Uncategorized
“Magical Meet Cute” – new novel imbues age-old “golem” theme with romance…and mystery
Review by BERNIE BELLAN I’d never read what would be considered a romance novel before, so when I received an email from a publicist for Harper Collins inviting me to read what was described as a new “rom-com,” I admit I was somewhat hesitant to accept the offer.
But – the premise of the novel, as described in that email was somewhat enticing. Here’s what it said:
“Ettel Resnick is a proud Jewitch woman. After being dumped by her fiancé of seven years, she recreated herself, selling her successful legal practice in Manhattan to open Magic Mud Pottery in Woodstock, New York. But everything changes on the fateful night Ettel returns from yet another singles event at the synagogue—and finds her town papered with antisemitic flyers.
“Desperate for comfort, she turns to the only thing guaranteed to soothe her Jewitch soul. Pottery. Heading to her studio, she gets super drunk, and crafts a golem. Ettel pours her heart into that little clay creature. She gives it everything she’s ever wanted in a partner, etching words onto his body—some sensible, some esoteric—before getting totally naked and burying that golem doll in her backyard.
“But when her ideal man turns up the very next day—and checks every detail inscribed on her clay man’s belly, including loving to play Scrabble and reading her books—she’s left wondering if she’s falling in love with the real deal, or if she’s truly summoned a golem.
“This laugh out loud romantic comedy explores witchcraft from a Jewish angle, fighting back against the anti-Semitic way Jewish witches have been portrayed throughout history. It also features a woman dealing with anti-semitism in her town and turning to the ancient Jewish protector—the golem.”
There are several things wrong with what that publicist wrote, however: First, the main character’s name was not Ettel Resnick, it’s Faye Kaplan. (That mistake alone made me wonder where the publicist got her information. Obviously, she hadn’t read the book.)
But second – and perhaps this is more important, to describe “Magical Meet Cute” as a rom-com is a disservice to a book that is far more than a rom-com.
Yes, it contains some of the elements of a romance novel and it does have some good laughs, but as the book develops it takes on a far more serious tone – and turns into a rollicking good mystery.
After reading something about the author, Jean Meltzer, I discovered that she had just about completed writing the book, but then October 7 happened and it cast a giant shadow over what she had mostly written. As a result, she now says that there is a much more serious overtone to her book than what she had anticipated in writing it.
A good part of “Magical Meet Cute” has to do with antisemitism and how completely shocked so many Jews are when it comes to having to deal with overt displays of antisemitism. In the book, Faye fights back, but others in the Jewish community are less willing to confront the threat posed by a group known as “the Paperboys.”
As the press release noted, the action in the book takes place in the very real town of Woodstock, New York (although I have no idea whether the Woodstock described here bears much resemblance to the real town.)
As for the reference to “witchcraft,” I admit that threw me off somewhat. I have encountered the notion of Jewish witches previously, especially in Alice Hoffman’s brilliant “The Dovekeepers,” but as I read “Magical Meet Cute,” I became much more aware of the notion of “Jewitches” which, in this book, is treated in a positive manner.
But, add to that the introduction of the theme of the “golem” in this novel, and you get something quite a bit more complex than what many readers might expect to find in a typical “rom-com.”
Yes, Faye Kaplan does drunkenly fashion a golem out of clay early on in the novel – and then the very next day a character appears who certainly does seem to tick off all the right boxes as a real golem. But, that’s where this book takes a very interesting turn, as the author explores the notion of the golem in Jewish history.
The theme of antisemitism and how ordinary Jews – just leading their everyday lives, are taken so completely by surprise when they encounter direct – and often vicious antisemitism, is especially hard hitting in “Magical Meet Cute.” And, because the notion of the golem as a magical defender of Jews has been around for centuries (as the author explains), it serves as a very convenient – and enticing device around which to develop a modern-day novel, especially in a time of rampant antisemitism.
That’s also where the book veers from romance to thriller – and Jean Meltzer does a fabulous job of injecting tremendous suspense – and trepidation, into the latter part of what is actually quite a long novel (over 480 pages).
