Connect with us
The Residences advertisement

Uncategorized

A new book made me appreciate Jewish Sunday schools — and the volunteer women who have powered them

(JTA) — As a kid I went to Sunday school at our Reform synagogue. I didn’t hate it as much as my peers did, but let’s just say there were literally dozens of other things I would have preferred to do on a weekend morning.

As a Jewish adult, I had a vague understanding that Sunday school was a post-World War II invention, part of the assimilation and suburbanization of American Jews (my synagogue was actually called Suburban Temple). With our parents committed to public schools and having moved away from the dense urban enclaves where they were raised, our Jewish education was relegated to Sunday mornings and perhaps a weekday afternoon. The Protestant and Catholic kids went to their own religious supplementary schools, and we Jewish kids went to ours. 

In her new book “Jewish Sunday Schools,” Laura Yares backdates this story by over a century. Subtitled “Teaching Religion in Nineteenth-Century America,” the book describes how Sunday schools were the invention of pioneering educators such as Rebecca Gratz, who founded the first Sunday school for Jewish children in Philadelphia in 1838. As such, they were responses by a tiny minority to distinctly 19th-century challenges — namely, how to raise their children to be Jews in a country dominated by a Protestant majority, and how to express their Judaism in a way compatible with America’s idea of religious freedom.

Although Sunday schools would become the “principal educational organization” of the Reform movement, Yares shows that the model was adopted by traditionalists as well. And she also argues that 20th-century historians, in focusing on the failures of Sunday schools to promote Jewish “continuity,” discounted the contributions of the mostly volunteer corps of women educators who made them run. Meanwhile, the supplementary school remains the dominant model for Jewish education among non-Orthodox American Jews, despite recent research showing its precipitous decline.

I picked up “Jewish Sunday Schools” hoping to find out who gets the blame for ruining my Sunday mornings. I came away with a new appreciation for the women whose “important and influential work,” Yares writes, “extended far beyond the classrooms in which they worked.” 

Yares is assistant professor of Religious Studies at Michigan State University, with a joint appointment in the MSU Program for Jewish Studies. Raised in Birmingham, England, she has degrees from Oxford University and a doctorate from Georgetown University.

Our conversation was edited for length and clarity.

Tell me how your book came to be about the 19th century as opposed to the common 20th-century story of suburbanization. 

There’s a real gap in American Jewish history when it comes to the 19th century, chiefly because so many American Jews today trace their origins back to the generation who arrived between 1881 and 1924, the mass migration of Jews from from Eastern Europe. So there’s a sense that that’s when American Jewish history began. Of course, that’s not true at all.

The American Jewish community dates back to the 17th century and there was much innovation that laid the foundations for what would become institutionalized in the 20th century. 

Sunday school gets a very bad rap among most historians of American Judaism. If they’ve treated it at all, they tend to be dismissive — you know, there was no substance, they just taught kids the 10 Commandments, it was run by these unprofessional volunteer female teachers, so it was feminized and feminine.

But there’s also a lot of celebration of Rebecca Gratz, who founded the first Sunday school for Jewish children. 

That’s the first indication I had that there might be more of a story here. Rebecca Gratz is lionized as being such a visionary and being so inventive in developing this incredible volunteer model for Jewish education for an immigrant generation that was mostly from Western Europe. And yet, by the beginning of the 20th century, [Jewish historians] say it has no value. So what’s the story there?

Two other things led me on the path to thinking that there was more of a story in this 19th-century moment. I did my Ph.D in Washington, D.C. And as I was searching through the holdings of the Library of Congress, there were tons and tons of Jewish catechisms.

“Sunday school gets a very bad rap among most historians of American Judaism,” says Dr. Laura Yares, author of the new book, “Jewish Sunday Schools.” (Courtesy of the author)

A catechism is a kind of creed, right? It’s a statement of religious beliefs. “These are things we believe as Jews.”

So Jewish catechisms had that, but they were also philosophical meditations in many ways. Typically, the first question of the catechism was, what is religion? And then the second question is, what is Jewish religion? 

And then I started reading them. They were question-and-answer summaries of the whole of Judaism: belief, practices, holidays, Bible, you name it, that the children were expected to memorize. This idea that you’ve got to cram these kids with knowledge went against this historiographic dismissal of this period as being very thin and that kids were not really learning anything. The idea that children had a lot to learn is something that Sunday school educators actually really wrestle with during this period. 

What was the other thing that led you to pursue this subject?

When I was beginning to research my dissertation, I was working as a Hebrew school teacher in a large Reform Hebrew school in Washington, D.C. And I remember very distinctively the rabbi coming in and addressing the teachers at the start of the school year. He said, “I don’t care if a student comes through this Hebrew school and they don’t remember anything that they learned. But I care that at the end of the year they feel like the temple is a place that they want to be, that they feel like they have relationships there and they have an (he didn’t use this word) ‘affective’ [emotional] connection.”

And so I’m sitting there by day at the Library of Congress, reading these catechisms that are saying, “Cram their heads with knowledge.” What is the relationship between Jewish education as a place where one is supposed to acquire knowledge and a place where one is supposed to feel something and to develop affective relationships? The swing between those two poles was happening as far back as the 19th century.

