Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Uncategorized

What American Jews fight about when they fight about Israel

(JTA) — Eric Alterman, born in 1960, says the view of Israel he absorbed growing up in a Jewish family in suburban Scarsdale, New York, was decidedly one-sided. 

“I went on this nerdy presidential classroom thing when I was in high school,” he recalls, “and some Christian kid from the South raised his hand and said to the rabbi, ‘I don’t get it, if the Jews could have a state, why can’t the Palestinians?’ And I was like, ‘How dare you?’”

Alterman would go on to attend Cornell University, where he wrote his honors thesis on Israel, Vietnam and neoconservatism; spend a semester abroad at Tel Aviv University; study Israeli military history while earning his master’s degree in international relations at Yale, and research a dissertation on American liberalism and the founding of Israel as a doctoral student at Stanford.

Although he frequently writes about Israel as a contributing writer at the Nation and the American Prospect, Alterman is best known for his liberal analysis of the media and U.S. politics. He’s written 11 previous books, including one on Bruce Springsteen.

Yet he never stopped thinking about the widening gap between the idealized Israel of his youth and the reality of its relations with the Palestinians, its Arab neighbors and the West. Even when Israel’s revisionist historians were uncovering evidence of massacres and forced expulsions of Palestinians during the War of Independence, and Israeli politicians and intellectuals began asking why, indeed, the Palestinians didn’t deserve a state of their own,  he saw that such discussions were considered blasphemous in most American Jewish circles.

Alterman, now a CUNY Distinguished Professor of English at Brooklyn College, explores that gap in his latest book, “We Are Not One: A History of America’s Fight Over Israel.” The book surveys U.S.-Israel relations, but with a focus on the ways defending Israel have shaped public discourse. It’s a book about arguments: within the administrations of 14 presidents, between Washington and Jerusalem, and mostly among Jews themselves. 

Earlier this month we spoke about how the pro-Isael lobby became a powerful political force, the Jewish organizations and pundits who fight to limit the range of debate over Israel, and what he thinks is the high price American Jews have paid for tying their identities so closely to Israel. 

“I try to take on shibboleths that in the past have shut down conversation and take them apart and sympathetically show the complexity of the actual situation that lies beneath — so that [criticism and disagreement] over Israel can be understood rather than whisked away by changing the subject, or what-aboutism, or by demonizing the person who is raising them,” said Alterman.

Our conversation was edited for length and clarity.

Jewish Telegraphic Agency: Let me start by congratulating you: It’s the first book about U.S.-Israel relations with a chapter named after a Bruce Springsteen album: “Working on a Dream.” 

Eric Alterman: Nobody else has caught that. But it’s not about U.S.-Israel relations. It’s the first book about the debate over Israel in the United States. There’s a million books on U.S.-Israel relations. 

So let’s define that more narrowly. The title reminds me of the United Jewish Appeal slogan over the years, “We Are One,” which was about American Jewish solidarity. So who is the “we” in your title, “We Are Not One”?

There are three or four different meanings. The “we” in this book are obviously the United States and Israel. An awful lot of people argue that the United States and Israel have identical interests in the world and that’s crazy, because Israel is this tiny little country in the Middle East and we’re a global superpower thousands of miles away. So obviously, we’re going to have differences. Number two, American Jews and Israeli Jews are very different people. They have very different life experiences. And they see things quite differently as evidenced by the political split between them. The title also refers specifically just to Americans, because we can’t even discuss most things anymore. The pro-Israel community, such as it ever was, is enormously split and it’s split in angry ways. 

Much of your book is about what happens to American Jews when the idealized portrait of Israel’s founding and its presumed blamelessness in its actions toward the Palestinians comes up against reality. In that context, tell me a little about your choice to devote a chapter to the Leon Uris novel “Exodus,” an extremely sanitized version of Israel’s founding, and the 1960 movie based on it.

The influence of “Exodus” is something I didn’t understand until I wrote the book. It’s crazy, because Leon Uris was this egomaniac who wrote kind of a shitty book and said that he wanted to add a new chapter to the Bible, and he kind of succeeded. I was born in 1960. When I was growing up in suburban New York, every single family had “Exodus” on their shelves. When the movie came out Israelis understood this. They said, “We can just shut down our public relations office now.” And from the standpoint of reality the movie is worse than the book because it has Nazis — the Arabs in the book are working with Nazism. Uris didn’t have the nerve to do that. So the book created this idealized Israel and this idea of [Palestinians as] evil, subhuman Nazis. 