In fact, I could have done with less of the romance and more of the thriller. When Faye Kaplan does meet – and fall in love with the character, who we come to know as “Greg” – who may or not be a real golem, I suppose it would have ruined the story for the two of them to go to bed right off the hop. But Meltzer describes Faye as quite beautiful, while Greg is what I would think would be almost any woman’s fantasy of a perfect male.
Not only is he gorgeous, he’s absolutely devoted to Faye. I won’t let you know whether they consummate their relationship, but there is an entire subplot revolving around Faye’s abandonment issues which prevents her from trusting Greg that is really quite sad, although totally credible.
As I made my way through “Magical Meet Cute,” I kept asking myself: Would someone who isn’t Jewish enjoy this book quite as much as someone who is? After all, there are so many references that, if you weren’t Jewish, you’d be wondering just what the heck they mean?
One that comes to mind off the top though – and it’s one I’ve never encountered previously, is Faye’s repeated use of the expression “Haman’s hat,” which she says whenever she’s quite surprised by something. I did a bit of reading on the subject but I simply couldn’t find an explanation why someone would say “Haman’s hat” as say, a substitute for something like “holy s_it.” (Maybe someone will enlighten me.)
Something else that intrigued me was Faye’s predilection for “hard kosher salami.” I realized early on it was her go-to comfort food, but aside from how unhealthy it is to eat, I couldn’t help but think of its phallic overtones. (By the way, Meltzer does enjoy using the term “shvantz” as a term of endearment in describing a certain part of Greg’s anatomy. I would have thought she might have resorted to the more commonly used “schmeckle.”)
When Meltzer introduces the group terrifying the Jews of Woodstock as “the Paperboys,” it’s obviously a not-too-thinly veiled reference to one of Donald Trump’s favourite white supremacist groups, “the Proudboys.” (I apologize if I’ve offended any Trump lovers. After all, there were “many good people on both sides,” as Trump suggested, during the white supremacist march through Charlottesville in 2017, weren’t there?)
“Magical Meet Cute” does have so much more to offer than simply a romance, but if I do have one qualm about the book it is that it so very long. It could have been cut down to no more than 300 pages but, having said that, I applaud the author for combining two quite different genres into quite the good read.
By the way, the book is slated for release August 27, but it’s available online right now from Amazon.
Uncategorized
Is it a tornado or bomb warning? No, it’s the Shabbat siren!
One Friday, shortly after I moved to New York City, I was walking through Bedford-Stuyvesant when an air raid siren went off. As it wailed, a group of older Black men playing chess in the park stood up, shook hands and clapped each other on the back. “Shabbat Shalom!” they said to each other. “Gut shabbes!”
I have no idea if any of these men were Jewish. But they knew what the siren was for. After all, they go off every week in the very Jewish neighborhoods of Crown Heights, Borough Park, Midwood and Williamsburg, to mark the arrival of Shabbat. Twice, actually: Once 18 minutes before Shabbat, as a warning, and then moments before Shabbat begins. They also blare before holidays such as Passover, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
Not everyone feels so positively about the Shabbat sirens, however — or, as one Redditor called them, “shalarms.” They’ve startled and panicked plenty of newer, unfamiliar residents. On Reddit, transplants near the Jewish neighborhoods often ask their fellow residents if there is some sort of bomb or tornado warning. A friend of mine told me she had to Google it when she first moved to the area, confused by the weekly wailing.
But why air raid sirens? Who runs them? Why aren’t there similar alarms in most Jewish neighborhoods, or other cities with many Jews? (A siren briefly made an appearance in London, and was quickly removed.) And how on earth did this custom develop in the first place? The mystery is surprisingly difficult to solve.
Of sirens and shofars
According to the Talmud, in the tractate Shabbat, Jews are supposed to announce the approach of the Sabbath with six blasts of a shofar, each of which corresponds to an act of preparation for the evening:
“The first blast is in order to stop the people from work in the fields. The second blast is to stop those who are working in the city, and to inform the proprietors to close the stores. The third is to inform them to light the Shabbat light.”
The Talmud instructs there be a pause after the third blast that lasts “the length of time it takes to fry a small fish or to stick bread to the sides of the oven” so that anyone who forgot to cook “and needs those foods for Shabbat may do so then.”