You write that owing to gaps in the archives, it was really hard to get an idea of the classroom experience. But to the degree that there’s a typical classroom experience in the 1860s, 1870s and you’re the daughter or grandchild of probably German-speaking Jewish immigrants, maybe working or lower middle class, what would Sunday school be like? I’m guessing the teacher would be a woman. Are you reading the Bible in English or Hebrew? 

You are probably going for an hour or two on a Sunday morning. It’s a big room, and your particular class would have a corner of the room. It’s quite chaotic. Most of the teachers were female volunteers. They were either young and unmarried, or older women whose children had grown. Except for the students who are preparing for confirmation — the grand kind of graduation ritual for Sunday schools. Those classes were typically taught by the rabbi, if there was a rabbi associated with the school.

There would be a lot of reading out loud to the students with students being expected to repeat back what they had heard or write it down so they had a copy for themselves. Often the day would begin with prayers said in English, and often the reading of the Torah portion, typically in English, although in many Sunday schools, we do have children reporting they learned bits of Hebrew by rote memorization. Or they memorized the first chapters of the book of Genesis, for example, but I’m not sure that they quite understood what they memorized. “Ein Keloheinu” is a song that often children tell us [in archival materials] that they had memorized in Hebrew. They probably would have learned at least Hebrew script, and a little bit of Hebrew decoding. But it is fair to say that if they were reading the Bible, they were reading it mostly in English, because you have to remember that most of the women who were volunteering to teach in these schools came of age in a generation where Hebrew education wasn’t extended to women. 

What’s the goal of these Sunday schools? 

The Sunday school movement arose because there was a whole generation of immigrant children who did not have access to Jewish education, because their parents didn’t have either the economic capital or the social capital to become part of the established Jewish community. They couldn’t afford a seat in the synagogue, they couldn’t afford to send their children to congregational all-day or every-afternoon schools [which were among the few options for Jewish education when Gratz opened the Philadelphia Sunday school]. Sunday schools are really a very innovative solution to a problem of a lack of resources. 

You also write that the founders of these supplementary schools want to defend children against “predatory evangelists.”

That was how Rebecca Gratz described her goal when she created the first Sunday school. She was very, very worried about the Jewish kids who were not receiving any kind of Hebrew school education. She talks about Protestant missionaries and teachers who would go out onto the street ringing the bell for Sunday school and offering various kinds of trinkets, and Jewish kids would get kind of swept into their Sunday schools. There was a very concrete need to give Jewish children somewhere else to go. 

So Gratz and the people who created the first Hebrew Sunday school in Philadelphia looked at what the Protestants were doing and they saw that Protestant Sunday schools were providing very accessible places where kids could go and get a basic primer in their religious tradition.

The approach was to teach Judaism as a religion, as opposed to Judaism as a people or culture, to demonstrate that being Jewish was as compatible as Protestantism with being wholly American.

That is certainly part of it. It’s a demonstration that Judaism is compatible with American public life. But I think there’s actually a much bigger claim that the Sunday schools are making. The claim is not only that Judaism is as good as Protestantism, but that Judaism does religion better than Protestantism. These rabbis who were writing catechisms and teaching confirmation classes were saying that Judaism does liberal religion better than liberal Protestants, liberal Catholics and other kinds of liberal denominations. You see the same sentiment in the Pittsburgh Platform as well, which is the foundational platform of the Reform movement written in the 1880s. Sunday schools take that idea and bring it down to a grassroots level.

There are many, many fewer Jews in America in much of the 19th century, before the waves of Eastern European immigrants arrived beginning in the 1880s They didn’t really have strength in numbers, or the kind of self-confidence to have a system of day schools, yeshivas or heders, the elementary schools for all-day or every day Jewish instruction.

And this is also a community that has grown up at the same time as the birth of public education in America, independent of churches. That really emerged beginning on the East Coast in the 1840s.This generation of Americans really believes in the power of public education to craft an American public. It’s a project that 19th-century American Jews believe in and want to sustain. So Sunday schools don’t just become the preferred Jewish model because of lack of resources, but because American Jews really believe in the idea of public education.

What happens at the beginning of the 20th century, with the arrival of Eastern Europeans with different models for Jewish education?

A new generation tries to reform Jewish education, led by a young educator from Palestine named Samson Benderly, who leads the new New York Bureau of Jewish Education. He tries to change American Jewish education to make it more professionalized, but to bring more traditionally inclined Jews on board he has to convince them that he doesn’t want to make more Sunday schools, because Sunday schools by the end of the 20th century had become very much associated with the Reform movement in a way that they weren’t when they were founded and for much of the 19th century.

A painting of Philadelphia philanthropist and Jewish education activist Rebecca Gratz by Thomas Sully. (The Rosenbach of the Free Library of Philadelphia)

Benderly is surveying the scene of recent immigrants living in New York City [tenements] and other kinds of downtown environments, and his proposal is to create these community institutions for these dense communities, where children can be taught Hebrew in Hebrew. His disciples also created Jewish camps as a way to get children out of the inner cities and develop the muscular Zionist ideal of healthy bodies and a robust sense of Jewish collectivity.

