Local News
Ben Carr answers questions at Gwen Secter Centre about his candidacy for the Liberals in Winnipeg South Centre
By BERNIE BELLAN It might have seemed an odd venue for a candidate in a federal byelection in to be grilled about his candidacy, but on Thursday, May 18, Liberal candidate for Winnipeg South Centre Ben Carr (in a byelection that will take place on June 19) faced a series of tough questions from audience members at the Gwen Secter Centre (which is in the north end) who were there for the second session of the Remis luncheon series.
As a preamble, I should note that Ben Carr was invited to speak to the Remis luncheon group well before the byelection was called in Winnipeg South Centre. Just as I have written about other speakers who have appeared at a Remis luncheon (and elsewhere in this paper you can read my account of the first of this years’ speakers, Joan Druxman, who spoke on May 11), I decided to write about Ben Carr’s appearanc at a Remis forum.
Ben Carr is the 37-year-old son of the late Jim Carr and Dr. Ruth Simkin. I have to make an admission at this point: I’ve known Carr ever since he was a classmate of my daughter Shira, beginning in Grade 7. That didn’t stop me, however, from throwing some pointed questions at him.
When he got up to speak Carr joked that he had been out campaigning recently in Tuxedo and when he knocked on people’s doors at least four individuals told him that they were related to him (which came as no surprise to him, he said, since he’s found through the years that both the Carr and Simkin families have many relatives in Winnipeg – and elsewhere).
Still, being the son of a famous politician, whose mantle he is now trying to adopt, has its pros and cons. I asked him, for instance, whether he’s encountered people who have accused him of capitalizing on his father’s name in running for the Liberals in the same riding that Jim Carr held for seven years until his untimely death last December?
Carr said “no,” that hasn’t been brought up to him personally.
“I recognize that I was gifted a set of principles by my parents,” he said. “You don’t choose where you come from, but you choose what you do with that.”
Someone else asked Carr whether he had ever been to Israel? He said that he had, when he was 24, when he was on a Birthright trip there – and had his bar mitzvah at the Kotel (Western Wall).
How that came about was an amusing story. Carr said that there were two rules all members of Birthright were supposed to follow: Stick with the group always and no drinking.
But, one time when the group was in Jerusalem, he and his cousin Joel decided to venture away from the group at one point, he explained. They came across someone who “looked like a rabbi,” Carr recalled. (To be honest, how hard is it to find someone who looks like a rabbi in Jerusalem?) They asked the individual whether he was a rabbi and when the man said he was, Carr said that he would like to be bar mitzvah’d.
The rabbi said to Carr and his cousin, “Okay, if you’re going to be bar mitzvah’d we’re going to the Kotel” and that’s where Carr was bar mitzvah’d.
As well, the rabbi happened to have a bottle of vodka, Carr added, which led to him and his cousin breaking the second Birthright rule.
And, although he’s relatively young, Carr has already had a varied career. After graduating from the French Immersion program at Kelvin, Carr became a teacher, he said, later a principal at Maples Met High School which, he explained, has an innovative program whereby some students attend school three days a week, and apprentice in a workplace the other two days.
Most recently Carr has been Vice President of something called the Indigenous Strategy Alliance, working in tandem with an Indigenous woman by the name of Rebecca Chartrand. He described their relationship as “what reconciliation should look like.”
Of course, growing up in a household immersed in politics (Jim Carr was first elected as an MLA in 1988, Carr pointed out, as part of the resurgent provincial Liberal showing led by then-leader Sharon Carstairs), he has had more than his share of exposure, both to campaigning and the day to day workings of government.
In 2015, when Jim Carr was elected to the House of Commons for the first time, Ben went along with his father to live with him in Ottawa for four months. Later, Ben held various positions in the federal government, including serving as Director of Parliamentary Affairs to the Minister of Canadian Heritage.
Still, while Winnipeg South Centre has been a Liberal-held seat for the past eight years, it has also been won by Conservatives in the past, most recently by Joyce Bateman (in 2011).
Carr said that “there are three issues I’m most proud of”: The national child care program, “which has lifted 450,000 kids out of poverty;” the government’s position on climate change where, he said, the government has found “a good balance;” and the national day care plan, “which is going to help women get back in the work force.”
He added that the government has introduced “changes in support for seniors,” including “dropping the age of eligibility to receive the Old Age Pension from 67 to 65 and increasing the Old Age Supplement.”
I said to Carr that there are two other issues that clearly distinguish the Liberals from the Conservatives: gun control and abortion. Since gun control was not likely to be an issue in Winnipeg South Centre though, I wondered whether abortion has been brought up to him since he’s been out knocking on doors?