As Jews were ousted from Jerusalem in the early second century, this practice fell out of favor — it drew too much attention to an already-persecuted group. But some version of the practice was kept alive in many Jewish communities around the world. Some places, including Krakow in Poland, had a town crier who would go through the Jewish neighborhoods to remind people of the incoming Sabbath. In Jerusalem in the 1930s, someone would walk through Mahane Yehuda market to warn shopkeepers that it was time to shutter their stores. And in Djerba, Tunisia, someone still blows a shofar on a roof in the Jewish neighborhood.
Perhaps this is what inspired the sirens — though the air raid sirens heard in Brooklyn do not give blasts in the sound of a shofar, nor are there six of them. They do seem to operate by a similar logic, however; a gap of 15 minutes between the two sirens allows people to rush home, take a quick shower or finish frying a small fish, apparently. In today’s New York City, no one needs time to trudge back from a field, but a warning call is still relevant.
And sirens announce Shabbat in religious cities across Israel, including in Jerusalem, differentiated from the sirens that warn of missile fire only by cadence — a steady tone for Shabbat, an oscillating pitch for rockets. (During times of war, to reduce confusion and blood pressure, Jerusalem has sometimes broadcast religious melodies instead of a siren.)
Battles over noise
The Brooklyn sirens are independently operated and they don’t come from one central authority in any given neighborhood; there are multiple in the Orthodox area of Midwood in Brooklyn, on top of various yeshivas, and several throughout the Satmar areas of Williamsburg and the edges of Bed-Stuy. Crown Heights seems to have only a single horn, on top of the synagogue Chevra Shas — but it’s powerful enough to reach my apartment, more than half a mile away.
They are not universally beloved; neighbors have complained about the noise level and disruption, filing complaints with the city for sirens that have reached as high as 106 decibels — about the same as a jackhammer — sometimes resulting in tickets from the city’s Environmental Protection Agency issued to the yeshivas or synagogues housing each alarm. There have been Change.org petitions to ban them, and people have regularly called the police on their local sirens.
But the synagogues operating the alarms have resisted, pointing out that noise limits have exemptions for religious institutions, and citing nearby churches bells and mosque calls to prayer that reach similar decibel levels.
A similar interfaith alliance has been forged in Israel. In 2016, Orthodox political parties in Israel, which usually stand in opposition to Arab parties, blocked a bill requiring mosques to lower their volume for the call to prayer. Their fear was that any ruling about religious noise ordinances would limit the Shabbos siren too.
Some cities, often more religious ones like Jerusalem or Bnei Barak, run Shabbat sirens municipally, but in others, they are installed and distributed by an organization called Noam Kedushat — which specializes in speakers that play melodies instead of a loud tone — or are even operated by individuals off of their own roofs. There have been feuds over the sirens, particularly in religiously divided cities; progressive party Meretz tried to block the sirens in Tel Aviv, categorizing them as noise disturbances, and there have been lawsuits in Beer Sheva over a Shabbat speaker one woman installed on her house.
As religion increasingly splits Israeli politics, the sirens have become increasingly contentious; secular residents regard them as an annoyance or impediment akin to the fact that Israel’s public transit does not run on Shabbat. This year, a group of activists claimed the sirens amounted to “religious coercion.”
In Brooklyn, however, even after Oct. 7 when antisemitism has risen, public feeling toward the sirens is generally warm. Every few months, a Reddit post pops up asking about the siren. And every time, commenters reliably identify the noise as “our Jewish friends,” “your Jewish neighbors” or something similarly friendly; some celebrate it as an announcement of the weekend.
At most, they find it slightly annoying, but not particularly bothersome. A woman at a bus stop on the same block as one of the sirens told me that it shocked her at first — “It was like a tsunami of sound,” she said. “But you get used to it. It’s annoying but it’s only on Fridays.”
As my friend Phil put it, they are part of the “delightful (noisy) fabric of the city.” He likes to imagine “it’s two old siren nerds going up on the roof to crank the war surplus siren they lovingly maintain.”
But is that what’s happening?