You write that Benderly’s vision is a sort of masculine response to the “feminizing” perception of the Sunday schools. 

These women teachers are recognizing that they’re being criticized for the kind of thinness of the Jewish education that they’re teaching in comparison to other models, but in periodicals like The American Jewess women are writing back and saying, “But you didn’t teach us Hebrew! I didn’t get that opportunity as a woman, so what do you expect?” It’s really important to note that the women did the best that they could in the time that they had available, and that they were the product of opportunities that were denied to them.

What lessons did you learn about Sunday school and Hebrew school education in the 20th century that relate to your research into the 19th century?

The move that is so decisive for shaping American Jewish education is suburbanization. Rather than having a large immigrant generation who are living in these tight ethnic enclaves, you have American Jewish children who are predominantly growing up in the suburbs, and socializing with children from all sorts of different backgrounds who are attending public schools. The place that you go to get your Jewish education is the synagogue supplemental school, which becomes the dominant model for American Jewish education up until today. Benderly might reflect that it looks a lot more like the Sunday school movement of the 19th century than his vision. 

Today’s model is really a religious model. And by that I mean that students go to Hebrew school primarily to kind of check a religious box, to learn about the thing that makes them distinctive religiously, and to achieve a religious coming-of-age marker, which is the bar, bat or b mitzvah. Certainly the curriculum today is more diverse, embracing more aspects of traditional Judaism then you would have seen in a 19th-century Sunday school: more Hebrew, more of a sense of Jewish peoplehood, ethnic identity and Zionism of course. But the question that American Jews are increasingly asking themselves is, is this a model that they still want? So you may have seen that the Jewish Education Project published a report recently on supplemental schools, which saw that enrollment has really, really declined.

Sunday schools are based on a vision of Judaism as a set of a religious commitments that American Jews actualize through belonging to a synagogue and sending their children to a synagogue or a religious school, where they will learn primarily a set of religious skills: the ability to read from the Torah, the ability to decode Hebrew, the ability to navigate the siddur.

Is that still the vision that most American Jews have for what Judaism means to them? I think increasingly the answer seems to be no.

How else did experience in a Hebrew school classroom influence you? Did you access anything else when you were writing the book? 

I think about the number of college kids and graduate students and empty nesters who are either volunteering or earning minimum wage, working at Hebrew schools, all over the country. That’s the labor force of American Judaism. These people also bring so much to the table. There are a lot of skills, dispositions and knowledge that don’t tend to get taken very seriously because this is a workforce that just gets kind of put into the category of “oh, they’re part time.” That made me look really closely in the historical archives to see if I could find anything out about the women who are volunteering to teach in Sunday schools. And what I found out was that [many] were public school teachers. And they brought a lot to the table. It was women in fact who were really pushing to make the Sunday school curriculum more experiential and to move away from rote memorization. 

As a historian formed by feminist methods, I find it really important to recognize that these women were giving over what they had, as opposed to critiquing them for not teaching in a more traditional way. I think we need to pay attention when women are being scapegoated for problems that are described as problems of Jewish continuity. It blinds us to the role that women’s volunteerism has played in American Jewish life. This whole Sunday school movement was possible only because these women volunteered their time and largely were not paid.

—
The post A new book made me appreciate Jewish Sunday schools — and the volunteer women who have powered them appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uncategorized

How Stanley Kubrick created a Jewish universe without Jews

Recently, while watching the new 4K transfer of Lolita in Criterion’s enormous new Stanley Kubrick set, I found myself lingering over an exchange near the start of the film. Humbert Humbert (James Mason) has come to murder Clare Quilty (Peter Sellers), who greets the revolver pointed at the lapel of his pajama with an objection to its owner’s background. “You are either Australian or a German refugee. This is a gentile’s house. You’d better run along,” Sellers mutters with sangfroid. The remark comes verbatim from Nabokov’s novel. Kubrick, a voracious, eclectic reader and an inventive adapter, chose to keep it and put it in the mouth of a Jewish actor.

As a budding cinephile in the late 1990s, I decided to anoint Kubrick my favorite director. When I learned he was Jewish, while preparing a school report on him, I didn’t know what to make of this odd fact. His films gave me very little help. Decades later, I’m still grappling with Kubrick’s small yet profound output — 13 feature films spanning half a century — and how being Jewish helped inform his distinctive cinematic universe. As several scholars have observed, it is largely a universe without Jews, yet one created with an outsider’s suspicion, curiosity and maybe even secret knowledge.

In 7th grade, I made a Geocities website devoted to Kubrick and Peter Greenaway, another director with a baroque aesthetic who was my other favorite auteur du jour. At that time, I was drawn to directors whose films were so visually opulent that they announced themselves almost before anything happened.