What most Americans don’t understand, or choose not to understand, is that before the 1940s most Jews were anti-Zionist, or non-Zionist. This changed in the 1940s, when, as a result in part of the Holocaust, and the reaction to that, and the triumph of Zionists, they became intensely pro-Zionist, leading up to the creation of Israel. But after that, they kind of forgot about Israel. One might have given their children JNF boxes to carry on Halloween instead of UNICEF boxes, or maybe they paid to plant trees. But Israel doesn’t show up in the American Jewish Committee’s 1966 annual report until page 35 or 36, and Nathan Glazer’s 1957 book “American Judaism” says that the creation of the Jewish state has had “remarkably slight effects on the inner life of American Jewry.”

With the events of 1967, Uris’ idealized notion of Israel came together with this terrible fear of a second Holocaust, and the terror and shame and frightening nature of that combined to transform American Judaism overnight to an enormous degree.

You are referring to Israel’s lightning victory in the Six-Day War, which even non-religious Jews saw as a kind of miracle, and redemption two decades after the Holocaust. And that transformation, you argue, put defense of Israel, combined with Holocaust consciousness, at the center of Jewish identity. 

More than just the center: It basically comprised almost all of it, for many secular Jews. I quote the neoconservative Irving Kristol in the book saying in 1976 that “the Holocaust and the founding of the state of Israel” was 100% of what Judaism means. 

Which in turn led to a the tremendous pro-Israel lobbying efforts, political activism and punditry.

The budgets of American Jewish organizations overnight went from social services and liberal social justice causes to defense of Israel. And rabbis were replaced at the center of public discourse by the heads of these organizations — most of whom had no religious training or knowledge of history or Judaism. 

Joe Biden, then vice president, speaks at the AIPAC 2016 Policy Conference in Washington, DC, March 20, 2016.
(Molly Riley/AFP via Getty Images)

One distinction you repeatedly make is between what most Jews believe compared to the Jewish organizations that claim to represent them. Surveys show the rank and file is consistently more liberal on Israel and less hawkish than the big organizations — a gap that showed up markedly around the Iraq War and the Iran nuclear deal. 

Right. The big mistake that so many in the media make is that they go to the heads of these organizations who pretend to speak for American Jews when they don’t speak for American Jews. They speak for their boards and their donors. 

The shift to Jewish lobbying on behalf of Israel coincides with an era in which there is seldom daylight between what Israel wants and what the United States wants or agrees to — often to the frustration of presidents. You are critical of those who exaggerate the pro-Israel lobby’s influence — folks like Stephen Walt and John J. Mearsheimer, authors of the 2007 book “The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy” — but, at the same time, you write, referring to the Israel debate in America, about “the continued stranglehold that money, power, organizational structure, and clearly defined paths to personal career advancement continue to hold over the shape of foreign policy.” How will you respond to critics who will say your book is trafficking in the myth of Jewish power and its conspiracy-minded hold over American policy?

The short answer is, that’s why I wrote a 500-page book — basically, for two reasons: One, everything is incredibly complicated. And some of those complications are consistent with antisemitic myths, and therefore they have to be teased out and broken down in such a way that you’re telling the truth rather than portraying the myth. 

If you say things without context, they sound antisemitic. I say that yes, Jews are very powerful in the media and many use that power on or about Israel. But I think if you lay out the examples that I use, if you look at them and examine them, I don’t see how you can conclude otherwise. The people I describe often say that about themselves — how much power and influence they yield.

Secondly, I’ve always found it just about impossible to discuss Israel with anyone, because you have to share exactly the same assumptions with that person. And if you don’t, then they take it personally, or you’re an antisemite, or, at best, you’re insufficiently sensitive to how important antisemitism is. And if you describe ways in which American Jews act in ways that are consistent with antisemitic myth, it has a way of shutting down the conversation. 

Undoubtedly there’s some criticism of Israel that is motivated by antisemitism, but there’s an awful lot of reasons to be critical of Israel, particularly if you are a Palestinian or care about Palestinians. This accusation [antisemitism] has shut down the discourse and part of my hopes in demonstrating the complexities of this history is to open this up.

So let me ask about your own stake in this. Your educational background and relationship to Israel are similar in many ways to the writers and thinkers in your book who tolerate no criticism of Israel. I don’t know if you call yourself a Zionist, but you have some connection to Israel, and you’re also willing to tolerate critiques of Israel. What’s the difference between you and some of the other people who went on the same journey?

For the longest time I was comfortable with the words “liberal Zionist,” but I don’t think they have any meaning anymore. I don’t think it’s possible to be a liberal Zionist — you have to choose. Israel is the only putatively democratic country that prefers Trump to either Obama or Biden, and it’s not even close. And young Israelis are moving further in that direction and young American Jews are moving further in the opposite direction. 