He answered: “For us, this (abortion) was settled a long time ago. You cannot be a candidate for the Liberal Party of Canada unless you stand for a woman’s right to choose. I don’t know where my opponents stand on abortion, but I’d like to hear from them.”
Someone else asked him who else is running in the byelection? Carr said that the Conservative candidate is Damir Stipanovic, the NDP candidate is Julia Riddell, and the Green Party candidate is Doug Hemmerling. (Given how important the Jewish vote is in Winnipeg South Centre and how many of our readers live in the riding, we will try to profile each of the three other candidates in the June 7 issue.)
Someone wondered whether Carr had encountered any anti-Semitism while on the campaign trail? He said that he hadn’t, but he did offer an anecdote that illustrated how prejudice can work both ways.
One time when Ben was out campaigning for his father in River Heights, he said, he was confronted by a woman when he knocked on her door, he said, who told him that Justin Trudeau was an “antisemite.”
The reason she felt that way, Carr explained, was that Trudeau “had let so many Muslims into the country.”
That led me to ask Carr whether he has had anyone tell him that they’re not happy with the Liberal position on Israel, (e.g., either voting for or abstaining during votes on resolutions at the UN which are critical of Israel)?
Carr was adamant that the “Liberal government has been equal to or better than the Harper government was.” (It’s somewhat fitting that in this same issue we devote a fair bit of space to what Stephen Harper had to say about Israel at the Negev Gala.)
He went on to say that there is “an attempt within the Conservative movement in Canada to position itself as the only defender of Israel within the House of Commons.
“There is a little bit of a misconception when it comes to the Liberal Party’s position on Israel,” Carr continued.
“The fundamental principle is that Israel has a right to exist and is the homeland of the Jewish people,” he said.
Turning once again to the Conservative Party, Carr said the Conservative Party today is not the Progressive Conservative Party of “Joe Clark and Brian Mulroney.
“What Pierre Poilievre is trying to leverage,” Carr maintained, “ is the worst in us – and combining it with a kind of populism to turn us against one another.
“The vast majority of Conservatives that I talk to in Winnipeg South Centre identify with the PC Party.”
Carr brought up something that had been posted to the Damir Stipanovic website, (votedamir.ca) but has apparently been expunged, but not before someone had captured a screenshot of what was written:
“It is becoming increasingly clear that the Trudeau Liberals benefitted from corruption and interference in the 2019 and 2021 elections. Leaks from the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) indicate that the Trudeau Liberals were aware of alarming reports and did not respond to the threats.
“An open and transparent public inquiry is now needed. With Winnipeg South Centre heading into a by-election, how do we know that the Chinese Communist Party is not funding Ben Carr and the Liberal party in this very riding?”
As noted, we will attempt to contact each of the three other candidates in Winnipeg South Centre in time for our June 7 issue, including Damir Stipanovic, whom we will also ask about the question posed on his website.
Local News
Gail Asper adds $10-million donation to ambitious $1.2 billion Hebrew University fundraising campaign
By MYRON LOVE Gail Asper, one of our community’s leading philanthropists, has recently returned from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem’s annual International Board of Governors meeting, during which she pledged $10 million to the university’s $1,2 billion international Powered By Purpose Campaign.
As reported in the Post last April, Asper has taken on the challenge of co-chairing the campaign (with patty Glaser from Los Angeles), which was kicked off at the recent board meeting. “It is important to lead by example,” she notes. “As my father (the late I.H. Asper) used to say, it is important to give what you can.”
Rami Kleinmann, President and CEO of Canadian Friends of the Hebrew University observed that “Gail’s gift is a testament to what is possible when personal conviction, a tradition of giving, and belief in a mission come together. We are deeply grateful for her leadership and for the Asper family’s remarkable partnership with Hebrew University.”
Professor Tamir Sheafer, president of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, speaking on behalf of the entire Hebrew University community, thanked Gail “for her remarkable generosity and her leadership. Her gift, and her role as co-chair of our international campaign, will help us keep Hebrew University a global leader in research and education for many years to come.”
Asper’s personal connection with the Hebrew University goes back more than 50 years. She recalls going to Israel for the first time with her family in 1974, when she was 14. In her 20s, she and her brothers went to Jerusalem with their parents where Israel Asper would be attending HU annual Board of Governors meetings.
“I met the president of the university,” she recounts. “I got to see what the university was doing and got to know the people on the board. There were board members from all over the world, all accomplished and interesting people.. It was so glamourous.”
