory no longer serves me well enough to say with certainty whether it happened late in regulation or in overtime. What remains vivid is Canadian defenceman Carl Brewer unleashing a slapshot from the blue line that secured victory for Canada.
Nearly 10,000 fans rose as one.
The building shook.
The old Arena erupted in a deafening roar.
Even all these years later, I can still hear it.
Ironically, one of the most famous hockey games ever played in Winnipeg was one I missed. When Canada faced the Soviet Union in the 1972 Summit Series at the old Winnipeg Arena, I was travelling in Europe.
My mother, Lillian Zeilig (1913-1994), and my father attended the game, however, and later described the atmosphere inside the building. Even though I was absent, the game remains part of my family’s sporting history and part of the city’s history as well.
Then came the World Hockey Association.
To younger generations, it may be difficult to appreciate just how revolutionary the WHA seemed at the time. Suddenly the National Hockey League no longer had a monopoly on elite players. Hockey’s established order was being challenged.
And nowhere was that challenge more visible than in Winnipeg.

I was standing at Portage and Main in June 1972 when Bobby Hull signed his famous one-million-dollar contract to join the Winnipeg Jets.
Standing beside him on a makeshift stage was Jets owner Benny Hatskin, who presented Hull with the giant cheque that quickly became a symbol of the World Hockey Association’s challenge to the NHL.
Thousands gathered that day to witness what proved to be a historic moment.
In one stroke, Hull’s signing gave the WHA credibility and transformed the Jets into something more than simply another expansion franchise.
Soon enough, we were watching Hull play.
Hull’s arrival helped create the Jets’ legendary “Hot Line” with Swedish stars Anders Hedberg and Ulf Nilsson. Many hockey observers regarded the trio as one of the greatest forward lines ever assembled, whether in the WHA or the NHL.
The arrival of the Jets transformed Winnipeg sports.
My father and I attended many games during the glory years of the WHA. Every game seemed important. Every season felt like an adventure.
One evening we watched the Jets play the Houston Aeros, who featured none other than Gordie Howe and his sons, Mark and Marty.
One goal from that game remains frozen in memory.
Howe crossed the blue line and unleashed one of those powerful wrist shots for which he was famous.
The puck exploded off his stick and flew past Jets goaltender Joe Daley before he could react.
Daley never moved.
One instant the puck was on Howe’s stick. The next it was resting in the back of the net.
I can still see it today.
Another unforgettable evening came when the Jets faced the mighty Soviet national hockey team.
During the Cold War, games against Soviet teams carried significance beyond hockey. The Soviets were regarded as perhaps the finest hockey machine in the world.
On the night of January 5, 1978, the Jets prevailed at the Winnipeg Arena by a score of 5–3. The win is remembered as the first time a club team defeated the Soviet national team.
Bobby Hull scored a hat trick.
The crowd was ecstatic.
Walking out of the Arena afterward with my father felt like walking out of history.
Football provided another collection of memories.
Many afternoons and evenings were spent at Winnipeg Stadium cheering for the Blue Bombers.
My late brother, Ken Zeilig (1939-1990), often joined us.

Together we watched great Bomber players such as Kenny Ploen, Leo Lewis, Dave Ramey and Billy Cooper, while legendary coach Bud Grant patrolled the sidelines wearing a Blue Bombers cap, a headset and often carrying a clipboard.
The Bombers of that era inspired fierce loyalty, especially when they made the playoffs.
Some of my strongest football memories involve late-season games played in late October and early November when winter had already begun tightening its grip on Winnipeg.
Those games could be brutally cold.
Fans arrived wearing sweaters beneath parkas, wool socks, gloves and toques. Some brought sleeping bags and wrapped themselves in them while sitting in the stands. Others arrived armed with flasks or bottles hidden in coats, convinced that alcohol would keep them warm.
Whether it actually worked was another question.
People stamped their feet continuously in an effort to restore circulation.
Breath hung in the air.
Hands grew numb.
Nobody cared.
We were watching the Blue Bombers.
One football memory stands above all the others.
We were sitting in the end zone when Billy Cooper scored a touchdown.
As the crowd rose to its feet, Cooper looked toward our section and tossed the football into the stands.
It landed in my father’s arms.
Suddenly we owned an authentic CFL football.
Dad said, “Wait here,” and hurried to our car to retrieve a blanket. He wrapped the football immediately, worried that an official might reclaim it.
Back home I proudly carried that football around the neighbourhood. I showed it to every kid on our street.
We threw it.
We kicked it.
We dropped it repeatedly on concrete.
The football gradually became scuffed and worn.
None of that mattered.
To me, it was treasure.
My father’s love of sports extended beyond hockey, football and baseball.
He was also an avid boxing fan.
Many Friday nights were spent watching boxing from Madison Square Garden on television. Then Muhammad Ali came along and, like millions of others, we became devoted fans. Ali was more than a boxer. He was a phenomenon. Watching his fights became another shared experience between father and son.
Baseball brought its own pleasures.