So you ask me if I am a liberal Zionist. I don’t think the word “Zionist” is useful at all anymore, because Israel is a country and it’s not going anywhere. I sometimes call myself an anti-anti-Zionist, because anti-Zionism is dumb. I’m very anti-BDS. If I thought [the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement] could end occupation, I would support it, even though the idea of boycotting Jews puts a bad taste in my mouth. But the theory behind BDS apparently, and I’ve spent a lot of time on this, is that the world will force Israel to give up its identity and turn the country over to its enemies. It’s inconceivable that Israel would do that and inconceivable the United States would pressure them to do that. So BDS is entirely performative. It’s more of a political fashion statement than anything else. 

And to me, it speaks to the failure of Palestinian politics throughout history. I have a great deal of sympathy for the Palestinians and their bad politics because it’s based on two problems. One is that they have never been able to see the future very well. So they should have agreed in 1921 and 1937, or whenever they would have had the majority and they were being given a country by the British. They should have taken the lousy offer from Ehud Barak and Bill Clinton in 2000. I kind of get it because they have so many competing constituencies, and it’s impossible to satisfy all of them at the same time. I understand that. It’s hard to imagine a Palestinian politician who could say yes, and if you look at Hamas and the Palestinian Authority, in both cases, it’s hard to imagine making peace with them.

I read that in your book, and my first thought was, well, isn’t that basically just confirming what the pro-Israel right has always said — that Israel has no partner for peace? So maybe the best it can do is maintain a status quo that assures some security for Israel and a workable something for the Palestinians.

Well, number one I hold Israel significantly responsible for the conditions under which that has developed and that they can change those. And number two, that’s no excuse for the way Palestinians are treated, either in the occupation or in Israel. So yes, I agree. There’s no one to make peace with today, but there are many steps Israel could take that could vastly improve the lives of the Palestinians, both in the occupied territories and inside Israel. And there are a lot of steps they could take that could build confidence for a future that could weaken Hamas, that could strengthen the Palestinian Authority, so that one day peace would be possible. But they do the opposite.

An Israel supporter at a New York rally to tell the United Nations “no more anti-Israel documents or resolutions,” Jan. 12, 2017. (Don Emmert/AFP via Getty Images)

You talk about funding of Israel studies and Jewish studies departments as a reaction against fears of a pro-Palestinian takeover of academia. At the same time, you write how Palestinian supporters “succeeded in colonizing Middle East studies departments, student faculty organizations, and far-left political organizations.” Why does that matter in the long run if, as you also write, nothing’s really going to change American policy on Israel?

I gave a talk before the book came out at Tel Aviv University and someone asked me that question. I said, You care about these transformations for two reasons. One, you really will be all alone in the world. You’ll have the support of conservative [Evangelical] Christians who are in many respects antisemitic and are using you for their own purposes. So if you lose American Jews, you will be existentially alone in a way you’re not now and that strikes me as very unpleasant. 

I do think that the quote-unquote pro-Israel community has a stranglehold on American politics that I can’t see changing anytime soon, and I think the change in the Democratic Party [that it will turn more pro-Palestinian] is very much exaggerated by both sides for their own reasons. 

That being said, the people who are being trained now to be in the State Department and the National Security Council and the Defense Department and the think tanks and the places where the intellectual foundation of U.S. policy is made are learning something very different from what you and I learned in college. Right now, there’s no such thing as an influential Palestinian lobby in this country. There’s no pushing back. There’s no percentage for anyone opposing Israel who has a career interest in the future. That will change, and the whole shaping of the discourse will change and that will change the relationship between the United States and Israel. It’s not going to happen anytime soon, but it’s definitely going to happen. 

As Jews in this country have remained largely liberal, Israel appears to be getting more illiberal, as we’ve seen with a new government that is more right-wing than any previously. And Israel has become more of a divisive element among Jews than a unifying force. As this gap appears to be widening, do you have any real hope for changing the discourse?

No, I don’t have any hopes for that. I don’t have anything optimistic to say about Israel. I think, politically speaking, from the standpoint of American Jews, everything is going in the wrong direction. But by demonstrating just how different Israeli Jews are than American Jews, and how little Israeli Jews care what American Jews think, I do think that it presents an opportunity for American Jews to think about what it means to be an American Jew in the Diaspora. Roughly half of the Jews in the world live in the United States. And since 1967 American Jews have defined themselves vicariously through Israeli Jews and taking pride in Israel. They expressed their identities by defending Israel and attacking the media when the media didn’t defend Israel.

Meanwhile, American Jews hardly ever go to synagogue. According to Pew, 20% of American Jews regularly attend synagogue and half of them are Orthodox, who are 10% of the community. What brought me back into Judaism was studying Torah. And hardly any American Jews are ever exposed to that. 

