Uncategorized
A century before Trump targeted Somalis, Jews faced the politics of blame
(JTA) — As President Donald Trump ramped up his rhetoric against Somali immigrants in Minnesota and ordered a surge in immigration enforcement because Somalis took part in a social-service fraud scheme, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey pushed back.
“’When a fraud takes place, when a crime takes place, you investigate it, you prosecute it, you charge it. You arrest the person that did the fraud or the crime, you put him in jail as an individual,” Frey told NPR. “You get held accountable as an individual. That’s how this works in America.
“You do not, however, hold an entire community accountable for the crimes of one.”
Frey’s remarks were echoed by other state and national figures. “We do not blame the lawlessness of an individual on a whole community,” said Rep. Ilhan Omar, the Minnesota Democrat, who herself immigrated from Somalia to the United States as a child.
Frey, who is Jewish, didn’t mention his own background in standing up for Somalis, a community of whom Trump has said, “And they contribute nothing. The welfare is like 88%. They contribute nothing. I don’t want them in our country. I’ll be honest with you.”
But had Frey turned to Jewish history, he may well have cited another instance in which a powerful political figure blamed an immigrant community for the crimes of a few, and an ethnic group was targeted by nativists who pinned the country’s ills on immigrants.
Frey might have reached back to 1908, when New York City Police Commissioner Theodore A. Bingham leveled what at the time was the most explicit, highest profile accusation of Jewish criminality made by a major American official since Gen. Ulysses Grant expelled all Jews from his military district to combat allegations of cotton smuggling and corruption.
That year, in an article in the North American Review, Bingham claimed Jews accounted for half of New York’s crimes, especially picking pockets, fencing stolen goods, arson and operating gambling and vice operations.
“It is not astonishing that with a million Hebrews, mostly Russian, in the city (one quarter of its population), perhaps half of the criminals should be of that race when we consider the ignorance of the language, more particularly among men not physically fit for hard labor,” Bingham wrote with the stilted prose of a bureaucrat and the dubious authority of the then popular pseudoscience of eugenics.
Bingham buttressed his accusation with statistics: “Forty per cent of the boys at the House of Refuge and twenty per cent of those arraigned in the Children’s Court” are Jews, he claimed. “The percentage of Hebrew children in the truant schools is also higher than that of any other.”
Jewish leaders saw Bingham’s accusations as all the more dangerous because they were based on a shred of truth: “They knew, for one thing, that there was a crime problem on the East Side, not so lurid as Bingham had painted, but serious enough,” wrote Irving Howe in his history of the period, “World of Our Fathers.”
Like Somali-Americans in Minnesota, the Jews of the era were on the cusp — with one foot in the poverty of the tenements and the other in the growing prosperity of a rising working and business-owning class. But the Eastern European Jewish newcomers also had an important lever: the German Jews who had arrived earlier and established positions of power in finance and politics.
Jacob Schiff, the powerful banker and philanthropist, became one of the most forceful critics of Bingham’s article, publicly denouncing it as reckless and un-American. Joseph Seligman, founder of the investment bank J. & W. Seligman & Co., similarly condemned Bingham, insisting that crime was a function of poverty and dislocation, not religion or ethnicity, and pointing out the danger of a police commissioner racializing crime. Both men brought their own statistics and experts to show Bingham had exaggerated Jewish involvement.
The grassroots response was just as strong, with letters to the Yiddish and general newspapers, mass protests and heated sermons.
“Mr. Bingham has been indulging in mere generalities and he should be forced to give facts, including the names, residences, in fact the exact figures of any one week or month, to prove his statements, or else he will be asked to make a public retraction and apologize to the race he has injured,” fumed Rabbi Joseph A. Silverman of New York City’s Temple Emanu-El.
Bingham was, and he did. “By mid-September,” Howe writes, “under severe pressure, Bingham retracted his charges ‘frankly and without reservation.’” He subsequently lost the support of Mayor George B. McClellan Jr. and was forced to resign in July 1909.
Bingham wasn’t the only figure to hold the entire Jewish community responsible for the crimes committed by its members. Eleven years earlier, police commissioner Frank Moss argued in his book “The American Metropolis” that “criminal instincts… are so often found naturally in the Russian and Polish Jews.” Between 1907 and 1909, McClure’s Magazine published articles by the muckraking journalist George Kibbe Turner claiming extensive Jewish involvement in the “white slave trade” — what today we would call human trafficking. While courts found little evidence of a wide-spead Jewish conspiracy to traffic women, “McClure’s used the white slavery investigation and grand jury to stoke anti-immigration and anti-Semitic fears throughout the city,” historian Mia Brett wrote in a paper for the Gotham Center at CUNY.