In 1989, her father – after more than 20 years on the board – told Gail that he was stepping down to spend more time building the still relatively new Canwest – and suggested that she should replace him as a board member. Not only did she join the board, but she also became one of the founding members of the newly formed Canadian Friends of Hebrew University Business and Professional Division, along with other now prominent community members such as Howard Morry and Murray Palay.
It wasn’t long after she joined the Hebrew U board that she moved on to the board executive,” she notes. “We would have meetings in Israel three or four times a year. Thank goodness now for Zoom. But I really enjoyed meeting with fellow board members, as well as university management and faculty.”
Among the Asper family initiatives at the University are: the Asper HUJI Innovate program – the University’s centre for innovation and entrepreneurship; theAsper prize in Innovation, which supports and celebrates promising Israeli start-ups; the Asper Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation, the academic and community hub housed within the Hebrew University Business School (HUBS); and ongoing exchanges that bring Canada’s brightest students to Israel for a semester or complete degree.
Gail reports that her new donation is intended the help make up for the rapidly decreasing number of scholarships and grants from foundations outside of Israel that would normally be potentially available for Hebrew University students and researchers, but which have declined in number due to the increasing hostility in academia to anyone connected to Israel.
She is happy to report that the five-year Powered By Purpose Campaign has received a major boost from a $250 million gift from billionaire American hedge fund manager John Paulson. “This is the largest gift ever received by the Hebrew University,” she notes. “This is also the first time that the university has received a donation from Mr. Paulson. We are really excited about it.”
In that earlier interview with the Post, Asper reported that one focus of the new campaign will be Jewish philanthropists and foundations who had been supporting American and Canadian universities but who have been told that, since October 7, 2023, that their donations are no longer welcome. “Others have pulled their donations because of anti-Jewish activity on campuses,” she pointed out. “We will be suggesting that their donations will be better spent supporting Israel’s leading universities rather than antisemitic universities in Canada and the US.”
One area that struck her about this most recent visit to the university was the large number of Israeli Arab students and faculty. “You see the diversity on campus,” she observes. “Close to 20% of the student body and staff are Arab Israelis. Most students seemed to be comfortable on campus and happy to be there.
“It was wonderful to be in Israel,” she says, “and nice to see other Winnipeggers – such as (Federation CEO Jeff Lieberman, (CIJA representative) Gustavo Zentner, and (philanthropist) Larry Vickar also in Israel to attend other institution Board of Governors meetings at a time when direct flights to Israel are scarce and there are very few tourists.”
Local News
Palestinian-born Dor Shachar chose Judaism and life in Israel over Islam and darkness in Gaza
By MYRON LOVE Dor Shachar is a rare individual indeed. It seems almost miraculous – certainly “beshert” – that this individual, who was born into a Muslim family in Gaza and raised as a Muslim, chose to leave behind the hell and darkness that is Gaza and embrace the light of Judaism and Israel.
On Monday, November 2, the proud Jewish Israeli shared the story of his transformation with an audience of about 150. Invitations were specifically sent out to Christian communities in Winnipeg because extreme Islam also targets Christians, as well as moderate Muslims.. Earlier, he also spoke in a couple of schools.
Among the attendees were several members of the Manitoba Conservative Party caucus – including interim leader Konrad Narth. Invitations to attend Shachar’s presentation were also sent to the other provincial parties, but no one from the other parties showed up.
As Shachar doesn’t speak English, his remarks were translated by Jona Rapaport, who is from Montreal and who had family members kidnapped on October 7.
Shachar’s narrative falls into two distinct parts – and I have to admit that the first act was at times very difficult to listen to. What he described of his life growing up in Gaza was horrific. He recalled that the clothes his family wore, the food they ate, and their appliances were all from Israel, and that his father worked on construction projects in Israel for many years. His father and grandfather pretended to be on friendly term with the Israeli soldiers who patrolled Gaza at the that time – in the 1980s –and the family invited soldiers – these same soldiers who would give the kids treats – into their homes. His father and grandfather were hospitable and seemingly friendly. As soon as the guest would leave though, the young Shachar was told that he one day it would be his duty to kill the “sons of apes and pigs” – referring to the Israelis living in Jewish communities that had been established in Gaza.
Shachar reported that his neighbours were future terrorist leaders, including Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar. He witnessed the digging of the first terror tunnels more than 40 years ago. As well, he saw the evil of the various hateful groups who used torture and terror to rule Gaza – from Fatah to Hamas and their affiliated terror groups. He described public scenes of torture and murder that rivaled the worst excesses of the European Dark Ages a thousand years ago. He recalled how in elementary school, students were taught how to throw rocks at Israeli soldiers.