So I think there’s an opportunity to reimagine Diaspora Jewry now that the Israel story doesn’t work, and it’s clear that it doesn’t work. Young American Jews are leaving or voting with their feet. They’re walking away. Israel-centric Judaism is in part responsible, although it’s not the whole story. Intermarriage is a big part of the story. The de-religionization of all groups is part of the story. But personally, I don’t see what a liberal American Jew would see in a Judaism that defines itself as it has for the past 50 years as defending Israel and remembering the Holocaust.

—
The post What American Jews fight about when they fight about Israel appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uncategorized

‘Zio Doctors got butthurt’: Sydney doctor leaves prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism

(JTA) — A physician at one of the busiest hospitals in Sydney, Australia, left a prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism and bullying of Jewish colleagues.

Jennifer Martinez, head of sexual assault services at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital since February 2025, reportedly departed from her role earlier this month even though she was less than halfway through a five-year minimum term.

New South Wales Health began investigating Martinez in August of 2025, after a complaint was filed with NSW Health Minister Ryan Park that June alleging “antisemitic bias” and “bullying behavior” on social media, as first reported by Sky News Australia, now rebranded as News24 Australia.

The complaint, lodged by the Australian Zionist Healthcare Alliance, expressed concern about at least 16 separate incidents, primarily on Instagram but also on other social media networks.

The writers accused her of “targeted online harassment of Jewish and pro-Israel healthcare workers,” as well as of mocking Jewish trauma and using antisemitic slurs, such as “Zio doctors” or “Zio doc flops.”

One post included in the complaint celebrates “when Zio Doctors got butthurt for [tears of joy emoji] emojiing their hysterical accusations & defamatory comments” and features the hashtags “#demons #gronk #gronkisnotajewishsluryougronk,” using an Australian derogatory slang word for a brutish moron. She also appeared to mock 600 Australian Jewish creatives whose private WhatsApp conversations about antisemitism and anti-Zionism had been leaked and whose names were published, leading to harassment.

Martinez also publicly identified herself as the individual behind her social media handle, thereby posing “a serious risk to public trust in the medical profession,” according to the complaint, shared with JTA on Monday.

About 15 months after the NSW Health investigation began, News24 reported last week that the process had concluded and that Martinez had “quietly left her position” at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. The News24 report said Martinez did not reply to requests for comment.

Sharon Stoliar, who co-founded the Australian Zionist Healthcare Alliance and filed the complaint, told JTA on Monday that she viewed Martinez’s reported departure as “too little too late, but also a victory in combating antisemitism.”

“She should not have even been given this position in the first place as she had already been quite openly posting some horrific antisemitic content online well before this appointment,” Stoliar said.

“There was either a significant failure of processes by not screening her adequately before appointment, or they did screen her and did not seem to care about her online bullying, discrimination and antisemitism,” she added.

The Sydney Local Health District, which oversees the hospital, did not reply to JTA’s request for comment. However, a district spokesperson told News24 that the department “supports a safe and healthy workplace to enable our staff to provide the highest quality of care” but would not confirm whether Martinez had been terminated.

Stoliar shared with JTA a letter she received from Rebecca Tyson, general manager of the hospital, on Nov. 3. The letter informed her “that the formal investigation has been completed” and “that the conclusions reached were reasonable.”

“As you will appreciate, the outcome of the matter is confidential,” Tyson wrote, adding that “the appropriate action has been taken.”

An email sent by JTA to Martinez’s official NSW Health address bounced back, saying that she is “unavailable and will not be monitoring this inbox.”

Martinez is listed as medical director for an Australian corporate medical and health services firm called TOTIUM, but she only appears on an older “team backup” page rather than on the current staff page. TOTIUM executives did not respond to JTA’s request for confirmation that Martinez works there.

Her Instagram account still exists but lacks any posts or followers. Her most recent social media post that is still viewable is a video on X from November 2023, in which Australian doctors call for a ceasefire in Gaza and “unimpeded humanitarian aid.”

But Stoliar’s complaint, as well as additional information she supplied to investigators at a later date, included numerous screenshots of former posts, many of which have also been shared on local broadcast networks.

Stoliar said she submitted the complaint fairly soon after Martinez’s appointment, but she felt that “it took far too long to see an outcome.” In the aftermath of the Hamas Oct. 7, 2023, attacks on Israel, Stoliar said she has witnessed the emergence of an environment in which regulators “have let antisemitism fester with no consequences.”

“This has emboldened healthcare professionals into thinking they can continue to openly share antisemitic content and discriminate Jewish colleagues,” she added.

The New South Wales Jewish Board of Deputies, the official elected body and umbrella organization for the New South Wales Jewish community, did not reply to JTA’s request for comment.