A loud mystery
It’s not clear how long the sirens have been marking Shabbat in New York City; a 1991 New York Times article on the Crown Heights riots noted the sirens. In a 2014 article on a Chabad news site, a rabbi named Mendel Goldstein claimed to have invented the Crown Heights siren and said at the time of publication that he’d been running it for 30 years, placing that siren’s birth in the mid-1980s.
There is shockingly little information about the sirens publicly available — not who owns them, or how they run, or whether they’ve been updated over the decades. A 2014 article in Gothamist, ostensibly about the sirens, is in fact largely about the city’s history with actual air raid sirens, during World War II. No synagogue or yeshiva has ever commented to a mainstream news outlet about the noise complaints, and no one has gone on record explaining how they run in NYC. Somehow, the Shabbos versions remain elusive, even though they’re a hard-to-miss part of life in Brooklyn.
And despite the warm feelings many Brooklynites seem to hold toward the sirens, people are oddly close-lipped and even hostile about their origin story or their owners.

I went to find the source of the sound nearest me one Friday afternoon, and was standing there, staring up at it and waiting when it went off, as dozens of Chabad families streamed by me. One man, perhaps seeing an opportunity to bring me into the Chabad fold, stopped and smiled and asked me if I knew what the tall pole with flared air horn speakers on top was, I said I knew what it was, but nothing else about it, and that I was a journalist trying to discover its history; he speed-walked away.
I got a bit more of information from an elderly white-bearded man, who stopped to ask me if I was looking for a synagogue. He told me that the siren goes off automatically, programmed once a year — disappointing information for Phil’s romantic vision of old nerds maintaining their analog siren. But my most knowledgeable source yet peeled off to greet a friend when I tried to learn more.
After reaching out to a Chabad-run neighborhood news site for Crown Heights, I got a number for Mendel Goldstein. When he didn’t answer numerous calls or messages, I asked around and got the number for his nephew Levi. He answered, but while he was jovial, he was also openly suspicious of my intentions. He wanted to know who gave out his phone number, and asked what the piece was about.
“I want to make sure, you know, you’re depicting the siren in a positive light!” he told me. I related my story about the chess players, and he seemed pacified; he said he’d get back to me with his uncle on the phone. He did not.
I had a similar exchange with another Chabad representative, Motti Seligson; he was excited about the idea, and told me he loved the siren and grew up with it. When I told him about my experience trying to reach Goldstein, he opined that that the inventor, whoever it might truly be — he notably did not confirm Goldstein’s claim to invention — didn’t want to talk about it and just wanted to humbly serve his community without any fanfare, or no more fanfare than an air raid siren that can be heard for blocks already provided.
Still, Seligson promised me he’d find somebody who would chat about the siren. He also promised to find me the perfect Shabbos dinner that would connect me to the perfect Chabad shul. He never got back to me either, even after I followed up about dinner. I tried a Chabad-run library; no answer.
I may never know the true history of my Friday sirens. But for me, they symbolize everything I love about New York — its diversity, its quirks, the way Judaism is woven into the city in a way everyone, Jewish or not, knows about and appreciates. Judaism is part of being a New Yorker, whether it’s the people graciously explaining to concerned Redditors that the sirens announce the weekend instead of an incoming hurricane, or it’s the men playing chess in the park and pausing to wish each other a gut shabbes.
I think of it every Friday as the siren sings faintly through my own Crown Heights apartment windows. Though these days the Shabbat siren also serves as a disheartening reminder of how early the sun sets.
The post Is it a tornado or bomb warning? No, it’s the Shabbat siren! appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
I’ve been chanting my bar mitzvah Torah portion annually for 40 years. It keeps me grounded in a polarized world.
The Phantom of the Opera had a run of 13,981 Broadway shows across 35 years. Baltimore Orioles legend Cal Ripken Jr., played in 2,632 consecutive baseball games over 17 seasons. The District of Columbia has voted for a Democratic candidate for president in 15 consecutive presidential elections. And this Thanksgiving weekend, I will chant my bar mitzvah Torah parsha (the weekly Torah portion), Vayishlach, for the 40th straight year.