In a particularly horrifying segment, Shachar recalled what happened to him when still in primary school. Apparently, he didn’t show enough zeal about hating Jews and Christians. He was hauled into the principal’s office – where he was whipped. When his father learned about this, he spent hours beating and torturing his son – including hanging a noose from a tree – for “dishonouring” the family. Only an intervention by an aunt most likely saved his life – although his father then proceeded to beat the aunt. He was relegated to looking after the family flocks.
Another time, when he was 11, his father found out that he was skipping school, beat him, tied him to a tree, and doused him in cold water. Shachar was locked in the outhouse for the night and forced to sleep on the floor.
A few months later – when he turned 12 – his father started taking the youngster with him to Israel to work on construction projects. After a couple of months, he managed to run away.
Thus began the second chapter of his life – his new life in Israel.
While working as a security guard watching over a neighborhood of villas where prospective tenants would come to see the apartments, he was approached one day by a resident by the name of Nissim Ozen.
“Nissim took interest in me,” he recounted. “He brought me home with him, got me clothes and shoes and other gifts.”
He began to be invited to Ozem’s home for Shabbat suppers and other meals and was welcomed to have hot showers and watch television.
At Pesach, he was invited for the family’s seder.
“I come for the seder and I see the longest table I have ever seen,” he recounted. “It stretched from the living room through the kitchen out to the garden. On the table, there was bread, only the matzah, some eggs, a shank bone and some greens. I asked my host if he was on a diet.“I didn’t yet know much Hebrew, but I learned about the Exodus.”
That was when Shachar decided that he wanted to become a Jew. Some of his new friends arranged for a local Bet Din. He was subsequently referred to another Bet Din in Tel Aviv, then a third in Kiryat Shemona in the north, and finally, to Jerusalem where he told that, because he was still a minor, he would need his father’s permission.
That was never going to happen.
Nonetheless, Shachar was able to go to school and become proficient in Hebrew – while he eagerly counted down the days until he turned 18 and could become Jewish.
But, there was another hitch in store.
It was now the mid-1990s and the first Palestinian suicide bombers began killing Israelis on buses, in restaurants and wherever they gathered. Shachar spoke of the notorious Yahya Ayyash – the bomb maker, Shachar recalled, who provided his dubious services to all the Palestinian factions. (The IDF caught up with him and killed him with a bomb in early 1996.)
Shachar pointed out that – contrary to what diplomats, politicians and leftists in the West believe – there is no difference between Hamas, the PLO/Palestinian Authority – given the facts and what they say in Arabic from “pay for slay” to other hate they espouse against anyone not aligned with them – even moderates. There is no “partner for peace” among the Palestinian factions, he says, – and no difference between those factions and Al Qaeda, ISIS, and the Taliban.
Unfortunately for Shachar, due to the increased level of attacks by Palestinian terrorists, Israel tightened restrictions on Palestinian workers who were allowed to work in Israel. All Palestinians workers had to have permits. Because he didn’t have one, he was sent back to Gaza, where he was tortured daily by Hamas operatives for six months.
Eventually, he was released to fend for himself in Gaza. Determined to return to Israel and become Jewish, he was – after a few months – able to slip across the border to Egypt and make his way via Turkey back to Israel
Back in Israel, he attended a yeshiva and resumed his efforts to become a Jew. It took him seven years to realize his dream. The climactic moment for him came, he recounted, one Purim when he joined a rabbi in Jerusalem for a “farbrengen.”
“I had never had alcohol before,” he said. “Alcohol is forbidden to Muslims. I quickly became woozy. Nonetheless, the rabbi kept pouring. Even while drunk, I kept insisting that I wanted to be a Jew. That was enough to convince the rabbi to support my efforts.”
Today, Dor Shachar is a proud Jewish Israeli – happily married – who speaks for Israel on the world stage and warns people, especially in the West, about the hateful dogma and true extremist intentions of Islamist ideology. Statistics indicate that 15-25% of Muslims in the West are radicalized. With the influx of people from Gaza and other areas that number may be grossly underestimated.
In Gaza and Judea and Samaria the numbers are higher.
The ultimate goal for Islamic extremists, Shachar warned, is world domination.
Local News
Harvey Richmond: an unusual career path with many twists and turns
By GERRY POSNER When you talk about someone whose life has had more than a few different moves, Harvey Richmond’s life would be right up there as one of the most circuitous. You could rightfully say that his life has been far from predictable.
Harvey, the middle son of three boys (Barrie – older, and Kenny – younger), whose parents were David and Nettie (Brown) Richmond, is now north of 85 years. He lives in the Los Angeles area and has been there for well over 40 years.