A few months after Stoliar lodged the initial complaint, Martinez spoke at an October 2025 rally in Sydney, where she characterized herself as the victim.

“Doctors and healthcare workers here in Australia are being doxxed, stalked and are having our jobs threatened. I am one of them,” Martinez said at the rally.

She made these comments after speaking on behalf of Australians who had joined a Gaza-bound flotilla that was intercepted by the Israel Defense Forces.

“They want us to be silent, to be afraid, to disappear. But we will not,” Martinez said. “Our duty is to care for life and defend human rights.”

Stoliar expressed hope on Monday that Martinez’s dismissal from her position “taught her a valuable lesson,” noting that “healthcare professionals are supposed to leave their biases at the door.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post ‘Zio Doctors got butthurt’: Sydney doctor leaves prominent position amid accusations of antisemitism appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

How one Reform synagogue became a test of religious pluralism in Jerusalem

(JTA) — Forty years ago on Simchat Torah, Eliahu Abergil, the Sephardic rabbi of Jerusalem’s Baka neighborhood, arrived at a service held by the fledgling Kol HaNeshama Reform congregation with a group of followers after learning that women were dancing with Torah scrolls alongside men. The confrontation turned physical, with some of Abergil’s followers trying to wrest the scrolls away from worshippers before police intervened.

New York-born Levi Weiman-Kelman, who was ordained at the Conservative Jewish Theological Seminary, had founded Kol HaNeshama in 1984 in his living room, with many of its early members young English-speaking immigrants settling in the neighborhood.

Four decades later, Kol HaNeshama again faced hostility, with five incidents targeting the Reform congregation over a matter of weeks, including break-ins, vandalism and harassment. Its leaders say intolerance has hardened in Israeli society and have accused political leaders of helping create the climate around the attacks, whether through inflammatory rhetoric or by failing to condemn the attacks.

But at a solidarity gathering in Kol HaNeshama’s sukkah after the latest attacks, Weiman-Kelman, also a former president of Rabbis for Human Rights, pointed to a countervailing change: the circle of people willing to stand with Kol HaNeshama had grown considerably. While in 1986 the communities that rallied around the synagogue were overwhelmingly Reform, this time, Orthodox rabbis and congregations were among those who signed letters of support and came to stand alongside a community whose theology and practices they do not necessarily share.

Kol Haneshema
A damaged window at Kol HaNeshamah synagogue in Jerusalem, September, 2026. (Courtesy of Debi Shoua Haim)

Oded Mazor, Kol HaNeshama’s current rabbi and a former rabbinical assistant to Weiman-Kelman, said some of the Orthodox communities were explicit: “We’re not Reform, we don’t think like you. But we value you, and we will defend your right to be who you are.”

“It’s no longer only our issue, as Reform Jews, to confront this violence. There’s an understanding that responsibility for a shared, pluralistic and tolerant public space belongs to all of us together,” he said.

Anti-Defamation League CEO Jonathan Greenblatt attended the first Friday services after Sukkot in a show of solidarity with the congregation. “No Jew should feel unsafe because of the way they practice Judaism,” he wrote on X.

Police arrested three minors suspected of involvement in the incidents, which included eggs thrown at worshippers on Rosh Hashanah and objects hurled through a window ahead of Yom Kippur. Nearly two months later, Mazor said the congregation had received no further update on the investigation, and police had not responded to several inquiries from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

The youths involved appeared religious but not haredi, according to congregants who interacted with them and the synagogue’s security-camera footage. Congregants also reported harassment and homophobic comments.

A large Pride flag hung on one wall of the sukkah at the solidarity event. The repeated targeting of Pride symbols has convinced Mazor that the attacks were aimed not only at the congregation’s Reform identity but also at its embrace of LGBTQ inclusion.

“They didn’t vandalize Reform prayer books, they didn’t graffiti the walls. They came to tear down a Pride flag and commit a hate crime against a Reform community and the LGBTQ community,” he said.

The crowd in the sukkah, some 200 strong at its peak, reflected a wide cross-section of Jerusalem Jewish life: men with and without kippot, and women with and without head coverings – from kippot to headscarves.

Among them were David Goodman and his wife, Amirit Rosen, the co-rabbis of Moreshet Avraham in Jerusalem’s Armon Hanatziv neighborhood, a congregation affiliated with Israel’s Masorti movement, the Israeli branch of Conservative Judaism.

“An attack on a Jew because of their Jewish identity is an attack on me,” Goodman said. “That’s true when it happens abroad, and all the more so when it happens to my neighbors in Jerusalem.”

The gathering was organized with the support of Reshut Harabim, an umbrella network bringing together more than 65 Jewish organizations and congregations working to promote pluralistic Jewish life in Jerusalem, and as part of a nationwide sukkah initiative run by Shomrim al HaBayit HaMeshutaf bringing Israelis from different religious and political backgrounds together.