The Jewish elite counted Bingham’s retraction as a victory, but the incident left many with the impression that the Jewish community needed a better mechanism for organizing around the fight against antisemitism. In New York, that meant the formation of the Kehillah, an ambitious experiment to create a unified Jewish communal organization. The Kehillah included educational and political committees, as well as a “Bureau of Social Morals” — a sort of self-policing body meant to help law enforcement root out crime among Jews. When it sank in that the bureau was only reinforcing an impression that the Kehillah had been formed to dispel, the bureau was scrapped.
The Kehillah lasted until 1922, when it disbanded over — spoiler alert — ideological disagreements among its constituent groups. But it created a precedent for centralized communal organizations to come, including UJA-Federation of New York.
In Minnesota too there are signs that the president’s attacks are strengthening the Somali community by sparking solidarity and organizing.“I think it’s giving us a chance for many Americans to learn about the Somali community, and not only that, but also to see the resilience,” Jaylani Hussein, executive director of the Minnesota chapter of CAIR, told CNN. “Also, it’s giving Somali Americans a chance to own their American identity and fight for it.”
When the Bingham incident is remembered, it is often to illustrate how officials trade on xenophobic fears over facts — and why such scapegoating, once unleashed, can do profound damage to both the targeted community and the civic fabric.
“We know that when a few people commit crimes, it does not implicate an entire community and to say so is racist, is xenophobic and just wrong,” Rabbi Adam Stock Spilker of Mount Zion Temple in St Paul told Fox 9 in Minneapolis last month.Meanwhile, the current police chief in Minneapolis, Brian O’Hara, has taken the very un-Bingham-like position that the “real problem” of social service fraud in the state doesn’t justify the “largely political” reaction of the federal government, especially immigration authorities.
“I had not known any Somali Americans until I moved to Minnesota,” O’Hara said Monday on “The Daily” podcast. “The Somali Americans that I have met here, including many of whom are police officers in this city, have been incredibly welcoming of me. From a personal perspective, [the immigration crackdown on Somalis] was just bizarre because I’m also aware that the overwhelming majority of people from that community are American citizens.”
The post A century before Trump targeted Somalis, Jews faced the politics of blame appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Rep. Hakeem Jeffries prioritizes settler violence as Democratic majority remains divided over Israel
Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of New York, who is set to become the next speaker of the House, said in an interview published over the weekend that he plans to advance legislation targeting violent Israeli settlers in the West Bank when the new Congressional term begins in January, offering an early indication of how he intends to manage the growing divide over Israel within the Democratic Party.
“What I have made clear is that within the first 100 days, I think the most decisive step that we can take relative to the situation in the West Bank is to move the West Bank Settler Violence Protection and Prevention Act,” Jeffries said in an interview with The New York Times published Saturday. At least 225 incidents of settler violence were documented during 2025 and part of 2026 by Israeli watchdog Yesh Din.
The bill was introduced last year by Rep. Jerry Nadler, co-chair of the Congressional Jewish Caucus, who is retiring at the end of the year. It has 174 Democratic co-sponsors. France and the U.K. are among the countries that have already imposed sanctions on violent Israeli settlers. Former President Joe Biden announced similar measures in 2024, but President Donald Trump reversed them shortly after taking office in 2025.
At the same time, Jeffries stopped short of endorsing a pair of bills to block some U.S. weapons sales to Israel, a demand of progressive Democrats. “I haven’t articulated a position one way or the other with respect to any of these bills,” Jeffries said, “because we’re going to have a conversation about the steps that we need to take together as a caucus.”
The distinction is important for Jeffries, a longtime supporter of Israel, as he’s preparing to lead a Democratic majority that is increasingly divided over Israel. His approach suggests he wants to address concerns about Israeli government policies without endorsing measures to end some U.S. military support for Israel. Many Jewish Democrats have also criticized the policies of the current right-wing Israeli government, particularly on settlement expansion and violence against Palestinians in the West Bank.
The party’s divide over Israel goes deeper
The Democratic Party’s sweeping midterm victories have given Jeffries considerable room to manage the debate over Israel without depending on the votes of its most progressive members. Jeffries was nominated Wednesday by an overwhelming majority of his Democratic colleagues to become speaker, pending a House floor vote when the new Congress convenes on Jan. 3. Only 11, including the six newly elected members affiliated with the Democratic Socialists of America, voted against.
Rep. Ro Khanna of California, a Democrat who has pushed for restrictions on military assistance to Israel, acknowledged that political reality, saying that progressives “have not succeeded in getting any commitments yet on Gaza or Israel.”