My mother had forbidden me from watching A Clockwork Orange, for obvious reasons, which is why I immediately grabbed a VHS off the shelf of a video store on the Upper West Side, long gone now, whose employees were so terminally bored that an adolescent boy could have easily rented a double feature of Deep Throat and Debbie Does Dallas. A Clockwork Orange was the first Kubrick film I saw and it overwhelmed me, not only because it was brutal and disturbing, but because it looked, sounded and felt like nothing else. As I made my way through Kubrick’s catalogue, I understood that these were films to become absorbed in, to revisit endlessly and learn by heart. They helped form my sense of what I wanted from movies.

Kubrick on the set of ‘Barry Lyndon.’ Photo by Sunset Boulevard/Corbis via Getty Images

The boy who taught himself HTML to design that fansite would have wanted The Complete Kubrick very badly. Nearly three decades after the director’s death, Criterion’s lavish boxset is the first time Kubrick’s entire cinematic output, including three shorts, has been gathered in one place. It occupies 30 discs, includes over 25 hours of supplements, is housed in lavish, luxurious packaging and arrives with a ridiculous list price of $599.95. The timing is curious: Kubrick’s centenary falls in 2028; the 30th anniversary of his death in 2029.

In the decades since Kubrick’s death, the cinematic canon has been reshaped several times over. It has been particularly fascinating to follow the changing reputation of Kubrick’s films. When I was growing up, 2001 and Dr. Strangelove were considered the obvious summits; Barry Lyndon, which was hailed upon its release in 1975 but was somewhat forgotten in the home video era (watching a slow-moving historical epic on a pan-and-scan VHS on a small, boxy tube did the film few favors), is again considered one of his greatest achievements. The Shining and Eyes Wide Shut, later works which many critics treated as disappointments, are now among his most analyzed and culturally influential.

Devotion to Kubrick’s labyrinthine works can take extreme forms. Rodney Ascher’s documentary, Room 237 (2012), which would have made an excellent supplement here, brings together viewers who have found radically different films inside The Shining. The historian Geoffrey Cocks, who has studied Kubrick’s preoccupation with Nazi Germany, reads it in the shadow of the Holocaust. Elsewhere in the documentary, The Shining is treated as an allegory of the genocide of Native Americans and a confession that Kubrick helped fake the moon landing. Eyes Wide Shut has acquired a more lurid posthumous life through claims that Kubrick was trying to expose a murderous network of elite pedophiles connected to Jeffrey Epstein who secretly run the world: in this outlandish telling, Warner Bros. executives had him killed, and the evidence (the missing 20 minutes that hardcore conspiracists refer to) was cut from the film.

I confess to finding that theory as addictive as it utterly bonkers. (It’s a very entertaining rabbithole to go down.) I’ve never finished arguing with Eyes Wide Shut, albeit for very different reasons. Around the time that I discovered Kubrick, I learned that he was shooting his first movie since Full Metal Jacket, which had been, up to the point, the only Kubrick film released in my lifetime. I became obsessed with the top secret project about which little was publicly known, downloading its minute-long trailer byte by byte (an operation that took an entire afternoon in 1998) and tracking down the Arthur Schnitzler novella, Traumnovella, or Dream Story, that the film was supposedly based on. Up until his death, in March 1999, Kubrick did his utmost to tease the audience, spreading and nurturing rumors that this was going to be the most risqué and explosively, explicitly sexual film ever made. (Why this speculation appealed to a 13-year-boy doesn’t need spelling out.)

At 14, I managed to attend a sneak preview screening of Eyes Wide Shut. I expected a revelation and came away crushed. By then Kubrick was dead; this would be the only new film of his I could ever anticipate. There was something profoundly frustrating about being left with this one, with its slow, often banal conversations, solemn sexual pageantry (a far cry from the titillation we’d been promised) and New York streets that seemed to belong nowhere. I still go back and forth between thinking the film is a masterpiece and elaborate failure. (I personally doubt that Kubrick had finished tinkering with it. Could such an infamously perfectionist director have failed to notice the sound man reflected in a mirror in one of the film’s early scenes and subsequently scrubbed out digitally? What else would Kubrick have changed if he could have?)

When watching Eyes Wide Shut, it’s instructive to recall that at one point Kubrick considered casting Steve Martin in the main role. If Tom Cruise isn’t exactly the clueless simpleton of The Jerk (a film that Kubrick loved), for most of Eyes Wide Shut’s two and a half hours, his combination of confidence and obliviousness makes him something of a Candide-esque hero. Cruise’s suave, handsome assurance keeps rubbing up against things it cannot comprehend, let alone control. This is the engine of the film’s sly comedy, which crescendoes in Cruise’s “unmasking” during the glacial orgy and the campy “sacrifice” that follows. How a viewer responds to such scenes determines whether he or she will go along with the film’s weirdly ambling nocturnal set pieces or find the whole thing unbearable.