Goodman said those networks help explain why the response to the attacks on Kol HaNeshama looks so different from the 1980s.

“What were once disparate communities have become a network that knows how to stand together,” he said. “There is immense power when we cooperate.”

Several Jerusalem organizations later chose Kol HaNeshama to host a memorial marking the anniversary of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin’s assassination, as a show of solidarity following the attacks, Mazor said.

Today Kol HaNeshama has about 280 member families and serves a much larger circle of worshippers, including native Israelis and immigrants who grew up Reform, Conservative and Orthodox or with no affiliation.

After the 1986 confrontation, Jerusalem Mayor Teddy Kollek helped the congregation secure a permanent home in Baka. The city leased Kol HaNeshama an abandoned stone building, which it renovated before eventually expanding into the larger complex it occupies today.

While it has deep roots in Jerusalem’s English-speaking immigrant community – and counts New York Times senior correspondent Isabel Kershner, former Israeli ambassador to Germany Jeremy Issacharoff and solar-energy entrepreneur Yossi Abramowitz among its current worshippers – Kol HaNeshama never became simply an expatriate Reform transplant.

Services are more participatory and retain more of the traditional prayer sequence than the formal, cantor-centered style historically associated with classical Reform Judaism, while also incorporating meditation, chanting and elements Mazor said might once have been considered “New Age.” The congregation has also long experimented with liturgy, including gender-diverse language for God, innovations Mazor said later spread to other congregations.

For longtime congregant Laura Zeitlin, Kol HaNeshama became a family home as much as a place of worship. Her son attended the synagogue’s preschool and later celebrated his bar mitzvah there. Zeitlin, who said she did not identify with a particular Jewish denomination while growing up in Argentina, said she was drawn to Kol HaNeshama because she could sit beside her husband and participate fully in services.

Her frustration over the recent attacks was directed not at religious difference itself but at what she saw as a lack of mutual respect. “We have respect for them, but they don’t have respect for us,” she said.

Ezra Ende, rabbi of the Reform congregation HaDror in Jerusalem’s Kiryat HaYovel neighborhood and also involved with Mevakshei Derech in Katamon, said other congregations in Jerusalem, including his own, had also faced threats.

“The reality is that there is more violence in Israel today and all liberal communities are feeling it,” he said.

Jerusalem Mayor Moshe Lion’s response to the attacks was a recurring point of contention among congregants and supporters. Lion spoke privately with Mazor before Yom Kippur and expressed support for the community, but did not publicly name Kol HaNeshama in condemning the attacks, despite calls from Union for Reform Judaism President Rick Jacobs and Gilad Kariv, a Knesset member from the Democrats party, to speak out.

“The fact that Lion didn’t come out and say anything” naming the synagogue “says everything,” Ende said.

Lion later issued a general statement condemning attacks on others’ religious practices, customs and ways of life. His office rejected suggestions that political considerations, including sensitivity to Jerusalem’s large haredi electorate, explained his reluctance to speak publicly about Kol HaNeshama by name.

A spokesperson told JTA that the city had chosen not to draw further attention to the attacks “so as not to escalate things.”

Mazor invited Lion to the Sukkot solidarity gathering, but the mayor declined, citing prior commitments.

Naama Kelman, Weiman-Kelman’s sister and a former dean of Hebrew Union College’s Jerusalem campus – where in 1992 she became the first woman ordained as a rabbi in Israel – noted that Lion had addressed students at HUC about a year earlier. But she suggested Lion may have been more comfortable appearing at HUC because it serves as an event venue as well and is not publicly identified primarily as a Reform institution.

“Lion doesn’t get it,” Kelman said. “This neighborhood is what’s going to keep the city pluralistic.”

Mazor, who was also ordained at HUC, as were his father and sister, said Kol HaNeshama was once the only egalitarian synagogue in that part of Jerusalem; today it sits among Masorti, egalitarian and partnership Orthodox congregations. Even in some mainstream Orthodox synagogues, expanded roles for women have become common, including women dancing with Torah scrolls on Simchat Torah, the practice Abergil railed against in 1986.

Mazor sees that evolution as evidence that attitudes once thought fixed can change with familiarity and exposure.

Kol HaNeshama hosts dozens of school and pre-army academy groups each year, many arriving with little knowledge of Reform Judaism and asking why a Pride flag hangs in the synagogue. “If schools create that encounter, then the conversation happens,” Mazor said. “Without those touchpoints, students will only know what extremists want to tell them about Reform Jews or LGBTQ people.”