As streaks go, mine certainly will not make a list of history’s greatest. Yet for four decades, I have leined (chanted) it in Israel, the Czech Republic, Vermont, California, Tennessee, Illinois, New York, D.C., and many other international and domestic cities. Whether home or away, every synagogue and Jewish community where I read Torah welcomed me as a fellow Jew as I chanted the ancient words: “וַיִּשְׁלַ֨ח יַֽעֲקֹ֤ב מַלְאָכִים֙ לְפָנָ֔יו אֶל־עֵשָׂ֖ו אָחִ֑יו אַ֥רְצָה שֵׂעִ֖יר שְׂדֵ֥ה אֱדֽוֹם – Jacob sent messengers ahead to his brother Esau in the land of Seir, the country of Edom.”
This 40th year will be particularly memorable because I will return to the place my streak started – Kesher Israel in Washington, D.C. – where I will read Vayishlach as my 94 year-old father sits in the front row of the synagogue and corrects any mistakes I make. After 40 years, I do not make many, but he still catches every one.
Vayishlach recounts the reunion of estranged brothers Jacob and Esau, as well as the failed unification of the children of Jacob and Hamor after a son of Hamor raped a daughter of Jacob. The parsha’s themes resonate strongly today. The first lesson is that brothers, no matter the distance between them, should never forget the family ties that bind them. The second lesson is that when one community commits an act of extreme violence against another, it is extraordinarily difficult to forget and make peace. These stories teach us that we Jews must always welcome our brothers and also protect ourselves from others who would do us harm.
Three chantings in my streak best reflect Vayishlach’s lesson of brotherly love: my second anniversary when I was living in Northern Israel on a kibbutz; my eighth anniversary when I was a college senior in rural Vermont; and my approximately twentieth anniversary when I was traveling with my father in the Czech Republic.
When I was 15 years old, I lived for a year on Kfar Blum in Israel’s Hula Valley. There was a small non-denominational synagogue on the kibbutz which struggled to get a minyan. I approached the lay leader of the synagogue – there was no rabbi – and asked if I might be permitted to chant my bar mitzvah portion on Shabbat. He seemed skeptical – after all, what American Jew knew enough Hebrew and the Torah “trope” (the musical melody used when chanting Torah) to read an entire parsha? Fortunately, my on-the-spot practice for him proved my credentials, and he permitted this young American to lead their Shabbat minyan. While I cannot say that I became a regular attendee, whenever I saw the older synagogue members around the kibbutz, they always had a smile and a nod for the young American Jew who could chant Torah.
Six years later, as a student at Middlebury College in Vermont, there was no Shabbat minyan on campus or in the nearby towns. So I called the historic Ohavi Zedek Synagogue (“OZ”) in Burlington, Vermont. OZ was founded in 1885 and is one of Vermont’s oldest and largest Jewish congregations. Again, after convincing the synagogue chazan (prayer leader) that I could read Torah, I drove an hour from Middlebury to Burlington to chant Vayishlach before a much larger congregation than I was used to. When I finished and briefly joined the kiddush after services, I awkwardly accepted Mazel Tovs from my Jewish elders. They expressed pride in my chanting and their hope that I would read Torah again in their shul.
About a decade later, I traveled with my father to the Czech Republic. It was a business trip for him and a vacation for me. Early on a Thursday morning, we went to the Old-New Synagogue in Prague’s Jewish Quarter for morning minyan. I knew this might be my only chance to keep my bar mitzvah streak alive, so before the Torah service, my father and I approached one of the leaders to ask if I might lein. In the spirit of detente, we negotiated an agreement: They would let me chant as long as one of their members stood next to me in case I could not, in fact, read Torah. I surprised them again, reading smoothly and earning an invitation to another post-service kiddush and a l’chaim.