Kubrick directing ‘Strangelove.’ Photo by Weegee (Arthur Fellig)/International Center of Photography/Getty Images

The film has stayed in my senses through years of misgivings. Its social dynamic has also become clearer. Cruise’s character is sufficiently inside the world of the rich and powerful, as personified by Syndey Pollack’s Ziegler, to be invited to his townhouse for a sumptuous Christmas party — the film’s first grand set piece — and then summoned discreetly by the host when a prostitute overdoses upstairs. He is a useful physician with a reassuring bedside manner. Two hours later, after Cruise tries and fails to infiltrate the dangerous erotic power base of the masters of the universe, Ziegler over a red billiard table, explains how little the doctor’s professional competence entitles him to know or participate in.The distinction between belonging and being admitted can seem insignificant until someone decides to enforce it. At a certain point, you run out of passwords.

Kubrick knew something about arranging those distinctions to his own advantage. The Jewish doctor’s son from the Bronx became an English country-house owner who could summon Hollywood executives across the Atlantic. Warner Bros. financed and distributed his films while granting him extraordinary freedom. The Warner Bros. chairman and CEO Terry Semel recalled flying to London to read scripts Kubrick would not send to California; a copy would arrive under his hotel-room door. Here was an outsider who had secured an unusually powerful place inside the system. He could look at its rituals with amusement while conducting elaborate rituals of his own.

That duality seems more illuminating than the familiar picture of a remote intelligence contemplating humanity from above. Kubrick’s camera is luxuriously attentive to the things his characters desire: the candlelit room, the mansion, the uniform, the beautifully appointed bathroom. Wealth and rank are seductive in these films, even when their possessors behave monstrously.

To this day, A Clockwork Orange remains my favorite among his films. Its pleasures are often on the surface: the Korova milkbar’s kinky white female statues serving as tables and dispensing drug-laced milk – they were designed by Liz Moore and inspired by  the work of the British pop artist Allen Jones – the brutalist concrete glimpsed in the film’s few exterior shots, the dancing Christs in Alex’s bedroom, Malcolm McDowell’s single false eyelash and insinuating gaze. The film has a nasty lightness that still astonishes me. Everything about the film, even the shocking scenes of violence and rape, seems designed to produce in the viewer an intense pleasure — often followed by a sense of disgust for finding it all so exhilarating. Kubrick’s knack for selecting and editing to music is virtually unmatched in the history of cinema. Rossini’s The Thieving Magpie sends a gang fight skipping along; bodies collide with the precision and extravagance of a comic ballet. After A Clockwork Orange, “Singin’ in the Rain” never sounded the same.

Malcolm McDowell raising a glass of milk in scene from Kubrick’s 1971 film ‘A Clockwork Orange.’ Photo by Screen Archives/Getty Images

The soundtrack of a Kubrick film bores its way into memory along with the images, until a piece of music can seem to contain a fully-realized scene. The circling spacecraft in 2001 acquires the poise of ballroom partners through Johann Strauss’s Blue Danube. Handel’s Sarabande gives the foolish, deadly business of honor in Barry Lyndon a heavy, implacable tread. His choices could be startlingly current: György Ligeti’s Requiem and Lux aeterna were completed in 1965 and 1966, barely before the film’s 1968 release. Later came Krzysztof Penderecki alongside the earlier Bartók in The Shining. Audiences entering a mainstream movie found themselves listening to some of the most adventurous, avant-garde music in Europe.

The Jewishness I didn’t know what to do with in 7th grade has acquired more texture through the books and testimony that have appeared since Kubrick’s death. Scholars like Nathan Abrams and David Mikics have traced his intellectual formation and his attachments to European Jewish writers. Kubrick tried to adapt Stefan Zweig’s Burning Secret, a 1913 novella about a rakish baron who befriends a 12-year-old boy in order to seduce his mother, before he turned his attention to Traumnovelle. His admiration for the Austrian-Jewish director Max Ophüls, who also adapted Schnitzler in La Ronde, offers another connection to the impossibly sophisticated and profoundly Jewish world of fin-de-siècle Vienna. Kubrick harnessed Ophüls’ fluid mobile camera, the unsentimental sexual bargaining, the casual (and not so casual) cruelty that supposedly civilized people inflict on each other. Kubrick’s European taste was an active part of his American filmmaking.

Since his death and the opening of his archives, even Kubrick’s unmade films have acquired remarkable solidity. In 2005 I wrote in these pages about Aryan Papers, Kubrick’s planned adaptation of Louis Begley’s Wartime Lies. Its Jewish boy and his aunt survive under Catholic identities; the question of who might pass, and who would be recognized, is a matter of life and death. The project remains among the scripts, research and photographs he left behind. His meticulous years’-long research into Napoleon received its own lavish afterlife in Taschen’s Stanley Kubrick’s Napoleon: The Greatest Movie Never Made. (Much of that exacting preparation eventually went into Barry Lyndon.)

The posthumous rediscovery of the atmospheric photographs that the young Kubrick shot for Look and other magazines in the late 1940s, has been another revelation. Already as a teenager, his eye was remarkably assured. These pictures show us a young man with a deep curiosity about what setting, atmosphere, clothing and makeup can reveal about people as well as a preoccupation with telling stories with images. One of Kubrick’s senior colleagues was Diane Arbus, to whom he would pay homage decades later with the immortally unsettling image of the Grady twins in The Shining.