Both Kelman and Mazor saw the attacks as part of Israel’s wider political climate, but stressed that antagonism toward Reform Judaism was nothing new. After the 1986 confrontation, then-Sephardic chief rabbi Mordechai Eliahu declared that “there is no freedom of worship in Israel” if that meant equal recognition for different Jewish denominations, while then-Religious Affairs Minister Zevulun Hammer said he supported protection for private worship but opposed “importing problems,” an apparent reference to American-style Jewish pluralism.

Still, Kelman said, “it’s gotten worse.”

The attacks on Kol HaNeshama are “a direct result of the kind of incitement that Ben-Gvir spews, hate and messianic extremist Judaism,” she said, referring to National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.

Kelman also pointed to comments by other officials mocking Reform Judaism, saying she was “terrified” by what she saw as their contribution to a growing gulf between liberal American Jews and Jewish Israelis. In May, minister May Golan attacked Kariv, a Reform rabbi, in the Knesset, accusing him of “marrying dogs in your bizarre synagogues.” Last year, Likud lawmaker Galit Distel Atbaryan told Kariv, “If you hold a bar mitzvah for a dog, I’ll come and celebrate,” before ordering “the enlightened Reform Jew” removed from a committee meeting she was chairing. The same rhetoric surfaced during one of the Yom Kippur incidents at Kol HaNeshama, when two youths who had been harassing worshippers arrived with a large dog and asked to arrange a bar mitzvah for it.

Mazor called the Oct. 27 parliamentary elections, which produced no clear governing majority and left coalition talks unresolved, critical for the “future of Israel as both a Jewish and democratic state, in which the Jewish character of the state is expressed through its democracy.”

“This is our national home, and we have to make it work,” he said.

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post How one Reform synagogue became a test of religious pluralism in Jerusalem appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

A travel vlogger with 70 million followers asks Israel’s president if backing Israel was ‘stupid or genius’

(JTA) — JERUSALEM — With people in banana suits and Marvel superhero costumes milling around the Jerusalem Theatre, the Nas Summit occasionally resembled a Comic Con for AI enthusiasts. Yet Israel advocacy proved almost as prominent at the gathering as discussions about the digital future.

Organized by Nuseir Yassin, the Arab Israeli entrepreneur behind Nas Daily, the massively successful travel vlog, the one-day conference on Nov. 11 drew about 1,000 attendees. It featured Israeli President Isaac Herzog, leading AI entrepreneurs including Mobileye founder Amnon Shashua and Mellanox founder Eyal Waldman, former hostage Omer Shem Tov, television personality Phil McGraw and content creators with a combined social media following exceeding 90 million, according to organizers’ figures.

Held in cooperation with Israel’s Foreign and Tourism ministries, the summit’s dual focus reflected Yassin’s own evolution since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack, when the Muslim entrepreneur, who grew up in the Arab town of Arraba in northern Israel, became increasingly outspoken about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Introducing Herzog as “my friend,” Yassin, based mostly in the United States, recalled the public declaration he made in the aftermath of the attack.

“I made a statement publicly saying, guys, after Oct. 7, I’m really Israeli first,” he said. “This is my home.”

Yassin, who built his following by traveling the world, said he now felt welcome in only about 20 countries because of his Israeli passport. “How do we get back to 190 countries where you don’t have to say you’re from Greece?”

He turned to Herzog, asking whether his decision to speak out three years earlier had been “stupid or genius.”

Herzog replied: “It was the right moral decision first and foremost. There’s something called moral clarity. There’s nothing greater than defending this incredible nation.”

Last month, Yassin, who has nearly 70 million followers across social media platforms, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency at an antisemitism conference in Denver that he considered anti-Zionism a form of antisemitism. Describing Zionism as “the most vanilla thing in the world – a group of people wanting a place to live,” he concluded that Israel’s detractors “just really don’t like Jews.”

Yassin’s mother, who attended the summit along with several other relatives, told JTA she was “extremely proud” of her son. His brother-in-law said a sign had recently been erected outside their hometown of Arraba announcing that Nas Daily came from there.

Yassin was also joined by his girlfriend, Aija Mayrock, a Jewish American writer and influencer who travels the world documenting far-flung Jewish communities. Moderating a discussion with her, Yassin admitted, was “the first time I’m nervous.”

Mayrock described criticism from people who argued that dating a Muslim man undermined her mission. But “the beautiful irony of this whole journey,” she told Yassin, “is that the one person to push me to do this was you.”

Israel’s Foreign ministry offered a glimpse into its own efforts to reach audiences that might otherwise ignore official government communications. Michael Freeman, until recently Israel’s ambassador to Nigeria, and Mordechai Rodgold, a former ambassador to Austria who now heads the ministry’s digital diplomacy efforts, discussed the decision to revamp an X account simply called @Israel, separate from its official ministry account, and give its posts a decidedly less diplomatic tone.