The debate is unlikely to end with one vote. Jeffries will still face pressure from a growing movement inside Congress to end all U.S. military aid to Israel, including defensive and offensive weapons sales.
On Election Day earlier this month, President Donald Trump said that the U.S. would halt roughly $4 billion in annual aid to Israel by the end of 2026. He was unclear how he would implement that, given the current memorandum of understanding between the U.S. and Israel runs through 2028.
Earlier this year, 103 of 212 Democrats supported a measure to eliminate the annual military assistance to Israel and another 10 abstained. Dozens also co-sponsored a pair of measures – the Block the Bombs Act and Ceasefire Compliance Act – that would restrict certain offensive arms sales to Israel and increase oversight of Israel’s policies in the West Bank and in Gaza. The DSA said in a post-election event that it is planning to use its growing influence to push for a full arms embargo against Israel and ultimately “break” the longstanding alliance between the U.S. and the Jewish state.
Jeffries’ long record of supporting Israel
Jeffries, 56, has consistently defended the U.S.-Israel relationship since his election to the House in 2012, even as other Democrats have become more critical of Israel’s government.
In recent weeks, progressive activists have resurfaced clips of Jeffries and Sen. Chuck Schumer expressing strong support for Israel in speeches each made to Jewish groups, arguing that the leadership is out of step with voters’ changing perspectives.
Among them: declaring, “Israel today, Israel tomorrow, Israel forever,” at a 2014 rally in support of Israel; in 2023, describing Jerusalem as New York City’s sixth borough; and, in 2025, saying that the U.S. “can’t take our foot off the gas pedal until Iran is brought to its knees.”
In the Times interview, Jeffries said the suffering of Palestinian civilians in Gaza was “unacceptable, unsustainable and un-American.” He also said the early moves made by the incoming Congress will make a two-state solution more viable. In a new memoir published last week, Biden warned Israelis they may not be able to count on the same level of support from future American leaders if the status quo continues. “I hope Israel wakes up,” he writes. “The days of American leaders like me — passionate defenders of Israel to the core — are passing.”
Even if the House passes the settler sanctions bill, it could face a Republican filibuster in the Senate or a veto from Trump.
For now, Jeffries has the votes and the political standing to set the agenda on settler violence, but without making major concessions to the Democratic Party’s most outspoken Israel critics.
The post Rep. Hakeem Jeffries prioritizes settler violence as Democratic majority remains divided over Israel appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Mark Ruffalo opposes Schumer for Senate leader, citing “religious beliefs and loyalties”
(JTA) — Actor Mark Ruffalo, an outspoken progressive and Israel critic, cited concerns over “entrenched religious beliefs and loyalties” in endorsing U.S. Sen. Chris Van Hollen for Senate majority leader over U.S. Sen. Chuck Schumer, the current Democratic caucus leader and a Jewish lawmaker from New York.
In a Saturday post on X, Ruffalo framed his endorsement of Van Hollen – and concerns about religious beliefs and loyalty – as being more than just about Israel.
“Israel is just one issue in a whole host of reasons Van Hollen is the right leader for our times,” Ruffalo posted. “We need Justice, we need leadership that follows the will of the people not entrenched religious beliefs and loyalties.”
Israel is just one issue in a whole host of reasons Van Hollen is the right leader for our times. We need Justice , we need leadership that follows the will of the people not entrenched religious beliefs and loyalties. Does not follow entrenched fossil fuel and corporate interests, nor throws a blind eye to the hard realties we face today. Van Hollen has showed he is willing to face these difficult times with the law, with integrity and the strength and spirit to fight the social and moral corruption that has set in with age old presumptions and the comfort that comes with unchecked power over decades. We have absolutely nothing to lose by replacing Sen Schumer. We can only gain more justice and freedom. Put pressure on your senators. Now is the time. Keep the momentum of this election going. Thank you, Senator Schumer, but it’s time to move aside.
https://t.co/GkpK4YG7dF
— Mark Ruffalo (@MarkRuffalo) November 21, 2026
Schumer is the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in U.S. history and has led the Senate’s Democratic caucus since 2017, including as majority leader from 2021 until 2025. Since the midterm elections, Schumer, the pro-Israel stalwart, has faced a chorus of progressive voices who are seeking a change in the leadership of the Democratic caucus.
Three veteran senators – Vermont independent Sen. Bernie Sanders, Democratic Sens. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan and Jeff Merkley of Oregon –have endorsed Van Hollen of Maryland for majority leader. Van Hollen also has the support of two newly elected senators who will take office in January, Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota.