Margaret Tyzack on the set of ‘2001: A Space Odyssey.’ Photo by Sunset Boulevard/Corbis via Getty Images

Criterion’s set brings together the director’s juvenalia, including Day of the Fight, his 1951 documentary about the boxer Walter Cartier, which grew out of a Look assignment, and offers a surprising connection to his second feature, the atmospheric and pulpy noir, Killer’s Kiss. His debut feature, the existential war fable Fear and Desire, is a shakier proposition. Kubrick tried to suppress it, and its strained allegory and uncertain acting (it can feel like a discarded “Twilight Zone” episode) make his embarrassment easy to understand. It is no rediscovered masterpiece and I imagine that Kubrick would wince if he were forced to watch the 4K transfer included in the set.

In the decades since his death, Kubrick has been brought considerably down to earth through family recollections (he loved cats, low-brow cinema and was a wonderful dancer, according to widow Christiana, and his daughters) and Robert P. Kolker and Abrams’s comprehensive 2024 biography. Criterion includes a restored version of Vivian Kubrick’s Making “The Shining,” a rare glimpse of him on set, talking with his parents, working through thorny logistical problems and tormenting  Shelley Duvall to force a performance of sheer terror out of her. (It’s hard to watch. At one point, he even tells the crew, “Don’t sympathize with Shelley. It doesn’t help her.”)  It’s also a reminder that even the most individual and exacting of auteurs works with collaborators to bring his visions to life.

So many films now seem small by design, even when considerable money has gone into them. (Is it any wonder that Paul Thomas Anderson and Christopher Nolan, arguably today’s biggest studio auteurs, are hardcore Kubrickians?) Kubrick’s films continue to demand so much of our attention because we feel that their images contain so much. He could produce that sense of vastness and of meaning  in a voyage across the universe or a jealous husband’s walk around a few city blocks. After all these years, I sometimes think I know my way around his films. Then a familiar line makes me wonder how much I’ve missed.

I’m in no hurry to run along.

 

The post How Stanley Kubrick created a Jewish universe without Jews appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

In ‘American Doctor,’ a Jewish surgeon denounces Israel’s war. Now, a Palestinian colleague has been killed.

To much of the world, news of another deadly Israeli attack on a Gaza hospital last Thursday may have been just another grim headline of endless carnage. But for audiences who attended documentary screenings in more than 200 cities this year, the news will resonate vividly.

Among the six people killed in the airstrike on Nasser Hospital — one of at least a half-dozen direct attacks on the facility since the war began — was Dr. Rizk Abu Shaira, a Palestinian surgeon who appears briefly in the documentary American Doctor.

The film has been shown from Duluth to Copenhagen and it has picked up honors at film festivals since its January debut at Sundance. Director Poh Si Teng produced the Oscar-nominated documentary St. Louis Superman in 2020 and has a national Emmy to her credit.

Dr. Mark Perlmutter in Po Si Teng’s documentary. Photo by

The film follows three American physicians who traveled to Gaza to treat the wounded during Israel’s war with Hamas. They are Dr. Mark Perlmutter, a hand surgeon who is Jewish; Dr. Feroze Sidhwa, a trauma surgeon who practices Zoroastrianism; and Dr. Thaer Ahmad, a Palestinian American emergency physician. Abu Shaira also appears in the film and on the movie poster, operating alongside Sidhwa.

“He was quite a joy to be around,” Sidhwa told me hours after last week’s attack. “He knew the dangers very well but came back to work.”

So did Sidhwa.

“I was almost killed at Nasser on March 23 [2025],” he said. “I was on my way down to a patient’s room when it was blown up.”

That incident, which Israeli officials said was directed at a senior Hamas official being treated there, is chronicled in the film, which Teng described as a “character-driven journey through three men who couldn’t be more different.” It began with Perlmutter, whom she contacted after seeing him on a news report. He introduced her to Sidhwa and Ahmad.

The Jewish physician among the three, Perlmutter is also the most outspoken in condemning Israel’s conduct. “You can love Israel but hate the fascist right-wing government that runs it,” he says in the film.

While the other two also express criticisms, they are more restrained — though astute moviegoers may notice a plush fabric map of Palestine in the children’s book Ahmad’s wife reads to their toddler, as well as on her pendant necklace, which could be interpreted as an expression of Palestinian pride or erasure of Israel. Regardless, that aspiration is in no way comparable to the horrors shown.

“Three surgeons and four [medical fellows] are working on one little girl for 2½ hours and she’s very likely to lose her left leg and part of her arm,” Perlmutter says in the film, which is presented without narration.

Sidhwa told me of similar determination when remembering Abu Shaira, the doctor slain in last week’s attack.

“Rizk insisted that we take [a severely injured patient] to the operating room [saying], ‘Maybe we can save him,’” he recalled.

“Everybody was rolling their eyes and I said, ‘I’ll operate on him with you.’ He died anyway, but just because we didn’t have the ICU resources needed to keep such a person alive.”

That’s when they can operate.