My father and I attended games involving the original Winnipeg Goldeyes and later the Winnipeg Whips at the makeshift baseball field inside Winnipeg Stadium, a field better known as a practice area for the Blue Bombers.
Baseball moved at a gentler pace than hockey or football. There was time to study the players, chat between innings and simply enjoy an evening or weekend afternoon together.
One of my favourite memories occurred during an exhibition game between the Northern League All-Stars and the National League’s St. Louis Cardinals.
The Cardinals were major leaguers.
The Northern League, by contrast, was classified as Class D baseball, as low on the professional ladder as one could go.
Yet somehow the All-Stars were giving the Cardinals all they could handle.
Caught up in the excitement and possessing all the subtlety of a ten-year-old boy, I jumped from my seat and shouted toward the Cardinal dugout: “Major League or Little League?”
Whether any Cardinal player actually heard me remains doubtful.
The people sitting around us certainly did.
My father may have been a little embarrassed.
I thought I was hilarious.
Another baseball memory stands apart from all the rest.
My father and I saw Satchel Paige.
Even today, writing those words feels remarkable.
Millions of baseball fans know Paige only through photographs, statistics and stories.
We watched him pitch with a touring team at the Provencher baseball diamond in St. Boniface.
At the time I could not have appreciated the significance of what I was witnessing.
Today I do.
Baseball also connected two important moments in Winnipeg history for me.
My father and I attended baseball events during the 1967 Pan American Games. More than three decades later, I returned with friends to watch baseball during the 1999 Pan American Games, this time in the beautiful new stadium at The Forks that became home to the modern Winnipeg Goldeyes.
The venues were different.
The city had changed.
The years had certainly changed me.
Yet sitting at a ballgame still felt comfortingly familiar.
Soccer entered our sporting travels as well.
One memorable occasion took us to Alexander Park to watch Scotland’s famous Hibernian Football Club play a Winnipeg senior all-star team. I can still hear the distinct Scottish brogue of the Hibernian players shouting to each other on the pitch.
Like the Maroons games years earlier, it was another reminder that sports could connect Winnipeg to the wider world.
Then there was the summer of 1988 when my father and I joined thousands of others at the Maginot Arena in St. Boniface to watch Mike Tyson fight Michael Spinks on a giant closed-circuit screen.
By then, more than two decades had passed since we had first become captivated by Muhammad Ali. Ali had been the dominant figure of our boxing years together, the fighter who transformed Friday-night television into must-see events in our home.
Now a new generation had its own phenomenon.
Tyson was very different from Ali. Ali dazzled with speed, charisma and poetry. Tyson overwhelmed opponents with intimidation and power. Yet both men possessed that rare ability to draw people together and make even casual sports fans feel they were witnessing something extraordinary.
Today such events seem commonplace.
At the time it felt extraordinary.
Thousands gathered to share a collective sporting experience.
For a few hours strangers became neighbours.
As I looked around the Maginot Arena that night, it struck me that boxing had carried my father and me across another chapter of our lives. We had gone from watching Ali on television together to sitting among thousands of others watching Tyson. The fighters had changed. The years had passed. But the pleasure of sharing those moments with my father remained very much the same.
There were other teams too.
Other games.
Other tournaments.
Events I have forgotten entirely.
What remains is not a catalogue of scores and statistics but rather a collection of snapshots.
A walk toward a stadium.
A ticket in my hand.
The smell of cigars and popcorn.
A crowd moving through a gate.
My father pointing out a player.
A conversation during an intermission.
A drive home afterward discussing the game and listening to the inimitable Jack Wells on CJOB break down another Blue Bombers game. With his trademark belly laugh, “Cactus” Jack would invite motorists to sound their horns during one of his famous “Happy Honkers” moments.
As the years passed, many of the places we visited disappeared.
The old Arena.
Winnipeg Stadium.
Alexander Park.
Facilities that once seemed permanent now survive only in photographs and memory.
Teams folded.
Leagues vanished.
Athletes retired.
The city changed.
So did I.
Yet whenever I think about those sporting events, my father is always there.
He is catching Billy Cooper’s football.
He is cheering the Jets against the Red Army team.
He is watching Gordie Howe score another unforgettable goal.
He is cheering for Bobby Hull, Anders Hedberg and Ulf Nilsson during the glory years of the WHA.
He is buying a hot chocolate for a little boy at the Arena.
Looking back, I realize that my lifelong love of sports owes a great deal to my father. He introduced me to the games, the teams and the athletes, but more importantly he taught me how much enjoyment could be found in sharing those experiences with others.
What I understand now is something that never occurred to me as a child.
The games were important.
The famous athletes were exciting.
The victories were memorable.
But they were never the real story.
The real story was the time we spent together.
Sports simply provided the setting.
The crowds have long since gone home.
The final whistles have long since blown.
The scoreboards are dark.
But the memories remain.
A father.
A son.
A brother.
And a city seen through the games they attended together.
That is the story I remember.
And it is a story worth telling.