Harvey grew up in the south end of Winnipeg and, for most of those years, his home was a corner house on Waverley and Grosvenor. The family was connected to the Shaarey Zedek synagogue even before it was located on Wellington Crescent.
Harvey went to Queenston School and later graduated from high school at Kelvin. Like many of his contemporaries, he was off to the University of Manitoba, where he obtained a Bachelor of Science degree with a major in Mathematics, then a Bachelor of Science in Pharmacy. He became a licensed pharmacist in 1961.
The plan was for Harvey to join his father, also a pharmacist, in his father’s drugstore. But, at that time, Dave Richmond was getting ready to retire, so Harvey went to work for Bunny Ringer at his drugstore on Pembina Highway, a place likely known to many readers. After two years there, Harvey realized pharmacy was not for him, so suddenly, the first detour in Harvey’s life hit him smack in the face.
Harvey was planning to visit his older brother Barrie, who was doing an internship in Chicago at that time. Flying there was not feasible for Harvey – or anyone else at that particular time, as Northwest Airlines was on strike, so he hopped into his car to drive to Chicago. On his way through Grand Forks, however, Harvey saw a sign advertising the University of North Dakota’s medical school. Why not? he asked himself. He applied, was accepted and thus, in 1966, he was a student in Medicine at the University of North Dakota. At that time, UND had only a two-year programme, with training in the basic sciences. The school had arrangements with other medical schools throughout the USA to accept students who had completed that school’s two year programme. So, after his two years at UND were completed, off Harvey went to the University of Minnesota. By 1971, he was a graduate in Medicine from that university.
During his time in Minneapolis, Harvey also married a woman from that city and, within three years, he was the father of two girls. In 1971, Harvey did his internship at Los Angeles County-USC Medical Centre in Los Angeles. He elected to enter Obstetrics and Gynaecology as his final rotation – which turned out to be a sign of things to come several years down the road. However, in 1971, Harvey was not totally sure that being an OB/Gyn was what he wanted to be.
Harvey signed up for a residency in Minnesota in Neurology, so the family returned to Minneapolis for Harvey to begin a new residency there. After a year, Harvey concluded that Neurology was also not for him, but he chose to remain in the Twin Cities and join a family practice with four other physicians, called Apple Valley Medical Center. While there, he developed a renewed interest in Obstetrics. This time, Harvey decided that Obstetrics and Gynaecology was really what he wanted to pursue, but he also recognized that he needed more comprehensive training to do that.
Thus, at the age of 40, he made yet another major career decision and began a residency in Obstetrics and Gynaecology. He did his residency at the University of Minnesota and St. Paul Ramsay Medical Center. If you can picture it, here was 40-year-old Harvey Richmond, married, with two little kids, now starting over in what was to become his chosen specialty. But – after he finished his residency, his marriage also ended.
Next, Harvey was offered a position in the Los Angeles area. In 1984, off to Long Beach, California he went. About a year later, he had an opportunity to take over a practice in Beverley Hills. He also received privileges to practice OB/Gyn at Cedars- Sinai Medical Centre in Los Angeles. Harvey officially joined the medical staff there in 1986 and has remained on staff ever since.
As Harvey puts it, “Over the course of my career, I have delivered an extraordinary number of babies.” One of his staff tried to calculate the total number and the estimate was in the range of 10,000 to 12,000 babies. Harvey reflects that a large part of his career has been devoted to caring for pregnant women, delivering their babies and practicing OB/Gyn. Additionally, throughout his time at Cedars, he has been on the teaching staff there, instructing OB/ Gyn residents in surgical procedures.
In 1988 Harvey married again. That marriage also ended – in 2003. However, the one constant throughout Harvey’s life the past 40 years has been his career at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center.
Harvey uncategorically states that he was extraordinarily fortunate to find something he loved to do, even though it took him quite a few years and several career changes to get to this point. His journey was difficult at times and he admits it has come at a personal cost in terms of his family.
Yet, his career has given him great satisfaction and filled him with a sense of purpose. As Harvey puts it, “I was privileged to be present during some of the most important moments in people’s lives.”
In the end, Harvey Richmond reflects on his medical practice this way: “ Looking back, I realize that my path was anything but direct. I began as a pharmacist, entered medicine almost by chance, tried Neurology, practiced Family Medicine, and eventually returned to residency so that I could become an Obstetrician and Gynaecologist. Each decision brought me closer to the work I was meant to do.”
To this day, Harvey is grateful to those who supported him along the way. Even at the age of 85, Harvey Richmond is still practicing medicine, although now on a part time basis, working only in the office. He remains active and still gets enjoyment out of his work. The path Harvey took had many twists and turns but, ultimately, many rewards along the way.