Van Hollen is an outspoken critic of Israel who has led efforts to investigate the country’s human rights practices and pressure its right-wing government. He has drawn blowback from some Jewish leaders in recent years over his criticism of Israel and of AIPAC, the pro-Israel lobbying group.
Schumer, who has longstanding ties to AIPAC and the pro-Israel community, has described himself as a “Shomer Yisrael” (“guardian of Israel”), noting that his surname derives from the Hebrew word shomer. Still, he has become increasingly critical of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in recent years, going so far as giving a speech from the Senate floor in 2024 calling for new elections and leadership in Israel.
Ruffalo, known for his work in “The Avengers” franchise, “Spotlight” and “The Kids Are All Right,” has been a divisive figure in the Jewish community. In an August Instagram Story, he linked Skydance CEO David Ellison, the chief driver of the then-proposed Paramount-Warner Bros. merger, to tech giant Oracle, which Ruffalo accused of powering “an apartheid system of oppression” in Gaza.
Oracle was co-founded by Ellison’s father, Larry Ellison, one of the world’s richest men; both Ellisons are Jewish and prominent Israel supporters. Oracle also owns a stake in the social media network TikTok’s U.S. operations, and has long been a target of progressives who point to the company’s links to, and public support for, Israel.
In a social media post that was reported in September to be no longer available, Ruffalo described Larry Ellison as a “classic oligarch” who is “crushing workers and consolidating the wealth of the world for their own power and concentrated dominance.”
Ruffalo drew criticism from Jewish organizations, including the Jewish Federation Los Angeles, which said the actor’s comments “combined Jewish wealth, media control, secret technology and sinister global power,” drawing on “recognizable antisemitic tropes with a long and dangerous history.”
In response to the criticism, Ruffalo denied being antisemitic or anti-Israel, and said “criticizing the actions of the Israeli prime minister, a military technology contract, or the executives who supply it is not the same as criticizing Jewish people.” He added that “my views come from my own political convictions and should never be interpreted as hostility toward Jewish people, for whom I have deep love and respect.”
Some 170 notable Jewish personalities signed an open letter supporting him.
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post Mark Ruffalo opposes Schumer for Senate leader, citing “religious beliefs and loyalties” appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
Israel does not need fake ‘unity’ with Netanyahu – it needs to move forward
For Israelis exhausted by years of political upheaval, bitter polarization and war, the appeal of national unity might seem obvious. Surely a country facing so many challenges would benefit from leaders putting aside their differences and working together.
Naftali Bennett breathed new life into this enduring hope by meeting last week with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, apparently without coordinating with his presumed opposition partners. But this revived discussion of a government that united the opposition and Netanyahu’s Likud party was short-lived. Bennett has since advocated a broad government under former IDF chief Gadi Eisenkot, with Netanyahu as a junior partner or more.
Except that Netanyahu has so dramatically upset many Israelis that the possibility of him having any role in the next government has sparked a very animated discussion.
It begs questions: What exactly is a national unity government? Why has Israel repeatedly resorted to one? And when did the understandable yearning for national solidarity become confused with the notion that elections need not produce winners and losers?
Israel’s unity governments
Unity governments are largely an Israeli invention. Germany, whose parliamentary system resembles Israel’s in important respects, has repeatedly been governed by grand coalitions between its principal center-right and center-left parties. This tends to happen when there are many splinter formations who are so radical that the centrists on either side would rather “reach across the aisle.”
Israel’s experience with unity has taken on an additional significance. Its history of war and national emergency has imbued political unity with an almost sacred quality, drawing on the deeply rooted Jewish ideal of achdut or solidarity. But an agreement between rival politicians to share power is not the same thing as national solidarity.
Israel’s first national unity government was formed on the eve of the 1967 Six-Day War, when Menachem Begin’s opposition movement joined a Labor-led administration that already enjoyed a parliamentary majority. It was an emergency arrangement rather than a political necessity.
The defining precedent came in 1984, seven years after Begin’s historic election victory ended nearly three decades of Labor dominance. Israel had developed a competitive two-bloc system, with Labor on one side and Likud, supported by right-wing and religious parties, on the other.
Unlike Americans, Israelis do not directly elect their head of government. Also unlike Americans – where a vote in Wyoming is worth many votes in California – each vote counts the same. Israelis elect a 120-member Knesset, and the decisive question is which parties can assemble a parliamentary majority. The largest individual party is not necessarily the one that governs. In 2009, for example, Kadima won more seats than Likud, but Netanyahu formed the government because he could assemble a coalition.