The hospital was also hit in August 2025, when the Israeli military targeted a camera it said it believed was being used by Hamas. Five journalists were among the dead. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called that a “tragic mishap” and promised an investigation. Reuters later established that the camera belonged to its journalist.

That kind of incident is why Teng, who has her own production company after previously working at The New York Times, Al Jazeera and ABC News, says she decided to make the film.

“I was seeing people getting killed and executed, [former] Al Jazeera colleagues. That was really tough,” said Teng, a naturalized American born in Malaysia now living in New York. “I’m not Palestinian, I don’t live there, I’m not Jewish, so what is my entry point?”

That was her introduction to Perlmutter, who plotted a way to sneak her into Gaza after Israeli authorities denied her entry, as they had a return visit by Ahmad.

“He said, ‘I’m gonna train you as my scrub nurse and bring you in.’ And I said, ‘Mark, that’s never gonna happen.’”

Instead, she worked remotely with a crew from her Al Jazeera connections. Production started in late 2024 and concluded a year later — breakneck speed for a major documentary, though perhaps contributing to one structural flaw: The film jumps back and forth between 2024 and 2025, making an already confusing chronology of war more difficult to follow.

Still, that hasn’t stopped audiences around the world from responding emotionally to the film.

“American Doctor was very difficult to watch,” said activist Michele Naar-Obed of Duluth. “To see the blatant violation of laws by the Israeli government purposely targeting hospitals, civilians including children, and journalists, aided and abetted by U.S weapons, was hard enough. But we learned the day before that the hospital was hit again, and there is evidence that the bombs can be traced back to the U.S.

“The only way to change the course of these two morally depraved governments will be through the mass movements of we the people,” she added.

Teng has a connection to Duluth, though she’s never been there. The closest she’s come was the Twin Cities, which she first visited 21 years ago as an international student. I met her then and invited her to write for the Duluth News Tribune, where I was editorial page editor. Those became her first columns in a mainstream newspaper.

It would be wonderful to see her on the Oscar stage, or just to get a nod as director, or even to legitimately entertain the idea, given all the accolades the film has already received.

But it would be far better if its story never had to be told.

The post In ‘American Doctor,’ a Jewish surgeon denounces Israel’s war. Now, a Palestinian colleague has been killed. appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Uncategorized

Sen. Elissa Slotkin is having a moment. Are Michigan’s Jews happy about it?

(JTA) — SOUTHFIELD – Ordinarily, Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin would seem an anodyne choice to speak at a Shabbat event for Jewish veterans.

Slotkin is Jewish and a former Defense Department official who served three tours in Iraq as a Central Intelligence Agency analyst. Emphasizing her national security background, the Democrat has also championed Israel as a U.S. ally and identifies as a Zionist.

Yet the clergy at Congregation Shaarey Zedek, a large Conservative shul in the Detroit suburbs, needed to defend their invitation to Slotkin in an email to congregants on Friday. One day before the Veteran’s Shabbat program, the synagogue’s leadership acknowledged “your concern, your offense, and even your hurt” in regards to Slotkin’s planned appearance.

The senator wound up not attending the service, with her staff citing flight trouble. The Federal Aviation Administration had ordered a four-hour ground stop for all U.S. flights late Friday stranding more than 1 million travelers.

But why were so many of the congregants at Shaarey Zedek up in arms about the prospect of their Jewish senator’s Shabbat appearance? The clergy didn’t elaborate, and a representative for Slotkin declined requests for an interview for this story.

Some Jewish former supporters of Slotkin’s summed up the biggest backlash to the Jewish Telegraphic Agency this way: She campaigned with the state’s senator-elect, Abdul El-Sayed. More broadly, Slotkin has also sought to put some distance between herself and the party’s staunchly pro-Israel wing as she has strayed left from her own moderate brand.

As Jews question their place in the Democratic Party, Slotkin’s moves — and her Jewish constituents’ reactions to them — could add further instability to the shifting ground.

Michael Horowitz, a Michigan resident and former CEO of the Jewish federation of Atlanta, is one Jewish community member who feels betrayed by her support of El-Sayed.

“I think as a leader in the party, she could have, and should have, called out some of the narrative coming from him and his supporters,” he told JTA about Slotkin stumping for El-Sayed across the state in the general election. “And I’m disappointed that she didn’t do that.”

The furor some Jews in the state have directed at their senior senator for associating with El-Sayed on the campaign trail is indicative of the deep wounds remaining in the state from the election — and a warning sign for the Jewish lawmaker in their midst hoping to rise in the ranks unscathed.

El-Sayed’s historic midterm win, and the Jewish community’s divisions over it, have grabbed the lion’s share of the national headlines from Michigan. But Slotkin’s profile has also grown — and she has teased she may run for president in 2028. If she does, some of her top former Jewish donors are signaling they see her support for the senator-elect as a problem.

El-Sayed has alienated many in the traditional pro-Israel camp with his criticism of Israel, and has had to walk back other statements of his from during the campaign that many Michigan Jews considered offensive. U.S. Rep. Haley Stevens, El-Sayed’s primary rival and a favorite of the state’s pro-Israel Jewish community, broke with her party in the race’s final days to endorse GOP nominee Mike Rogers. Slotkin took the opposite approach, campaigning with El-Sayed across the state and emphasizing the areas they agreed on.

