Do you agree with Zohran Mamdani about Israel?  Are you voting for him next week?

Those are two different questions, and I’m going to make the case that they can have two different answers: No and Yes.

First, let’s do a quick reality check that, outside the Jewish community, this is not what the upcoming mayoral election is about. To his supporters, the Mamdani candidacy is about kitchen-table issues — yes, the buses and the grocery stores, but also taxes and inequality as well as a generational shift in our politics and resistance to the Trump regime’s anti-democratic actions. Mamdani didn’t talk about Israel/Palestine until asked over and over again to do so.

That said, it’s fair for any minority group to focus on issues that affect their community, and for many American Jews, that includes Israel. And, as critics of Mamdani have pointed out, there are ways in which his views on Israel have practical consequences for New York City: how a mayor responds to conflicts and confrontations, how a mayor’s statements encourage or discourage acts of violence, and how a mayor does or doesn’t express the values of the city’s population.

It is also reasonable to disagree with positions Assemblyman Mamdani has taken on issues related to Israel. For example, I personally agree with Mamdani in supporting a Jewish state where all people have equal rights, and I agree that Israel, particularly under its current government, falls well short of that standard. But I disagree that Zionism necessarily entails that inequality, I disagree that incendiary statements (such as ‘globalize the intifada’) are acceptable even if some may have non-violent interpretations of them, and I disagree with many of the principles that the Democratic Socialists of America and Students for Justice in Palestine have espoused.

So, no, I don’t agree with every view this candidate has about Israel and Palestine.

But were I still living in Brooklyn (my family moved to the suburbs three years ago due to the cost of housing, one of Mamdani’s signature issues), I would enthusiastically vote for him. Because not only are there more important issues for New York City and for the country. there are even more important issues for Jews.

First, within a few months, it seems all but certain that the Trump regime will send the National Guard and militarized ICE personnel into New York City as it has done in Los Angeles, Portland and Chicago. Who is going to stand up to this authoritarian militarism?  Andrew Cuomo?  Curtis Sliwa?  New York, and New York’s Jews, need a mayor who will defend what’s left of our democratic society, and stand up for all those who are unfairly targeted, who are deported without due process, or who are abused in state custody.

(Arguably, the election of Mamdani, whom Trump falsely calls a ‘communist’, might enrage the president still further. But it would be reprehensible to cower in the face of an authoritarian strongman and foolish to hope that a disreputable, dishonest collaborator like Cuomo would keep us safe from him.)

Again, this is a matter of Jewish concern specifically. New York Jews are overwhelmingly liberal, and overwhelmingly anti-Trump. The regime has already targeted several high-profile Jewish organizations and already stated that the entire Democratic party is a domestic extremist organization. For God’s sake, where do you think that leaves us?

Personally, I am far more afraid of Trump’s militias, the white supremacists in own party, and the “lone wolf” antisemitic vigilantes who almost always happen to be angry young right-wing men than I am of a supposedly anti-Israel mayor of New York City.

And then there’s Mamdani’s circle of Jewish advisors and confidantes, including my former city councilman, Brad Lander. When Mayor Mamdani has to make tough judgment calls about issues that affect the Jewish community, I have confidence that Lander and other associates, not to mention the rabbis whose synagogues Mamdani visited over the high holidays, will represent our concerns and that Mamdani will hear them.

Meanwhile, the Cuomo campaign (and many of its Jewish supporters) has indulged in outright racism, spreading noxious bigotry. This kind of Trumpist politics is ugly, it is immoral, and it fans the flames of prejudice that is often directed at Jews. Yet nowhere in the letter signed by over a thousand rabbis (most of him, like me, not residents of New York City) did I see a single word condemning it. (On the contrary, the letter spread further calumnies against Mamdani, insinuating that he has not condemned antisemitic rhetoric, which he has, numerous times.) This is exactly the kind of sewer politics with which Donald Trump’s populist movement has poisoned the country, and it is dangerous. If a Jewish candidate were subjected to antisemitic rhetoric, we would rightly demand that bigotry be called out. We should be collectively ashamed of our leaders for not doing so here.

Finally, whether we like it or not (and I do not), anti-Zionism has entered the political mainstream – not because of antisemitism, but because of two years of brutal warfare, dehumanizing rhetoric, and humanitarian abuses on the part of the Netanyahu government. Zohran Mamdani is not normalizing anti-Zionism; he is reflecting where tens of millions of Americans already find themselves ideologically. (And again, he is not running on this issue, even secondarily.)  That ship has long since left the harbor.

For that reason, the “No-Yes” option is likely here to stay. American Jews need to learn to disagree with politicians about Israel (just as Israel-first voters have learned to disagree with Christian theocrats in the Trump administration), try to tease apart legitimate Jewish self-determination from the Jewish supremacy politics of Israel’s Right, and work with our imperfect allies toward the common good.

That common good includes basic issues of affordability and economic fairness (which is why so any billionaires are spending huge sums to help Cuomo). It includes freedom of speech and due process of law, which protect minorities like ours from the tyranny of the majority. And it includes the kind of country we want to live in, the kind of people we want to be. I may disagree with Mamdani about Zionism, but I have not a scintilla of doubt that we agree on these fundamental issues, and that those fundamentals are the most important questions for Jews, New Yorkers, and Americans.

Vote No-Yes.

The post Zohran Mamdani: The no-yes option appeared first on The Forward.