Today, when Jews neither feel safe in our communities nor welcome in others, my 40-year bar mitzvah Torah reading streak motivates me to build bridges across our Jewish faith and with others. After all, our survival throughout history depended on maintaining our Jewish traditions while also being thoroughly engaged in contemporary society. When I chant this verse – “וַיָּ֨רׇץ עֵשָׂ֤ו לִקְרָאתוֹ֙ וַֽיְחַבְּקֵ֔הוּ וַיִּפֹּ֥ל עַל־צַוָּארָ֖ו וַׄיִּׄשָּׁׄקֵ֑ׄהׄוּׄ וַיִּבְכּֽוּ; Esau ran to greet Jacob, embraced him, fell on his neck, kissed him, and they wept” – I choose the uplifting interpretation that the two brothers reunited in love. I will continue to be inspired by the lessons of Vayishlach that have never been more important to our Jewish communities, in cities and countries, large and small.
The post I’ve been chanting my bar mitzvah Torah portion annually for 40 years. It keeps me grounded in a polarized world. appeared first on The Forward.
Uncategorized
NFL suspends star wide receiver Puka Nacua following allegations of antisemitism, assault
(JTA) — The NFL suspended Los Angeles Rams star wide receiver Puka Nacua for three games on Thursday, months after he faced a lawsuit from a woman who alleged that he had made an “unprovoked antisemitic statement.”
But Nacua — who led the league in receptions last season — won’t miss any additional games, as the league is allowing him to serve the suspension while he recovers from an injury.
Madison Atiabi, who is Jewish, alleged that Nacua, 25, said “f— all the Jews” at a dinner in L.A. last New Year’s Eve. According to the lawsuit, Atiabi said she “immediately felt uncomfortable and emotionally distressed.”
Atiabi also alleged that Nacua “forcibly” bit her on the left shoulder, “leaving a circular imprint of his teeth on her body,” and that he bit her friend’s thumb “with such force that her companion screamed in acute pain.”
Nacua’s attorney, Levi McCathern, said in a statement at the time that Nacua denied the antisemitism allegations “in the strongest possible terms.” McCathern characterized the biting as “horseplay.” No charges were filed, and the civil case is ongoing.
The NFL allows players to serve suspensions while on the injured list. But the timing of the suspension for Nacua — who previously got in trouble for making an antisemitic gesture on a livestream — raised questions about whether the NFL intended for one of its brightest young stars to miss any game time.
After Nacua sustained a knee injury Nov. 8, the Rams placed him on injured reserve, stipulating that he would miss at least four games but leaving open the possibility of a return before the playoffs. He underwent surgery to repair a sprained MCL on Tuesday, ruling him out until next season.
By waiting until Nacua returned from injury to announce its decision, the NFL could have ensured that Nacua missed games he would otherwise have played. The league also could have levied a more significant fine.
Nacua, who is still on his rookie contract, will reportedly lose $950,000 in lost game checks. He is expected to sign a lucrative free-agent contract after the season, meaning that he would have been in line to forfeit a much heftier sum — potentially several million dollars — had the league levied the suspension upon his return.
The NFL also reportedly told Nacua that future violations of the league’s personal conduct policy could lead to significant discipline, including a permanent ban.
The March lawsuit came a few months after another high-profile antisemitism scandal involving Nacua.
Last December — roughly two weeks before the alleged New Year’s Eve incident — Nacua appeared on Jewish influencer Adin Ross’ livestream show, where he was encouraged by Ross to perform an antisemitic touchdown dance during his next game. The dance recreates an infamous gesture known as “The Happy Merchant” that depicts Jews as greedy. Nacua performed the dance on the livestream, but never during a game.
After facing backlash — including calls for the Rams to cut Nacua — the wide receiver apologized in an Instagram post that featured the branding of the “Stand Up To Jewish Hate” campaign, the advocacy group founded by New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft. That post is no longer visible.
“When I appeared the other day on a social media livestream, it was suggested to me to perform a specific movement as part of my next touchdown celebration,” Nacua wrote in the now-removed post. “At the time, I had no idea this act was antisemitic in nature and perpetuated harmful stereotypes against Jewish people.
“I deeply apologize to anyone who was offended by my actions as I do not stand for any form of racism, bigotry or hate of another group of people.”
The NFL and the Rams also released statements at the time, neither of which named Nacua.
This article originally appeared on JTA.org.
The post NFL suspends star wide receiver Puka Nacua following allegations of antisemitism, assault appeared first on The Forward.