In 1984, the rival blocs were effectively tied, 60–60. Neither could govern independently. Labor’s Shimon Peres and Likud’s Yitzhak Shamir therefore agreed to share power, rotating the premiership after two years.
The results were remarkable. Israel withdrew from most of Lebanon, retaining a security zone in the south, and implemented an economic stabilization program that brought runaway inflation under control. Peres honored the rotation agreement in 1986.
Yet unity had its limits. In 1987, Peres reached an understanding with Jordan’s King Hussein that might have opened an important diplomatic path toward resolving the Palestinian question. Shamir blocked it. The episode demonstrated how a government capable of making difficult decisions could also prevent them.
The 1988 election produced a different situation. Likud and its right-wing and religious allies had approximately 65 seats, enough to govern without Labor. Shamir nevertheless formed another unity government, this time without rotating the premiership. It collapsed in 1990.
Later unity governments under Ariel Sharon arose amid the trauma of the Second Intifada and, subsequently, to facilitate Israel’s disengagement from Gaza.
These experiences illustrate an important distinction. Some unity governments were born of parliamentary necessity, others of national emergency, and still others of a desire to implement policies that would otherwise be politically impossible. None demonstrated that bringing opposing parties into the same cabinet was generally pratical.
The most recent experiment came in 2020, when Netanyahu and Benny Gantz agreed to rotate the premiership after three inconclusive elections. Netanyahu would serve first, followed by Gantz. But the government collapsed over the failure to pass a budget, long before Gantz’s turn arrived. Gantz’s supporters accused Netanyahu of deliberately exploiting a loophole in the agreement; Netanyahu disputed responsibility.
The contrast with 1986, when Peres honored his commitment to Shamir, helps explain, in part, why Netanyahu has become so toxic.
Unity today?
That history raises questions about the present enthusiasm for unity. The first is whether there is a pressing karmic need for Netanyahu to be banished. The second is whether any new unity agreement could be sustained. The third, and perhaps the most fundamental, is what such a government could actually accomplish.
Israel faces profound disagreements over accountability for Oct. 7, judicial independence, military obligations for the ultra-Orthodox, the future of the West Bank and the place of Arab citizens in its democracy. These are not merely disputes over the pace of reform. They concern the direction in which the country should move.
A unity government that postponed these questions would not necessarily reconcile the country. It might simply institutionalize paralysis.
There is also a peculiar asymmetry in the Israeli discussion of unity.
When Netanyahu’s right-religious bloc won 64 Knesset seats in 2022, he formed a government without inviting his opponents to participate. Nobody seriously argued that the millions of Israelis who voted for opposition parties were thereby entitled to representation in the cabinet. Netanyahu had won a parliamentary majority and proceeded to govern.
That is how parliamentary democracy works.
Yet when the possibility arises that Netanyahu’s opponents might assemble a majority, the argument for unity frequently resurfaces. The implication is that the votes of Likud supporters must somehow be honored through Netanyahu’s continued participation in government, even if a different parliamentary majority is available.
The present situation is admittedly complicated. Netanyahu’s bloc lacks a majority, while Eisenkot and his prospective partners face difficult choices concerning cooperation with Arab parties and the ultra-Orthodox. A broad coalition may be one way to overcome those obstacles.
But political difficulty is not the same as democratic necessity. A parliamentary majority that includes Arab parties, or depends on their support, is no less legitimate than one that includes Likud. Nor does respecting the millions of Israelis who support Netanyahu require that he remain in government.
This is where the language of national unity becomes misleading. Reconciliation among citizens is an essential national objective. Sharing cabinet positions among politicians is a particular political arrangement, whose merits depend on the policies it can implement.
Israel’s history demonstrates that unity governments can accomplish extraordinary things when their participants share an urgent purpose. It also demonstrates how fundamental disagreements can turn them into mechanisms for mutual veto.
Bennett’s intervention has made the possibility of another such government a serious political question. But the discussion should not begin and end with the distribution of ministries, the order of a rotation or the reassuring symbolism of rival leaders sitting around the same cabinet table.
It should begin with what the government intends to do.
Democratic elections exist to allow citizens to choose between competing political programs. Sometimes the result makes cooperation between rivals unavoidable. Sometimes a national emergency makes it desirable. But unity cannot become a substitute for accepting that elections have consequences.
Israel needs national solidarity. Whether it needs another national unity government is an entirely different question. My answer is a categorical no. So extreme is Netanyahu’s chicanery that any deal with him would be a terrible mistake that would be a tragedy for Zionism itself. If Israel is to survive it needs Netanyahu out.
The post Israel does not need fake ‘unity’ with Netanyahu – it needs to move forward appeared first on The Forward.