Slotkin has built a name for herself as a bipartisan figure: She worked in both the George W. Bush and Obama administrations before running for Congress. She has sought to play a role as a bridge between El-Sayed’s progressive wing of the party and more moderate members of the voting bloc, including Jews.

Michigan U.S. Sen. Elissa Slotkin speaks at the state Democratic Party’s election-night watch party in Detroit, Nov. 3, 2026. (Andrew Lapin/JTA)

“The state of Michigan can send one Jewish senator and one Muslim senator, the first time ever in history,” she told the cheering crowd at the Michigan Democratic Party’s election night watch party in Detroit, hours before El-Sayed’s victory. “That is who we are. That is the promise of America, and we are going to do it and show the whole damn world today.”

That approach speaks to some in the Jewish community. Mary Ellen Gurewitz, a vice chair of Michigan’s state board of canvassers and Jewish El-Sayed supporter, told JTA that she was glad to see Slotkin campaign with him.

The Jews who are opposed to Slokin over her support for El-Sayed, Gurewitz said, have their priorities wrong.

“That is so self-defeating. They need to be communicating with, and speaking on good terms with, their representatives in Congress,” she said. “To say, ‘We don’t want to talk to you because you supported Abdul,’ that’s just astounding to me.”

But Slotkin’s strong support of El-Sayed risks splitting her supporters rather than bringing them together. Slotkin won her 2024 Senate bid against Mike Rogers by 19,000 votes, in a year when Trump won Michigan in the presidential election. Analysts at the time chalked up her narrow win to her political identity as a moderate. Despite her background as an intelligence analyst with extensive Middle East experience, she did not make Israel a defining issue in that election.

Two years later, El-Sayed, also facing Rogers but from a progressive flank, improved on Slotkin’s margins considerably. Around 340,000 votes separated El-Sayed and Rogers as of press time, according to Associated Press tallies that have given El-Sayed a seven-point victory. 

One of the major issues of the campaign was the lobbying activities of AIPAC. El-Sayed made AIPAC’s spending against him a key part of his own campaign pitch. Before then, Slotkin had already begun backing away from the group.

“I have not been endorsed by AIPAC,” Slotkin told the populist-minded show “Breaking Points” in 2025, noting that this was a shift from when she had accepted the group’s support in her first congressional run in 2018. She also hedged when the hosts asked her if AIPAC “should register as a foreign lobby.”

In the meantime, independent of El-Sayed, the senator has taken on President Donald Trump. She drew headlines last year for filming a video urging active duty military to “refuse illegal orders,” and again in recent weeks for saying she wanted to send a “deterrence message” to college graduates thinking of working for Trump’s administration.

And last week, Slotkin took on a leader of her own party, too. She joined progressive Vermont independent Bernie Sanders to announce they would not support New York Sen. Chuck Schumer for majority leader. The announcement helped to lay the table for Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, a progressive Israel critic, to formally challenge Schumer, who is Jewish, days later.

“We need a new generation of leadership,” Slotkin said then.

There are other signs that Slotkin is listening more to the progressive flank of her party these days. Along with much of the Democratic Party, she has shifted on Israel. In April the senator voted to block the sale of offensive weapons to Israel, saying, “Being pro-Israel today is not about simply supporting the political or military agenda of Prime Minister Netanyahu, just like being pro-American should not be equated with loyalty to President Trump.” She continues to support funding for the Iron Dome, the country’s missile defense system.

Slotkin’s rhetoric on Israel was another concern for Horowitz, the donor who was previously much more supportive of her. A Jewish Democratic Council of America fundraising call between the two of them briefly led to accusations that she was unethically using her Congressional office to fundraise in 2022.

Now, though, he accuses her of jumping “on that AIPAC dogwhistle.”

“I know she has had criticism of some of the actions of the Israeli government, which is fine,” he said. But, he added, “What she does, and how she says it, becomes tools and ammunition because it’s coming from a Jewish leader.”

Halie Soifer, head of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, does not share the qualms about Slotkin that some Michigan Jews have.

“Senator Slotkin reflects a growing Jewish American consensus of support for Israel’s security and right to self-defense, while opposing extreme policies of the current Israeli government,” Soifer told JTA in a statement.

“We are confident that Senator Slotkin will continue to be a leader and champion on the issues that matter most to Jewish Americans, and we’re grateful for her leadership.”

Back at Shaarey Zedek, the congregation’s leaders may have dodged a scuffle thanks to the FAA. But before they realized that, the rabbis and cantor wanted to offer their own praise of the senator.

Slotkin, they told their members, would address them “with kindness and respect, with humility and empathy, and with an open mind and heart to the differing opinions and concerns of our shul.”

This article originally appeared on JTA.org.

The post Sen. Elissa Slotkin is having a moment. Are Michigan’s Jews happy about it? appeared first on The Forward.

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2017 - 2023 Jewish Post & News