“We’ve survived empires. We can survive a comments section,” read one post that attracted more than 42 million views. Another joked, “Israel. Proof that size really doesn’t matter.” The officials acknowledged that the irreverent approach, intended to reach younger audiences, had ruffled feathers both inside and outside the ministry.

Other discussions explored Israel’s regional future, with Israeli-American content creator and activist Rudy Rochman arguing that Israelis and Palestinians must recognize that “there’s no future where either disappears. We’re obviously not going to kill each other. Both of us are staying here.” Shem Tov, the former hostage, joined Yassin and Bahraini peace activist Fatema Alharbi to consider whether Israel had fought its last war.

Herzog also spoke about prospects for regional peace, stressing the need for willing partners and for confronting what he called the “empire of evil from Tehran.” Addressing AI, he said Israel, as “the high-tech nation,” should be “in the top three” globally, citing the country’s capacity for improvisation and thinking outside the box.

Tzvi Feifel, who immigrated from Chicago three years ago, was among the co-founders of Agentic Israel, a free community of some 600 AI professionals in fields ranging from law to hospitality. He was among several attendees wearing AGNTK Israel T-shirts, stylized with Hebrew vowel marks. Feifel, who said he was “excited and optimistic” about AI,  also runs Vectis, which helps small and medium-sized businesses integrate AI.

Yassin’s expertise in content creation was one of the things that attracted Feifel to the conference. As AI floods the internet with easily generated material, he said, he is constantly trying to “stay sharp and understand best practices and what people are doing to capture attention in an age where there is so much spam and noise.”

Yitzy Hammer, a lawyer from Modi’in, came to the summit hoping to come to terms with AI and what it might mean for his profession.

“I live very much on the fence between AI doom and gloom and this is the most exciting thing that ever happened to me,” he said.

AI had already transformed legal work, and Hammer said he saw little future for junior lawyers. He called the prospect of widespread job losses leaving people dependent on universal basic income, a guaranteed government payment, “terrifying,” but said AI agents that allow him to accomplish in seconds tasks that once took days were “incredibly exciting.”

A self-described conference junkie who usually skips lectures in favor of networking, Hammer said he had unexpectedly sat through the entire morning’s presentations and came away more confident that people could adapt to the upheaval.

“I found peace here,” he said.

McGraw, the American television psychologist known as Dr. Phil, was less enthusiastic about AI’s application in his own field.

During a virtual appearance moderated by Yassin, McGraw alternated between praise for Israel, which drew enthusiastic applause, and warnings against relying on chatbots for psychological support, particularly for people experiencing suicidal thoughts.

“It’s gonna pump you sunshine and blow smoke up your ass,” he said, adding that as a therapist, “I’m not going to do that.”

For Suman BK, a Nepalese caregiver who arrived in Israel six months ago on a work visa, the technology discussions were less important than the opportunity to meet Yassin and other creators whose work he had followed for years.

“I want to learn from them what I can adopt on a daily basis,” he said. “And to see also the president of Israel.”

With tickets costing between 499 and 999 shekels, BK acknowledged that the conference was a significant expense. Other Nepalese caregivers he knew had declined to attend because of the price.

“It’s expensive but it’s once in a lifetime.”

Suman BK, left, a Nepalese caregiver living in Israel, confers with German influencer Luca Pferdmenges at an AI summit in Jerusalem, Nov. 11, 2026. (Deborah Danan)

German travel influencer Luca Pferdmenges, who completed visits to all 195 countries in 2025, offered another perspective on Israel’s appeal.

Pferdmenges, whose social media audience exceeds 3 million, told JTA that Tel Aviv was his favorite city in the world, citing its vegan food and the unusual sense of familiarity he encountered among strangers.

“To me it’s crazy that you can speak to anyone, even the guy next to you on the bus,” he said, adding that even countries renowned for their hospitality rarely matched the openness he experienced in Israel.

Wednesday’s summit marked his 17th visit to Israel since 2018.

The conference concluded with an after-party featuring Israeli band Yemen Blues, as attendees joined Yassin and the other presenters onstage to dance.

Yassin has previously spoken about eventually returning to live in Israel, although in an interview last year he said he did not expect to move back within the next decade, explaining that he wanted to establish himself as an entrepreneur before devoting more attention to regional bridge-building. Living in Israel, he said, would inevitably draw him further into the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Asked by JTA on Wednesday whether holding the summit in Israel rather than elsewhere was a deliberate choice, he replied without hesitation.

“Of course. That’s the whole point. I love it here.”

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post A travel vlogger with 70 million followers asks Israel’s president if backing Israel was ‘stupid or genius’ appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News